10 year old Arrested for Cutting Meat in School

I find it astonishing that Florida law classifies a steak knife as a weapon but not a pocketknife or firearm.

It classifies knives by their type a steak knife is a relatively long bladed knife with a point. There is little reason to classify it differently from a similarly sized bowie knife.

The firearms are covered by different laws.

As someone else said, I think intent has a lot to do with it. Just because a rule or law is passed, that doesn't mean it should take the place of common sense.

How do you know the intent of carrying a weapon before it is used?

I wonder why the teachers couldn't simply see that she was using the knife to cut her food.
I wonder, had they decided the knife was a weapon, why they couldn't just simply take it away from her.
I wonder why they didn't call the principal or school security instead of the police.
I wonder why, having been called, the police felt it necessary to arrest her.
These might well all have been fixed by policy.

It seems to me that the only person in this entire scenario who used an ounce of common sense was the girl herself. She knew a knife was a tool used to cut meat.

So does OJ Simpson. The thing is that people are made of meat.
 
You are wrong. It has nothing to do with use, that would be covered in seperate issues. The issue here is possession not threat, not attack, but possession. So it is only about situations of possession, as other situations have other additional laws about them.

So you think that children should be able to bring weapons to school with out limit? That seems to be your position as they have not acted in any way with those weapons and until they do they can keep them.

Had there been students with weapons at Columbine...
Had there been students with weapons at Virginia Tech...
Had there been customers with weapons at Westroads Mall in Omaha here...

The plain fact of the matter is that Zero Tolerance policies pretty much remove the overt criminal act from being found guilty of being a criminal. If I legally own a gun, for example, and walk in to a shopping mall... carrying a legally owned and licensed handgun, in plain sight... holstered on my hip...

I can be arrested for that.

Why? Have I shot anyone yet? Have I threatened anyone? No. Because the mall has a "no weapons at all" policy.

That didn't stop someone from bringing an AK-like weapon in to westroads here and killing 8 innocent people.

And yet, people will say that the mere BRANDISHING of the weapon (as in, showing that I have it on my hip... merely HAVING IT THERE ready to be drawn and fired) is "threatening" to them. They feel threatened by the fact that I have it...

(too bad I can't complain about feeling threatened by their stupidity)

... so what should we do to remove that threatening gun from their eyes? Allow me to carry it concealed! Yup, Nebraska has a concealed-carry law...

... just not where a property owner says they don't want guns at all, period.

I've digressed quite a bit...

If I'm going to go to jail for a crime, let me commit an actual criminal act first, eh? As in, actually causing harm against someone else, not just having the potential to do so.

If more laws go this route, we'll end up completely repressed.

Edited to add: Oh, and as far as bringing weapons to school? That's really not an issue, since this STEAK KNIFE was not a WEAPON! It can't be classified as such until it's used as such... until the intent behind its use was as such... until that time, it's just a tool.

Nothing more, nothing less.
 
Last edited:
You continue to raise this strawman despite having been corrected on it.

It's a false dilemma. There is a middle ground.

Name it. Define what knives can and can not be brought to school. You object to the definitions of that in florida, and many seem to be not against possession of weapons by students but use of such weapons in certain maners.
 
Had there been students with weapons at Columbine...
Had there been students with weapons at Virginia Tech...
Had there been customers with weapons at Westroads Mall in Omaha here...

Three strawmen in a row. Are you trying for a record?

It is interesting that most of the cases where spree killers are stoped by an armed individual that that individual is an off duty police officer.
The plain fact of the matter is that Zero Tolerance policies pretty much remove the overt criminal act from being found guilty of being a criminal. If I legally own a gun, for example, and walk in to a shopping mall... carrying a legally owned and licensed handgun, in plain sight... holstered on my hip...

I can be arrested for that.

Why? Have I shot anyone yet? Have I threatened anyone? No. Because the mall has a "no weapons at all" policy.

So private property owners have no rights to decide what weapons people can carry on their property now?

You don't like property owners having such rights it is very clear that you want legislation to prevent people from forbidding others from carrying weapons when on their property! The nerve of those people thinking that just because you own the property you have any rights to what people can do there!
 
How do you know the intent of carrying a weapon before it is used?
???

How do you know someone intends to use a tuna sandwich as a weapon until he uses it?

How do you know he intends to use his metal lunch box as a weapon until he uses it?

How do you know he intends to use the classroom flagpole as a spear until he uses it?

El Al, Israel's national airline, hasn't had a hijacking in almost 40 years. One of their security experts explained the reason: "We don't look for weapons. We look for hijackers."

Maybe schools should change what it is they look for.
 
Name it. Define what knives can and can not be brought to school. You object to the definitions of that in florida, and many seem to be not against possession of weapons by students but use of such weapons in certain maners.

Evaluate that she wasn't a threat and take the knife away. No need for the cops.
 
One of the things I find interesting is that no one involved, including those who support the school and police action, seem to comprehend that this girl is a CHILD. We're not talking about a 17 year old, we're talking about a fifth grader. The idea that adults could be utterly at a loss as to what to do about someone they can pick up and carry under their arm... it boggles the mind.

And of course children of that age are incapable of using knives for any purpose other than eating their lunch...

http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/english/doc/2004-06/02/content_335813.htm

Still, a boxcutter is only a tool. No reason to take it from her if she had been seen to have it before she murdered her fellow pupil, right?

http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2005/05/31/national/main698615.shtml
 
And of course children of that age are incapable of using knives for any purpose other than eating their lunch...

That's why taking a steak knife to school should not be tolerated. But it doesn't need to be blown out of all proportion either.
 
If I was that kid's lawyer, the first thing I would be asking is "what constitutes a weapon?" At what point did that steak knife BECOME a weapon, causing school administrators to act?

Hopefully her lawyer will know the law a little better and not ask that question. Weapon is a defined term and the definition has already been posted. A steak knife clearly meets that definition.
 
That's why taking a steak knife to school should not be tolerated. But it doesn't need to be blown out of all proportion either.

Indeed. I was simply pointing out that the assertion that there is nothing to worry about because the person involved is a child is nonsense.
 
Indeed. I was simply pointing out that the assertion that there is nothing to worry about because the person involved is a child is nonsense.
But it matters which child it is, doesn't it? A well-behaved, apparently happy, well-adjusted kid? Or a brooding, hostile, angry kid who's always getting picked on by others and who was caught pouring gasoline on a cat last week? I wouldn't worry about the first if he were carrying a machete. I'd worry about the second every time he picked up a pencil.

But zero-tolerance says, treat them both the same. Idiocy.
 
I'm not claiming it wasn't.



At some point she had to decide a steak knife was a weapon.

I assume you are joking - to most non-weapons persons if it looks like a weapon it is one and if it doesn't, nobody could possibly use it as one. A steak knife would not be even my 10th choice as a weapon - but to the average person, it is quite useable for that purpose. One of the reasons knives are almost alway specifically listed as banned in schools by school board policies.
 
How do you know the intent of carrying a weapon before it is used?


If the school policy is to remove intent from the equation and just rely on possibilities, then the following situations need to be considered:

All pencils should be banned, as they can be used to stab people.
All hard-back textbooks should be banned, as they can be used to bludgeon people.
All scissors should be banned, as they can be used to cut people.
All loose-leaf notebooks should be banned, as the spiral wire could be used to poke people.
All footwear should be banned, as shoes could be used as projectiles.

Etc.
 
How do you know the intent of carrying a weapon before it is used?


Oh, and in answer to your question, "Simple observation and a bit of common sense".

In this case, the intent was obviously to cut a steak into bite-sized pieces.
 
Do you have no judgment about what constitutes a weapon? If you don't, where is "weapon" defined in such a way that you know what constitutes a weapon?
Knife. Guns and knives listed in all of these I have ever seen. Most list all or some portion of these specifically: pepper spray, tear gas, wallet chains or decorative chains (sometimes with a length rule), clubs,batons,.....and most end with some form of "and other devices which may be used as a weapon.".No matter how you play it, a steak knife qualifies under even the worst written of these policies, as does a water-gun.

Feel free to play with the old "anything can be a weapon". It is, of course, true - but neither the school board not even knowledgeable teachers/admins are going to report a rolled up newspaper or a Bic pen (my favorite for aircraft use) yet both can be quickly weaponized.
 
Knife. Guns and knives listed in all of these I have ever seen. Most list all or some portion of these specifically: pepper spray, tear gas, wallet chains or decorative chains (sometimes with a length rule), clubs,batons,.....and most end with some form of "and other devices which may be used as a weapon.".No matter how you play it, a steak knife qualifies under even the worst written of these policies, as does a water-gun.

Feel free to play with the old "anything can be a weapon". It is, of course, true - but neither the school board not even knowledgeable teachers/admins are going to report a rolled up newspaper or a Bic pen (my favorite for aircraft use) yet both can be quickly weaponized.

I have revised my position since I made that statement.
 
Last edited:
If the school policy is to remove intent from the equation and just rely on possibilities, then the following situations need to be considered:

All pencils should be banned, as they can be used to stab people.
All hard-back textbooks should be banned, as they can be used to bludgeon people.
All scissors should be banned, as they can be used to cut people.
All loose-leaf notebooks should be banned, as the spiral wire could be used to poke people.
All footwear should be banned, as shoes could be used as projectiles.

Etc.
I still carry a pencil lead in my left inside elbow from the third grade-my assailant (a friend - even after same) carries part of one in the top of his right hand (and had a deeper hole). He hit first, I hit better!


School was more fun then and most of us survived it just fine with gravel in the playground, bolts and metal connections exposed, etc.
 
Last edited:
I assume you are joking - to most non-weapons persons if it looks like a weapon it is one and if it doesn't, nobody could possibly use it as one. A steak knife would not be even my 10th choice as a weapon - but to the average person, it is quite useable for that purpose. One of the reasons knives are almost alway specifically listed as banned in schools by school board policies.

The thing is that blade length is one of the few real ways to define knives in a legal fashion.
 
If the school policy is to remove intent from the equation and just rely on possibilities, then the following situations need to be considered:

All pencils should be banned, as they can be used to stab people.
All hard-back textbooks should be banned, as they can be used to bludgeon people.
All scissors should be banned, as they can be used to cut people.
All loose-leaf notebooks should be banned, as the spiral wire could be used to poke people.
All footwear should be banned, as shoes could be used as projectiles.

Etc.

There are far more effective weapons that also will not be banned because you see, there is a difference when something has a legitmate use in the context of the school and one that does not.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom