9/11 New information.

...
I have read ... multiple sections of FEMA, 9/11 and various versions of NIST for 1 & 2 and 7, plus god knows what else, ...?
And you found what?
On the topic of 911, you said there are new questions...
They haven't been answered, not the new ones. ...
What are they? Was the statement BS?
Does this mean you are like 911 truth, and claim the OCT cannot be defended, and it is busted on about every count?

Which count is busted? What 911 new information, aka questions...
They haven't been answered, not the new ones. ...
What are the "new ones"?
 
Thank you for that back pedal.

I have read Mowrer, Nordenson, Bailey and ARUP several times, as well as multiple sections of FEMA, 9/11 and various versions of NIST for 1 & 2 and 7, plus god knows what else, I don't keep a bibliography.

How about you, how much have you read?
Pretty much all of it.

I've also read all of the "truther papers". I used to like to pick up a David Ray Griffen book and flip a page at random and count the words to the first factual error or out-right lie. I remember looking at one and opening it up to, "UA 77 was not intercepted by the anti-aircraft batteries at the Pentagon".. That had to be the stupidest thing I've ever read.

The reason I asked you is you seem to be unaware of the task the NIST was performing and also no grasp of the scope and purpose of the Nordenson/Bailey testimony.

You asked if there were code changes associated with the NIST's work. That was their work, to make recombination based on their findings as they relate to public safety. They did this. They did not recommend code changes to make buildings collapse proof.

Nordenson/Bailey were working for the insurance companies in order to maybe recoup some loss. They failed because the didn't show that anything done by the designers, owners and builder would have be within what was what would be reasonable expected.
 
The reason I asked you is you seem to be unaware of the task the NIST was performing and also no grasp of the scope and purpose of the Nordenson/Bailey testimony.
No, I am aware of this, and it is one of the things that troothers continually refer to, vis a vis:

Determine why and how WTC 1 and WTC 2 collapsed following the initial impacts of the aircraft and why and how WTC 7 collapsed

Many people expected this to cover the mechanism by which the top damaged section led to the destruction of the largely intact lower section, however in their own words:

it includes little analysis of the structural behavior of the tower after the conditions for collapse initiation were reached and collapse became inevitable.

The word inevitable has caused a lot of controversy, and life might have been much simpler if they had made that sentence 4 words shorter.

Nordenson/Bailey were working for the insurance companies in order to maybe recoup some loss. They failed because the didn't show that anything done by the designers, owners and builder would have be within what was what would be reasonable expected.

That is your interpretation.

Another is that their report may have focused on what their employer wanted it to say. You can't use a report as proof if it does not back up your claims. This is of course speculation, but it is not unreasonable or wild speculation. Can we assume that the lawyers chose these experts at random, or was there some very serious discussion about what was expected for the report to be useful before paying thousands of dollars per day in fees to have these reports prepared?

However, the court case was not a trial for the accuracy of the reports, but for the validity of the claims (in what was an extremely complex case with a lot of side stuff going on as everyone sued and counter sued everyone else and their dog). The judgement was that the events could not have been predicted and therefore adequately designed for. It does not address the specifics of the reports.

Another thing you may notice is that the reports reference each other in way that is unusual for reports written in isolation at the same time. One could be forgiven for thinking that they were actually written in concert.

So, in summary and conclusion, the expert reports in the case tried to prove that the building was very badly designed, and broke all sorts of rules. This led to the failure of girder 44-79 at column 79 on either the 13th or 9th floor. When this girder failed, it impacted the floor below, causing the failure of its girder 44-79 at column 79, and this pattern continued all the way to the ground, including through the reinforced floors at levels 7 and 5. The rest of the building was insufficient to redistribute the gravitational load sufficiently, resulting in enough lateral load on the exposed column 79 (due to insufficient bracing on all faces), combined with the assumed amount and direction that the column was already out of plumb due to tolerances, to a buckling and complete collapse of column 79 from ground to roof. The rest of the building was inadequately designed to redistribute this shift in weight, leading to global structural collapse, something unprecedented in high-rise history.

What they did or did not show (in the case) is not something you can actually claim, as they were a small part in the larger case. All we can say is that the judgement was given based on evidence presented by all parties. The individual reports were not on trial. If they were, and based on the fact that a judge ruled them insufficient to prove the designers and builders as culpable, could one reasonably conclude that they might be mistaken?

If they weren't enough to convince a judge that what happened was forseeable and indeed predicted, then should we put any weight in them at all? If one follows that thought pattern, then can we then assume that they are not accurate?

This is where it all gets complicated. How can we accept these expert reports as a likely collapse sequence when they were used as proof in a case that failed.
 
Last edited:
N

If they weren't enough to convince a judge that what happened was forseeable and indeed predicted, then should we put any weight in them at all? If one follows that thought pattern, then can we then assume that they are not accurate?

This is where it all gets complicated. How can we accept these expert reports as a likely collapse sequence when they were used as proof in a case that failed.

Let's not confuse a so called presumably unbiased non political fact finding report with a civil legal case, the goal of which is to find professional liability or negligence related to the planning, design and construction to recover the pay out to an insured. The lawsuit was taken by the Owner's surety who understandably sought to find someone with deep pockets to pass the cost of the insurance claim to.... in this case the insurance companies of the architects, engineers etc.

It's certainly conceivable that if there was discovery and real fact finding in a trial design and or construction flaws might have been revealed and perhaps at least a partial cause the the total collapse.

We know the judge dismissed the plaintiff's case because it was felt that the conditions of the event were so far outside the normal performance envelop that professional misconduct made no sense. The decision doesn't find that there should have been infill for the flutes etc. It doesn't address any of the factual claims in detail.
 
Many people expected this to cover the mechanism by which the top damaged section led to the destruction of the largely intact lower section.

How many of these "many people" actually would understand the explanation? The engineering world had no problem with it's wording.

The word inevitable has caused a lot of controversy, and life might have been much simpler if they had made that sentence 4 words shorter.

Why? There hasn't really been any controversy outside the fringe conspiracy groups. If you know of any please share.



That is your interpretation.

Yes it is. :)

Another is that their report may have focused on what their employer wanted it to say. You can't use a report as proof if it does not back up your claims. This is of course speculation, but it is not unreasonable or wild speculation. Can we assume that the lawyers chose these experts at random, or was there some very serious discussion about what was expected for the report to be useful before paying thousands of dollars per day in fees to have these reports prepared?

Lawyers wouldn't chose experts just because they present the case the way the want...............:rolleyes:

However, the court case was not a trial for the accuracy of the reports, but for the validity of the claims (in what was an extremely complex case with a lot of side stuff going on as everyone sued and counter sued everyone else and their dog). The judgement was that the events could not have been predicted and therefore adequately designed for. It does not address the specifics of the reports.

Another thing you may notice is that the reports reference each other in way that is unusual for reports written in isolation at the same time. One could be forgiven for thinking that they were actually written in concert.

No kidding?

So, in summary and conclusion, the expert reports in the case tried to prove that the building was very badly designed, and broke all sorts of rules. This led to the failure of girder 44-79 at column 79 on either the 13th or 9th floor. When this girder failed, it impacted the floor below, causing the failure of its girder 44-79 at column 79, and this pattern continued all the way to the ground, including through the reinforced floors at levels 7 and 5. The rest of the building was insufficient to redistribute the gravitational load sufficiently, resulting in enough lateral load on the exposed column 79 (due to insufficient bracing on all faces), combined with the assumed amount and direction that the column was already out of plumb due to tolerances, to a buckling and complete collapse of column 79 from ground to roof. The rest of the building was inadequately designed to redistribute this shift in weight, leading to global structural collapse, something unprecedented in high-rise history.

In a nut shell.

What they did or did not show (in the case) is not something you can actually claim, as they were a small part in the larger case. All we can say is that the judgement was given based on evidence presented by all parties. The individual reports were not on trial. If they were, and based on the fact that a judge ruled them insufficient to prove the designers and builders as culpable, could one reasonably conclude that they might be mistaken?

I simply reported what the judge concluded. Was I wrong? I made no claims on my own, you actually did when you claimed the case showed criminal negligence.

If they weren't enough to convince a judge that what happened was forseeable and indeed predicted, then should we put any weight in them at all? If one follows that thought pattern, then can we then assume that they are not accurate?

It wasn't enough because the judge decided that the arguments they made did not show these defects caused the collapse to within a reasonable degree. The building far outlasted design requirements for code safety.

This is where it all gets complicated. How can we accept these expert reports as a likely collapse sequence when they were used as proof in a case that failed.

Not complicated at all. They showed that there was a likely sequence given the time that occurred on 9/11. The exact cause is likely never to be known exactly.

It was funny watching "truther" get their panties in a bunch trying to find faults.

Wouldn't it be fun if the "truthers" actually had a theory that could be scrutinized? :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
The word inevitable has caused a lot of controversy, and life might have been much simpler if they had made that sentence 4 words shorter.

The controversies with the truth movement over "inevitable" are only from those truthers who who claim CD and do not understand the engineering or those truther engineers who dishonestly pretend to not understand the engineering.

The reality is that once initiated the progression to global collapse (for the "Twin Towers" - WTC1 and WTC2) was inevitable.

However there has been - still is - controversy - division in the "debunker" ranks. There is at least one area where there has been controversy and another area where there could be controversy:

1) The "has been" area of controversy is in the errors that Bazant made in his later papers and the misapplication of Bazant's 2001-2 work with Zhou in ways which do not apply to the real 9/11 collapse events. Many debunkers still do not acknowledge the limits of accuracy of Bazant's work BUT those disagreements are NOT about "inevitability'; AND

2) The "could be" area of controversy is that NIST was right to assert "inevitable" BUT the basis of their assessment may have been flawed. At least one paper has queried the accuracy of Bazant's original work which was the apparent underpinning premise for NIST's original conclusion. Subsequent analysis of the real event collapse mechanisms shows that "global collapse was inevitable" for reasons differing from the Bazant energy approximations. Bottom lines on this one are:
(a) NIST may have been "right for the wrong reasons" BUT still right so that does not assist truther claims to the contrary;
(b) The assertion that Bazant's quantification assumptions were in error has not been resolved - and the point should now be moot/irrelevant for reasons given above.

For all that your assertion "life may have been much simpler" only applies to truthers - whether of the "genuine truther" persuasion OR those alleged "truthers" who are beset by some combination of dishonesty/incompetence.
 
Last edited:
For all that your assertion "life may have been much simpler" only applies to truthers - whether of the "genuine truther" persuasion OR those alleged "truthers" who are beset by some combination of dishonesty/incompetence.

What about those truthers assailed by doubt and confusion. If Nist are right for the wrong reasons, can one be faulted for being wrong for the right reasons?;) A little hypothetical scenario for you.

I don't have a lot of time today, but I will be back later for proper replies.
 
What about those truthers assailed by doubt and confusion. If Nist are right for the wrong reasons, can one be faulted for being wrong for the right reasons?;) A little hypothetical scenario for you.

I don't have a lot of time today, but I will be back later for proper replies.

They need to learn basic reasoning skills.
 
How many of these "many people" actually would understand the explanation? The engineering world had no problem with it's wording.

Same to you DGM, I hope to get back to you soon with a decent reply, until then, mull over the following:

Bazant gave us the pancake theory, which was 100% correct, and would silence all of the truthers. Until it wasn't.

We've had the pile driver theory, and the piston pressurised air theories, which are also 100% correct. Until they aren't.

We've had the "things fell, they were not ejected" theory, which is 100% correct, and yet NIST tells us that building 7 and other buildings took damage from ejected materials, which is also 100% correct. They could have said falling debris if that was what they meant.

We've had the burning jet fuel theory, which of course was 100% correct, until it was no longer correct.

We've had the 40% free fall theory, which is also 100% correct, until you show that it isn't.

We have the girder walk off theory for WTC7, which could never be wrong, until you look at the real facts.

We've had the fuel oil fires theory, which is absolutely spot on, until it is ruled out.

We have the no explosions explanation, until you hear the recordings and read the eye witness testimony, but of course, that is correct too.

We have the molten metal question, which doesn't exist, but if it does, then it's not steel therefore it doesn't count.

Can you please tell me which theory we are supposed to be following now, so that we know what to talk about.
 
All well and good but the limit is the maximum allowed by law not s target.
Police and Camera units start enforcing at the limit plus 10% + 2mph.
So in a 70 limit it's 79 before they will prosecute, in a 30 it would be 35 etc.

Sorry for the continued off topic, but this is a common misconception.
The police will ping you for exceeding the limit, full stop.

You are eligible for the speed awareness course at anything under 10% + 9.
I've been pinged doing 73 in a 70, as an example.
 
What about those truthers assailed by doubt and confusion.
Those are the ones I refer to as "Genuine Truthers" - those who invented the label "truther" for themselves and it was an honourable name. Probably back in the day - my experience says 2006-7-8-9>>10?? - a large proportion of truthers were genuinely confused people who did not comprehend the 9/11 events. The proportion of trolls, Poes, pretenders and game players was - in my experience - far less than it is these days. IMO debunkers have destroyed the purity of "truther" as an honourable term by parodies such as "twoofer" used as an insult and my using truther/twoofer etc indiscriminately. Not distinguishing those "genuine truthers" from the game player trolls who form a larger portion of the demographic in recent years.

If Nist are right for the wrong reasons, can one be faulted for being wrong for the right reasons?;)
Take NIST out of the consideration - make it "....can one be faulted for being wrong for the right reasons?;)" - of course not - hence my distinguishing of "genuine truthers" from trolls, Poes and game players. My own interest in 9/11 arose from a desire to explain issues within my own areas of expertise for those who did not understand. It arose from a discussion with a colleague in my former home town - he was a full on conspiracy theorist and asked me what I thought of the CD of WTC. His interest more in NWO and chemical contrails - 9/11 a side line for him. But understanding WTC collapse became the challenge for me so that I could explain it to him.

A little hypothetical scenario for you.
The reason I suggested taking NIST out of the equation is that when I first got involved I found a lot of confused thinking - mixed up over "What really happened?" and "Did NIST explain it right?" Debate often switching between the two topics resulting in confused argument. 9/11 events like the WTC collapses occurred in 2001. NIST reported years later. So if NIST got it wrong it was too late to change what was written as historical fact in 2001.

I don't have a lot of time today, but I will be back later for proper replies.
Ball in your court. I've explained my ROE's :thumbsup:
 
Last edited:
Bazant gave us the pancake theory, which was 100% correct, and would silence all of the truthers. Until it wasn't.

(a) No, he didn't. It was FEMA's first working hypothesis, later superseded by NIST. (b) In the few days after the attack when Bazant and Zhou was submitted, I don't think truthers were even on anyone's radar.

We've had the pile driver theory, and the piston pressurised air theories, which are also 100% correct. Until they aren't.

You may note that these are describing different aspects of the collapse, so there's no reason for them not to both be true.

We've had the "things fell, they were not ejected" theory, which is 100% correct, and yet NIST tells us that building 7 and other buildings took damage from ejected materials, which is also 100% correct. They could have said falling debris if that was what they meant.

I'm pretty sure that is what they meant. Care to give a quote that demonstrates what they said that was misleading?

We've had the burning jet fuel theory, which of course was 100% correct, until it was no longer correct.

I'm not sure what exactly wasn't correct about the theory that the jet fuel burned.

We've had the 40% free fall theory, which is also 100% correct, until you show that it isn't.

40% free fall theory? Now you're just making stuff up so you can pretend there are lots of theories out there.

We have the girder walk off theory for WTC7, which could never be wrong, until you look at the real facts.

I think NIST made it quite clear that the walk-off theory was their best hypothesis. And I seem to remember the Arup simulation also predicted girder walk-off, and it's just keyboard warriors with no structural engineering qualifications who've never done any FEA modeling of WTC7 who claim otherwise.

We've had the fuel oil fires theory, which is absolutely spot on, until it is ruled out.

Again, clearly stated as a working hypothesis until evidence was found that ruled it out. That's the way investigation works.

We have the no explosions explanation, until you hear the recordings and read the eye witness testimony, but of course, that is correct too.

I've heard the recordings and read the eyewitness testimony. The only explosions correlated to the beginning of the collapse don't seem to appear on all the copies of the same recording, probably because they've been edited in.

We have the molten metal question, which doesn't exist, but if it does, then it's not steel therefore it doesn't count.

Dumbest. Comment. Ever. It's classic truther misdirection to point to accounts of molten metal, which eyewitnesses think was molten steel but which can't be because their accounts wouldn't make sense if it were, and claim that it means there were temperatures too high to have been created by the fires. If the molten metal seen was anything other than molten steel, then no, it doesn't count, because lots of other metals that would have been melted in the fires were known to be present. And nobody has yet come up with a coherent theory by which a CD might possibly produce molten steel at the times it was claimed to be observed.

Can you please tell me which theory we are supposed to be following now, so that we know what to talk about.

As in any scientific investigation, we are following the theory that best fits the available evidence right now. If more evidence emerges, the theory may have to be refined. That's just he way the world works. And so truthers use that inescapable fact of life to come up with a heads-I-Win, tails-you-lose argument: if no official information is published then the government is either covering something up or unable to get its story straight, and if information is published that is less than 100% perfect then the government is failing in its supposed duty to educate the willfully ignorant. Reality doesn't work that way.

For someone who claims not to buy into the 9/11 conspiracy theories, though, you seem to be unusually well-versed in parroting the usual truther talking points.

Dave
 
Sorry for the continued off topic, but this is a common misconception.
The police will ping you for exceeding the limit, full stop.

You are eligible for the speed awareness course at anything under 10% + 9.
I've been pinged doing 73 in a 70, as an example.

I have seen this claim before but it's never been backed up.
I you have evidence for it then please go to http://forums.pepipoo.com/ and post it there. It's the best motoring law advice site in the UK. There are police traffic officers both serving and ex on there and motoring defence lawyers.
Not one poster has shown that they have been prosecuted for anything under the ACPO guidelines, we would love to have a real example.
Obviously in law a driver can be prosecuted for anything over the limit.
 
Last edited:
Sorry for the continued off topic, but this is a common misconception.
The police will ping you for exceeding the limit, full stop.

You are eligible for the speed awareness course at anything under 10% + 9.
I've been pinged doing 73 in a 70, as an example.
It is a complex topic because there is ambiguity over understanding of "exceeding".

Taken as literal "letter of the law" 71 exceeds 70.

But the objective is one of process control - behavioural process control - of a distributed behaviour.

Best illustrated IMO by work in production management - leading exponents of "Quality Management" such as Demming. It is (relatively :o) easy to show that the literal zero exceedance target is invalid systemic logic.

There is no simple answer - discussion nearly always falls into two emotively polarised camps - those who do not understand the "process control" aspect and claim 71 exceeds 70 - and those lesser number of frustrated process control and/or behavioural psychology professionals who know better but also know they will never "win".

Try this aspect as a thought experiment:

Speed "zones" are often set by measuring actual traffic speeds and setting the limit at the 85th percentile of the varying range of speeds that real motorists actually travel at.

It presumes obviously that the "body of judgement" of the real motorists is valid. (And if you follow that logic through you will see that it is a truism.)

So 15% of the actual body of motorists whose judgement is valid exceed the decided limit.

Are those 15% "wrong"? If you ever try to get your head around that one it will open up the complexity of the issue. Wont solve it. :D

And - yes - it is way off topic. Many years since I discussed it on a forum - 2008-9 from memory.
 
Obviously in law a driver can be prosecuted for anything over the limit.
We "crossed in posting".

That is true but it overlooks a principle of legal enforcement practice. Put simplistically laws have a purpose and preference should be given to enforcing the purpose of the law especially where literal "letter of the law" does not meet the purpose.

In the broader picture of legal practice such subtleties are not usually called into play in the enforcement of minor regulatory standards such as "speeding".

The "10% plus 2" rule is a reasonably valid way of handling the situation. It would be better in measurement theory if it was 10 units NOT 10% - and that is probably as far as we need go off topic.
 
Same to you DGM, I hope to get back to you soon with a decent reply, until then, mull over the following:

Bazant gave us the pancake theory, which was 100% correct, and would silence all of the truthers. Until it wasn't.

We've had the pile driver theory, and the piston pressurised air theories, which are also 100% correct. Until they aren't.

We've had the "things fell, they were not ejected" theory, which is 100% correct, and yet NIST tells us that building 7 and other buildings took damage from ejected materials, which is also 100% correct. They could have said falling debris if that was what they meant.

We've had the burning jet fuel theory, which of course was 100% correct, until it was no longer correct.

We've had the 40% free fall theory, which is also 100% correct, until you show that it isn't.

We have the girder walk off theory for WTC7, which could never be wrong, until you look at the real facts.

We've had the fuel oil fires theory, which is absolutely spot on, until it is ruled out.

We have the no explosions explanation, until you hear the recordings and read the eye witness testimony, but of course, that is correct too.

We have the molten metal question, which doesn't exist, but if it does, then it's not steel therefore it doesn't count.

Can you please tell me which theory we are supposed to be following now, so that we know what to talk about.

Excuse me? Bazant did not give a pancake theory. The pancake theory is really a short hand and sloppy way to express the what happened... the top mass fell upon floor systems which were incapable of arresting the fall so the collapse progressed floor by floor. Why the floors were referred to as "pancakes" is anyone guess... they are large and thin and flat perhaps?

Pile driver? YES there was a mass of materials descending... like a pile drive which exerts a concentrated vertical force downward. The descending mass functionally was the same as a pile driver... energy directed downward.

Pressurized Air? YES the air within the "sealed" tower... had to be displaced by the falling mass... no two objects can occupy the same volume of space at the same time. The mass pushing downward on the floor it encountered pushed downward on the 40,000 cu yards of air on the floor below... compressing it somewhat... PRESSURIZING it... like what happened in a bellows or internal combustion engine... and that pressurized air... all 40,000 cu yards of it came explosively out the window areas... the places of least resistance. And with this air came all manner of "things" destroyed by the blast and "over pressurized" air including clg tiles, furniture and office contents.

Fell not ejected?? BOTH the face steel and all the structural steel FELL... Perhaps an odd steel member was "sprung" out. The ejected material was as described above. The falling facade at a horizontal AND a vertical component... like a flag pole which falls... these forces are "resolved" from purely vertical ones... as they were "toppling" or falling "over"... not simply collapsing downward.

Burning Jet Fuel? Of course jet fuel burned... spread... started other fires... maybe even exploded when atomized and ignited.

The "speed of collapse" was not constantly accelerating. First of course is that the thing was breaking apart and different parts behaved differently all driven by gravity and all resisted somewhat by the structure and the integrity it had. The collapse time is not precise but for the twins it was in the area of 15 seconds... while a free fall object from the top would take about 8 or 9. The percentage AVERAGING the collapse in a % of free fall is meaningless and explains nothing.

Explosions? Of course there were explosions... but not bombs. Loud sounds are called "explosions" by witnesses... Most are electrical transformers and liquid tanks which heat up become pressurized and explode. Electrical arcing can produce explosive sounds.

There was no melted steel recovered.. or hardened steel which had melted and cooled. There are no photos of cooled melted and solidified steel. There were all manner of melted things... plastics for sure and there were lots of them... and they burn too! Lead from back up batteries... even glass perhaps!

THERE IS NO ONE THEORY... the event was complex and chaotic and many mechanical and chemical processes were in play destroying the integrity of the buildings... turning them into a pile of smoldering metal, sand, dust and so on.
 
The "10% plus 2" rule is a reasonably valid way of handling the situation. It would be better in measurement theory if it was 10 units NOT 10% - and that is probably as far as we need go off topic.

The theory I heard, which I cannot substantiate, is that historically speedometers were only tested to within a 10% threshold. Those of you who have experience of older cars may fondly remember the bouncing needles :) I think the idea was that you could counter sue the manufacturer if it wasn't reporting an accurate speed if you got a ticket, I'm not sure of the specifics.
 
What about those truthers assailed by doubt and confusion. If Nist are right for the wrong reasons, can one be faulted for being wrong for the right reasons?;) A little hypothetical scenario for you.

I don't have a lot of time today, but I will be back later for proper replies.

Most we get here have a certain, unbreakable certainty .
 
I have seen this claim before but it's never been backed up.
I you have evidence for it then please go to http://forums.pepipoo.com/ and post it there. It's the best motoring law advice site in the UK. There are police traffic officers both serving and ex on there and motoring defence lawyers.
Not one poster has shown that they have been prosecuted for anything under the ACPO guidelines, we would love to have a real example.
Obviously in law a driver can be prosecuted for anything over the limit.

I was stuck on the speed awareness course.
So not prosecuted, though if I'd elected not to go I would have been stuck with the fixed penalty and points.

It stated in the letter I was doing 73 in a 70, between Monmouth and Ross (probably the bit just over the hill outside Monmouth, just inside England, as that's where I thought I'd seen a police car).

I was surprised, to say the least, but short of finding, scanning and posting the letter here not sure what else I can say.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom