Abortion effectively outlawed in S.Dakota

So women can have all the sex they want, and take none of the responsibility for protection, because they can choose whether or not a man will be trapped into paying for the product of her activity?



That is a complete mischaracterization of my position.

Accurately, you advocate for women to have the option to force a man to provide for a child he did not desire, simply because she did desire it. You would force him to subsidize her choices.



Did you miss that I am pro-choice?



Abortion exists, it incidentally benefits men, it directly benefits irresponsible women, and it should remain a womans option - and the man should not be held hostage to her whims.



So - you are fine with a clear double standard so long as it is the woman that benefits from it?

Bull crap. For me, abortion exists (properly) for women, and I would have it so that women take responsibility for their own choices. You would have it as it is - women get 100% of the choice, but only 50% of the responsibility.

If men and women share equally in the responsibility to prevent unwanted pregnancies, and men and women share equally in the responsibility to care for wanted children, and women have 100% of the authority to choose whether or not to carry a pregnancy to term, in spite of the man's desires, then women should bear 100% of the responsibility for raising such a child.

You are saying that men have no responsibility if a woman gets pregnant because she has access to abortion. Even though men have access to cheap, effective birth control that has practically no side effects.

Adults understand that they can not control every aspect of a situation but will still need to take responsibility if they are involved. It is childish to focus on "fair" especially when the differences are based on something as fundamental as anatomy.
 
You are saying that men have no responsibility if a woman gets pregnant because she has access to abortion. Even though men have access to cheap, effective birth control that has practically no side effects.

Adults understand that they can not control every aspect of a situation but will still need to take responsibility if they are involved. It is childish to focus on "fair" especially when the differences are based on something as fundamental as anatomy.

You're missing something there, Kitty.

Sarge is saying that if the decision to abort or not is 100% the woman's, then "men have no responsibility if a woman gets pregnant and chooses to carry it to term". 100% of the decision is the woman's, 100% of the responsibility is the woman's.


Note that I am not endorsing either side of the argument with this post, just trying to mediate between the two sides.
 
Yes, the problem is clear. But the proposed remedy gives ALL men the ability to avoid responsibility ALL the time. I don't see how that's better. So as long as it's unfair either way, why not choose the outcome that's better for the child and better for the taxpayers?
 
Yes, the problem is clear. But the proposed remedy gives ALL men the ability to avoid responsibility ALL the time. I don't see how that's better. So as long as it's unfair either way, why not choose the outcome that's better for the child and better for the taxpayers?

So there's no middle ground to be had?
 
No.

The law defines murder. The law defines it differently in this case, depending on who does the killing. That is an inherently illogical proposition. Either an unborn child is a human or it is not. if it is, then killing it is usually wrong. if it is not, then whether or not to abort is a decision best left soley to the bearer - and anyone else causeing its death should bear a punishment appropriate for a property crime.





That isn't circular logic. That is you attempting to answer a legal question with philosophy.

The law defines murder - and in this case defines it differently depending on who is doing the killing. That is a double standard. I'd prefer to remove the double standard. If it isn't murder when the mom does it, it shouldn't be murder when someone else does it.





Sure - so long as the mother does not get to terminate the pregnancy without the consent of the father. Heck, I'll even go so far as to allow the mother to carry to term, then not have to provide support for the child she didn't want.


No, the more logical circumstance would for the mother to retain complete control over whether or not she has the child, then bear the responsibility if the father swore off parental rights before the child is born.

The argument could be made that the fetus presents an imminent danger to the health of the pregnant woman while it does not present any danger to the health of someone attacking the pregnant woman (i.e. self defense-esque)
 
If men and women share equally in the responsibility to prevent unwanted pregnancies, and men and women share equally in the responsibility to care for wanted children, and women have 100% of the authority to choose whether or not to carry a pregnancy to term, in spite of the man's desires, then women should bear 100% of the responsibility for raising such a child.

I disagree with you, but I see your point.

If I want to be pregnant and my guy does not, I can lie and say I'm using birth control. Then when I get pregnant, even though he doesn't want a baby, I demand child support. That's unfair, even in my book. (I guess all guys who do not want to be fathers should insist on using a condom and spermicide.)

If I DON'T want a baby, but my guy does, I can always hide the abortion from him. That's unfair too, BUT -- as was mentioned upthread, the alternative is requiring the guy's permission and acceptance for the abortion, and I think that's equally unfair to the woman.

Honestly, I think the reason the decision lies with the woman is because ultimately she has to carry the fetus for 40 weeks. Before I got pregnant, I thought it would be this wonderful amazing time, and I'm sure it might be for some women. But it's a nightmare for others, and hell for some. I'm sure most women forget the unpleasant parts, but the problems I've had already would make me not wish pregnancy on my worst enemy.
 
If you've got a suggestion, I'm happy to hear it.

This is, as I posted before, not my argument, either way. I was simply clarifying Sarge's position because Kitty seemed intent on missing it.

You, however, have criticisms of the one and claim the other is simply "the better choice of the two", but isn't that presenting this as a false dichotomy? At the very least, it's just telling anyone who disagrees with you "tough ****". Surely you have more to offer the discussion than that?
 
Perhaps the woman decides this time, then the man decides the next. ;)
 
How and why does that make them human or not? You know that animals have language and memories, and severe autism may include no language ability?

Do animals form complex languages? Do they exhibit tendencies of sentient intelligence?
 
If I want to be pregnant and my guy does not, I can lie and say I'm using birth control. Then when I get pregnant, even though he doesn't want a baby, I demand child support. That's unfair, even in my book. (I guess all guys who do not want to be fathers should insist on using a condom and spermicide.)
Indeed, that would be the recommended option if you think the woman is likely to pull a trick like that.

If I DON'T want a baby, but my guy does, I can always hide the abortion from him. That's unfair too, BUT -- as was mentioned upthread, the alternative is requiring the guy's permission and acceptance for the abortion, and I think that's equally unfair to the woman.

Honestly, I think the reason the decision lies with the woman is because ultimately she has to carry the fetus for 40 weeks.
I have no quibble with the slight injustice involved in that. The woman's right to choose what happens with her body vastly outweighs the man's desire to have a child to raise.

Exploring the options - let's see what happens if we give the guy an OPTION to relinquish responsibility for the fetus prior to its birth (practically speaking, some time before the third trimester):
* If he chooses to do so, he also has to pay a deposit which will go to cover either the full cost of the abortion, or part of the medical expenses for the birth. This is in acknowledgement of the shared responsibility. If the woman chooses to have an abortion, her share of the burden comes from physical discomfort and psychological trauma.
* If the woman doesn't inform him in time, no responsibility should fall on him.
* If he is informed but fails to respond in time, this is counted as not excercising his option.
* If neither parent knows of the pregnancy in time, what then? (This is more common than you might think). And how do you tell the "she didn't know" case from "chose not to inform him"?

This, at first glance, appears "fair" - both parties have an option to skip out of the burden of raising the child. The woman retains control over whether or not the fetus is aborted, with full financial burden if she chooses not to, but also prior knowledge that this is how it will be.

The problem is that choosing an abortion is a very personal decision. A woman who for religious or philosophical reasons is opposed to abortion will now face the full cost of raising the child, with (from her perspective) no option to avoid it. Even without such philosophical issues, there's a significant financial pressure for her to have the abortion if the man doesn't wish to share the burden. Raising a child as a single parent is no joking matter.

Another problem arises within a marriage. Here, the power swings the other way - the woman has full control over whether or not the child is born, and the husband cannot avoid financial responsibility (well, I suppose divorce is an option, but that can be a lengthy procedure). Even more fun when the husband isn't the father...
 
This is, as I posted before, not my argument, either way. I was simply clarifying Sarge's position because Kitty seemed intent on missing it.

You, however, have criticisms of the one and claim the other is simply "the better choice of the two", but isn't that presenting this as a false dichotomy? At the very least, it's just telling anyone who disagrees with you "tough ****". Surely you have more to offer the discussion than that?

I accept criticisms of both, and am unaware of any other options, so I am not intentionally presenting a false dichotomy. I evaluate one undesirable option as being worse than the other. If there is another option, I'm quite interested.
 
This I agree with--I think that introducing laws that define an unborn fetus as a person ARE a double-standard and that it shouldn't be considered murder. I think it should still be a crime, however, as a violent act on the mother.

I would consider that to be a more desirable situation.

Even if taxpayers have to pick up the slack?

Well, yes. If we say that the father has no choice, then the father can have no responsibility. In that case, society is exactly the correct agency to provide a social safety net.

You are presenting a dilemma--something where all the outcomes are in some way undesirable or unfair. I can give a reason why my flawed remedy is better than your flawed remedy: It doesn't result in passing a burden to people that had nothing to do with the child's birth-- that can be invoked by any father-to-be just by declaring it.

I disagree, but can find no real flaw with you reasoning, except that so long as society insists the father gets no choice, then society should rightly bear responsibility for the costs.
 
I accept criticisms of both, and am unaware of any other options, so I am not intentionally presenting a false dichotomy. I evaluate one undesirable option as being worse than the other. If there is another option, I'm quite interested.

I would say that we could leave it to the Courts to decide each case...but then, the Courts would likely take too long and the pregnancy would be over before a decision could be handed down.

Perhaps a Court appointed mediator. Allow the man and woman to discuss the options and their desires.

If a male takes precautions and still winds up impregnating a female, I would be inclined to grant him no responsibility for a pregnancy the female decides to carry to term. I would allow the converse of this to be a valid point for the female as well - say the female wants an abortion and the male doesn't. If the female can show that she took precautions (BC, morning-after pill, spermicide, etc) and still was impregnated and does not wish to carry the fetus to term, she should be allowed to abort - or if she decides to carry to term out of deference to the male's desires, she should be free from any obligation to the child.


Note that I realize there would still be issues this doesn't really cover - but at least it offers some protection for men and women from being responsible for children they took measures against having.
 
You are saying that men have no responsibility if a woman gets pregnant because she has access to abortion.

That isn't even close to what I am trying to say - and I hope that I am simply not expressing myself well.

Both men and women have the opportunity to prevent pregnancy, and both have some responsibility (equal, probably) if pregnancy occurs. After that point, however, only the woman has any control over what happens. So long as that is the case, the woman should bear full responsiblity for the consequences of her decision.

Even though men have access to cheap, effective birth control that has practically no side effects.

If he gets her pregnant, he is 50% responsible, and should bear half the costs of any decisions he is allowed to make that influences the progress of the pregnancy.

Adults understand that they can not control every aspect of a situation but will still need to take responsibility if they are involved. It is childish to focus on "fair" especially when the differences are based on something as fundamental as anatomy.

It is more childish to insist on having it all.
 
Yes, the problem is clear. But the proposed remedy gives ALL men the ability to avoid responsibility ALL the time. I don't see how that's better. So as long as it's unfair either way, why not choose the outcome that's better for the child and better for the taxpayers?

I disagree that this is the outcome.

If the choice remains the womans, she may have the child or not. If the father also wishes to have the child, he is on the hook. If he does not wish to have the child, he is off the hook. He gets exactly the same choices as the woman, without having the slightest control over her. She actually still retains the greater choice - she gets to have the baby regardless of his decision, while his ability to father a child rests entire in her hand.
 
I disagree with you, but I see your point.

If I want to be pregnant and my guy does not, I can lie and say I'm using birth control. Then when I get pregnant, even though he doesn't want a baby, I demand child support. That's unfair, even in my book. (I guess all guys who do not want to be fathers should insist on using a condom and spermicide.)

If I DON'T want a baby, but my guy does, I can always hide the abortion from him. That's unfair too, BUT -- as was mentioned upthread, the alternative is requiring the guy's permission and acceptance for the abortion, and I think that's equally unfair to the woman.

Honestly, I think the reason the decision lies with the woman is because ultimately she has to carry the fetus for 40 weeks. Before I got pregnant, I thought it would be this wonderful amazing time, and I'm sure it might be for some women. But it's a nightmare for others, and hell for some. I'm sure most women forget the unpleasant parts, but the problems I've had already would make me not wish pregnancy on my worst enemy.

I do not propose that the father have any authority over the decision to abort. I merely propose that the current situation makes the father responsible for something he has no control over.
 
I disagree that this is the outcome.

If the choice remains the womans, she may have the child or not. If the father also wishes to have the child, he is on the hook. If he does not wish to have the child, he is off the hook. He gets exactly the same choices as the woman, without having the slightest control over her. She actually still retains the greater choice - she gets to have the baby regardless of his decision, while his ability to father a child rests entire in her hand.

The asymmetry in this situation flows from the basic fact that one gender, you know, actually has the baby growing inside of them.

Male choice exists prior to insemination. You're making a strong argument for men to be more responsible for birth control.

Once that egg is fertilized, it's the woman's choice, and yes, if you father a child, you pay for it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom