10 year old Arrested for Cutting Meat in School

And if it was school policy? Why is everyone concluding that she chose to call the police, instead of seeing a weapon and following school policy about weapons?

Policy is supposed to be a way you get things done, a method of handling potential problems.
What it has become is a method of avoiding having to make a judgement, because we all know being judgemental is an evil, nasty thing that could ruin a person's self-esteem. Policy is something to hide behind to avoid any chance of litigation.
That is what is ridiculous.
 
Are people here seriously saying that schools and the like should not have the power to have rules about what can and can not be brought onto their property?
No. People here are seriously saying that such rules are open to criticism when they are written poorly and enforced stupidly (whether the enforcement is a requirement or a judgment call).
 
Well are we defining use or defineing prohibited objects? In use legaly anything that you use to hurt someone else other than our own body is a weapon. So kicking someone with shoes on is assault with a deadly weapon(or at least can be charged as such).

As for what the school considers a weapon, why don't you look up their definition?

link

On that page it specifically allows knives under 3" in blade length if not intended to conceal. As most steak knives are longer than that it would be not allowed. This seems to be for Seattle Washington. And it is only a state prohibition, it notes that schools generaly prohibit all knives.

This happened in Ocala, Fla. How does a link from Seattle Washington help?
 
It is interesting... at least some of the people making the biggest stink about these zero tolerance policies are the same ones who vote for the "tough on crime" politicians. This all comes from the same "right-wing authoritarianism" and fear-based decision making that runs all through our culture.
That just isn't true. This sort of insanity comes from both the left and the right and the left has been particularly guilty. Zero tolerance springs almost entirely from the left and it's mutant spawn - political correctness. What you are saying just, simply not true.
 
And why do you say it is a response to the rare school mass shootings and not part of the reason that violent deaths in schools have been declining?

Statistically, there really is no "violent death in school problem", and never really has been.

http://nces.ed.gov/programs/crimeindicators/crimeindicators2007/ind_01.asp

From July 1, 2005, through June 30, 2006, there were 14 homicides and 3 suicides of school-age youth (ages 5–18) at school. Combined, this number translates into 1 homicide or suicide of a school-age youth at school per 3.2 million students enrolled during the 2005–06 school year.

Between July 1, 1992, and June 30, 1999, no consistent pattern of increase or decrease was observed in the number of homicides at school. During this period, between 28 and 34 homicides of school-age youth occurred at school in each school year. The number of homicides of school-age youth at school declined between the 1998–99 and 1999–2000 school years from 33 to 13 homicides. The number of homicides of school-age youth at school increased from 11 to 21 between the 2000–01 and 2004–05 school years, but dropped to 14 in 2005–06. The percentage of youth homicides occurring at school remained at less than 2 percent of the total number of youth homicides over all available survey years even though the absolute number of homicides of school-age youth at school varied to some degree across the years. Between the 1992–93 and 2004–05 school years, from one to eight school-age youth committed suicide at school each year, with no consistent pattern of increase or decrease.

(bolding mine)
 
Last edited:
The school should've confiscated the knife and handed it back to the parents with a note reminding them of the rule. But frankly, any parent who gives their ten-year-old something like that to take to school is probably two knives short of a full cutlery drawer.
 
That just isn't true. This sort of insanity comes from both the left and the right and the left has been particularly guilty. Zero tolerance springs almost entirely from the left and it's mutant spawn - political correctness. What you are saying just, simply not true.

Sorry, I don't buy your position, especially since I usually take reference to "political correctness" as a sign that a person hasn't really given things very much thought.

If you'd like to do some reading on the subject, click the linky-dink.:D
 
The school should've confiscated the knife and handed it back to the parents with a note reminding them of the rule. But frankly, any parent who gives their ten-year-old something like that to take to school is probably two knives short of a full cutlery drawer.

So you don't beleive in following state law?

(13) “Weapon” means any dirk, knife, metallic knuckles, slungshot, billie,
tear gas gun, chemical weapon or device, or other deadly weapon except
a firearm or a common pocketknife, plastic knife, or blunt-bladed table knife

A steak knife does not fit as a common pocketknife so it is illegal in florida to have one in school.

Why is everyone so lazy that they don't look at what florida state law says?
 
Last edited:
Our society seems to be hell bent on taking thought and judgment out of the disciplinary process. It perhaps seems like good reasoning: make *sure* the problem gets attention, and not just a lick and a promise; eliminate any possibility that the good-old-boys net and local friendships don't get in the way of equal justice. But the results, as demonstrated here, can be grotesque. We don't allow cops leeway - when they see something going down, they have to make an arrest and allow the judges and prosecutors take care of it - the alternative is a Mexican police system, where greasing the palm up front is the best way to beat the rap. It's too bad that one's person's common sense is another's sloppy execution; that's the cost of diversity in society. Back when people all grew up in the same community one could trust community standards because everyone knew what the price was for each step across the line, and everyone - school people, parents and law enforcement knew and supported them.

Asking the police or school officials to use common sense doesn't work - as told above, one could loose a job over it, and possibly wind up being partially responsible for some low probability but very dangerous outcome. On the other hand, we have this sort of thing - a kid with a record because she didn't want to display the bad manners of simply chewing pieces off hunk. Pretty soon it might be the same in your local restaurant. Finger food, everyone?
 
This all comes from the same "right-wing authoritarianism" and fear-based decision making that runs all through our culture.


Sure, those schools are dominated by right wingers with barely a liberal agenda in sight. Cough, cough.
 
Does the school call the police every time there's a playground fight? Does the school call the police every time they catch someone writing their nickname in the bog? Does the school call the police every time they catch an under-aged pupil smoking? Some things, while technically criminal, really are better dealt with by the school.

If there's a law, ordinance or rule which prevents the school using its discretion in cases like this, then it's time it was changed. Unless anyone thinks it's appropriate to see a ten-year-old child dragged through the courts because their parents gave them an inappropriate eating utensil.
 
BPSCG said:
I'm wearing a watch with a metal wrist band. I could take it off my wrist and wrap it around my hand, making a dandy ad hoc knuckle duster (never heard that term before - I'd always heard, "brass knuckles").

And that would then change assault to assault with a deadly weapon.
Well, okay. But don't you think that 99% of the time, 99% of people have access to a "deadly weapon"?

Are people here seriously saying that schools and the like should not have the power to have rules about what can and can not be brought onto their property?
If the rules require a ten-year old girl to be arrested, then the rules are an ass.

Rules and laws are what people do when good judgment and and courtesy fail. If people acted with good judgment and common sense all the time, you could get rid of almost all the laws. Zero-tolerance policies are the admission on the part of a school district that its executives have chosen to give up trying to use good judgment in the administration of its schools. They're saying, "We can't be bothered making difficult decisions even though that's what we get paid for; we're putting in an auto-pilot system of rules so we don't have to think."

And then the auto-pilot fails.
 
On the other hand, we have this sort of thing - a kid with a record because she didn't want to display the bad manners of simply chewing pieces off hunk.

No, she may get a record because she took a weapon to school.

If she was worried about chewing pieces off hunk, then she could have cut the steak at home and brought the pieces to school.

I find it hard to imagine what sort of person does not realise that taking a knife to school is not likely to lead to trouble.
 
it is only a state prohibition, it notes that schools generaly prohibit all knives.
Rather worryingly, it also says that there is no specific statute prohibiting the possession of pepper spray or tazers in school.
 
No, she may get a record because she took a weapon to school.

If she was worried about chewing pieces off hunk, then she could have cut the steak at home and brought the pieces to school.

I find it hard to imagine what sort of person does not realise that taking a knife to school is not likely to lead to trouble.

While this is clearly all true, it doesn't do away with the fact that the school's reaction was out of all proportion to the crime. It seems common sense isn't very common in Florida. Except in the JREF office, of course! :D
 
Well, okay. But don't you think that 99% of the time, 99% of people have access to a "deadly weapon"?

Yes, but so what? Not all deadly weapons are created equal.

It is interesting that those arguing against this provide nothing in the way of guidelines to show when an object should or should not be taken from students.
If the rules require a ten-year old girl to be arrested, then the rules are an ass.

Quite possibly. So you think that under no circumstances that a 10 year old should be arrested for something that they bring to school?
Rules and laws are what people do when good judgment and and courtesy fail. If people acted with good judgment and common sense all the time, you could get rid of almost all the laws. Zero-tolerance policies are the admission on the part of a school district that its executives have chosen to give up trying to use good judgment in the administration of its schools. They're saying, "We can't be bothered making difficult decisions even though that's what we get paid for; we're putting in an auto-pilot system of rules so we don't have to think."

And then the auto-pilot fails.
So you are infavor of them having much broader power over disipline, and what happens then when you don't agree with their decision?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom