10 year old Arrested for Cutting Meat in School

I still carry a pencil lead in my left inside elbow from the third grade-my assailant (a friend - even after same) carries part of one in the top of his right hand (and had a deeper hole). He hit first, I hit better!

See this is why you needed knives. You both so totaly failed.
 
I hereby declare this thread and argument over!

You see, I have zero tolerance for stupidity, and those people who love the Zero Tolerance policies in our schools, I have decided (rather arbitrarily), are just plain stupid.

Want to defend your position? Too bad... My zero tolerance policy prevents you from doing that.

Think you're right? Too bad, I'm right because I say so.

What if you actually are right? Too bad... I don't want to have to make that sort of distinction or decision... god knows having to hear all of the evidence is time-consuming, and I could very well be WRONG... and I just don't want to have to admit that... so I'm just going to declare that this whole discussion is over. You're wrong, I'm right.

Furthermore, all of you are hereby given 10 day suspensions from this forum.

...


....


.....

Okay, if your irony meter isn't off the scale by now, you're daft. If you are a proponent of ZT, and still are after reading that... I'm sorry, nothing more I can say will help you.
 
If the rules require a ten-year old girl to be arrested, then the rules are an ass.


I believe that the majority of people don't quite understand the purpose of rules such as these. "Gun Free Zones" and "Zero Tolerance Policies" are implemented not so much to promote public safety but rather to maintain the "illusion" of public safety. Folks inclined to violent crime are not detered by rules. This is a fact that the rule makers would rather the masses remain ignorant of. It's this ignorance that encourages the rule makers to implement ridiculous, inneffective laws. It's all about sustaining the illusion. It keeps folks happy...
 
Last edited:
Okay, if your irony meter isn't off the scale by now, you're daft. If you are a proponent of ZT, and still are after reading that... I'm sorry, nothing more I can say will help you.

Wonderful strawman. Do you have something meaningful to actualy bring up?
 
There are far more effective weapons that also will not be banned because you see, there is a difference when something has a legitmate use in the context of the school and one that does not.



Exactly. And a steak knife....actively being used to cut meat...in the lunch room....during lunch...has a legitimate use in the context of the school.
 
Wonderful strawman. Do you have something meaningful to actualy bring up?

It's a strawman because you say so?

What exactly did I 'set up so I could knock down'? This is an example of the absurdity of the whole Zero Tolerance thought process!

Oh, and didn't I declare this thread over? Move on already!
 
Last edited:
There are far more effective weapons that also will not be banned because you see, there is a difference when something has a legitmate use in the context of the school and one that does not.
So, learning and applying cood manners does not belong in school?
JC on a pogo stick! I am very glad my kid had better teachers than yourself--as did I.

The announce "Policy" at one of his schools was that there was a "Zero Tolerance Policy on fighting, and that fighting involved 2 people. You could not just discipline one person for fighting. Unfair, or something. If someone walked up behind you and clobbered you, you were fighting. If you saw it coming, and put a notebook or a backback between you and the blow, you were fighting. Zero Tolerance.
When it was pointed out that a kid who didn't care could place a large bet on a foorball game, then walk up to the star QB and slug him, getting them both suspended, the policy was changed.
 
I beleive that the majority of people don't quite understand the purpose of rules such as these. "Gun Free Zones" and "Zero Tolerance Policies" are implemented not so much to promote public safety but rather to maintain the "illusion" of public safety. Folks inclined to violent crime are not detered by rules. This is a fact that the rule makers would rather the masses remain ignorant of. It's this ignorance that encourages the rule makers to implement ridiculous, inneffective laws. It's all about sustaining the illusion. It keeps folks happy...

100% agree.

Gun free zones didn't help the people at Columbine, Virginia Tech, or Westroads mall...

All those gun free (aka: "zero tolerance for guns") zones did was disarm the public, making them easier targets.
 
And if it was school policy? Why is everyone concluding that she chose to call the police, instead of seeing a weapon and following school policy about weapons?

The girl didn't have a weapon, she had a steak-knife.
 
Last edited:
Exactly. And a steak knife....actively being used to cut meat...in the lunch room....during lunch...has a legitimate use in the context of the school.

So you can bring in knives if you bring in meat to cut?

Most students do not need to cut meat, cutting meat has little to do with the vast majority of school lunches.

So because her mother couldn't cook meat except in such a way that you needed a serrated knife to cut it, why shouldn't see be blamed? Learn to cook woman!
 
It's a strawman because you say so?

What exactly did I 'set up so I could knock down'? This is an example of the absurdity of the whole Zero Tolerance thought process!

Oh, and didn't I declare this thread over? Move on already!

The strawman is that no one was infavor of all zero tolerance programs, just that they can be useful.

But let personal baises hold sway, that never hurt anyone ever.
 
So, learning and applying cood manners does not belong in school?
JC on a pogo stick! I am very glad my kid had better teachers than yourself--as did I.

The announce "Policy" at one of his schools was that there was a "Zero Tolerance Policy on fighting, and that fighting involved 2 people. You could not just discipline one person for fighting. Unfair, or something. If someone walked up behind you and clobbered you, you were fighting. If you saw it coming, and put a notebook or a backback between you and the blow, you were fighting. Zero Tolerance.
When it was pointed out that a kid who didn't care could place a large bet on a foorball game, then walk up to the star QB and slug him, getting them both suspended, the policy was changed.

So that was a stupid policy. Why not just blame who ever of them is the minority? That is also using personal judgment and is in no way a zero tolerance policy. It is full of wonderful bias.
 
I believe that the majority of people don't quite understand the purpose of rules such as these. "Gun Free Zones" and "Zero Tolerance Policies" are implemented not so much to promote public safety but rather to maintain the "illusion" of public safety. Folks inclined to violent crime are not detered by rules. This is a fact that the rule makers would rather the masses remain ignorant of. It's this ignorance that encourages the rule makers to implement ridiculous, inneffective laws. It's all about sustaining the illusion. It keeps folks happy...
Bingo.
 
The girl didn't have a weapon, she had a steak-knife.

Must be good for Rob Emerson to know that when he was stabbed it was not with a weapon

He was lying so much, he was being attacked by a man with a steak knife and claimed he was being killed, that is clearly ridiculous.
 
So that was a stupid policy. Why not just blame who ever of them is the minority? That is also using personal judgment and is in no way a zero tolerance policy. It is full of wonderful bias.
Okay, someone needs to call a tow truck, because you just drove off over cliff.
 
Must be good for Rob Emerson to know that when he was stabbed it was not with a weapon

No, he was stabbed with a weapon...

You clearly have a problem with definitions.

From http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/weapon

1. any instrument or device for use in attack or defense in combat, fighting, or war, as a sword, rifle, or cannon.
2. anything used against an opponent, adversary, or victim: the deadly weapon of satire.
3. Zoology. any part or organ serving for attack or defense, as claws, horns, teeth, or stings.

A steak knife is not "for use in attack or defense in combat, fighting, or war."

However, when the steak knife is used "against an opponent, adversary, or victim", then the "weapon" term applies to the steak knife.

Why oh why do I even have to get this granular in detail? You'd think people with an adult level of intelligence would be able to get this without all this crap.
 
Last edited:
Okay, someone needs to call a tow truck, because you just drove off over cliff.

No you are arguing for bias. It is entirely unavoidable when you bring discretion into it. Everyone is biased and judges all events that they see on those biases. There discretion is informed by their biases, as there is no way for it not to be.
 
No, he was stabbed with a weapon...

You clearly have a problem with definitions.

Nope it was "wooden-handled steak knife" and as steak knives are not weapons, he was not stabbed with a weapon.

Either that or the girl did bring a weapon into school
 
No you are arguing for bias.

If, by bias, you mean that a 10 year old girl cutting meat with a steak knife should not be punished as severely as a seventeen year old girl with known violent tendencies brandishing a machete, then, yes, I am arguing for bias.

More accurately, I'm arguing for judgment and discretion, without which laws are just arbitrary rules to punish people for no purpose.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom