10 year old Arrested for Cutting Meat in School

A good friend of mine in high school used to make homemade napalm, played war games with live ammo in the woods with his buddies, and carved a swastika in his arm with a knife.

He was our saludatorian, and went on to West Point.

(When he was accepted to WP, he had to burn the swastika from his flesh with a piece of hot iron.)
Didn't do the second two, but did figure out how to make a different material similar to napalm that could be use for delayed fires with a timed fuse (chemical). My teen years were (heh,heh):D a blast!!
 
That is the intention of a bureaucracy for its employees, non-thinking direction followers. The purpose of public schooling is to educate children to understand their child-like roles in a bureaucracy as adults.

Seems like a bit of paranoid thinking to me.
 
"Essential" vs "Use"

No, he was stabbed with a weapon...

You clearly have a problem with definitions.

From http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/weapon



A steak knife is not "for use in attack or defense in combat, fighting, or war."

However, when the steak knife is used "against an opponent, adversary, or victim", then the "weapon" term applies to the steak knife.

Why oh why do I even have to get this granular in detail? You'd think people with an adult level of intelligence would be able to get this without all this crap.


Making this distinction has great usefulness. The con-fusion of these separable concepts is one of the problems at the root of this entire debate. It seems it would be entirely reasonable to both prohibit defined items the "essential nature" of which makes them weapons, and, separately, any and all items "used" as weapons. In the latter case, the (pencil, etc) does not become a weapon until used as such, but the (gun, etc) is always a weapon, regardless of use.
As I work in a high-security mental hospital, I am familiar with the difficulty of defining weapons; this distinction has been useful to us, and I suggest others consider incorporating the concept into their rules.
The list of "defined weapons" needs to be carefully made, and widely publicised. However, in spite of our best efforts, the lists need to be revised annually, based on experience.
 
It is interesting... at least some of the people making the biggest stink about these zero tolerance policies are the same ones who vote for the "tough on crime" politicians. This all comes from the same "right-wing authoritarianism" and fear-based decision making that runs all through our culture.

LOL!

What an idiot.

This derives directly from political correctness, the bastard bastard of the left.

Tokie
 
I was under the assumption that the majority on this forum were bright enough to understand the meaning of the title. Obviously you did understand it by your above words, as did everyone that responded. Why exactly did you have the concern?

Good luck with that assumption Gnomy...most in here a constipated pedants waiting to leap on any little error in presentation or grammar or what not...heaven help you if your mis-place a comma, regardless of obvious meaning, the retorts will go on and on and on for 20 pages.

It's funny in the same sort of way watching a 2nd grader play with his own snot is.

Tokie
 
Wow...Token"Conservative" is back, and the first two posts I happen to read by him are insulting ones. What are the chances of that?
 
If you asked whether or not the people on this thread would approve of allowing children to bring knives to school, I'm sure the overwhelming majority would say no. After all, we'd still have a line that needs to be drawn. Guns are out, but switchblades? Butcher knives?

The thing is, a teacher could have taken all of 30 seconds to go over to the student, confiscate the knife and explain to the student that it's not acceptable to bring those sorts of objects to school. If they were really quite worried about whether or not she had malicious intent, her parents could have been called, and the rules about bringing such objects to school could have been gone over with all parties present.

If a teacher sees someone using a pencil, they think nothing of it. If a teacher sees someone threatening another person with a pencil, they confiscate the pencil and reprimand the child.

This template could certainly have been followed quite easily in this case. That's not to say that the teacher should have done nothing, but informing the principal and having him/her talk to the student seems to be the most sensible option.

But people often overlook sensibility.
When I was a kid it most boys carried pocket knives with them most of the time. I guess humanity simply turned into a bunch of homicidal maniacs for no particular reason. Maybe it's evolution. Or it could be that our parents weren't hysterical jackasses like we are.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom