9/11 New information.

<snip for brevity>
C) The right side arrow is effectively "rising" to impact the underside of the Top Section floors also shown in blue. Same mechanism "upwards" as the "downwards" one on the other side - mirror image. And that shows why your concept of "weaker from beneath" is not correct. Near enough same strength/resistance whether "downwards" or "upwards".
I'm not sure I'm explaining it properly, so I'll give it another shot. A (BTW, I recently found this site http://www.sharpprintinginc.com/911...op=view_page&PAGE_id=269&MMN_position=517:517 which I think is close to how my understanding of the situation is developing)B.
A Thanks for trying. We - you and I - will need to build some common ground as a basis for discussion. And preferably avoiding being distracted by the massive amount of "noise" you are facing.
B The "owner" is a member who posts on several forums as "Major_Tom" He has done a lot of very good technical research. His reasoning does not always persuade me. (Diplomatic understatement) And he has developed an offensive style of posting - historically as a response to the sort of aggressive confrontation he met on this forum and which you have seen first hand.

One big problem you will face here is that many members hold to the view that "truthers are always wrong" and "debunkers are always (or mostly) right". Major_Tom says some things that are true but he is considered a "truther" and therefore must be wrong. The mental gymnastics by those claiming he is wrong on issues where he is right gets tedious.

You will need to filter out the issues of fact and assess them for truth independent of who said them.
Oh, the column overlay you used for your diagram, can you point me at a copy of it please?
Unfortunately no! The source is the work of forum poster Achimspok who together with Major_Tom, femr2 and several other colleagues did a vast amount of visual data measurement and interpretation.

I've lost access to the original source and much of their work was on graphics storage servers (ImageShack or some such) which deleted the files after "X" years. Poor strategic choice. Major_Tom has saved a lot on his site which you linked previously.

Much of their discussion was published on The911Forum BUT the graphics hosted elsewhere. The911Forum has an ironic reason for existence - it was set up by members from here in the JREF era who faced the same sort of aggressive opposition as you have encountered and are still facing here.

Achimspok was and AFAIK remains a convinced truther. Major_Tom in the past held to some pro "truther" positions. None of which should affect in the slightest the reality that those claims that either of them make which are true are true independent of their support for aspects of trutherism. The assertion "the cloudless daytime ski (Ooops "sky" - thanks Oystein) is blue" is TRUE FACT independent of whether the assertee is a truther or a debunker.

A
https://drive.google.com/file/d/0BzJdhqX_Dp66YnJGMldUckphTms/view?usp=sharing

Expected forces are shown with the blue arrows. (Please don't nit-pick, this is a simplified, 2d representation)
It is a good initial effort.

I wont deliberately "nit pick" but recall my repeated suggestions about being specific.

I'm not sure of many aspects of what you are trying to say.

HOWEVER you are more or less heading down the same path as my explanation which you were responding to.

Your identification of forces is reasonable - the two main problems I see are that you don't puit the forces into a clearly stated context AND one of balance. I"ve already said in my post that the vertical forces are the dominant ones. The outwards pushing is not significant - second or even lower order.

We will need to close the gap between our understandings and that is where a common problem arises. It has to be either by you understanding my explanation - which I can fill out to full and coherent detailed argument OR by me understanding your initial thoughts which we will still need to develop into a coherent hypothesis.

I'm tempted to make preliminary comments - which may lead to a dead end. But let's try - I'll "intersperse" them - mostly as questions trying to clarify what you are saying:

Red arrows indicate forces acting upon the upper section as it falls, <<What is "falling"? against the weakest joints which were designed to resist the blue arrows. <<What the floor connections were "designed to resist" was the weight of ONE floor plus its live load contents plus some safety margin This is why I suggest that pretty much as soon as it meets resistance, <<You have taken a "quantum leap" - what is "falling" to "meet resistance" the floor sections of the upper block give way individually (without a discernible jolt),<<both true in the real collapse but so far your explanation has taken a few leaps
Sorry but I cannot continue - there is not enough "framing" of the multiple points you assert. Most of them are true but have to be put legitimately into context.
and it can no longer be treated as a solid block, <<??? it becomes a cloud of debris. <<Not "cloud" implying dust - the top block starts to break up at the point shown by my (Achimspok) picture. The yellow perimeter wall arrows shearing off the blue lined floors. Both down acting and up acting.
This is consistent with video evidence, but does oppose the pile driver and piston theories when they assume the upper section acts as a unit, but NOT when they are represented as a mass. The piston theory loses some momentum, because without a solid block, and as witnessed in the video evidence, some volumes of air assumed to be pressurised actually have a path of least resistance going up.

Green arrows represent forces acting upon the lower section as debris falls, peeling away the banana skin, against the expected blue arrows. This is another weakness inherent in the design, as I see it. Forces acting in this direction would expel complete sections as witnessed, some weighing tons, as the debris falling inside the structure pushes the skin outward/away, snapping welds etc. The corner sections (individually, and in different ways at different points), assaulted as they are by outward forces in 2 directions, will give favouring one falling with it, or neither remaining standing briefly, or both.

The remaining core sections, destabilised, and impacted by the debris cloud, do random ****. As the majority of the cloud is falling away, and the core is a bit more solid, it retains some integrity briefly. In fact the video evidence which shows parts of the cores still standing immediately after the collapse. The height of this section actually closely fits where the reinforced mechanical floors are.
Way beyond my ability to process at this stage - we need to relate the bits of truth you present to what actually happened - AKA set them validly in context.


I think I've presented enough to show where I am coming from.
Yes - and the challenge facing me if I try to put all those bits of partial truth into a valid setting of what really happened. It will be easier if you follow though my explantion - agree step by step to framing or context setting THEN ask for more details if you need them for specific points.
 
Last edited:
error - made by truthers and far too many debunkers

*emphasis mine

Thank you for acknowledging this.
It is reality and a big source of frustration when trying to explain for members who have genuine concerns and a need for sound explanations and some debunker inserts their own pet theory creating a diversion or derail.

It's the whole "Right, but for the wrong reasons" thing that can get me accused of nit-picking I think. If a debunker or skeptic makes a mistake, even or especially someone like NIST, I have to call it.
Not necessarily "have to call it" - you may prefer to call it BUT if it is a derail you may achieve nothing more than evasion or distraction.
Your overall conclusion may be sound, even bang on, but if there is a fault in the middle, my brain cannot follow that to your conclusion, does that make sense?
Yes - it is perfectly normal. Part of th learning process. BUT - if the end point is true and "you" do not understand the steps in the middle then the need is to clarify those bits in the middle so you do understand them.

And Step #1 might be to get rid of the bits which are not legitimately "in the middle".

IF I am - or some other person is - explaining some aspect of WTC collapse mechanism THEN whether or not NIST, Bazant, Nordenson, ARUP got it right is almost certainly irrelevant.

It's like some people cannot get past a mistake in spelling or grammar.
Decode the "41" in my user name. I'm of the spelling pedant generation. I know the feeling. And don't ever write "You should of..." if you don't want me to dismiss your argument :rolleyes:

However the answer in the situation you are discussing is NOT "The conclusion is wrong" it is "I need to comprehend the bits in the middle of this argument"

...and also - "I need to ignore bits which are irrelevant - which do not fit..."

and even more important "I should not deny the conclusion on the false basis that I do not (yet) follow the reasoning"

"You are wrong because I do not understand you" is false logic. :D
 
Last edited:
Recollection from an excellent old post by tfk that drew mostly, IIRC, from Glanz's book.

ETA: This post: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=6993609#post6993609

Excellent post from TFK... shows are stupid uneducated people can be led to believe anything when it comes from an "expert".

I don't think anyone at the time thought that with advances in avionics there could possibly be a commercial plane hitting a high rise. It was a hypothetical argument and preceded the notion of using a commercial plane as a weapon... A fighter jet or a private plane would certainly do little damage as the accident of Cory Liddle a few years on showed.

++++

I wonder what Richard Roth thinks now that the towers' design has been shown to be vulnberable to commercial plane strikes... twice??????
 
Excellent post from TFK... shows are stupid uneducated people can be led to believe anything when it comes from an "expert".

I don't think anyone at the time thought that with advances in avionics there could possibly be a commercial plane hitting a high rise. It was a hypothetical argument and preceded the notion of using a commercial plane as a weapon... A fighter jet or a private plane would certainly do little damage as the accident of Cory Liddle a few years on showed.

++++

I wonder what Richard Roth thinks now that the towers' design has been shown to be vulnerable to commercial plane strikes... twice??????
https://www.nae.edu/Publications/Br...ecurity/ReflectionsontheWorldTradeCenter.aspx
https://www.nae.edu/File.aspx?id=7345
ftp://ftp.ecn.purdue.edu/ayhan/Korucu/Karim and Fatt_(ASCE)0733-9399(2005)131_10(1066).pdf
911 truth can quote mine the bible and come up with CD, thermite and inside job.

The WTC shell was designed to stop a plane going 180 mph, not a murderer going 490 to 590 mph. Richard Roth might have no clue, but Robertson knows the difference.

The design of the WTC would stop planes, whereas many old designs would even let a small event break into the buildings with engines flying around office space and fires spread. May not knock down the ESB, but it would kill hundreds if occupied at peak business hours - The WTC would stop a B-25 at the shell, and a 767 at the shell if the speeds and energy are below 180 mph and 185 pounds of TNT in kinetic energy.

It is engineering, not BS in books, and our opinions... the engineers show what the shell can stop. Math and physics, used in engineering showed when built the WTC shell would stop a 180 mph impact.

What other buildings can stop is based on their design. Roberstson was upset with the BS of 600 mph 707... it was as if they took the fact they expected the design to stop a plane, and failed to understand what Robertson had for the design. As if they knew he was looking at a 707, failed to get the detail; ask Boeing the speed, and came up with a cruise speed at 30,000 feet, 600 mph true airspeed... when Vmo is 350 knots at sea level. Thus the 600 mph is BS for an accident, BS based on ignorance.
However the other side of the coin is what can knock over the WTC... that speed and energy can be calculated, and a 707 going 600 mph can't knock over the WTC.

Ask a pilot what happens when a plane hits at 600 mph, and we will learn about the jet fuel fireball, step back...

Yes! 911 truth takes the BS of aircraft impact and make up BS about 911; who cares if the WTC can stop a kinetic energy impact of 184 pounds of TNT, but can't stop a 1300 and 2000 pounds of TNT kinetic energy impact; we are 911 truth, we lie and produce dumbed down opinions based on overwhelming ignorance, as we spew we have overwhelming evidence... we are ignorance and lies dumbed down for your, our 911 truth followers...
poor 911 truth, 14 years of crazy claims


...
And it appears that "Blue Sky Syndrome" is still endemic.
skynotblue.gif
skynotblue.gif

3ae98e4d-2519-48b3-bd23-e8f80333b855.jpg

The sky never was the limit, and always more than blue.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom