10 year old Arrested for Cutting Meat in School

A couple of years ago I heard a similar zero-tolerance-idiocy story. A child took one of the flimsy plastic knives out of the school cafeteria, and a teacher found him with it. The child was suspended, parents and police immediately called as the child was "carrying a weapon on school premises".

Sensibly, the parents said that if the school expelled their child because the plastic knife was a weapon, they would take the school to court for supplying weapons to minors.

The school backed down. :)

Baa, the fun stories I remember are senile old people who get commited to mental institutions because they attack staff with plastice knives.
 
So you're now claiming that it was possible for her to bring in a table knife? I thought the rules were explicit... anything over 3". I don't know many table knives that small.

But don't let the facts get in the way! Zero Tolerance people never do. :)


Now find a story of someone being killed by police officers for stabbing a cop with a table knife.

Still most people here do seem to find it apropraite to bring in 6" fixed blade knives to school.
 
Sure some kids are responsible, but others aren't, and some are downright malicious.

There seems to be a growing mindset in our society which only promotes the illusion of security. A responsible individual, whether a child or adult, is not inclined to use a knife, or any other item, as a weapon in an offensive assault. A malicious individual OTOH is not deterred by policy, rules or laws. Anything can be banned if we employ the rationale that it can be taken from you by a malicious person and used with criminal intent. Where do we draw the line???
 
Now find a story of someone being killed by police officers for stabbing a cop with a table knife.

http://www.pulsetc.com/article.php?op=Print&sid=1411

There is no record of what inmate No. 22121 used to hide the scratches on his cell wall during the first half of September, 1958. The 22,120 inmates who’d preceded him had developed a substantial body of knowledge regarding knives, so it couldn’t have been much of a problem. All we know for sure is that sometime in early September, while the guards walked the night shift and insomnia-plagued prisoners lay awake turning things over in their minds, No. 22121 took to rubbing a table knife with a round end against the wall of his cell.

[...] By the morning of September 15, No. 22121 had managed to fashion a deadly weapon out of a standard institutional table knife. He told the guard on duty that morning that he was feeling sick and didn’t want to go to his job in the prison tailor shop.

Shortly after the guard left he pulled his blanket over his head and plunged the knife into his stomach.

There, done.

If a dangerous criminal did it, so could the 10 year old girl!!1111 We'll never be safe from our children!!1111

So therefore, we should ban table knives. All table knives. If you can't eat it with a knife, then it sucks to be you!

Still most people here do seem to find it apropraite to bring in 6" fixed blade knives to school.

Sure, I mean, yeah. If someone does it, arrest the ****er. I totally see your viewpoint here. They should be tazered too.

If they're five? Seven? Eight? Ten? Who cares if they're kids. Kids are all geniuses and totally know all societal norms, no matter where they come from or what their background is. They're all hiveminded little kids, and should all be punished as harshly as possible for the smallest of offenses. TOTALLY reasonable.

Also, is a table knife a 6" fixed blade or not? How are we defining "fixed blade" here?

Autolite said:
There seems to be a growing mindset in our society which only promotes the illusion of security. A responsible individual, whether a child or adult, is not inclined to use a knife, or any other item, as a weapon in an offensive assault. A malicious individual OTOH is not deterred by policy, rules or laws. Anything can be banned if we employ the rationale that it can be taken from you by a malicious person and used with criminal intent. Where do we draw the line???
Why should they let facts get in the way?

Besides, didn't you know? They aren't children, they're pod aliens from Planet X. And they all secretly hate you. Why else does the government act like the average 10 year old child is just ready to spring into action with knives?

Oh, and another thing: We should ban screwdrivers. (I got in trouble in my high school for bringing in a screwdriver. Because, you know, everyone that has one automatically plans to use it as a weapon, naturally).

Tweety bird wallet chains? Arrest 'em! GI Joe plastic guns? Arrest 'em!

Totally sane.
 
Last edited:
http://www.pulsetc.com/article.php?op=Print&sid=1411


There, done.

If a dangerous criminal did it, so could the 10 year old girl!!1111 We'll never be safe from our children!!1111

So therefore, we should ban table knives. All table knives. If you can't eat it with a knife, then it sucks to be you!


Ah good, now you also have removed disposeable razor blades, and tooth brushes.

But you also failed as it was a modified knife table knife, not a table knife. A great many pieces of metal can be modified in such a way.

The clear way that this should have been settled is based on what the teacher thought of the child's parents, if they where friends the teacher should use their discretion to make it not a problem if they say have had disputes, then you get the girl suspended.

That is what discretion is all about. What is the fun of having power if you don't get to use it?
 
Still most people here do seem to find it apropraite to bring in 6" fixed blade knives to school.

PT, you know very well that's not true. With a handful of exceptions, most people in this thread think it was extremely inappropriate for a ten-year-old to bring a steak knife to school, but the school should've contacted her parents about it, not the police.
 
Ah good, now you also have removed disposeable razor blades, and tooth brushes.

But you also failed as it was a modified knife table knife, not a table knife.
If kids can't be trusted with sharp knives, why should they be trusted with knives they can make sharp?

Oops! Sorry, didn't mean to go all logical on you. Did it hurt?

Let's put it this way. If we consider the girl enough of a criminal to arrest her, then might there be a chance that she's enough of a criminal to make a blunt knife sharp?
A great many pieces of metal can be modified in such a way.
A great many things can be used as a weapon. I can use a pencil or a pen as a weapon. I certainly could make a weapon out of that more easily than I could out of a wallet chain, which is banned in many schools.

The clear way that this should have been settled is based on what the teacher thought of the child's parents, if they where friends the teacher should use their discretion to make it not a problem if they say have had disputes, then you get the girl suspended.

That is what discretion is all about. What is the fun of having power if you don't get to use it?

I thought you were arguing the opposite. That the teachers should blindly punish people based on them carrying anything that is "not wise" to bring.
 
Last edited:
Well, I were a parent, I would be proud of my daughter's ability to properly use a steak knife without giving it much thought. I would be far less impressed if she had memorized the school rules instead.

And how would you react if, while your daughter were displaying her pride-inspiring ability to use a knife, some malicious little boy (perhaps a member of one of the many pre-teen gangs who accord their members "props" for committing senseless acts of violence), feeling envious of her steak while he had nothing but peanut butter and crackers, distracted her, grabbed her knife and stabbed her? Oh no, you wouldn't be filing a lawsuit or demanding that someone be fired and a new law be passed, would you--despite the fact that the whole thing was your fault. Yes. This little girl's parents were negligent for allowing her to bring that knife, no matter what they thought of her abilities, and no matter what she or they knew or didn't know about the law or the school's policies.

Or suppose instead, that the malicious little boy took the knife and stabbed some other kid, and her parents sued you for giving your child the knife. Would you then expect the school to leap to your defense and pay your legal fees as well? And when the school get's sued, and your taxes get raised as a result you won't complain about that, will you?

I'm bloody tired of parents reneging on their responsibilities and foisting them off on me and my colleagues. We teachers are now expected to act not only as educators, but as counselors, psychologists, nurses, investigators, bodyguards, role models and surrogate parents as well. All while being paid less per child under our purview than a teenaged babysitter, and putting our own lives and livelihoods on the line everyday. We are legally mandated reporters, held responsible if we fail to discern parental neglect or abuse; we're supposed to diagnose and report developmental disorders, learning disabilities, and autism; we have to supervise and protect dozens of children of varying degrees of emotional maturity and propensity for violence from drug pushers and gangs and accidents and acts of the Intelligent Designer. We've got right-wing nut jobs constantly screaming for our jobs, if not insisting that we be jailed because their kids aren't scoring well enough on some stupid test, and creationists who want us to help brainwash their kids instead of teaching them the science they need in order to become productive members of society.

Most of us are well educated and very well trained, experienced professionals who are quite capable of doing our own jobs very well, but we have to do too many other people's jobs instead, and we get blamed when conservatives succeed in getting school budgets stripped to the point where they have no choice but to also hire untrained incompetents because they're the only ones who'll fill the vacant jobs. And when we try to protect ourselves and our families from a very possible sudden loss of income (if not from the blades and bullets that are all to commonly used against us) with unions or by following the "zero tolerance" policies that we didn't create in the first place, we're accused of conspiracy and selfishness and lack of judgement.

And despite the fact that we are professionals, who know how to educate, we're forced to kowtow to school boards for the most part made up of largely uneducated idiot parents who barely remember even being in school, couldn't find their way around a textbook if their lives depended on it, and won't take responsibility for their own kids--but they got themselves elected to the board because, despite their utter lack of experience or training, they just know they can do a better job of telling us how to do our jobs than the idiot parents who sat on the board before them.

I feel sorry for this little girl. She's probably going to have emotional issues for a very long time, if not the rest of her life, because of being arrested for something so silly. But the only people who deserve blame are her parents, because they were either too lazy or too busy or too proud of her knife handling abilities to take a minute and a half out of their day to slice her steak for her, and perhaps make her a nice steak sandwich (you've heard of sandwiches, haven't you?) for her lunch.
 
Last edited:
PT, you know very well that's not true. With a handful of exceptions, most people in this thread think it was extremely inappropriate for a ten-year-old to bring a steak knife to school, but the school should've contacted her parents about it, not the police.

It does not seem that way. Most people seemed to think that it was appropriate to bring the knife to school for the reasons she did.
 
I thought you were arguing the opposite. That the teachers should blindly punish people based on them carrying anything that is "not wise" to bring.

That is what people want, personal biases to be the basis of these decisions.

Why can't people come foward and say proudly that they want personal biases to inform the judgements made in these situations? They all seem to live in a magic world free from personal bias.
 
I would think that raising your kids to NOT stab people would be more responsible than preventing them from having anything that could remotely be used in a dangerous way.

But what do I know? Maybe teaching your kids to stab people is perfectly logical.
 
I would think that raising your kids to NOT stab people would be more responsible than preventing them from having anything that could remotely be used in a dangerous way.

But what do I know? Maybe teaching your kids to stab people is perfectly logical.

And when they don't follow your teachings?
 
I would think that raising your kids to NOT stab people would be more responsible than preventing them from having anything that could remotely be used in a dangerous way.

Correct, but what about the other kids? It's impossible to remove everything that's potentially dangerous, but that doesn't mean it's appropriate to let a child take a steak knife to school.
 
Lucky the bitch wasn't tazered. That would show her.
You have no way of knowing that. Some people never learn. She's quite possibly well on her way to becoming a hardened criminal. Do you have any idea what the recidivism rate is among ten-year-old girls? She'll probably come back to school after Christmas break with a scimitar.
 
And when they don't follow your teachings?

Sorry, but isn't the actions of the child the fault of the parent? If a child brings a sharp knife, it's the parent's fault if she's killed by another child... but it's not the parent's fault if the child stabs the other kid.

Consistent!

Ian Osbourne said:
Correct, but what about the other kids? It's impossible to remove everything that's potentially dangerous, but that doesn't mean it's appropriate to let a child take a steak knife to school.
Right, so arrest the bitch!
 
PT, you know very well that's not true. With a handful of exceptions, most people in this thread think it was extremely inappropriate for a ten-year-old to bring a steak knife to school, but the school should've contacted her parents about it, not the police.
and, if you have read the policy and law, you would know the principal could have been fired - or the teacher -especially if he/she made that decision without notifying the principal. Notifying the police is a requirement (by Marion County specifically), not a suggestion. The police make arrest/don't arrest decision.
 
...Extraneous, self pitying BS snipped...
I feel sorry for this little girl. She's probably going to have emotional issues for a very long time, if not the rest of her life, because of being arrested for something so silly. But the only people who deserve blame are her parents, because they were either too lazy or too busy or too proud of her knife handling abilities to take a minute and a half out of their day to slice her steak for her, and perhaps make her a nice steak sandwich (you've heard of sandwiches, haven't you?) for her lunch.

On that we agree--that she will have problems.
And her parents are partially to blame. Possibly. Some 10 year olds are fully capable of, and are allowed to, pack their own lunches.
But you cannot call yourself an educator if you dodge educating because of "Policy".
The situation could have, and should have been handled by removing the knife, sending the young lady in question to detention, and calling in the parents. Situational awareness is not just a pilot's term--the environment of the rules violation DOES count. "Educators" could have used the situation to educate, but chose instead to hide behind a stupid"one size fits all" Policy.
So don't lay all the blame on parents.
 
Y'know, instead of having the police come in and arrest children, can't we use them for more important things? Like arresting dope fiends that DARE (:)) to smoke a joint, arresting people for downloading music to their computer, or people that actually... say... commit assaults or murders?
 
Anything can be banned if we employ the rationale that it can be taken from you by a malicious person and used with criminal intent. Where do we draw the line???
We need to make sure that nothing that could be turned into a dangerous weapon is allowed to find its way into schools.

Like toilet paper and styrofoam cups.

This reminds me of a record I had when I was a tiny little kid. It was the music from Tchaikovsky's ballet, The Sleeping Beauty, with voiceover narration of the story. After the evil fairy condemns the princess to prick her finger on the spindle of a spinning wheel and fall asleep for a hundred years, (end of side one) the king summons his wise men to find a solution.

(Cue mysterious-sounding music on bassoons...)
"The first wise man said, 'I've got it! We must send the princess far, far away.'"
"'NO!!!' said the king."

(More mysterious-sounding music on bassoons...)
"The next wise man said, 'I've got it! We must watch the princess night and day!'"
"'Nooo....' said the king."

(More mysterious-sounding music on bassoons...)
"The third wise man said, 'I've got it! We destroy every spinning wheel in the land'"
"Yes!' said the king."

Even at the age of four, I thought this was a really stupid solution.
 
And now a word from our sponsor:
Mr_stabby.jpg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom