Abortion effectively outlawed in S.Dakota

Note that I realize there would still be issues this doesn't really cover - but at least it offers some protection for men and women from being responsible for children they took measures against having.

Well, we do have laws.

In the US, abortion is legal.
In the US, child support is (I believe) a matter for the states, and is often mandatory.

For men and women:

-- If you don't want to support a child, don't have one. You can prevent this through your behavior, or a surgical procedure if you want to be sure. Anything else you do has the potential to fail, and a pregnancy might ensue.
--If you want children, you're probably going to be required to support them. You can procreate, or adopt.
--If you believe abortion is wrong, fine. I don't. We'll agree to disagree.
--If you want to undergo an elective surgical procedure (cosmetics, abortion), by all means, arrange an appointment with your doctor.
 
I disagree that this is the outcome.

If the choice remains the womans, she may have the child or not. If the father also wishes to have the child, he is on the hook. If he does not wish to have the child, he is off the hook. He gets exactly the same choices as the woman, without having the slightest control over her. She actually still retains the greater choice - she gets to have the baby regardless of his decision, while his ability to father a child rests entire in her hand.

How is that different from the problem I described--that under your proposal, by his words alone a father can disavow responsibility for the child?
 
I would say that we could leave it to the Courts to decide each case...but then, the Courts would likely take too long and the pregnancy would be over before a decision could be handed down.

Perhaps a Court appointed mediator. Allow the man and woman to discuss the options and their desires.

If a male takes precautions and still winds up impregnating a female, I would be inclined to grant him no responsibility for a pregnancy the female decides to carry to term. I would allow the converse of this to be a valid point for the female as well - say the female wants an abortion and the male doesn't. If the female can show that she took precautions (BC, morning-after pill, spermicide, etc) and still was impregnated and does not wish to carry the fetus to term, she should be allowed to abort - or if she decides to carry to term out of deference to the male's desires, she should be free from any obligation to the child.


Note that I realize there would still be issues this doesn't really cover - but at least it offers some protection for men and women from being responsible for children they took measures against having.

I would argue that it is more important that the child have appropriate support, and that since they entered into intercourse with the knowledge that birth control is not 100% foolproof, it makes sense for them to bear the costs instead of taxpayers, regardless of their preferences at that point.
 
I would consider that to be a more desirable situation.



Well, yes. If we say that the father has no choice, then the father can have no responsibility. In that case, society is exactly the correct agency to provide a social safety net.



I disagree, but can find no real flaw with you reasoning, except that so long as society insists the father gets no choice, then society should rightly bear responsibility for the costs.

The problem is that society cannot hinder the costs by preventing the father from impregnating someone. In my opinion he offers up the possibility of needing to support the child by consenting to intercourse. That circumstances may limit his options later is no reason to absolve him of the responsibility for that choice.
 
Ahhh, so the "person-x should have kept their **** in their pants if a baby wasn't desired" only applies to men?


ETA: In other words:

If she has a bad day and gets pregnant against her will, she can just abort.

If he has a bad day and she gets pregnant against his will, tough **** for him.


Seems fair enough to me :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
How is that different from the problem I described--that under your proposal, by his words alone a father can disavow responsibility for the child?

You describe the circustance as if the father has both half the choice and half the responsibility. That clearly is not the case. As it stands now, the mother has the choice to have/not have sex, use/not use birth control, and an absolute, infallable choice about whether or not to end a pregnancy. The father has fewer choices - and none at all once pregnancy begins.
 
I would argue that it is more important that the child have appropriate support, and that since they entered into intercourse with the knowledge that birth control is not 100% foolproof, it makes sense for them to bear the costs instead of taxpayers, regardless of their preferences at that point.

I disagree, on the same principle that allows for society to routinely bear the costs of subsidizing poor choices by members of the society.

Abortion is 100% effective, and the woman owns 100% of the choice to use or not use this procedure. If a man expresses a desire not to father children and is up front with the woman at every step of the way, and the woman elects to have a child anyway, then there is no logic for burdening the man with the financial responsibility for her choice.
 
Ahhh, so the "person-x should have kept their **** in their pants if a baby wasn't desired" only applies to men?


ETA: In other words:

If she has a bad day and gets pregnant against her will, she can just abort.

If he has a bad day and she gets pregnant against his will, tough **** for him.


Seems fair enough to me :rolleyes:

Wow....
 
The father has fewer choices - and none at all once pregnancy begins.

No, the man has choices. His just occur much earlier, and are cheaper, and easier. He can have a vasectomy. He can wear a condom (which would be the sensible course of action regardless or questions of fertility...good God, do people really not know about HIV? It's 2011!). If he can't be bothered to spend a couple of bucks and a couple of seconds on a condom, then what basis does he have for moaning about how unfair it is that the woman can choose to have invasive surgery later? Which sounds like the easier, smarter, cheaper, better choice? He had his damn chance to do the right thing and he didn't. Failure to choose correctly does not give you the right to another round of choices.
 
No, the man has choices.

You are incorrect.
I said the man has fewer choices, and he inarguably does.

His just occur much earlier, and are cheaper, and easier.

Not true. The man's pre-pregnancy choices occur at exactly the same time as the womans pre-pregnancy choices. They are

1. Don't have sex.
2. Use some form of birth control

He can wear a condom (which would be the sensible course of action regardless or questions of fertility...good God, do people really not know about HIV? It's 2011!).

Fine advice, but it doesn't offer an additional choice - it is birth control.

If he can't be bothered to spend a couple of bucks and a couple of seconds on a condom, then what basis does he have for moaning about how unfair it is that the woman can choose to have invasive surgery later?

You are confused about the nature of the argument. I don't desire to strip the woman of her ability to choose to have an abortion. I have been crystal clear on that score. I simply desire for her to accept responsibility for her choice.

Which sounds like the easier, smarter, cheaper, better choice? He had his damn chance to do the right thing and he didn't. Failure to choose correctly does not give you the right to another round of choices.

Yet you desire for the woman to have exactly that - a second round of choices. Except that you propose it is okay for the man to share in the responsibility for the second round of choices that only the woman can make.
 
Ahhh, so the "person-x should have kept their **** in their pants if a baby wasn't desired" only applies to men?


ETA: In other words:

If she has a bad day and gets pregnant against her will, she can just abort.

If he has a bad day and she gets pregnant against his will, tough **** for him.


Seems fair enough to me :rolleyes:

I already agreed it was unfair. I'd repeat my point but I've already said it multiple times.
 
You describe the circustance as if the father has both half the choice and half the responsibility. That clearly is not the case. As it stands now, the mother has the choice to have/not have sex, use/not use birth control, and an absolute, infallable choice about whether or not to end a pregnancy. The father has fewer choices - and none at all once pregnancy begins.

And yet he has a reliable method of not becoming a father--using birth control in the first place, or not having sex with someone. That she gets two chances doesn't erase his responsibility.
 
Except that you propose it is okay for the man to share in the responsibility for the second round of choices that only the woman can make.

Life is unfair. Biology is a harsh mistress. Owing to the mechanics of sex, men have choice only up until they shoot their load. If they do it in the wrong place, at the wrong time, in the wrong person, without a useful and sensible piece of technology, then it's over for them. They had all the choices up until then, and they failed to make the good ones. Anything after that is too late.

Tough cheese. If you feel that's unfair, apply to the Creator and complain of how the male reproductive system works. Or how life is unfair in general. I'm sure relief and correction will soon follow.

Women get different choices, over a longer period of time, but they are worse choices and much more unpleasant. It's not "fair" for them, either. I'm sure plenty would like to be able to teleport a fetus into the father's body and let him make the choices.

Anybody old enough to be having sex is old enough to have figured out 1) how the hell their own bodies function, 2) how to be smart about said functions, and 3) that life is unfair and biological reality does not bend to accommodate foolish human ideals. Your semen doesn't care who it fertilizes, your fetus doesn't care that you're still in college, your tumor doesn't care that it's going to kill you, and your body does not plan to drop fifty pounds without effort so you can look like that attractive actor.
 
And yet he has a reliable method of not becoming a father--using birth control in the first place, or not having sex with someone. That she gets two chances doesn't erase his responsibility.

Yes - the exact same choices she has, right up to the point that she has an optio he does not have. Parse it any way you want, she has the sole ability to decide, and he gets no vote. So long as that is true, he should bear no responsibility for the off spring.

Tell you what - lets apportion responsibility for the child based on relative responsibility for the pregnancy.

They have equal responsibility for choosing to have sex 50/50
They have equal responsibility for using contraception 50/50
The woman has sole responsibility for knowing when she is likely to get pregnant 100/0
The woman has sole responsibility for choosing to carry a child to term 100/0

So, the woman is 300/100 responsible for the child. She pays 3/4s, he pays 1/4.
 
Last edited:
Life is unfair. Biology is a harsh mistress. Owing to the mechanics of sex, men have choice only up until they shoot their load. If they do it in the wrong place, at the wrong time, in the wrong person, without a useful and sensible piece of technology, then it's over for them. They had all the choices up until then, and they failed to make the good ones. Anything after that is too late.

Yet you are fine with relieving the woman of responsibilty for her choices.

Tough cheese. If you feel that's unfair, apply to the Creator and complain of how the male reproductive system works. Or how life is unfair in general. I'm sure relief and correction will soon follow.

The "creator" isn't the one mandating the un-willing father sacrifice a significant share of his wealth to subsidize the womans choice to carry a child to term.

It's the law that does so. I am mildly disturbed at this - being a proponent of the 14th and all.

Women get different choices, over a longer period of time, but they are worse choices and much more unpleasant.

That is completely false. Women get exactly the same choices over exactly the same time span, at no greater cost than the men, right up until they get a choice that men are not afforded at all.

It's not "fair" for them, either. I'm sure plenty would like to be able to teleport a fetus into the father's body and let him make the choices.

Anybody old enough to be having sex is old enough to have figured out 1) how the hell their own bodies function, 2) how to be smart about said functions, and 3) that life is unfair and biological reality does not bend to accommodate foolish human ideals. Your semen doesn't care who it fertilizes, your fetus doesn't care that you're still in college, your tumor doesn't care that it's going to kill you, and your body does not plan to drop fifty pounds without effort so you can look like that attractive actor.


Follow your own advice - take it up with the "creator". These circumstances actually are his handiwork.
 
Last edited:
That is completely false. Women get exactly the same choices over exactly the same time span, at no greater cost than the men, right up until they get a choice that men are not afforded at all.

And because of that biological inequality, you believe that no man should have to pay half of support for a child if he doesn't really want to. I understand you feel that way, but I just don't agree.
 
And because of that biological inequality, you believe that no man should have to pay half of support for a child if he doesn't really want to. I understand you feel that way, but I just don't agree.

I'm not trying to convince you. You've made your case well enough, and you've clearly expressed your opinion.

But for the record, the inequity in this circumstance has nothing at all to do with biology. The inequity stems from law (and that stems from a societal norm). It is infinately more correctable than a biological inequity would be.
 
Do you have a solution that doesn't allow men, on demand, to refuse to support their born children?
 
Yet you are fine with relieving the woman of responsibilty for her choices.

I think you're confusing me with someone else. I've never said anything remotely like that. Everyone's responsible for all their choices, regardless of whether it's "fair" or not that they have those choices.

The "creator" isn't the one mandating the un-willing father sacrifice a significant share of his wealth to subsidize the womans choice to carry a child to term.

It's the law that does so. I am mildly disturbed at this - being a proponent of the 14th and all.

If the unwilling father was unwilling to be a father, he should have taken better care of where, when, and how he distributed his semen. I believe people should have the right to own guns, but I also think they should be held fully responsible of where the bullets they fire go.

That is completely false. Women get exactly the same choices over exactly the same time span, at no greater cost than the men, right up until they get a choice that men are not afforded at all.

Really? Women can control where their semen falls? News to me. I guess I know less about women and how their penises operate than I thought.

But yes, they should insist the bastard wear a condom, and are fools not to. That they don't doesn't make the man any less a fool for not wearing one, either.

Follow your own advice - take it up with the "creator". These circumstances actually are his handiwork.

I'm not the one expecting life to be "fair". I accept the constraints of biology and recognize that ultimate responsiblity for the distribution of my semen and the consequences thereof is mine. That others could have done something at some points doesn't remove my responsibility.
 
Do you have a solution that doesn't allow men, on demand, to refuse to support their born children?

I don't have a desire to deprive men of the choice not to be fathers, so no.

I can see only two correct possibilities:

1. Women retain control over whether or not they carry a child to term. if the father expresses a desire not to be a father from the begining, then the woman (rightly) is responsible.

2. Women cede control over whether or not they have an abortion.


Of the two, option one seems to be the better choice by far.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom