10 year old Arrested for Cutting Meat in School

No, she may get a record because she took a weapon to school.

Juvenile record so it should not effecter her as much as an adult record.

Or does florida allow the trial of 10 year olds as adults? I thought that such laws generaly did not go below 12.
 
One of the things I find interesting is that no one involved, including those who support the school and police action, seem to comprehend that this girl is a CHILD. We're not talking about a 17 year old, we're talking about a fifth grader. The idea that adults could be utterly at a loss as to what to do about someone they can pick up and carry under their arm... it boggles the mind.
 
One of the things I find interesting is that no one involved, including those who support the school and police action, seem to comprehend that this girl is a CHILD. We're not talking about a 17 year old, we're talking about a fifth grader. The idea that adults could be utterly at a loss as to what to do about someone they can pick up and carry under their arm... it boggles the mind.

Not all 10 year olds are that small and not all adults are that large. I had just turned 11 when I was taller than my mother. By 13 I was over 6' tall.
 
You where asking for definitions, I provided them for your lazy behavior.

We can do without the insults, don't you think?



Here's the entire chapter

Definition of weapon:
(13) "Weapon" means any dirk, knife, metallic knuckles, slungshot, billie, tear gas gun, chemical weapon or device, or other deadly weapon except a firearm or a common pocketknife, plastic knife, or blunt-bladed table knife.

Apparently a steak knife qualifies as a weapon under Florida State Law, although it could be argued a steak knife qualifies as an exception in spirit if not in letter.

In light of that, I will revise my position. The parents, at least, should have been aware it was against the law.

What it doesn't change, though, is the fact that the policy leaves no room for judgment. Yes, technically she was breaking the law. But what purpose is served by prosecuting a ten-year old that had no intention of using it as a weapon? The absolute enforcement of law with absence of judgment isn't justice.
 
If I was that kid's lawyer, the first thing I would be asking is "what constitutes a weapon?" At what point did that steak knife BECOME a weapon, causing school administrators to act?

I would argue that the knife, at the time and point that the child was using it, was a TOOL... no different than a stapler, or a pencil, or a ruler, or any number of other things the child had access to.

What makes an object a WEAPON is the intent behind its use by the user. Thus the whole "no weapons" policy is actually pretty much common sense, and even redundant or just plain unnecessary. It's like saying "don't attack or threaten anyone in any way, with any object." Because damn near any object can be used as a weapon.

But ya know what? Bring a steak knife to school... because if you don't, and you end up choking on your steak, we'll be sued for that too.
 
Not all 10 year olds are that small and not all adults are that large. I had just turned 11 when I was taller than my mother. By 13 I was over 6' tall.
Don't be silly. In addition to being a child, she's also a girl. It's absolutely ridiculous to even contemplate a supposed necessity for police involvement when a small girl happens to use a knife to cut her food. She wasn't exactly charging towards someone's throat, as I understand it.

Wow, I can't believe I'm in agreement with JoeEllison. :p
 
Yes, but so what? Not all deadly weapons are created equal.
And not all students are, either. Yet this ten-year-old girl using a steak knife for her lunch is treated like a 17-year-old boy carrying a switchblade to settle a grudge. Why should they be treated equally? Because some stupid rule says so?

It is interesting that those arguing against this provide nothing in the way of guidelines to show when an object should or should not be taken from students.
So you believe administrators shouldn't have any latitude in making decisions, that they shouldn't be required to use their own best judgment?

Quite possibly. So you think that under no circumstances that a 10 year old should be arrested for something that they bring to school?
Not in this case, no.

So you are infavor of them having much broader power over disipline,
Yes. I thought I'd made that clear. That's why they get paid the big bucks. Allow them to have broad discretionary powers; if you're going to tell highly-paid administrators that they have no discretionary powers, that they are not to exercise judgment, that they must follow a rigid set of rules designed to cover every conceivable situation, then you might as well fire them all and replace them with a laptop computer that will rigidly enforce every rule to the letter, no matter how stupid the consequences.

... and what happens then when you don't agree with their decision?
Hold them responsible. If they make a bad decision on a trivial matter, shrug your shoulders, say "lesson learned," and everyone moves on. If they make a bad decision that gets someone killed, fire them.
 
It is a state law. Blame the Florida state senate and their Governor.


My comment was an eye rolling reply to the post which saw evil neo-cons behind the push to zero tolerance in schools. In my experience, many school administrators like zero tolerance because it relieves them of responsibility, no matter their politics.
 
Don't be silly. In addition to being a child, she's also a girl. It's absolutely ridiculous to even contemplate a supposed necessity for police involvement when a small girl happens to use a knife to cut her food. She wasn't exactly charging towards someone's throat, as I understand it.

Wow, I can't believe I'm in agreement with JoeEllison. :p

And that is the age when girls tend to be taller than boys.
 
And not all students are, either. Yet this ten-year-old girl using a steak knife for her lunch is treated like a 17-year-old boy carrying a switchblade to settle a grudge. Why should they be treated equally? Because some stupid rule says so?

Why should two 14 year olds be treated the same as a 30 year old and a 14 year when each group has sex? If the crime is having sex with a 14 year old then the first three mentioned are all guilty.
So you believe administrators shouldn't have any latitude in making decisions, that they shouldn't be required to use their own best judgment?

They have the same freedom that people have in my above cases.

No one has said she was charged with any crime, just that she was arrested.
Yes. I thought I'd made that clear. That's why they get paid the big bucks. Allow them to have broad discretionary powers; if you're going to tell highly-paid administrators that they have no discretionary powers, that they are not to exercise judgment, that they must follow a rigid set of rules designed to cover every conceivable situation, then you might as well fire them all and replace them with a laptop computer that will rigidly enforce every rule to the letter, no matter how stupid the consequences.

Hold them responsible. If they make a bad decision on a trivial matter, shrug your shoulders, say "lesson learned," and everyone moves on. If they make a bad decision that gets someone killed, fire them.

Good to see people stand up and argue that equal is unjust.
 
My comment was an eye rolling reply to the post which saw evil neo-cons behind the push to zero tolerance in schools. In my experience, many school administrators like zero tolerance because it relieves them of responsibility, no matter their politics.

Good to know that there is nothing so unfair as treating everyone equaly.
 
Co-pilots, for example can be so reluctant to confront the pilot that plane crashes occur. I saw this on one of those 'how do you survive' shows but I can't seem to find a reference for it.

The U.S. NTSB (National Transportation Safety Board) blamed this as a
significant factor in the crash of the Flash Airlines Boeing 737 in Sharm El
Sheik in 2004 that killed 148. The aerospace people refer to this as Crew
Resource Management (CRM) and according to the NTSB inadequate CRM
has been implicatd in several other incidents. Summary comments by NTSB
on the Flash Airlines accident can be found here:

http://www.ntsb.gov/events/2006/flashairlines/default.htm


Sorry for the derail of the knife discussion.
 
The school should've confiscated the knife and handed it back to the parents with a note reminding them of the rule. But frankly, any parent who gives their ten-year-old something like that to take to school is probably two knives short of a full cutlery drawer.

My mother gave me a butterknife and it got confiscated. Who would have thought you couldn't take a butterknife- it wouldn't even have occured to me.
 
Good to know that there is nothing so unfair as treating everyone equaly.

You misspoke...

ZT rules don't treat everyone equally... they treat every CIRCUMSTANCE equally... every SITUATION equally.

According to the theory of ZT, any person that has a weapon WILL use it to kill someone. Any person that makes a threat WILL carry out that threat. Kids with play guns WILL be able to make those guns fire real bullets! OMG!!!! PANIC!

It's not about the people... it is, to a distressingly high degree, NOT about the people. It's hardly even about the ACTS these people commit... it's about fear more than anything else.

1) Fear of lawsuits, and "getting it wrong on the other extreme"... "We would rather jail, persecute, suspend, expel, bully, and terrify all sort of children, if it saves ONE CHILD'S LIFE from another Columbine."

2) Fear of being WRONG. "OMG, with responsibility to make decisions comes the chance that we may have to LIVE WITH THE CONSEQUENCES OF THOSE CHOICES! OMG, I can't handle such responsibility! I want my mommy!" ... This is coming from adults... professional "educators" who should be far more mature by now.

3) Fear of losing votes. The school board, legislators, governors... they don't want it to be said that because of a lax policy on school violence, some kids got killed.

4) Imposing fear on the masses. Those same politicos use the fear of children being hurt to create a false crisis that gives these people more media attention, more power, and causes an illusion that they're actually doing something worthwhile.

The key phrase to watch out for, which should immediately spike your "BS-o-meter" is this: "protect the children".

As in "we're doing this to..."
"This policy is important so we can..."
"We have to trample on your basic fundamental rights..."
"We're going to take drastic action at even the slightest whiff of a potential problem..."

Why is this so effective? Because any dissenters can immediately be silenced with a simple question:

"So you DON'T want to protect the children?" (Imagine an incredulous tone when reading that)

It's all knee-jerk appeal-to-emotion politics.
 
Good to know that there is nothing so unfair stupid as treating everyone equaly.
Fixed it for you. I guess you'd approve of the Bible's zero-tolerance policy as regards adultery. Mark Twain:
"Thou shalt not commit adultery" is a command which makes no distinction between the following persons. They are all required to obey it:

Children at birth.
Children in the cradle.
School children.
Youths and maidens.
Fresh adults.
Older ones.
Men and women of 40.
Of 50.
Of 60.
Of 70.
Of 80.
Of 90.
Of 100.

The command does not distribute its burden equally, and cannot.

It is not hard upon the three sets of children.

It is hard -- harder -- still harder upon the next three sets -- cruelly hard.

It is blessedly softened to the next three sets.

It has now done all the damage it can, and might as well be put out of commission. Yet with comical imbecility it is continued, and the four remaining estates are put under its crushing ban. Poor old wrecks, they couldn't disobey if they tried. And think -- because they holily refrain from adulterating each other, they get praise for it! Which is nonsense; for even the Bible knows enough to know that if the oldest veteran there could get his lost heyday back again for an hour he would cast that commandment to the winds and ruin the first woman he came across, even though she were an entire stranger.
 
It is interesting... at least some of the people making the biggest stink about these zero tolerance policies are the same ones who vote for the "tough on crime" politicians. This all comes from the same "right-wing authoritarianism" and fear-based decision making that runs all through our culture.

ORly?

I thought it was due to the omnipresent fear all corporations and public officials have of lawyers suing for every little thing, a result of the left-wing's love affair with heavy-handed, intrusive regulations into every aspect of life, resulting from their love of authoritarian control and the profitability of the left-wing grievance industry in securing multi-million dollar settlements for feigned indignations.
 
So you don't beleive in following state law?



A steak knife does not fit as a common pocketknife so it is illegal in florida to have one in school.

Why is everyone so lazy that they don't look at what florida state law says?

I find it astonishing that Florida law classifies a steak knife as a weapon but not a pocketknife or firearm.

Quite possibly. So you think that under no circumstances that a 10 year old should be arrested for something that they bring to school?
As someone else said, I think intent has a lot to do with it. Just because a rule or law is passed, that doesn't mean it should take the place of common sense.

No one has said she was charged with any crime, just that she was arrested.

According to the article:

The student now faces a felony charge for the possession of a weapon on school property and the principal suspended her for ten days.

Some things I wonder about this situation:

I wonder why the teachers couldn't simply see that she was using the knife to cut her food.
I wonder, had they decided the knife was a weapon, why they couldn't just simply take it away from her.
I wonder why they didn't call the principal or school security instead of the police.
I wonder why, having been called, the police felt it necessary to arrest her.
I wonder why the parents, or an alternate family friend, couldn't be contacted.
I wonder why the principal felt it necessary to suspend her, especially after the school spokesman said she did nothing inappropriate.

It seems to me that the only person in this entire scenario who used an ounce of common sense was the girl herself. She knew a knife was a tool used to cut meat.
 
Last edited:
You misspoke...

ZT rules don't treat everyone equally... they treat every CIRCUMSTANCE equally... every SITUATION equally.

According to the theory of ZT, any person that has a weapon WILL use it to kill someone. Any person that makes a threat WILL carry out that threat. Kids with play guns WILL be able to make those guns fire real bullets! OMG!!!! PANIC!

You are wrong. It has nothing to do with use, that would be covered in seperate issues. The issue here is possession not threat, not attack, but possession. So it is only about situations of possession, as other situations have other additional laws about them.

So you think that children should be able to bring weapons to school with out limit? That seems to be your position as they have not acted in any way with those weapons and until they do they can keep them.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom