10 year old Arrested for Cutting Meat in School

In California, the school policy is similar but it appears the school is not absolutely bound to report every student who is caught with a 'dangerous' weapon:

http://www.californiahealthykids.org/c/@6A3o4j9_QwScs/Pages/lawsdbproduct.html?record@1185

This bit: "willfully using force or violence on another, except in self-defense", is an improvement over my high school's policy from twenty years ago. That policy clearly stated that the school had no responsibility to determine if one party in a fight was acting in self defense; for any fight both sides would get a vacation. They enforced it too, so kids who didn't care about their grades would start fights with "smart kids" they didn't like, giving them the choice of a beating or a suspension that would likely hurt their grades. I also remember that if you got caught with a switchblade or a butterfly knife, the teacher would confiscate it from you and that was it; no detention or anything. I'm sure that would have changed if someone was actually stabbed, but it never happened while I was there.
 
No, I am saying that we shouldn't allow kids to bring in weapons willy nilly. Dangerous objects that are necessary for class, provided by the teacher, monitored, etc are perfectly fine.
Should we allow dangerous objects that are necessary for eating?

Maybe schools should post a 'sporks only' rule?
 
Knife At Lunch Gets 10-Year-Old Girl Arrested At School


So, we had her arrested!!!

Teachers that are unable to deal with a 10 year old girl cutting her meat with a knife without calling the Police should not be teaching.

Stupid REQUIRED response - due to the zero-tolerance for weapons due to the over-reaction to (very rare) school shootings by keeping weapons out of schools period (so admins/teachers will not have them if a situation occurs) and extending that zero-tolerance to toy weapons and tools (like knives). The teachers in the real world would have no problem dealing with this - in a world where parents would react stupidly if something major wasn't done - and the response is required by the school board/law they must follow that.
 
Last edited:
Are you suggesting that anything that can be used as a weapon be removed from schools? Because there isn't going to be a lot left, if that's the case.

The problem I have with zero tolerance policies are statements like this:



Yes, you did have a choice. You just had to exercise some judgment.

At the risk of sounding silly -my district has a zero-tolerance policy. If I do not follow it, I can be fired. If I do not report a student with a weapon, I can be fired. If I allow a student to have a weapon I can be fired.
Yes, I have a choice if I am willing to be fired. I cannot be certain (rules vary a bit) but I suspect that the same applies to the teachers you are speaking of. I may think the rule is applied stupidly or is inherently stupid - but I do not plan to get fired for violating it. Questions?

Note: I am not an administrator and do not know the specific requirements on them - but, given the fear factor in the school board, I am fairly sure they are required to bring in the police if a device of weapon capacity is found on a student, in a students locker/possessions, etc. With the same penalty if they do not.
 
Fixed.

Now we could debate zero tolerance policies. I, for one, am in favour of them when it comes to weapons. First of all, they could severely hurt themselves or someone else on accident. Second, someone with less innocent motives may take hold of it and use it to hurt themselves of others. Third, they could intentionally severely hurt themselves or others despite having a legitimate excuse for having it.

And lastly, I would predict a lot of lawsuits :p .

But children need to be armed in school! If you take their weapons away how will they ever learn to properly settle their disputes in the fashion of adults?
 
If there was any indication she might be a danger, I'd be much more sympathetic to their actions. But she was using it to cut meat at lunch. She wasn't attempting to hide it as she likely would have if she intended to use it as a weapon. There was no indication of an altercation, so far as I can tell. It was a knee-jerk overreaction: "Sharp thing! Must call cops!"

And if it was school policy? Why is everyone concluding that she chose to call the police, instead of seeing a weapon and following school policy about weapons?
 
Stupid REQUIRED response - due to the zero-tolerance for weapons due to the over-reaction to (very rare) school shootings by keeping weapons out of schools period (so admins/teachers will not have them if a situation occurs) and extending that zero-tolerance to toy weapons and tools (like knives). The teachers in the real world would have no problem dealing with this - in a world where parents would react stupidly if something major wasn't done - and the response is required by the school board/law they must follow that.

And why do you say it is a response to the rare school mass shootings and not part of the reason that violent deaths in schools have been declining?
 
Couldn't help thinking of JJM 777's stupid reaction to the Saudi rape victim being sentenced to 200 lashes:
Which is more horrid and filthy, to punish one person according to a law that was publicly known to everyone (and which the said person violated), or to torture a multitude of "suspects" without trial, which includes the inconvenient possibility that many of them are innocent?

This ten-year-old girl knew (or should have known) that bringing a knife to school was illegal. Her parents knew (or should have known) that bringing a knife to school was illegal. Yet she did it anyway. She deserves to be arrested!

I'm wearing a watch with a metal wrist band. I could take it off my wrist and wrap it around my hand, making a dandy ad hoc knuckle duster (never heard that term before - I'd always heard, "brass knuckles").
 
Couldn't help thinking of JJM 777's stupid reaction to the Saudi rape victim being sentenced to 200 lashes:


This ten-year-old girl knew (or should have known) that bringing a knife to school was illegal. Her parents knew (or should have known) that bringing a knife to school was illegal. Yet she did it anyway. She deserves to be arrested!

I'm wearing a watch with a metal wrist band. I could take it off my wrist and wrap it around my hand, making a dandy ad hoc knuckle duster (never heard that term before - I'd always heard, "brass knuckles").

And that would then change assault to assault with a deadly weapon.

Are people here seriously saying that schools and the like should not have the power to have rules about what can and can not be brought onto their property?
 
No, I am saying that we shouldn't allow kids to bring in weapons willy nilly. Dangerous objects that are necessary for class, provided by the teacher, monitored, etc are perfectly fine.

Okay. Define "weapon".
 
At the risk of sounding silly -my district has a zero-tolerance policy. If I do not follow it, I can be fired. If I do not report a student with a weapon, I can be fired. If I allow a student to have a weapon I can be fired.
Yes, I have a choice if I am willing to be fired. I cannot be certain (rules vary a bit) but I suspect that the same applies to the teachers you are speaking of. I may think the rule is applied stupidly or is inherently stupid - but I do not plan to get fired for violating it. Questions?

Do you have no judgment about what constitutes a weapon? If you don't, where is "weapon" defined in such a way that you know what constitutes a weapon?
 
Okay. Define "weapon".

Well are we defining use or defineing prohibited objects? In use legaly anything that you use to hurt someone else other than our own body is a weapon. So kicking someone with shoes on is assault with a deadly weapon(or at least can be charged as such).

As for what the school considers a weapon, why don't you look up their definition?

link

On that page it specifically allows knives under 3" in blade length if not intended to conceal. As most steak knives are longer than that it would be not allowed. This seems to be for Seattle Washington. And it is only a state prohibition, it notes that schools generaly prohibit all knives.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom