10 year old Arrested for Cutting Meat in School

Is a pencil or pen a weapon? Would if be if someone stabbed you with it?

Again we are getting into mixed definitions here. A pen and pencil are not considered weapons by any law classifying objects as weapons for the purposes of determining what is legal to carry.

The definition of weapon in Florida school system has been posted here before, why do you fail to see it? The knife in question is clearly classed as a weapon by Florida laws with regards to being in school.

As for laws regarding assault with a deadly weapon and similar, that is different because such laws do not require the item in question to be a legally restricted weapon.

You are using multiple meanings of a word to make it that nothing is a weapon unless it is actively being used as such. So if children can bring any kind of martial device to school with them, why not come out and say it instead of hiding behind "it was just a steak knife"
 
No you are arguing for bias. It is entirely unavoidable when you bring discretion into it. Everyone is biased and judges all events that they see on those biases. There discretion is informed by their biases, as there is no way for it not to be.
And your silly example assumed that people charged with the responsibility to use good judgment would use the worst possible judgment. Hence my comparing your post to an automobile wreck.

Jeezum Crow, I'm finding myself agreeing with both JoeEllison and Tony here... :boggled:
 
If, by bias, you mean that a 10 year old girl cutting meat with a steak knife should not be punished as severely as a seventeen year old girl with known violent tendencies brandishing a machete, then, yes, I am arguing for bias.

More accurately, I'm arguing for judgment and discretion, without which laws are just arbitrary rules to punish people for no purpose.

So you want people to based on their own baises to selectively prosecute crimes?
 
And your silly example assumed that people charged with the responsibility to use good judgment would use the worst possible judgment. Hence my comparing your post to an automobile wreck.

Jeezum Crow, I'm finding myself agreeing with both JoeEllison and Tony here... :boggled:

"Good" and "worst" judgment are subjectively assigned by your own biases.
 
"Good" and "worst" judgment are subjectively assigned by your own biases.
Okay, obviously you've decided to stop making any sense whatsoever, so I'll leave you to argue with whatever strange voices you're hearing between your ears. You and your voices, and whoever else thinks you have anything worthwhile to contribute any more, enjoy yourselves.
 
Last edited:
Again we are getting into mixed definitions here. A pen and pencil are not considered weapons by any law classifying objects as weapons for the purposes of determining what is legal to carry.

**** the law. Im asking you.

C'mon, think for yourself. Are pencils and pens weapons? Would they be if someone stabbed you with them?

The definition of weapon in Florida school system has been posted here before, why do you fail to see it? The knife in question is clearly classed as a weapon by Florida laws with regards to being in school.

Because the rules of the Florida school system, like most school systems, are ********. Why can't you think for yourself?

You are using multiple meanings of a word to make it that nothing is a weapon unless it is actively being used as such.

I'm using the standard definition. A weapon is an object used to kill or injure. She wasn't using this object to kill or injure, therefore, it isn't a weapon.

So if children can bring any kind of martial device to school with them, why not come out and say it instead of hiding behind "it was just a steak knife"

Because it was just a steak knife and it was being used as such. I this case, it is clearly not a weapon.
 
So you want people to based on their own baises to selectively prosecute crimes?

I want people to use judgment and discretion to selectively prosecute crimes as they do already. Not every infraction of the letter of the law necessitates prosecution.

Do you prosecute everyone who comes to your door uninvited for trespassing?
 
I want people to use judgment and discretion to selectively prosecute crimes as they do already. Not every infraction of the letter of the law necessitates prosecution.

Do you prosecute everyone who comes to your door uninvited for trespassing?

So then when people use their judgment and discretion in ways you don't agree with, then what?

Everyone is biased. Everyone bases their decisions on their biases. You specifically want those biases in the process.
 
Perhaps the school board should get more serious about their ZT policy and only allow students to eat pudding from troughs at lunchtime. Mmmmm....troughs full of pudding! :drool:

Seriously, though, I think the reaction was overzealous and it's unfortunate that more discretion isn't used and/or allowed by school policy. However, I also have to question the wisdom of a parent allowing their child to take a knife to school for any reason. And as a parent, I never actually had to read a school's policy to know that a steak knife would not be considered appropriate to bring to school, in addition to being a potential accident waiting to happen...but well, common sense isn't so common, it seems. Poor kid, caught in the middle between ZT and dippy parents.

ETA: I'm assuming the parents allowed it, it's also possible that the child did it on her own without her parent's knowledge. In which case, well...10 year olds don't always make the best decisions, that's why they're called kids, I guess.
 
Last edited:
I'm using the standard definition. A weapon is an object used to kill or injure. She wasn't using this object to kill or injure, therefore, it isn't a weapon.

So only when things are actively being used to kill people can they be prohibitted in school?
 
I would also remind people that any human will generally lie to cover thier butts.

As a ten year old she is probably in grade school, so I don't understand why the police were called, the dean of students maybe.

Now middle schoolers have been repeatedly warned and informed that they are not to have a long list of contraband items, knifes, guns of any sort including toy guns. Thezse item will definitly get you a trip to the dean's office and most likely a sixth month suspension to the alternate school.

Now other contra band such as drugs is treated very much teh same. How ever contraband such as the I-Pod or cel-phones are a little more discretionary. If you aren't showing off in class it isn't likely to be taken nor result in explusion.

Our district has had students use knives in fights in school, so they at least pretend there is a reason behind the zero tolerance policy.

Zero tolerance is a bad idea.

I think in my schools district it would be at the discretion of the dean and the principal.
 
Last edited:
Okay, obviously you've decided to stop making any sense whatsoever, so I'll leave you to argue with whatever strange voices you're hearing between your ears. You and your voices, and whoever else thinks you have anything worthwhile to contribute any more, enjoy yourselves.

You simply want people with your biases to be in charge and use your biases to base their decisions on.
 
Okay, obviously you've decided to stop making any sense whatsoever, so I'll leave you to argue with whatever strange voices you're hearing between your ears. You and your voices, and whoever else thinks you have anything worthwhile to contribute any more, enjoy yourselves.

Agreed... I'm out too.

I guess he "wins" by default.
 
So then when people use their judgment and discretion in ways you don't agree with, then what?

BPSCG addressed this. I agree with him. (Now I need a shower).

Everyone is biased. Everyone bases their decisions on their biases. You specifically want those biases in the process.

Yes.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps the school board should get more serious about their ZT policy and only allow students eat pudding from troughs at lunchtime. Mmmmm....troughs full of pudding! :drool:
And when the class bullies drown the class nerdwimp in a trough full of pudding, what will you say then, hm? Think of the children, for God's sake!!! We need to ban all weapons, including pudding and troughs.

Except butterscotch pudding, of course. Yum.
 
So only when things are actively being used to kill people can they be prohibitted in school?

Goodbye. I have no use in discussing with someone who is intent on avoiding thinking for themselves whenever possible. When you show a willingness to use your brain, I'll gladly continue.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom