9/11 New information.

<Insert long drawn out scream here>

I am talking about explosions, it's you lot who are inferring that means explosives. That's the whole bloody point I am trying to make.

Yes, pin drop was exaggeration, born of frustration. SS from NIST said there were no testimony or recordings of explosions. He used this as evidence for a lack of explosives. (absence of evidence not being evidence for absence).

Anyway, when trying to clear up that there was multiple instances of explosions, I get a plague of answers saying there were no explosives. It is certain other members here who cannot make the distinction, not I.

Oh, and the list of names and statements referred to below was not posted by me, it was quoted in the same post as a quote from me, making it look like my quote was split, either accidentally or intentionally I know not.
Did you know the video you posted was a sonic boom? is that an explosion? lol

The big point is what do your BS explosion sounds mean for 911 Truth lies of CD and BS explosives.
Instead of quibbling about explosion vs explosive, why did you bring up sounds, loud sounds? What does it mean for the failed claim of CD?

Following are 16 WTC first responder descriptions of explosive noises well before the towers collapsed:

"Sounded like bombs" –Keith Murphy
"A huge explosion" –Gerard Gorman
"Sound of popping and exploding" –Alwish Monchery
"Explosions" –William Burns
"Kept hearing these large boom, boom" –Rosario Terranova
"Sounded like explosions." –Anthony Fitzgerald
"Like a shotgun going off" –Mark Meier
"Sounded like explosions" –Wilfred Barriere
"Sounded like bombs, like blockbusters" –John Murray
"You could hear explosions" –Richard Smiouskas
"Sounded like an M-80, that's how loud they were" –Tim Pearson
"Sounds like a shotgun" –Eric Ronningen
"Sounded like an explosion" –John Morabito
"There were lots of explosions" –Jeff Birnbaum
"Under the assumption that the sounds were secondary bombs." –Andrew Rodriguez
"Sounded like bombs. Like a bomb going off. I mean, it was huge." –FDNY Deputy Chief Peter Hayden
Did you research some of the explosions to see what they were?

Are these the explosions you are talking about, some of them?
 
This may be old news to some of you, but I only stumbled across it recently.

What do you think to the research carried out by this guy?

http://zkt.blackfish.org.uk/119/Simple_CD_Models_WTC1.pdf

Actually, yes, this is new, to me at least. I finally got round to looking at it. It's the usual mixture of misapplication of Bazant & Zhou, conflation of Bazant with NIST, taking everything other truthers say on faith, and scientific illiteracy; Appendix 2 in particular is an absolute howler in the way it betrays a total inability to apply simple Newtonian mechanics. Everything from about fig. 9 onwards is completely worthless as it tries to model the actual collapse as an orderly progression of impacts between parallel floors falling vertically, whereas in fact the reduction in jolt intensity that the author notes is simply indication of the increasingly chaotic nature of the collapse averaging out a large number of small, localized impacts into a constant resistive force. But perhaps the stupidest thing the author claims is that, as the upper block accelerates downwards at 0.7G, "There appears to be very little in the way of structural resistance, and what little there is has completely disappeared by Floor 5." This is complete rubbish; it's the structural resistance that's reducing the acceleration by 0.3G.

Add to that the fact that the bizarre use of capitalization and the excessive use of quote marks make the paper quite disorientating to read, and overall it's pretty worthless. But Appendix 2 is so wrong, it's actually funny. Someone who can't understand the concept of kinetic energy well enough to calculate it correctly claiming expertise on the energetics of the WTC collapses is very much what I've come to expect of the truth movement.

Dave
 
But perhaps the stupidest thing the author claims is that, as the upper block accelerates downwards at 0.7G, "There appears to be very little in the way of structural resistance, and what little there is has completely disappeared by Floor 5." This is complete rubbish; it's the structural resistance that's reducing the acceleration by 0.3G.

It's one of the common fallacies I mentioned before, about people treating the top block as a solid. I think beachnut got upset when I said that was lunacy.

If I read things correctly, the floor sections in WTC1&2 were designed to take loading from the top (as one would expect from a floor) and some forces from the outside towards the core (wind etc), but unlike other systems (ie fixed girders) it was exceedingly vulnerable from beneath. Therefore I assume that any resistance meeting the floor sections in the top block as it went down would immediately separate the floor sections from their connections. Likewise, and forces acting on the perimeter columns, forcing them outward away from the core, would almost instantly sever the perimeter connections of the floor sections.

I understand that the connections at the core would then fail under the load of the entire floor section and start to fall, however there I run in to bother. I can basically picture all of the floor sections falling towards the perimeter, and pushing out those columns, exposing the weakness as it went, but it does present a sort of peeled banana scenario, leaving the core obviously weakened and unstable, but not entirely collapsey.
 
It's one of the common fallacies I mentioned before, about people treating the top block as a solid. I think beachnut got upset when I said that was lunacy.
...
It is not a fallacy. The BS in the paper you posted is in the conclusions, and BS associated with trying to back in CD. If the dolt who did the paper understood his model, it is evidence for a gravity collapse, not CD charges planted on lower floors; sort of. lol, the block part of his model is fine, it is the conclusion, the BS he makes up. Okay, some of his BS is BS... The fallacy in 911 truth, are their conclusions; sometimes the basic methods are fine; like the typing and grammar... lol

In a model you can treat the top as a block... In momentum model you treat the top as a "block" (a mass) and then each floor added, and the time for collapse is 12.08 seconds.
It is a model, not lunacy. You call science lunacy, and you don't know it.

No big deal, your posts reveal you don't have a background in science. Simplifying things is not lunacy. You made up BS. Which block model did you have problems with?


A floor in the WTC can hold 29,000,000 pounds, and it fails...
 
Last edited:
It's one of the common fallacies I mentioned before, about people treating the top block as a solid.

No, it isn't. It's nothing to do with it. It's the pretence that 0.3g of retardation doesn't exist despite already having been acknowledged.

I understand that the connections at the core would then fail under the load of the entire floor section and start to fall, however there I run in to bother. I can basically picture all of the floor sections falling towards the perimeter, and pushing out those columns, exposing the weakness as it went, but it does present a sort of peeled banana scenario, leaving the core obviously weakened and unstable, but not entirely collapsey.

That's what happened all right; there are pictures showing the free standing cores after the main collapse had passed. Without the lateral support from the bracing of the floors to the perimeter they were too slender to support their own weight; they were never intended to. They lasted a very small number of seconds.

Dave
 
It's one of the common fallacies I mentioned before, about people treating the top block as a solid. 1 I think beachnut got upset when I said that was lunacy. 2
1 Yes it is. Probably the most prevalent error made by truthers given that it is one of the false premises underpinning T Szamboti's "Missing Jolt" (And both sides get MJ wrong because many debunkers still fall for the errors in the starting assumptions of MJ and related aspects of the "initiation >> transition>>" stage of Twin Towers collapses.) So it is wrong BUT take care that you put it in context. It is not wrong in the sense of "blocks of energy" as Dave Rogers explains. But it is wrong in the structural analysis of how the "top part" interacted with the "bottom part" (And what happened to the "middle" - the bits in between.)
2 Either ignore his comments or - better - filter out the black or white extremes of hyperbole and dig the gems/nuggets of truth he invariably gets right.

At the risk of joining the "Off Topic" rabble here are som comments on your next paragraph:
If I read things correctly, the floor sections in WTC1&2 were designed to take loading from the top (as one would expect from a floor) and some forces from the outside towards the core (wind etc), but unlike other systems (ie fixed girders) it was exceedingly vulnerable from beneath. << It's not "one-way" - not more vulnerable "from beneath". The critical issue is the strength in (vertical) shear of the join of floor joist to column. That is near enough same in both directions. And (hypothesis to follow) shearing due to vertical loads was the dominant force resisting "Top Section" falling as the collapse mechanism transitioned from "initiation" to "progression" stage. AND that progression resulted in global collapse. Put in lay language once the top SECTION - which was not a rigid block - started to move downwards there was nothing strong enough to stop it. And the main resistance it met was those floor joist to column connections which failed in gross shearing. (The "gross" to bypass any pedantry from detail focussed nit-pickers.) Therefore I assume that any resistance meeting the floor sections in the top block as it went down would immediately separate the floor sections from their connections. << Yes - begging some issues of terminology - your understanding is correct. Likewise, and forces acting on the perimeter columns, forcing them outward away from the core, would almost instantly sever the perimeter connections of the floor sections. << Maybe - the bigger forces are the vertical shearing ones. Although outwards forces putting tension on the floor joists may have been present they were certainly secondary and probably too late - the joist connections already failed. Its an issue of understanding the overall mechanism and the sequence of sub-events.

I understand that the connections at the core would then fail under the load of the entire floor section and start to fall, << Read the summary which follows - it is a different mechanism to what you are seeing in this bit >>> however there I run in to bother. I can basically picture all of the floor sections falling towards the perimeter, and pushing out those columns, exposing the weakness as it went, but it does present a sort of peeled banana scenario, leaving the core obviously weakened and unstable, but not entirely collapse.

Here a sequence of briefly stated steps of mechanism and some outline comments.

1) After the aircraft impact caused damage and started massive fires conditions deteriorated until the damaged zone could not support the "Top Section". The damaged "impact and fire zone" failed by a mechanism of cascading failure of columns where - as each one or more columns failed - the load they carried was transferred ("re-distributed") to the remaining columns. Up to the point where there were not enough "survivors" to support the Top Section. (You can leave explosive CD in the picture as an option at this point if you wish - it makes no difference to the principles of the explanation.)

2) Top Section starts moving down. The following graphic is a still frame from the WTC2 collapse at that stage in collapse:
ArrowedROOSD.jpg


Key points:
A) Note the left side "falling yellow arrow" shows how the Top Section outer perimeter landed on the lower section floors (blue lines) Imposing a large load - multiple stories of full structure imposed on ONE floor at a time in sequence.

B) Note also that the falling perimeter columns MISS the lower section columns. BY many feet in this extreme example BUT - tho it was lesser "miss' for WTC1 and the other two sides of WTC2 - the falling column ends missed. That falsifies the main truther error - made by truthers and far too many debunkers. Alleged columns hitting lower columns causing "jolts" - the T Szamboti version from truthers. BUT also be aware that many debunkers also do not accept that the column ends missed. (Some use all sorts of evasive mental gymnastics - we don't need to go there.) Bottom line is column ands missed and the Top Section perimeter falling impacted on the lower section floors and sheared the connections.

C) The right side arrow is effectively "rising" to impact the underside of the Top Section floors also shown in blue. Same mechanism "upwards" as the "downwards" one on the other side - mirror image. And that shows why your concept of "weaker from beneath" is not correct. Near enough same strength/resistance whether "downwards" or "upwards".

There are many other points which can be demonstrated by that same picture or the dynamic video I took the frame from.

It goes a long way to explaining the transition of "Twin Towers" collapses from the "failing" cascade process of the "initiation" stage into the "ROOSD" "pancaking" process of the "progression stage". With the proviso that many persons - both debunker and truther sides - get their emotive knickers in knots over the terms "ROOSD" and "pancaking". :D

It's a separate issue but the core collapse was by an analogous mechanism. Rain check for L8R
 
Last edited:
<snip for brevity>

C) The right side arrow is effectively "rising" to impact the underside of the Top Section floors also shown in blue. Same mechanism "upwards" as the "downwards" one on the other side - mirror image. And that shows why your concept of "weaker from beneath" is not correct. Near enough same strength/resistance whether "downwards" or "upwards".

I'm not sure I'm explaining it properly, so I'll give it another shot. (BTW, I recently found this site http://www.sharpprintinginc.com/911...op=view_page&PAGE_id=269&MMN_position=517:517 which I think is close to how my understanding of the situation is developing).

Oh, the column overlay you used for your diagram, can you point me at a copy of it please?

https://drive.google.com/file/d/0BzJdhqX_Dp66YnJGMldUckphTms/view?usp=sharing

Expected forces are shown with the blue arrows. (Please don't nit-pick, this is a simplified, 2d representation)

Red arrows indicate forces acting upon the upper section as it falls, against the weakest joints which were designed to resist the blue arrows. This is why I suggest that pretty much as soon as it meets resistance, the floor sections of the upper block give way individually (without a discernible jolt), and it can no longer be treated as a solid block, it becomes a cloud of debris. This is consistent with video evidence, but does oppose the pile driver and piston theories when they assume the upper section acts as a unit, but NOT when they are represented as a mass. The piston theory loses some momentum, because without a solid block, and as witnessed in the video evidence, some volumes of air assumed to be pressurised actually have a path of least resistance going up.

Green arrows represent forces acting upon the lower section as debris falls, peeling away the banana skin, against the expected blue arrows. This is another weakness inherent in the design, as I see it. Forces acting in this direction would expel complete sections as witnessed, some weighing tons, as the debris falling inside the structure pushes the skin outward/away, snapping welds etc. The corner sections (individually, and in different ways at different points), assaulted as they are by outward forces in 2 directions, will give favouring one falling with it, or neither remaining standing briefly, or both.

The remaining core sections, destabilised, and impacted by the debris cloud, do random ****. As the majority of the cloud is falling away, and the core is a bit more solid, it retains some integrity briefly. In fact the video evidence which shows parts of the cores still standing immediately after the collapse. The height of this section actually closely fits where the reinforced mechanical floors are.

I think I've presented enough to show where I am coming from.
 
Last edited:
error - made by truthers and far too many debunkers
*emphasis mine

Thank you for acknowledging this.

It's the whole "Right, but for the wrong reasons" thing that can get me accused of nit-picking I think. If a debunker or skeptic makes a mistake, even or especially someone like NIST, I have to call it. Your overall conclusion may be sound, even bang on, but if there is a fault in the middle, my brain cannot follow that to your conclusion, does that make sense?

It's like some people cannot get past a mistake in spelling or grammar.
 
”error - made by truthers and far too many debunkers
*emphasis mine

Thank you for acknowledging this.

It's the whole "Right, but for the wrong reasons" thing that can get me accused of nit-picking I think. If a debunker or skeptic makes a mistake, even or especially someone like NIST, I have to call it. Your overall conclusion may be sound, even bang on, but if there is a fault in the middle, my brain cannot follow that to your conclusion, does that make sense?

It's like some people cannot get past a mistake in spelling or grammar.

Speaking of wrong reasoning, I suggest you keep this post in mind Mr. Clark.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7759934&postcount=1037

“BUT If the focus is "decide CD or not" then coming at it from all the evidence of no CD other than via the tortuous path via "was there thermite?" leads straight to my conclusion - It doesn't matter if there was 100 tonnes [of thermite] on site, there is not the slightest evidence that it was used.”

IT DOES MATTER!
 
IT DOES MATTER!

Why? If the world trade center towers held 10,000 Dancing Jews, "many many tonnes" of explosives, 10 consecutive floors packed full of thermite, and a couple of tactical nukes, none of them were employed to destroy those towers on 9/11/2001. So what is the difference?
 
Green arrows represent forces acting upon the lower section as debris falls, peeling away the banana skin, against the expected blue arrows. This is another weakness inherent in the design, as I see it.

I think that's a little hard on the designers. The collapse mode, given that collapse is initiated, is not normally a significant concern in building design; the aim is to make the building strong enough not to collapse under normal circumstances. In this instance, of course, the circumstances were far from normal.

Dave
 
Red arrows indicate forces acting upon the upper section as it falls, against the weakest joints which were designed to resist the blue arrows. This is why I suggest that pretty much as soon as it meets resistance, the floor sections of the upper block give way individually (without a discernible jolt), and it can no longer be treated as a solid block, it becomes a cloud of debris. This is consistent with video evidence, but does oppose the pile driver and piston theories when they assume the upper section acts as a unit, but NOT when they are represented as a mass. The piston theory loses some momentum, because without a solid block, and as witnessed in the video evidence, some volumes of air assumed to be pressurised actually have a path of least resistance going up.

"They" who? Bazant's infamous "crush down/crush up" is a set of three differential equations, one of which represents to behavior of the lower structure: It models the mass and momentum of the falling top section and the accumulating rubble layer, some of which is assumed to be lost over the side, and it models the resistance that would be offered if all the columns buckled. There is NO term in that equation that assumes anything about the top section other than its mass.

If you want to understand Bazant's analyses, the first thing you need to do is forget everything you've read on "truther" sites, then start over with the original source.

ETA for the record: The NIST reference to Bazant is to Bazant and Zhou's energy analysis paper, not to his later model that causes "truthers" so much heartburn. Contrary to Ozeco's belief, NIST wasn't "right for the wrong reason." They said the total collapse was inevitable because Bazant's analysis showed that the structure could not dissipate or absorb all of the kinetic energy that was unleashed. I have no idea why Ozeco thinks that's the "wrong reason."
 
Last edited:
"They" who? Bazant's infamous "crush down/crush up" is a set of three differential equations, one of which represents to behavior of the lower structure: It models the mass and momentum of the falling top section and the accumulating rubble layer, some of which is assumed to be lost over the side, and it models the resistance that would be offered if all the columns buckled. There is NO term in that equation that assumes anything about the top section other than its mass.

If you want to understand Bazant's analyses, the first thing you need to do is forget everything you've read on "truther" sites, then start over with the original source.

ETA for the record: The NIST reference to Bazant is to Bazant and Zhou's energy analysis paper, not to his later model that causes "truthers" so much heartburn. Contrary to Ozeco's belief, NIST wasn't "right for the wrong reason." They said the total collapse was inevitable because Bazant's analysis showed that the structure could not dissipate or absorb all of the kinetic energy that was unleashed. I have no idea why Ozeco thinks that's the "wrong reason."

Banzant is not an analysis, it is a hypothetical theory of resistance to collapse given the highest resistance afforded by the buildings structure.
That's why in the Greening, Benson, Banzant, paper it specifically states that Banzant's column buckling Ideas agrees well with the early part of the collapses!
Because some buckling was evident.
The top block Idea is just an easy way to do the mass retention nessisary to drive the collapse downward at the, observed rates.
 
I think that's a little hard on the designers. The collapse mode, given that collapse is initiated, is not normally a significant concern in building design; the aim is to make the building strong enough not to collapse under normal circumstances. In this instance, of course, the circumstances were far from normal.

Dave

I was trying to be particular, and was not equating weakness with flaw. I did not mean to imply that the designers should have foreseen this and designed around it. I was merely suggesting that in designing to withstand the expected forces in blue, they (unintentionally) created a weakness to the forces in green.

For the weakness to be relevant, there would have to be a severance of the the exterior columns above these outward forces, something they may not have designed for.

It does suggest to me, however, that the boast of being able to withstand one or more 707 impacts may not have been factual, or scientifically tested.
 
Banzant is not an analysis, it is a hypothetical theory of resistance to collapse given the highest resistance afforded by the buildings structure.
That's why in the Greening, Benson, Banzant, paper it specifically states that Banzant's column buckling Ideas agrees well with the early part of the collapses!
Because some buckling was evident.
The top block Idea is just an easy way to do the mass retention nessisary to drive the collapse downward at the, observed rates.

The Bazant paper referred to by NIST is simply an analysis of how much energy could be absorbed by column buckling, taken as a simplified limit case, versus how much gravitational energy was present. It does not contain any "hypothetical theory of resistance to collapse" except that if the energy could not be absorbed or dissipated, then the collapse could not be halted. The logic is that in the real collapse, the failure modes that actually occurred happened because they required less energy than Bazant's limit case.
 
I was trying to be particular, and was not equating weakness with flaw. I did not mean to imply that the designers should have foreseen this and designed around it. I was merely suggesting that in designing to withstand the expected forces in blue, they (unintentionally) created a weakness to the forces in green.

For the weakness to be relevant, there would have to be a severance of the the exterior columns above these outward forces, something they may not have designed for.

It does suggest to me, however, that the boast of being able to withstand one or more 707 impacts may not have been factual, or scientifically tested.

The boast was basicly a PR claim that was parodied and ridiculed repeatedly over time by New Yorkers.
The towers survived the impacts all right, but not the impacts and fires, that's the Achilles heel of the buildings.
 
The Bazant paper referred to by NIST is simply an analysis of how much energy could be absorbed by column buckling, taken as a simplified limit case, versus how much gravitational energy was present. It does not contain any "hypothetical theory of resistance to collapse" except that if the energy could not be absorbed or dissipated, then the collapse could not be halted. The logic is that in the real collapse, the failure modes that actually occurred happened because they required less energy than Bazant's limit case.

The whole paper is a hypothetical best case column buckling sinario, that's why I say it should not be termed an analysis as that implied an actual study of the real event.
Hypothetical theory best describes the paper and always has that's part of the reason for the missing jolt misunderstanding.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom