9/11 New information.

It does suggest to me, however, that the boast of being able to withstand one or more 707 impacts may not have been factual, or scientifically tested.

Yes, I'm pretty sure that's more or less true. The claim was in response to a campaign against having the towers built, rather than in response to any design brief or safety regulation. Leslie Robertson made a reference to three pages of calculations, which would have been very crude compared to anything that could be done in the computer age, and as for scientific testing I think we can take it as a given that nothing practical was done. That's why the truther claim that "the towers were designed to survive an airliner impact so they shouldn't have collapsed" is one that shouldn't be taken the least bit seriously.

Dave
 
The whole paper is a hypothetical best case column buckling sinario, that's why I say it should not be termed an analysis as that implied an actual study of the real event.
Hypothetical theory best describes the paper and always has that's part of the reason for the missing jolt misunderstanding.

The Bazant & Zhou paper explicitly denied doing any such thing. It said that the only way to do that would be with extensive computer simulation.
 
The remaining core sections, destabilised, and impacted by the debris cloud, do random ****. As the majority of the cloud is falling away, and the core is a bit more solid, it retains some integrity briefly. In fact the video evidence which shows parts of the cores still standing immediately after the collapse. The height of this section actually closely fits where the reinforced mechanical floors are.

I think I've presented enough to show where I am coming from.

Debris cloud implies something which does not have the mass or represent the same gravitational force as this debris did when locked into a structure.

The broken up floors are quite and almost equally destructive as the slabs which cannot really drop as a single plate.

It's like the difference between dropping a stack of plates in a burlap bag and the same plates broken apart in the same burlap bag. Pretty much the same magnitude of destructive punch.
 
*emphasis mine

Thank you for acknowledging this.

It's the whole "Right, but for the wrong reasons" thing that can get me accused of nit-picking I think. If a debunker or skeptic makes a mistake, even or especially someone like NIST, I have to call it. Your overall conclusion may be sound, even bang on, but if there is a fault in the middle, my brain cannot follow that to your conclusion, does that make sense?

It's like some people cannot get past a mistake in spelling or grammar.

There will be no one step after the next from static to complete chaotic collapse. Ain't happenin' So there is always going to be some fog and black boxery. It's HOW much black boxery! Truther make it all one big black box... debunkers try to look inside and explain some of what is there.
 
...
It does suggest to me, however, that the boast of being able to withstand one or more 707 impacts may not have been factual, or scientifically tested.
It did survive an impact much greater than the design would stop. There is no need to make up more BS, you can do research and learn what the WTC can stop.

A 707 going 180 mph would have stopped at the shell. Thus, it was not a boast, it was the truth. It is based on the strength of steel used in the WTC.

The ESB failed to stop an 18 pounds of TNT impact by a B-25, fires killed and the plane did damage.

The WTC had steel "columns" moved to the shell, thus the WTC steel shell could stop a 707 with a Kinetic Energy impact of 187 pounds of TNT; 10 times more energy than punched a hole in the ESB. It is called engineering, and it is factual. Ask the guy who designed it...

... lol, making up BS is easier than finding knowledge
https://www.nae.edu/Publications/Br...ecurity/ReflectionsontheWorldTradeCenter.aspx
https://www.nae.edu/File.aspx?id=7345
Research, practical research is possible with the Internet, unlike the usual quote mining based opinion BS from 911 truth.

It is possible to find another study which studies the WTC, and it confirms the WTC could Stop an airliner at certain speeds.
There was a white paper which listed the top speed of a 707 for the WTC to survive; it was BS since higher speeds has the plane breaking through the shell; do you want a 707 in the building? Taking the lateral strength of the WTC and a plane going 600 mph, the WTC will not be knocked down, as seen on 911, but the design was to stop the plane, and save the occupants; that design ended at 180 mph, not 600 mph.

The 600 mph statement was in a white paper, a kind of propaganda for how great the WTC towers were. I suspect someone took the energy/forces the WTC could withstand in a hurricane, took the energy of impact for a 707 at 600 mph, like a 2,000 pound bomb and said it will stand... it did; both are right.

Like I said, another studies checks what Robertson said, and it can be found for the researcher who is good...

impactenergywtc.jpg

The 180 mph 707 would be stopped at the shell. The impact imagined was for an accident aircraft, not an on purpose impact.
 
Last edited:
The Bazant & Zhou paper explicitly denied doing any such thing. It said that the only way to do that would be with extensive computer simulation.

What I am saying is useage of the term, analysis for the Banzant paper implies a wrong conclusion, http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/analysis

Usually analysis refers to a direct study, not a (Limited Case) hypothetical mathmatical conjecture.
Or am I wrong in that Banzant stated it was a (Limited case)?
 
What I am saying is useage of the term, analysis for the Banzant paper implies a wrong conclusion, http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/analysis

Usually analysis refers to a direct study, not a (Limited Case) hypothetical mathmatical conjecture.
Or am I wrong in that Banzant stated it was a (Limited case)?

B&Z states pretty clearly what it's analyzing and why: It was not an analysis of the collapse mechanism; it was an analysis of the maximum energy that the columns could absorb by buckling versus how much energy was unleashed -- an analysis of a simplified limit case -- to answer the question of whether or not the building should have been expected to resist total collapse under near-ideal assumptions. I was replying to AClark's assertion about "pile driver and piston theories when they assume the upper section acts as a unit, but NOT when they are represented as a mass." NIST made no such assumption, nor is any such assumption necessary, and when you say "Banzant is not an analysis, it is a hypothetical theory of resistance to collapse" I think you're confusing the issue I was trying to clarify.
 
NIST made no such assumption, nor is any such assumption necessary, and when you say "Banzant is not an analysis, it is a hypothetical theory of resistance to collapse" I think you're confusing the issue I was trying to clarify.

In fact, NIST didn't analyse the collapse progression of WTC1 and 2 at all, a fact quite often complained about by truthers. Whether these are the same truthers who then try to point out flaws with the NIST collapse model, I couldn't possibly say.

Dave
 
Can I get your opinions on use of the word "Buckling" please, as it is used a lot in these sort of conversations.

Usually I would associate buckling with a single span, forcibly bending under tremendous forces. Dealing with multi-span lengths however, particularly with regards to WTC 1 & 2, I think it has been used to describe flex or separation in the joints, where often the individual spans look pretty much intact after separation.

Is this still the correct usage of buckle, when referring to a column made up of sections?
 
Last edited:
Can I get your opinions on use of the word "Buckling" please, as it is used a lot in these sort of conversations.

Usually I would associate buckling with a single span, forcibly bending under tremendous forces. Dealing with multi-span lengths however, particularly with regards to WTC 1 & 2, I think it has been used to describe flex or separation in the joints, where often the individual spans look pretty much intact after separation.

Is this still the correct usage of buckle, when referring to a column made up of sections?

The multipart columns of a high rise if the bracing is removed somehow would yield at the connections... and break into relatively straight lengths. The failure is at the connection which is not strong enough in tension.
 
Or in shear, yes?no?

More likely tension in the outside of the curve where it bends, followed by fracture propagating laterally across the member. That's a common way for relatively rigid bodies to break. Bolts might shear, but I would think whole columns would be much more likely to fail where they're bent too tightly.

Dave
 
Yes, I'm pretty sure that's more or less true. The claim was in response to a campaign against having the towers built, rather than in response to any design brief or safety regulation. Leslie Robertson made a reference to three pages of calculations, which would have been very crude compared to anything that could be done in the computer age, and as for scientific testing I think we can take it as a given that nothing practical was done. That's why the truther claim that "the towers were designed to survive an airliner impact so they shouldn't have collapsed" is one that shouldn't be taken the least bit seriously.

Dave

This three-page analysis calculated two things:
  1. The lateral load imparted on the towers by a 707's momentum at full speed - would that be greater than or less than the maximum design wind load. Result: Less than. Tower would not shear at the base
  2. If you surgically remove columns along the wing span of a 707 - would vertical loads redistributed to remaining columns overload those? Result: No.
They concluded that the tower would not immediately collapse from a plane impact.


And they were right: The towers did not immediately collapse.


They did not - and could not - compute the effect of ensuing fires on the damaged (columns cut, fire proofing compromised, ...) structure.
 
This three-page analysis calculated two things:
  1. The lateral load imparted on the towers by a 707's momentum at full speed - would that be greater than or less than the maximum design wind load. Result: Less than. Tower would not shear at the base
  2. If you surgically remove columns along the wing span of a 707 - would vertical loads redistributed to remaining columns overload those? Result: No.
They concluded that the tower would not immediately collapse from a plane impact.

Is that recollection or speculation? It sounds about the limit of what could have been done, but as I recall Robertson didn't have the original calculations. In any case there couldn't have been any actual testing of the results. But you're right, the result was correct in that both towers survived the initial impact; I think opinions differ on whether they would have eventually fallen, even without the fires.

Dave
 
Is that recollection or speculation? It sounds about the limit of what could have been done, but as I recall Robertson didn't have the original calculations. In any case there couldn't have been any actual testing of the results. But you're right, the result was correct in that both towers survived the initial impact; I think opinions differ on whether they would have eventually fallen, even without the fires.

Dave

Recollection from an excellent old post by tfk that drew mostly, IIRC, from Glanz's book.

ETA: This post: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=6993609#post6993609
 
Last edited:
A 600 mph 707 would kill people inside the WTC, and thus the study based on shearing/topple the WTC is worthless, and meaningless. The white paper was BS, and ignored the physics of what would be a massive kinetic energy impact and massive jet fuel fireball if the plane was loaded...

An engineer would want to stop an accident like the ESB B-25 killing and ripping through office space, even at 18 pounds of TNT in kinetic energy.
The goal is to stop damage to the interior, save people... With the WTC this became easy to design since the interior columns are moved to the shell.

Moving interior columns to the exterior shell, the WTC tower would stop aircraft impacts from doing interior damage for an accident aircraft. (at 180 mph)

https://www.nae.edu/Publications/Br...ecurity/ReflectionsontheWorldTradeCenter.aspx

https://www.nae.edu/File.aspx?id=7345

Robertson planned on stopping an aircraft lost at 180 mph at the shell. The following study found it takes a speed of 130 m/s to enter the WTC shell. Thus the 80 m/s impact Robertson planned on would be stopped outside the WTC.
130 m/s impact has the kinetic energy of 500 pounds of TNT
Robertson's design was for 184 pounds of TNT at 80 m/s.
The impacts of 11 and 175 were 1300 and 2000 pounds of TNT.

ftp://ftp.ecn.purdue.edu/ayhan/Korucu/Karim and Fatt_(ASCE)0733-9399(2005)131_10(1066).pdf

I think I said increasing the thickness of the steel to 1/2 inch would stop the attacks on 911... meant to say > 20 mm... oops

The 707 at 600 mph comes from the WTC white paper, not from the guys who did the WTC structural design. Who cares if a plane ripping through the towers is going to topple it, when you want the plane to stop at the shell and spare the people inside from being ripped up and smashed into the core...
Thus the 600 mph study/easy wind conversion to impact impulse survival is BS. The fireball could kill all on the floors hit.

An aircraft at 600 mph is not an accident, it is a weapon of mass destruction.
The WTC would not stop 600 mph, the plane will enter and damage parts of the core. If you want to design for a bigger impact you have to increase the thickness of the steel. If you want to know the limits of the building you ask the structural engineer, not some white paper used as a marketing tool.


I love it... With Robertson explaining he did design to resist a 707 at 180 mph, he also looks at the possible energy of faster and larger aircraft to say this... This is perfect for 911 truth dolts who can't figure out 911.
This means if you want to design to stop the larger aircraft and possible fires;;; you have to put of the $$$$$$$$$$$$...

The design of the WTC was easy for stopping a 707 at 180 mph; if you could have the WTC stand with thinner steel as built... and it would not stop a 707; then you add thickness to match your design point of stopping the 707 at 180 mph. As the paper above found, increasing the thickness of the WTC to over 20 mm would stop the 911 attacks. Have to check the speeds they used...

I keep seeing BS about how in the "old" days it was impossible to design for this or that because there were no supercomputers. What a load of BS.
 
Last edited:
The multipart columns of a high rise if the bracing is removed somehow would yield at the connections... and break into relatively straight lengths. The failure is at the connection which is not strong enough in tension.

I don't know if you are agreeing with me or not.

NIST, and many others before and since use the term "buckling", for example "column 79 buckled". So, does this mean that columns and spans bent and warped, or that the joints gave and the column disassembled?

If the joints gave way before the spans bent, does the term buckle still apply?
 
I don't know if you are agreeing with me or not.

NIST, and many others before and since use the term "buckling", for example "column 79 buckled". So, does this mean that columns and spans bent and warped, or that the joints gave and the column disassembled?

If the joints gave way before the spans bent, does the term buckle still apply?

The Columns will buckle do to heat yes, but they will never form perfect knees, they will sheer in an a partial S bend when the load is no longer centered over the Column.
Buckling occurs only on the floors most heat effected.
Buckling is bending or squatting, the joints coming apart at the weld joints is sheer lag weld fracture do to impact induced work damage of the welds breaking the welds every 32 feet.
All arc welds have a zone of free ferrite deformation where the process of arc welding causes steel decarbonization, that leaves the steel prone to rippage, and leveraged tear, if worked faster than it can ductilely deform.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom