9/11 New information.

Out of the box wrong... did you read Bazant? no
Bazant gave us the pancake theory, which was 100% correct, and would silence all of the truthers. Until it wasn't.
As already answered, Bazant did not give us a pancake theory. You might not want to visit Bazant, he used differential equations to explain how a building might collapse. It is a mathematical model based on his structural engineering expertise. Not sure how a model can be more than a model, but 911 truth out of ignorance attack Bazant because they know for sure, despite the fact non of them are structural engineers, a building can't collapse... it has to be CD; ignorance and fantasy. Of course Bazant's model ruins your NanoThermate BS fantasy.
A day or two after 911 Bazant wonders what kind of event the WTC was so he models the collapse, I bet it was on a napkin, with math. Gee, the WTC did collapse, why not estimate the possible interaction of the collapse with math.
A model... and 911 truth can't do math. thus we have this kind of failure to understand as you have done.
It is a model, by attacking it or making up BS statements like you did, it shows you have no point.

We've had the pile driver theory, and the piston pressurised air theories, which are also 100% correct. Until they aren't.
Pressurized air is truth, the air inside the WTC, of which 95 percent is air, has to go somewhere... thus this makes no sense.
What pile driver theory. The energy released is equal to 130 2000 pound bombs, yet you ignore it, unable to let go of the NanoThermate fantasy.
I imagine the top floors hitting the lower undamaged floor was like a pile driver with gravity driving it, as the lower floor fails instantly. It is hard to grasp instant; 911 truth can't.

We've had the "things fell, they were not ejected" theory, which is 100% correct, and yet NIST tells us that building 7 and other buildings took damage from ejected materials, which is also 100% correct. They could have said falling debris if that was what they meant.
Fell and ejected are kind of the same. After ejected, a part falls. Parts were ejected by the other stuff falling; I don't understand why an event, two events both equal in energy to 130 2000 pound bombs can't eject stuff as it falls. I can demo this with a simple collapse of my garage attic, with stuff ejected out of the garage all due to interaction in an earth gravity field... just like 911.

We've had the burning jet fuel theory, which of course was 100% correct, until it was no longer correct.
You mean people said it was jet fuel? Yes, 60,000 pounds of jet fuel hit the WTC towers, and set fires almost instantly on multiple floors, making 911 the biggest office fires set in seconds in history, with none of your NanoThermate BS.
Did jet fuel fires cause the collapse, no the jet fuel fires were a part of the chain of events leading to the collapse. cause and effect, a first grade tool, first grade, not used by 911.
The office fires caused the collapse. The office fires at the time of collapse had produced more heat energy than 2700 TONS of your fantasy NanoThermate. The jet fuel only had the heat energy of 315 TONS of TNT, thus you can ignore the jet fuel contribution since 630 TONS is less than 2700 TONS... and you can be like NIST, making engineering decisions, on the conservative side... BINGO
Your NanoThermate BS dust paper, has the heat energy that does not match thermite.... Paper and Plastic burning have more heat energy than the BS thermite fantasy lie.

We've had the 40% free fall theory, which is also 100% correct, until you show that it isn't.
The buildings collapsed as seen on video. Thus this is BS, no point, never will be.

We have the girder walk off theory for WTC7, which could never be wrong, until you look at the real facts.
Probable cause by NIST, it appears you failed to read it, and can't source what they said.
Probable, do you understand you can offer a different theory, but if you include NanoThermate, you are off in fantasy.
The interior of WTC 7 collapsed first, then one of the Penthouses falls into WTC 7, and then the roof begins to fall... A collapse over 18 seconds, and not close to free-fall. You have to include the entire system, and 911 truth is fixated on a single point falling for a short period near free-fall (gee on earth, who would guess) because the interior was Gone;
We've had the fuel oil fires theory, which is absolutely spot on, until it is ruled out.
Gee, if you say no oil fire, it is more conservative. But the fuel to run generators might leave more black smoke... who cares...
The office fires are what had the most heat energy on 911. Never seen a building survive a fire not fought with broken windows, and damage.
I know of building which were totaled by fire, 911 truth can't explain why fires destroys the strength of steel.
We have the no explosions explanation, until you hear the recordings and read the eye witness testimony, but of course, that is correct too.
There are no explosions from explosives. Simple.
You have no point to go with this BS. Does your NanoThermate make loud explosions?
Loud noises are not explosives. Simile can't save your NanoThermate.

We have the molten metal question, which doesn't exist, but if it does, then it's not steel therefore it doesn't count.
There was melted metal, no melted steel evidence.
You go some evidence for melted steel? No.
Show us some melted steel from the WTC...

You made up some new stuff, like 40 percent, don't remember seeing 40 percent free-fall. Is that a speed or acceleration.

Can you please tell me which theory we are supposed to be following now, so that we know what to talk about.
How is your NanoThermate theory going.
 
Last edited:
The theory I heard, which I cannot substantiate, is that historically speedometers were only tested to within a 10% threshold. Those of you who have experience of older cars may fondly remember the bouncing needles :) I think the idea was that you could counter sue the manufacturer if it wasn't reporting an accurate speed if you got a ticket, I'm not sure of the specifics.

Why even post this?
 
The theory I heard, which I cannot substantiate, is that historically speedometers were only tested to within a 10% threshold. Those of you who have experience of older cars may fondly remember the bouncing needles :) I think the idea was that you could counter sue the manufacturer if it wasn't reporting an accurate speed if you got a ticket, I'm not sure of the specifics.

No, the law says your speedo isn't allowed to under read, most are set to over read by a few mph.
It was the Association of Chief Police Officers that came up with the prosecution guidelines, up to now all forces stick to them.
 
Post 105
A relevant point Beachnut.
Not sure if everyone has these but in many places in Canada there are signs on the roadway warning "High Accident Intersection", or similar, some with flashing amber lights. Yet still those places see many accidents.

There is this 'thing' called human nature...............
Post 106
Give the man a cigar!
We are told that 'we need a new investigation'. Only then can another full explanation of the events of 9/11/01 (we need to start including the "01" every time now IMO).
However, one MUST have a reason for instituting a new, costly, investigation before embarking on one. That REQUIRES at the very least, a detailed list of the items to be investigated. The 911TM however would have any investigation running about contemplating mutually exclusive, some utterly ridiculous, lines of investigation, from nukes, to therm?te (ther?te as incidiary melting - therm?te as a 'match' for conventional demolition charges - therm?te as high explosive), to space beams, from hijacked planes, to remote control of civilian flights, to remote controlled drones, to modified 'substituted' planes, through to no planes at all, and on and on, and on....... It would never actually end since every time something was declared not in play, they would come up with another avenue to skip down. They complain about 'war without end' yet it certainly looks like if they had their way we'd see an 'investigation without end'. Certainly some with a monetary interest would not balk at having that come about.

I have seen TM proponents proclaim that this vast and various plethora of memes is their strength, that it demonstrates that there is something amiss with the 'official story'. No, IMHO, all it does is demonstrate that the 911TM is substituting their own fantasies for reality.

That's a very interesting point.(<<edit>> refers to post 105)

We have similar things over here. One of the common ones is "Flood", but there are others.

The "I pay my taxes" brigade, say if we know it floods time after time, why not fix the drainage issue!

If we know that there are a lot of accidents at a junction, redesign the junction.

Of course the "fix it" solution requires spending money.

The typical response by the authorities is usually to put up a speed camera, which generates revenue instead.

Of course, there is always this approach:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RFCrJleggrI

Great, now that we have beat roadway traffic issues to death and beyond, I note that you jumped on the strawman digression rather than the immediately following , on topic, post 106.


<<things that make ya go hmmmm>>
 
We have the no explosions explanation, until you hear the recordings and read the eye witness testimony, but of course, that is correct too.

Not much I can add to what has already been said.

One thing though, the only sounds of explosions I've heard (at the correct time) was during the film "9/11 Mysteries". The problem is, Sofia Smallstorm the creator of this film admitted to adding them in after the fact "for effect". This was back around 2008/9 (don't remember exactly).

Naturally if you have other examples I'd be glad to give a listen.
 
As in any scientific investigation, we are following the theory that best fits the available evidence right now. If more evidence emerges, the theory may have to be refined. That's just he way the world works. And so truthers use that inescapable fact of life to come up with a heads-I-Win, tails-you-lose argument: if no official information is published then the government is either covering something up or unable to get its story straight, and if information is published that is less than 100% perfect then the government is failing in its supposed duty to educate the willfully ignorant. Reality doesn't work that way.

Dave

Whatever, can you tell me what the current theory is, say for WTC 1 collapsing as it did, at the speed it did, and we'll go from there. Or WTC 2. Or even WTC 7? Pick one, tell me what the latest, up to date, best we can do with the data theory is, and we'll discuss it.
 
Whatever, can you tell me what the current theory is, say for WTC 1 collapsing as it did, at the speed it did, and we'll go from there. Or WTC 2. Or even WTC 7? Pick one, tell me what the latest, up to date, best we can do with the data theory is, and we'll discuss it.
Do you really think there is one current "official" theory? Do you think there can be?

There are several plausible theories (none include CD), no one ever claimed to know the exact cause (or claimed an "official" status)
 
Last edited:
Many people expected this to cover the mechanism by which the top damaged section led to the destruction of the largely intact lower section, however in their own words:


The only people who expected this were people who don't have even the most basic understanding of physics. The report wasn't produced for them.
 
Whatever, can you tell me what the current theory is, say for WTC 1 collapsing as it did, at the speed it did, and we'll go from there. Or WTC 2. Or even WTC 7? Pick one, tell me what the latest, up to date, best we can do with the data theory is, and we'll discuss it.

I can only tell you what I think happened. Structural members of WTC1 failed due to a combination of structural distortion, thermal weakening and load redistribution; at the point where they were no longer able to bear the weight of the top section, a cascade failure occurred, and once the top part of the building was in motion the lower part was overwhelmed by the dynamic load. Lots of people have calculated collapse times by different methods, and the ones that don't drive a coach and horses through the laws of physics give good agreement with the observed collapse times. None of that is particularly controversial except among those whose agenda it doesn't suit.

Dave
 
Talking of "theories" for collapse progression in the towers is silly. What NIST really revealed is that you can directly OBSERVE how progression occurred, if you know what you're looking at. Once you know what the structure of the towers is, if you have any semblance of intelligence, you can determine how collapse progression occurred just by watching it. It quite clearly wasn't a controlled demolition, wasn't an implosion, and wasn't anything else nefarious. Although it's probably the single most common 9/11 CT, I've never really understood why it exists.
 
Whatever, can you tell me what the current theory is, say for WTC 1 collapsing as it did, at the speed it did, and we'll go from there. Or WTC 2. Or even WTC 7? Pick one, tell me what the latest, up to date, best we can do with the data theory is, and we'll discuss it.

Fire caused the collapse of 1, 2, 7. Kind of the big picture, thus the fantasy of NanoThermate is BS.

A floor in the WTC tower can only hold 29,000,000 pounds. Thus we have the pile driver of mass, and the "pancake" of failing floors, and the core stripped of its lateral support...

LOL, you can call the gravity collapse anything you want, it was caused by fires not fought.

LOL, you waited 14 years to play can't figure it out?

Read NIST, what do they say.

And who cares what happens after initiation, the lower section can't stop the upper mass. Thus a study of the collapse after initiation can be limited to video, and understanding a floor fails with more than 29000000 pounds. It is kind of simple
The WTC is a system, floors, shell, core. The core and shell share the gravity load, the core and the shell hold up all the floors, and the shell is the reason the reason the WTC does not fall in high winds... If you remove or damage big parts of the floors, core, or shell, the WTC will fail. If you a WTC tower with a kinetic energy impact of planes, and add fires on multiple floors... the impact dislodges the fire proofing, and the fires quickly destroy the strength of steel. The building will fail.

You are confused the same as you were with alive terrorists; due to zero research.
What will happen to your theory of Nanothermate?
 
Not much I can add to what has already been said.

One thing though, the only sounds of explosions I've heard (at the correct time) was during the film "9/11 Mysteries". The problem is, Sofia Smallstorm the creator of this film admitted to adding them in after the fact "for effect". This was back around 2008/9 (don't remember exactly).

Naturally if you have other examples I'd be glad to give a listen.

Tell these men they didn't hear explosions https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5HTRJZujQj8

Tell these men what pressurised air blowing out windows sounds like https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eAAveeeVVfM

This one is obvious propaganda https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xvCU9Z9aWW0

Of course Firefighters for truth have testimony of 118 first responders who describe hearing explosions in their written testimonies that you are welcome to read.
 
No new information yet, I see you are giving up all pretence of any kind of neutrality as you work through the Truther playbook
 
Last edited:
Tell these men they didn't hear explosions https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5HTRJZujQj8

Why would I do this? Do you think things don't explode in fires? The operative words you missed was "at the correct time". CD explosions happen before the building is seen to fall. I know this because I've seen several live. I also know they are really, really load and can be heard (and felt)for miles. I have a deaf friend I go and see CD demolitions with. She loves them because she says it's the few things she can hear. (I go because she's cute and they're cool)

Tell these men what pressurised air blowing out windows sounds like https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eAAveeeVVfM

Why would I do this? Can they tell me what the collapse of a 110 foot structure should sound like?


Nice job. Now tell me about when in the day this happened and your reasoning. (Hint: It's well after the towers and way too early to have anything to do with WTC7).

Of course Firefighters for truth have testimony of 118 first responders who describe hearing explosions in their written testimonies that you are welcome to read.

What does this have to do with explosives? You're sounding more and more like a dyed in wool conspiracy theorist every day.
 
Last edited:
What does this have to do with explosives? You're sounding more and more like a dyed in wool conspiracy theorist every day.
This.^ He hasn't stopped Gish-galloping since he came.

@ AClark: This is Gish Gallop.


What the hell is 40% of free fall? A meaningless term.
Maybe it means that 40% of the stuff was falling freely and the remaining 60% was not? :D
 
Last edited:
Whatever, can you tell me what the current theory is, say for WTC 1 collapsing as it did, at the speed it did, and we'll go from there. Or WTC 2. Or even WTC 7? Pick one, tell me what the latest, up to date, best we can do with the data theory is, and we'll discuss it.
The most current hypothesis for the collapse progression of WTC 1 and 2 is the pancake collapse one described by FEMA and later supported by the evidence presented by forum poster Major_Tom.

To save us another round of "but didn't NIST say...", NIST rejected FEMA's hypothesis of collapse initiation. NIST doesn't comment on FEMA's description of collapse progression, which is the specific part of FEMA's hypothesis I'm talking about.

https://www.fema.gov/pdf/library/fema403_ch2.pdf section 2.2.1.5 p.2-27.
 
Tell these men they didn't hear explosions https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5HTRJZujQj8

Tell these men what pressurised air blowing out windows sounds like https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eAAveeeVVfM

This one is obvious propaganda https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xvCU9Z9aWW0

Of course Firefighters for truth have testimony of 118 first responders who describe hearing explosions in their written testimonies that you are welcome to read.
911 truth tactic, they cherry pick and quote mine the sounds, yet never include everything the witnesses said. They leave out the rest of the story, and try to imply explosives... No blast effects on steel, where were explosives used? And your narrative is NanoThermate... what evidence do you have besides failed old men who faked the conclusion in a vanity journal.

Loud sounds, but no explosives.

LOL, you got a sonic boom... was that your NanoThermate going faster than the speed of sound?

You posted a video with a sonic boom in after WTC towers fell, and before WTC 7 collapsed... OPS... big fail https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6B4IVcCuIZE darn, there are no good sonic booms on line... yet... But it is funny you think sounds are proof of the NanoThermate narrative of woo, or for explosives. Explosives leave evidence, thus you have WTC parts hitting WTC parts, and other things that make loud noises in fires, and collapses of giant buildings. WTC 7 was super silent... unless you were right next to WTC 7.

You mean testimony like this???

Following are 16 WTC first responder descriptions of explosive noises well before the towers collapsed:

"Sounded like bombs" –Keith Murphy
"A huge explosion" –Gerard Gorman
"Sound of popping and exploding" –Alwish Monchery
"Explosions" –William Burns
"Kept hearing these large boom, boom" –Rosario Terranova
"Sounded like explosions." –Anthony Fitzgerald
"Like a shotgun going off" –Mark Meier
"Sounded like explosions" –Wilfred Barriere
"Sounded like bombs, like blockbusters" –John Murray
"You could hear explosions" –Richard Smiouskas
"Sounded like an M-80, that's how loud they were" –Tim Pearson
"Sounds like a shotgun" –Eric Ronningen
"Sounded like an explosion" –John Morabito
"There were lots of explosions" –Jeff Birnbaum
"Under the assumption that the sounds were secondary bombs." –Andrew Rodriguez
"Sounded like bombs. Like a bomb going off. I mean, it was huge." –FDNY Deputy Chief Peter Hayden

Are these your sounds of explosives? Yes, no, maybe?

What does your NanoThermate explosives sound like, in the fantasy narrative on 911? SHHHHHHHHHHHhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

The current fact based narrative for collapse was the same on 911, fire. Did you miss the fires, or what?

Back to the sounds... loud ones, are not proof of explosives, but are proof of gullible 911 truth followers who fall for Nukes, and BS NanoThermate.
 
Last edited:
What the hell is 40% of free fall? A meaningless term.

I suspect it's a reference to NISTS's finding that WTC 7 collapsed at "40% longer than freefall."

The 40% figure was included in the draft report (August 2008), and in the Final report issued later that year. The Final report included more details, demanded by truthers like David Chandler, specifically regarding the "2.25 seconds of freefall" of WTC 7.

Summary: NIST's draft report only mentioned that the total collapse time was 40% longer than freefall. In the Final, they added more information about the stages of descent; 1st stage was less than freefall, and involved columns breaking early in the collapse; 2nd stage was the facade collapse, with 2.25 seconds of freefall, about 100 feet; and 3rd stage was the facade hitting the ground below, and slowing to less than freefall acceleration.

NIST pointed out in the final report that, even with the brief period of freefall (Stage 2), the overall collapse time was still 40% greater than that of freefall.

Truthers have been trying to pretend that NIST "reversed" itself, never acknowledged its "shocking reversal" and etc., but all they did was describe (in more detail) the three stages that led to 40% longer than freefall collapse time overall.

Example:
NIST’s final report acknowledges 2.25 seconds of free-fall, described as a “more detailed” analysis, but continues incoherently to support its earlier 40% slower than free-fall analysis as well.

Reference
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom