9/11 New information.

How do you explain the fact that a too slender column will buckled... or even the nothing that a columns CAN BE TOO SLENDER? That's Euler. That's what made the spire and remaining core columns come down.

Actually Euler buckling would have occured when the top portion of the building started moving, however the real damage to the columns was done, do to impact ossilations causing weld deformation, that caused the spire to topple from it's own weight.
Impact sound energy transfers in steel, at 5800 meters per second, and can have a pronounced effect on the structure of welds, and since welds held the columns together damage them the columns disunification is impossible to prevent and the columns, disassemble into 32 ft. Sections exactly as they were originally assembled.
 
Actually Euler buckling would have occured when the top portion of the building started moving, however the real damage to the columns was done, do to impact ossilations causing weld deformation, that caused the spire to topple from it's own weight.
Impact sound energy transfers in steel, at 5800 meters per second, and can have a pronounced effect on the structure of welds, and since welds held the columns together damage them the columns disunification is impossible to prevent and the columns, disassemble into 32 ft. Sections exactly as they were originally assembled.

I believe... toppling from its own weight.. or buckling... is what Euler's work predicts for too slender columns.

Clearly the column to column connections were hardly as strong as the 36' long columns they connected... meant to simply hold them in place until the bracing steel was attached. These connections would fracture pretty easily from the column oscillating turning them into a stack of sticks on atop the other... not terribly stable.
 
using models, using science is lunacy

I think a lot of people who have tried to model, or calculate the collapse make some very basic errors.
Treating the "above impact" sections as a solid block, for example, is just downright lunacy. ...?
Thus you see no reason for simplifying systems so you can model them... cool, the BS method of engineering, use opinions as evidence, wave the hands, say CD did it... lol

At least you admit limited understanding of engineering models.
The basis for physics and engineering, simplifying to learn and explain, and then call science lunacy, call engineering models lunacy.

Why are you calling The scientific method lunacy.


This may be old news to some of you, but I only stumbled across it recently.
What do you think to the research carried out by this guy?

http://zkt.blackfish.org.uk/119/Simple_CD_Models_WTC1.pdf
It is not science to attack other work, and be ignorant of what the work was. It is like and idiot blindly attacks Bazant. Not science, it is BS.
The paper proves it was a gravity collapse, and you failed to comment on the BS you present.

It proves the dolt has no clue of the limits of Bazant's model. In fact to make up BS and attack work which he can't do himself, is silly.
You don't need to attack Bazant to back in CD and BS theories, you need a model, and evidence. The paper is based on the opinion it was CD, backed with opinion. Big fail.

The paper shows the collapse was progressing like momentum transfer from the top mass crushing and destroying lower floors. Thus the paper proves it was a gravity collapse. Was this BS in your what to present in a Gish Gallop bag of BS from 911 truth.

The paper's only clue at getting stuff right was the fact Bazant's model is a model, not a video of the WTC collapse. Bazant's model is not based on the WTC, it is based on what Bazant presents, the fact that a building can failed without help from outside forces. Did you read Bazant's paper?

Bazant's model will not be proved wrong by some CD nut who has no clue he proved it was a gravity collapse.

The paper says the first 44 meters of collapse do not show resistance, yet he shows the resistance in the paper, and it exactly a momentum transfer. The collapse is slowed by the building due to physics, and thus the paper is BS based on the need to have CD, yet proves it was a gravity collapse. In addition he makes up what he thinks other people think.


You present a paper attacking a paper, and thus the paper offered no value, no research...

This is a paper which does research, as posted above, it reflects work, your paper reflects a nut trying to bash Bazant because he can't find evidence to support his fantasy CD lie.
https://app.aws.org/wj/supplement/WJ_2007_09_s263.pdf
You are fooled by liars.
Posting work which fails to understand Bazant's paper is only a sign of BS
 
Last edited:
I believe... toppling from its own weight.. or buckling... is what Euler's work predicts for too slender columns.

Clearly the column to column connections were hardly as strong as the 36' long columns they connected... meant to simply hold them in place until the bracing steel was attached. These connections would fracture pretty easily from the column oscillating turning them into a stack of sticks on atop the other... not terribly stable.

The welds were three times as strong as the steel, but brittle and subject to sheer lag breakage if worked from side to side during floor failures.

Eular governs, a slinder Column of a constant material non interrupted material, no welds.
 
Extrapolating simple equations beyond a reasonable time frame. As an example, I remember when obesity was big in the news, particularly amongst children. Some idiot calling themselves a researcher (I won't call them a scientist) plotted the data, and extrapolated that because we had had a jump from insignificant to 5%, it would follow that by 2030 we would see 25% of children classed as clinically obese.


Well, you didn't say when that projection was made, but as of 2012 about 18% of children 6-11, and about 15% of high school students as of 2013, were clinically obese (assuming you're in the U.S.). Reaching 25% in another 14 years doesn't seem all that unlikely. About 36% of adults (20 or over) in the U.S. were clinically obese as of 2010.

Could it be that knowledgeable experts doing calculations and projections are more capable than you realize?
 
This may be old news to some of you, but I only stumbled across it recently.

What do you think to the research carried out by this guy?

http://zkt.blackfish.org.uk/119/Simple_CD_Models_WTC1.pdf

Who is "this guy"? I find no name or affiliation; not even a date.

I don't think I have seen this piece before.
As others have noted, that piece operates under the assumption that NIST claims the the collapse progression happened according to Bazant's papers. As such, the piece successfully "debunks" such a claim.
We knew already that Bazant's models (assuming that columns failed progressively in compression) do not describe the actual collapses.

Calling this the "NIST/Bazant model" is deceptive, as NIST didn't subscribe to Bazant models as accurately describing the actual collapse progression.
Strawman fallacy, if you will.

JSanderO, GlennB, pgimeno,. and possibly others already provided hints about the true collapse progression. pgimeno even before you linked to this piece. It's mostly pancaking, followed by unbraced walls toppling outward, followed by unbraced cores succumbing to something akin to Euler buckling. (Earlier, parts of the core experienced a process similar to pancaking, where lateral beams hit each other, stripping core columns of bracing)
 
This is pure comic gold and not a video meant to support "truthers". Funny stuff. (I didn't read the comments).

:) Yeah, I get that, but I'd like to keep away from comments like those.
 
Not sure where he got the idea that, '...membership is almost 100% male. Women just don't fall for this ********'
lol, it is a parody... like 911 truth is a parody on reality. /truth

How many idiot leaders in 911 truth are women... i know one with the insane claim of DEW did it... almost as insane as Jones' thermite lie, or Gage's plagiarize the virtual smorgasbord of BS from multiple dumbed down 911 truth claims based on idiotic opinions.... /more truth

however, after raising four women, I tend to agree... we men are not smart, we are lucky we did not blow ourselves up, get arrested, or die in the dumb acts we did... It must be a case of thinking before acting... /bs
 
Last edited:
... Look below, when I talk about explosions, they deny explosives, or actually confirm explosions, but say that's irrelevant. It's not irrelevant when NIST said there were no explosions at all. Ever. Anywhere. Not even a bang. You could hear a pin drop. ... And you paid these guys **** loads for them to lie to you, might as well let them run for president.
Appears your politics are blinding... it was funny, you claims a kid debunked you on Flight 93... that was cool. made my day

Are these possible proof for explosives used on 911...
Following are 16 WTC first responder descriptions of explosive noises well before the towers collapsed:

"Sounded like bombs" –Keith Murphy
"A huge explosion" –Gerard Gorman
"Sound of popping and exploding" –Alwish Monchery
"Explosions" –William Burns
"Kept hearing these large boom, boom" –Rosario Terranova
"Sounded like explosions." –Anthony Fitzgerald
"Like a shotgun going off" –Mark Meier
"Sounded like explosions" –Wilfred Barriere
"Sounded like bombs, like blockbusters" –John Murray
"You could hear explosions" –Richard Smiouskas
"Sounded like an M-80, that's how loud they were" –Tim Pearson
"Sounds like a shotgun" –Eric Ronningen
"Sounded like an explosion" –John Morabito
"There were lots of explosions" –Jeff Birnbaum
"Under the assumption that the sounds were secondary bombs." –Andrew Rodriguez
"Sounded like bombs. Like a bomb going off. I mean, it was huge." –FDNY Deputy Chief Peter Hayden
This is testimony from witnesses on 911, is it possible evidence for explosives use on 911?

Gee, you could have something... What do you think?
Can you convince me? Or what?
 
Sounded like explosions is not the same as explosives being used.

What do those firefighters say today, now that they know what happened? Keep in mind that all of those men spent time of the pile looking for the bodies of their friends, and all know what damage from an explosive charge looks like. Not one firefighter reported damage consistent with explosives.

I can tell you right now that there is not a single member of the FDNY or NYPD who would have kept silent about such a find. Truthers always ignore this fact as integrity is beyond their comprehension. Seriously, no way the NYPD would just look the other way with 60 dead brother and sister officers. Have you ever met a cop? When a police officer is killed in the line of duty it's all hands on deck until the killer is in handcuffs or a body bag. Every law enforcement agency extends offers of aid, whatever it takes for justice. Even retired cops show up and start beating the bushes.

But anyway, you just listed a bunch of names. Here's an idea, call some of them up and ask them about explosion on 9-11. Please, call them.
 
Appears your politics are blinding... it was funny, you claims a kid debunked you on Flight 93... that was cool. made my day

Are these possible proof for explosives used on 911...

This is testimony from witnesses on 911, is it possible evidence for explosives use on 911?

Gee, you could have something... What do you think?
Can you convince me? Or what?

sounded LIKE is not IS... like is a comparison not an affirmative statement.

I attended a talk by Graham MacQueen where he presented his case that their were ear witness from the FDNY to explosions from presumably placed CD devices.

The trouble with his work is that he did perform any controls... asking people to listen to loud sounds and describe them... sounds of crashes, concrete dropping, real bombs etc.

He went into this testimony looking for people who heard explosions... He didn't even ask FDNY what sorts of things DO explode in burning buildings... and there are plenty of them.

This was irresponsible, unscientific and sloppy. It is published on some truth website. Pathetic.
 
Last edited:
Sounded like explosions is not the same as explosives being used.

Just last week in the UK a chunk of power station that was being prepped fro demolition collapsed (Didcot). The collapse was described as an explosion by lots of witnesses, even though there were no explosives...just the collapsing building.
 
Look below, when I talk about explosions, they deny explosives, or actually confirm explosions, but say that's irrelevant. It's not irrelevant when NIST said there were no explosions at all. Ever. Anywhere. Not even a bang. You could hear a pin drop.

Oh dear, you don't seem to understand that not all explosions are caused by explosives and your "pin drop" hyperbole is bull ****.
 
Oh dear, you don't seem to understand that not all explosions are caused by explosives and your "pin drop" hyperbole is bull ****.

<Insert long drawn out scream here>

I am talking about explosions, it's you lot who are inferring that means explosives. That's the whole bloody point I am trying to make.

Yes, pin drop was exaggeration, born of frustration. SS from NIST said there were no testimony or recordings of explosions. He used this as evidence for a lack of explosives. (absence of evidence not being evidence for absence).

Anyway, when trying to clear up that there was multiple instances of explosions, I get a plague of answers saying there were no explosives. It is certain other members here who cannot make the distinction, not I.

Oh, and the list of names and statements referred to below was not posted by me, it was quoted in the same post as a quote from me, making it look like my quote was split, either accidentally or intentionally I know not.
 
SS from NIST said there were no testimony or recordings of explosions. He used this as evidence for a lack of explosives. (absence of evidence not being evidence for absence).

Anyway, when trying to clear up that there was multiple instances of explosions, I get a plague of answers saying there were no explosives. It is certain other members here who cannot make the distinction, not I.

That is utterly false:

17. An emergency responder caught in WTC 7 between the 6th and 8th floors said he heard two loud booms. Isn't that evidence that there was an explosion?

The sound levels reported by all witnesses do not match the sound level of an explosion that would have been required to cause the collapse of the building.

http://www.nist.gov/el/disasterstudies/wtc/faqs_wtc7.cfm

Took me less than two minutes to find.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom