9/11 New information.

I suspect it's a reference to NISTS's finding that WTC 7 collapsed at "40% longer than freefall."

Thank you Dave. This lot seem to forget everything they say after they say it. It was one of them who mentioned 40% longer after I mentioned free-fall, but they have now conveniently forgotten. Now watch them all suddenly remember again, and say that they didn't understand because I didn't say it right.

I'm beginning to see that many of the voices here don't actually know what they are talking about, and just spout any old rubbish. As long as it is anti-truth rubbish, what does it matter? They will tie you up in pointless little side arguments using all sorts of debating tricks, and then turn around and say that is what I am doing. They just say everything is wrong, or not proven, or has no evidence, or is just plain daft, forgetting that they have absolutely no evidence themselves, and would not stand up to their own scrutiny.

If I ask them to prove something, they don't have to. It happened on 9/11, why do we have to prove it, when you can see it? The worst sort of BS there is. Some will agree when you get right down to the specifics when they have no wriggle room, but they rest will just cry BS, and try to distract you with things they accuse you of saying due to their inference.

Look below, when I talk about explosions, they deny explosives, or actually confirm explosions, but say that's irrelevant. It's not irrelevant when NIST said there were no explosions at all. Ever. Anywhere. Not even a bang. You could hear a pin drop.

It's the problem when dealing with certain people like NIST, and funnily enough what truthers are accused of: making a mistake, and then trying to deny any mounting evidence, rather than just manning up, owning it, and working out something else that takes it into account. And you paid these guys **** loads for them to lie to you, might as well let them run for president.
 
Ok, now the claim makes sense. The '40% freefall theory' sounds ridiculous without the qualification.

Ironically the 40 percent never changed for the period NIST was talking about... , as noted above...

he never said which building, just BS about 40 percent, which can't change for the event, thus the statement was more BS


We've had the 40% free fall theory, which is also 100% correct, until you show that it isn't.
NIST said WTC 7 18 stories took 40 percent longer than computed free-fall time. It never changed... What was the point?

Out of context BS, which means someone never read NIST... lol

Which building? lol
 
Last edited:
Look below, when I talk about explosions, they deny explosives, or actually confirm explosions, but say that's irrelevant. It's not irrelevant when NIST said there were no explosions at all. Ever. Anywhere. Not even a bang. You could hear a pin drop.

When did the NIST say this? Please post the reference in full context. (the video you posted proves you have no clue).

Edited by zooterkin: 
Edited for rule 0/12.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Look below, when I talk about explosions, they deny explosives, or actually confirm explosions, but say that's irrelevant. It's not irrelevant when NIST said there were no explosions at all. Ever. Anywhere. Not even a bang. You could hear a pin drop..

LOL, it was a train, I have a quote it sounded like a train...

Simile will get you BS.

NIST never said there were no loud noises.

I like the Sonic Boom you posted, cool...

What would be making loud sounds after the towers collapsed and before WTC 7 collapsed in the middle of the day? What? You posted BS to support what? There were no explosives used to bring down the WTC.

Next...
 
Look below, when I talk about explosions, they deny explosives, or actually confirm explosions, but say that's irrelevant. It's not irrelevant when NIST said there were no explosions at all. Ever. Anywhere. Not even a bang. You could hear a pin drop.

Pretty sure NIST never said that let alone the further absurdity you go on to mention.
What NIST said, I'm paraphrasing, is that there were no sounds recorded that are consistent with high explosives that would be required to sever the large columns of the WTC structures.

Having worked in a lumber yard I can attest to the fact that dropping dimensional lumber pieces onto other pieces will make a sound extremely similar to a gunshot. Similarily large, heavy objects dropping , easily sounds like an explosion yet lacks the sharp retort that results from the supersonic pressure wave from high explosives that cut through thick steel. IOW the sound of high explosives is distinct from a large number of sounds that humans would describe as explosive.
Therein lies the rub. While truthers are quite happy to accept literal veracity of witness descriptions, skeptics require that the physical and/or documentary(ie. the recordings) evidence conform to the details that must apply if those witnesses are correct.
 
Last edited:
It's not irrelevant when NIST said there were no explosions at all. Ever. Anywhere. Not even a bang. You could hear a pin drop.

Not sure how you got from "no explosions" to "you could hear a pin drop". Lots of things that aren't explosions make loud noises. Like... oh I don't know... buildings collapsing?
 
This may be old news to some of you, but I only stumbled across it recently.

What do you think to the research carried out by this guy?

http://zkt.blackfish.org.uk/119/Simple_CD_Models_WTC1.pdf

I think he makes a classic "error" in thinking that the stronger more robust columns as you move down would provide increasing resistance to the collapse.

But this is not what was "collapsing". What has collapse / being destroyed in the first case were the floor slabs... which were the same thickness and strength and offered the same resistance at any ht in the building (the mech floors were a bit stronger).

The columns were BY PASSED in the collapse... and they had nothing to do with it or resisted it in any way. The columns were "victims" which could not remain stable and standing without the BRACING which was provided by the floor plates. As the floor plates "collapsed" were crushed and destroyed... the axial members became increasingly unstable and toppled, buckled and fell from what are essentially Euler forces, vibration and jostling leading to weakening and or failing of steel column and surviving core beam connections. Facade steel peeled off... core steel buckled and toppled after being stripped of bracing. Core managed to survive for perhaps 14 seconds before being over come by Euler forces etc.

Also the floors which were "collapsing" in the upper 12 floors were engaging the floors beginning at the floor 97 and destroying those below over the 3.75 seconds it took for the top to disappear. The destruction during those 3.75 seconds involved multiple upper floors at the top of the "intact" section obscured by the facade and the falling debris canopy.

Another reductionist detail focused missing the forest for the trees argument.
 
Pretty much what JSanderO has just said. The author is addressing the Bazant/Zhou model as if it described what actually happened, rather than the limiting case it was intended to be.

I got about 3 paragraphs into the piece before giving up.
 
I think a lot of people who have tried to model, or calculate the collapse make some very basic errors.

Treating the "above impact" sections as a solid block, for example, is just downright lunacy.

Extrapolating simple equations beyond a reasonable time frame. As an example, I remember when obesity was big in the news, particularly amongst children. Some idiot calling themselves a researcher (I won't call them a scientist) plotted the data, and extrapolated that because we had had a jump from insignificant to 5%, it would follow that by 2030 we would see 25% of children classed as clinically obese.

Are Euler forces still considered?
 
I think a lot of people who have tried to model, or calculate the collapse make some very basic errors.

Are Euler forces still considered?

How do you explain the fact that a too slender column will buckled... or even the nothing that a columns CAN BE TOO SLENDER? That's Euler. That's what made the spire and remaining core columns come down.
 
Last edited:
It's the problem when dealing with certain people like NIST, and funnily enough what truthers are accused of: making a mistake, and then trying to deny any mounting evidence, rather than just manning up, owning it, and working out something else that takes it into account.

Like, say, the mistake of saying "We've had the 40% free fall theory, which is also 100% correct, until you show that it isn't," then pretending that anybody should be able to figure out that you meant "NIST made the observation that the total collapse time of WTC7 was 40% longer than would be expected from freefall," which is neither "40% freefall" nor a "theory", and has never been challenged or withdrawn. And this as one of your central examples of the inconsistency of the "official story".

Look, you are shockingly ignorant of the facts surrounding 9/11 - I mean, you even thought the invasion of Afghanistan came after the invasion of Iraq, for FSM's sake - yet the moment anybody tries to educate you, you respond with snark and ridicule and pretend you know better than anyone else. The first stage in learning is to admit that you don't know everything already, and however much you pretend otherwise, you're nowhere nearer taking that first step. Until you can, and given that your views are pretty much irrelevant, why should any of us bother with you any more?

Dave
 
Whatever, can you tell me what the current theory is, say for WTC 1 collapsing as it did, at the speed it did, and we'll go from there. Or WTC 2. Or even WTC 7? Pick one, tell me what the latest, up to date, best we can do with the data theory is, and we'll discuss it.
The most current hypothesis for the collapse progression of WTC 1 and 2 is the pancake collapse one described by FEMA and later supported by the evidence presented by forum poster Major_Tom.

To save us another round of "but didn't NIST say...", NIST rejected FEMA's hypothesis of collapse initiation. NIST doesn't comment on FEMA's description of collapse progression, which is the specific part of FEMA's hypothesis I'm talking about.

https://www.fema.gov/pdf/library/fema403_ch2.pdf section 2.2.1.5 p.2-27.
What happened about the highlighted bit? I thought you were willing to discuss it. But man, is it difficult to get you to focus.
 
I think a lot of people who have tried to model, or calculate the collapse make some very basic errors.

Treating the "above impact" sections as a solid block, for example, is just downright lunacy.

Extrapolating simple equations beyond a reasonable time frame. As an example, I remember when obesity was big in the news, particularly amongst children. Some idiot calling themselves a researcher (I won't call them a scientist) plotted the data, and extrapolated that because we had had a jump from insignificant to 5%, it would follow that by 2030 we would see 25% of children classed as clinically obese.

Are Euler forces still considered?
www.me.berkeley.edu/~lwlin/me128/BeamDeflection.pdf

That paper will explain a lot of what you don't understand, the connections simply were not strong enough to hold the buildings together.
They fell like a house of cards, once the connections sheered it really is and always was that simple.
 
NIST also agrees with the "pancake theory".

Immediately after collapse initiation, the potential energy of the structure (physical mass of the tower) above the impact floors (94th to 99th in WTC 1 and 77th to 85th in WTC 2) was re- leased, developing substantial kinetic en- ergy. The impact of this rapidly accelerat- ing mass on the floors directly below led to overloading and subsequent failure of these floors. The additional mass of the failed floors joined that of the tower mass from above the impact area, adding to the kinetic energy impinging on the subse- quent floors. The failure of successive floors was apparent in images and videos of the towers’ collapse by the compressed air expelled outward as each floor failed and fell down onto the next. This mecha- nism appears to have continued until dust and debris obscured the view of the col- lapsing towers.

https://app.aws.org/wj/supplement/WJ_2007_09_s263.pdf
 
Tell these men they didn't hear explosions https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5HTRJZujQj8

Tell these men what pressurised air blowing out windows sounds like https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eAAveeeVVfM

This one is obvious propaganda https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xvCU9Z9aWW0

Of course Firefighters for truth have testimony of 118 first responders who describe hearing explosions in their written testimonies that you are welcome to read.

...your true colors are showing...
 
<snip for focus>

Look below, when I talk about explosions, they deny explosives, or actually confirm explosions, but say that's irrelevant. It's not irrelevant when NIST said there were no explosions at all. Ever. Anywhere. Not even a bang. You could hear a pin drop.

<snip for focus>

I am certain you have copious, accurate, documented sources for this, right?

I call.
 

Summary of the failure of the truss connections to the perimeter columns:

"WELDING RESEARCH
SEPTEMBER 2007, VOL. 86
-s
272
Summary
Analysis of the connections supporting
the composite floor system of the WTC
towers showed that at and below the im-
pact floors, the greater majority (above
90%) of the floor truss connections were
either bent downward or completely re-
moved from the exterior column. This was
probably related to the overloading of the
floors below the impact region after col-
lapse initiation. Depending upon weld
joint geometry, detachment of the main
load-bearing seats was a result of either
fracture in the heat affected zone of the
base material (standoff plate detached
from spandrel) or through the weld metal
(seat angle detached from standoff plate).
Failure in both cases was assumed to be a
result of a shear mechanism as a result of
overloading from floors above impacting
those below. There did not appear to be a
significant change in distribution of failure
modes of the floor truss connections when
comparing those connections inside vs.
outside of the impact region or those ex-
posed to pre-collapse fires and those that
were not."
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom