Abortion effectively outlawed in S.Dakota

I don't have a desire to deprive men of the choice not to be fathers, so no.

I can see only two correct possibilities:

1. Women retain control over whether or not they carry a child to term. if the father expresses a desire not to be a father from the begining, then the woman (rightly) is responsible.

I agree---if the method of expressing he doesn't wish to be a father consists of acquiring a vasectomy and utilizing a condom. If the woman conceives after he does those things, she can sue the doctors and the manufacturers for any money she feels appropriate for childcare, leaving the father free of legal responsibilities. Very fair.
 
I don't have a desire to deprive men of the choice not to be fathers, so no.

You're not though. Regardless of the fact that a woman has two chances to choose, the man still has the choice of whether to be a father on the outset. So he's not being deprived of choice, it's that he's not offered a second choice because he's not the one carrying the fetus.
 
Ahhh, so the "person-x should have kept their **** in their pants if a baby wasn't desired" only applies to men?


ETA: In other words:

If she has a bad day and gets pregnant against her will, she can just abort.

If he has a bad day and she gets pregnant against his will, tough **** for him.


Seems fair enough to me :rolleyes:

You're going to have to take that up with evolution.

Is it "fair" that only a woman can become pregnant; that the child grows inside of her?

There is no symmetry, here. That's biology, sorry. Until it is viable, the fetus is a part of the woman. This gives her involvement and therefore control over that situation in a unique way.

Sorry.
 
I don't think women should be punished for having sex, so I don't think men should either. Accidents happen. You may use a condom, but they can break. So I agree with those of you who say that:

1) If a woman wants an abortion, she should be allowed to have one. If she does not want an abortion, she should be allowed to carry the pregnancy to term. No one else should have any say in this matter.

2) If the father wants the child and the mother doesn't, tough luck to him. It's her body, not his.

3) If the mother wants the child and the father doesn't, he should be allowed to refuse responsibility early in the pregnancy. Then the mother still has two choices: to abort or take full responsibility.

This should be the default procedure. But I also think that there should be a simple, easy to use legal mechanism to change it. For instance, if the woman is pro-life, the couple could have a contract in which the man is forced to take responsibility for the child in case of pregnancy. If he doesn't agree with the terms of the contract, then he shouldn't have sex with her.

The only part of the procedure that shouldn't be changed under any circumstances is the mother's right over her own body. A pro-life father shouldn't ever have any say in this matter, even if both people agree beforehand that they will carry an eventual pregnancy to term. He is allowed to refuse responsibility for the child, but he can't force the mother to have the child or to abort. I think this is probably the best solution: the woman is still given greater choice (since it's her body), but we don't have to tell men the very same things we abhor when said to a woman ("shouldn't have been a slut!").
 
Wow--people are actually claiming that men have less reproductive freedom than women?

ETA: Has there ever in the history of the U.S. been a law that singled out males such that a patient might freely choose a medical procedure and a doctor might be willing to perform it, but the law prohibited it? Ever? Even one?
 
Last edited:
Yet you are fine with relieving the woman of responsibilty for her choices.



The "creator" isn't the one mandating the un-willing father sacrifice a significant share of his wealth to subsidize the womans choice to carry a child to term.

It's the law that does so. I am mildly disturbed at this - being a proponent of the 14th and all.



That is completely false. Women get exactly the same choices over exactly the same time span, at no greater cost than the men, right up until they get a choice that men are not afforded at all.




Follow your own advice - take it up with the "creator". These circumstances actually are his handiwork.

Having an abortion is is a form of birth control. It is taking responsibility. As for men - everything TragicMonkey said.

I know how you MRA types love to focus on those evil, evil women laying in wait with their penis fly traps to steal the seed and "rightful" earnings of poor unsuspecting men. The reality is that most child support is ordered after a long term relationship ends and the child (or children) are old enough to call him daddy. Only a very small percentage of child support is ordered to infants born of a short term relationship.

Pregnancy coercion is more likely to be a man's game. There was a recent their study which showed that nearly 20% of women in their teens and 20's experienced coercion (had their partners threaten to leave them if they did not get pregnant, for example) and 15% had their birth control sabotaged. These actions are often accompanied by violence or abuse.

Men, as Monkey has so eloquently stated, have every opportunity to prevent pregnancy. They can use either condoms or a vasectomy. This is not fair. Women have no vasectomy equivalent - there is no simple, inexpensive, reversible surgery that will allow for full or temporary sterilization. Most doctors won't even consider a tubal ligation for a woman in her 20's because of the threat of a malpractice suit.

If a man chooses to ignore his options, he may be faced with an unintended pregnancy. If he has chosen his sex partner unwisely, he may need to pay child support for a child that he does not want. There are financial repercussions for mistakes. Thousands of people are losing their homes because they made a poor decision. They don't get their money back because the real estate market misled them.

Child welfare exists because society recognizes a child's right to support from both parents. Abortion is a woman's right because it is her body. In both cases the father's rights are secondary because his body, health and well-being are not being directly affected. That's the problem right there - the idea that a woman or child could have rights that trump a man's.
 
Also can we please get away from the myth that women are profiting from child support.

Child support is for the child. Any woman who uses that money for personal gain is doing something illegal and should be punished. Child support is supposed to pay for a percentage of a child's needs (percentage depends on many factors.) The custodial parent still needs to provide for the child. Child support in the country is also woefully inadequate. Almost 20% of children in America live at or below the poverty line and many of them live with a single parent.

While there may be the occasional woman who is supported entirely by child-support, she is statistically so rare as to be insignificant. The truth is that most single parents raise a child while holding down a full time job. If "tricking" a man into paying child support is a scam, it's the most labor intensive and least profitable grift out there.
 
I know how you MRA types love to focus on those evil, evil women laying in wait with their penis fly traps to steal the seed and "rightful" earnings of poor unsuspecting men. The reality is that most child support is ordered after a long term relationship ends and the child (or children) are old enough to call him daddy. Only a very small percentage of child support is ordered to infants born of a short term relationship.

Pregnancy coercion is more likely to be a man's game. There was a recent their study which showed that nearly 20% of women in their teens and 20's experienced coercion (had their partners threaten to leave them if they did not get pregnant, for example) and 15% had their birth control sabotaged. These actions are often accompanied by violence or abuse.

I'm not one of those "MRA types" and I don't think that there are "evil, evil women laying in wait with their penis fly traps to steal the seed and 'rightful' earnings of poor unsuspecting men." I agree that the issue is often a red herring -- or just plain derailing. As you said, most child support is ordered to children born out of long term relationships. Comparatively speaking, in a reproductive rights discussion, this issue doesn't deserve much attention.

But other than that (and I'll try to make this short so the main discussion can continue), in the relatively rare cases when it happens, do you really think men shouldn't be allowed to refuse responsibility for a child while the mother is still able to abort? I'm saying this not so much from a MRA point of view, but from the perspective that having no children should be legitimized as a life choice (I have had people wish I impregnated my girlfriend by accident because we don't want to have children :|). I most definitely don't think that women profit from having someone else's babies. That would be an extremely stupid and ineffectual way to earn a living. But still, I am concerned about the right not to have children. It doesn't affect my life because my partner doesn't want children; but I recognize that things are often more complicated for other couples.
 
Last edited:
I think you're confusing me with someone else. I've never said anything remotely like that. Everyone's responsible for all their choices, regardless of whether it's "fair" or not that they have those choices.

That is the exact consequence of what you said - that women may choose to have a child that theoir partner does not want, and the courts will force the man to subsidize her choice. This is what you argue for.



If the unwilling father was unwilling to be a father, he should have taken better care of where, when, and how he distributed his semen. I believe people should have the right to own guns, but I also think they should be held fully responsible of where the bullets they fire go.

Do you believe that if a man goes in half with a woman to buy a gun, but tells her not to shoot someone with it, he is responsible when she does so anyway? That is what you are argueing for.



Really? Women can control where their semen falls? News to me. I guess I know less about women and how their penises operate than I thought.

Don't be silly. Women have all the same birth control options that a man has, and they have complete control over what happens to the fetus after conception.

But yes, they should insist the bastard wear a condom, and are fools not to. That they don't doesn't make the man any less a fool for not wearing one, either.

Nor should it make a man any more responsible for her choosing to carry to term.



I'm not the one expecting life to be "fair". I accept the constraints of biology and recognize that ultimate responsiblity for the distribution of my semen and the consequences thereof is mine. That others could have done something at some points doesn't remove my responsibility.

There is no biological constraint involved with this legal double standard. none.
 
That is the exact consequence of what you said - that women may choose to have a child that theoir partner does not want, and the courts will force the man to subsidize her choice. This is what you argue for.

Do you believe that if a man goes in half with a woman to buy a gun, but tells her not to shoot someone with it, he is responsible when she does so anyway? That is what you are argueing for.


Don't be silly. Women have all the same birth control options that a man has, and they have complete control over what happens to the fetus after conception.

Nor should it make a man any more responsible for her choosing to carry to term.


There is no biological constraint involved with this legal double standard. none.

See the question in my ETA above.

When Congress or states pass laws that are based on a mistrust of males and that single out males for the prohibition of medical procedures they freely choose with a doctor's consent, then I'll begin to believe that man have equal or less reproductive freedom than women.
 
But other than that (and I'll try to make this short so the main discussion can continue), in the relatively rare cases when it happens, do you really think men shouldn't be allowed to refuse responsibility for a child while the mother is still able to abort? I'm saying this not so much from a MRA point of view, but from the perspective that having no children should be legitimized as a life choice (I have had people wish I impregnated my girlfriend by accident because we don't want to have children :|). I most definitely don't think that women profit from having someone else's babies. That would be an extremely stupid and ineffectual way to earn a living. But still, I am concerned about the right not to have children. It doesn't affect my life because my partner doesn't want children; but I recognize that things are often more complicated for other couples.

It's so easy for a man to fix it so he doesn't have unwanted children. Vasectomies are outpatient procedures. They can even be reversed if you change your mind later. And condoms are fairly widely available. What's the failure rate of both together? Infinitesimal, if that high!

Women are responsible for the wombal area. Men are responsible for the semenical targetation. Whether that target is the deceptively fertile womb of a gold-digging hussy, the interior of a cheap prophylactic, or the face of that hot neighbor of mine in #201, that's where our responsibility lies. Lays. Uh, is.
 
Having an abortion is is a form of birth control. It is taking responsibility. As for men - everything TragicMonkey said.

I know how you MRA types love to focus on those evil, evil women laying in wait with their penis fly traps to steal the seed and "rightful" earnings of poor unsuspecting men. The reality is that most child support is ordered after a long term relationship ends and the child (or children) are old enough to call him daddy. Only a very small percentage of child support is ordered to infants born of a short term relationship. [/qutoe]

Inaccurate and irrelevent. I am not an MRA type. I am a "take responsibility for your choices or stop whining about a desire to be treated equally" type.

Pregnancy coercion is more likely to be a man's game. There was a recent their study which showed that nearly 20% of women in their teens and 20's experienced coercion (had their partners threaten to leave them if they did not get pregnant, for example) and 15% had their birth control sabotaged. These actions are often accompanied by violence or abuse.

Again with the irrelevencies. This discussion has nothing to do with pregnancy coercion.

Men, as Monkey has so eloquently stated, have every opportunity to prevent pregnancy. They can use either condoms or a vasectomy. This is not fair. Women have no vasectomy equivalent - there is no simple, inexpensive, reversible surgery that will allow for full or temporary sterilization. Most doctors won't even consider a tubal ligation for a woman in her 20's because of the threat of a malpractice suit.

Bull, and more bull. Women have more contraceptive choices than men do - period.

If a man chooses to ignore his options, he may be faced with an unintended pregnancy. If he has chosen his sex partner unwisely, he may need to pay child support for a child that he does not want. There are financial repercussions for mistakes. Thousands of people are losing their homes because they made a poor decision. They don't get their money back because the real estate market misled them.

Extrodinarily poorly constructed analogy. Very few consumers were forced by the law to purchase a house they expressely said they did not want.

Child welfare exists because society recognizes a child's right to support from both parents. Abortion is a woman's right because it is her body. In both cases the father's rights are secondary because his body, health and well-being are not being directly affected. That's the problem right there - the idea that a woman or child could have rights that trump a man's.

Ascribe the motives you fear to someone else. I've stated my case clearly - and it is based on fairness before the law. That you disaprove of the concept does not make me a villain.
 
Extrodinarily poorly constructed analogy. Very few consumers were forced by the law to purchase a house they expressely said they did not want.

What if the consumers put in a bid for a house, won it, and then tried to back out? If they really didn't want to run the risk of home ownership, maybe they shouldn't have hired a real estate agent, gone to look at houses, gotten approval for a mortgage, and put in a bid.
 
Having an abortion is is a form of birth control. It is taking responsibility. As for men - everything TragicMonkey said.

I know how you MRA types love to focus on those evil, evil women laying in wait with their penis fly traps to steal the seed and "rightful" earnings of poor unsuspecting men. The reality is that most child support is ordered after a long term relationship ends and the child (or children) are old enough to call him daddy. Only a very small percentage of child support is ordered to infants born of a short term relationship.

Inaccurate and irrelevent. I am not an MRA type. I am a "take responsibility for your choices or stop whining about a desire to be treated equally" type.

Yet you have a problem with a man taking responsibility for a pregnancy he caused.

Again with the irrelevencies. This discussion has nothing to do with pregnancy coercion.

You are claiming that women are forcing men to be fathers in order to get at their wallets. In reality, when someone is trying to force a person to be a parent against their wishes, it is more likely to be a man.

Bull, and more bull. Women have more contraceptive choices than men do - period.

Let's look at these choices shall we. There's the pill - massive amounts of hormones that trick the body into thinking it is already pregnant with all the hormonal issues and secondary health problems that go along with that. Or they can use an IUD which can lead to sterility. Or they can use a barrier method like the sponge or a diaphragm, which have a 10% failure rate when used properly. Or they can have an abortion which is an intrusive surgery. Or they can trust a man to wear a condom (see pregnancy coercion, above.) Yep, women have it so good.

But really, how is the amount of birth control options relevant?

Extrodinarily poorly constructed analogy. Very few consumers were forced by the law to purchase a house they expressely said they did not want.

All consumers decided to buy a house and are now underwater because of that decision. They can walk away but they may still face bankruptcy.

Ascribe the motives you fear to someone else. I've stated my case clearly - and it is based on fairness before the law. That you disaprove of the concept does not make me a villain.

What you are proposing is not "fair" and is far removed from law. You are saying that no man should be expected to take responsibility for where he plants his seed simply because he does not have final say.

If abortion did not exist, we would not be having this conversation. Any man who got a woman pregnant would be expected to support the child.
 
I'm not one of those "MRA types" and I don't think that there are "evil, evil women laying in wait with their penis fly traps to steal the seed and 'rightful' earnings of poor unsuspecting men." I agree that the issue is often a red herring -- or just plain derailing. As you said, most child support is ordered to children born out of long term relationships. Comparatively speaking, in a reproductive rights discussion, this issue doesn't deserve much attention.

But other than that (and I'll try to make this short so the main discussion can continue), in the relatively rare cases when it happens, do you really think men shouldn't be allowed to refuse responsibility for a child while the mother is still able to abort? I'm saying this not so much from a MRA point of view, but from the perspective that having no children should be legitimized as a life choice (I have had people wish I impregnated my girlfriend by accident because we don't want to have children :|). I most definitely don't think that women profit from having someone else's babies. That would be an extremely stupid and ineffectual way to earn a living. But still, I am concerned about the right not to have children. It doesn't affect my life because my partner doesn't want children; but I recognize that things are often more complicated for other couples.

In the very rare cases when it happens, the most important person in the equation is the child. In order for that child to have the best chance of growing into a productive member of society, it will need resources from both parents. If the father expects society to pick up the slack because he was stupid about who he slept with, he is irresponsible.
 
In the very rare cases when it happens, the most important person in the equation is the child. In order for that child to have the best chance of growing into a productive member of society, it will need resources from both parents. If the father expects society to pick up the slack because he was stupid about who he slept with, he is irresponsible.

And I suspect in reality, many orders for child support go unpaid with no attempt made to enforce them. I'm only going from anecdotes, but it makes some sense, especially when the parents are divorced or estranged. Sometimes the only way a woman can get away from the father is to shoulder the costs of child support herself.

ETA: But child support really is a separate issue from reproductive freedom.
 
What if the consumers put in a bid for a house, won it, and then tried to back out?

Then I'd be fine with making the consumers honor the contract. of course, that is nearly the opposite of what happens when a women chooses to havw a baby against the expressed wishes of her partner.

In fact, the law allows for consumers to put in a bid for a house, have the offer accepted, then back out of the deal without penalty.

If they really didn't want to run the risk of home ownership, maybe they shouldn't have hired a real estate agent, gone to look at houses, gotten approval for a mortgage, and put in a bid.


Do you not see just how far off this comparison is? In your analogy, the buyers are actually in the market for a house to start with. In our actual circumstance, the man isn't looking for a house at all, but because the woman is, the man is forced to buy her one.
 
And I suspect in reality, many orders for child support go unpaid with no attempt made to enforce them. I'm only going from anecdotes, but it makes some sense, especially when the parents are divorced or estranged. Sometimes the only way a woman can get away from the father is to shoulder the costs of child support herself.

ETA: But child support really is a separate issue from reproductive freedom.

Less than half of single parents (male and female, btw) receive all the child support they are owed.
 
Last edited:
Then I'd be fine with making the consumers honor the contract. of course, that is nearly the opposite of what happens when a women chooses to havw a baby against the expressed wishes of her partner.

In fact, the law allows for consumers to put in a bid for a house, have the offer accepted, then back out of the deal without penalty.




Do you not see just how far off this comparison is? In your analogy, the buyers are actually in the market for a house to start with. In our actual circumstance, the man isn't looking for a house at all, but because the woman is, the man is forced to buy her one.

Oh, for god's sake, I rent an apartment. I have no interest in following through what you yourself said is a bad metaphor.

Why can't you accept that the man, due to biological realities, has a shorter time limit on decision to have a kid or not? The woman doesn't get a longer time to decide because of favoritism in law, she gets a longer time to decide because it's her damned uterus. He controls the semen, she controls the uterus. That's how it is. What you seem to want is some magical remedy in law that allows the man to enjoy his biological reality while at the same time granting him equal right as the woman over her biological reality. Does she get a say in whether he has a vasectomy or not? And if he chooses not to can she have the kid and then dump it on him, and absolve herself of legal responsibility for the kid? Of course not.

You can't have your cake and eat it, too. She can't, why should he?
 
Then I'd be fine with making the consumers honor the contract. of course, that is nearly the opposite of what happens when a women chooses to havw a baby against the expressed wishes of her partner.

In fact, the law allows for consumers to put in a bid for a house, have the offer accepted, then back out of the deal without penalty.




Do you not see just how far off this comparison is? In your analogy, the buyers are actually in the market for a house to start with. In our actual circumstance, the man isn't looking for a house at all, but because the woman is, the man is forced to buy her one.


Ok, you're pretty worked up, so how big a problem is this? Specifically, what percentage of child support is actually paid to a woman who became pregnant specifically to force a man to support her?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom