10 year old Arrested for Cutting Meat in School

"....self-pitying BS"....On that we agree--that she will have problems.
And her parents are partially to blame. Possibly. Some 10 year olds are fully capable of, and are allowed to, pack their own lunches.
But you cannot call yourself an educator if you dodge educating because of "Policy".
The situation could have, and should have been handled by removing the knife, sending the young lady in question to detention, and calling in the parents. Situational awareness is not just a pilot's term--the environment of the rules violation DOES count. "Educators" could have used the situation to educate, but chose instead to hide behind a stupid"one size fits all" Policy.
So don't lay all the blame on parents.

I don't pity myself, I pity the fools--oops sorry my Mr.T alter ego popped in their for a second. :)
And on second thought, I won't place all of the blame on just her parents, I'll also blame you and other fools who enable such negligent parenting by complaining about teachers who follow the rules insisted on by parents on the school board. The course of action you suggest would most likely have been a reasonable one. And I have little doubt that at least some of the people involved would have chosen it had it been entirely up to them. That's completely irrelevant, however, as it was not left up them, and the knife never should have been there in the first place. And, yes, some 10 year olds are fully capable of packing their own lunches. This one, apparently was not capable of doing so in a responsible manner, with the requisite level of forethought. If she was allowed to do so nonetheless, then that is again her parents' negligence. I agree with you about situational awareness; as I've already stated previously I don't support "zero tolerance"; but I'll never blame those who've been forced to work under such an idiotic policy from implementing it.
 
Last edited:
Prometheus said:
I'll also blame you and other fools
That's fine.

But you don't have anyone else to blame but yourself for winding up on my ignore list. :)
 
That's fine.

But you don't have anyone else to blame but yourself for winding up on my ignore list. :)

Actually LW... I think our teacher friend here has a good point.

Here I am studying to be a math teacher... I'm putting 5 years of time in to my education here. Do I really want to risk losing a job in the local school district because of a technical violation such as not calling the police as mandated? Remember that many cities have a single school district, so losing your job from that one means you're damn near out of luck with regards to finding another job in that city. Do I really want to have to move just to continue my career? Do i want to have to sell my house, just because I didn't follow some stupid rule?

Lucky for me, I live in a city with like 15 school districts around the area. Still, having to change jobs, and having the "reason for leaving" on my resume, it could be a real career killer...

All for a job that pays $35,000 per year?

Don't blame the teachers for following the rules and covering their asses. They have families, kids of their own, and mortgage payments to worry about.

Blame the idiot administrators that make up these rules. Blame the asshats in the school boards for instituting ZT policies.

TBH, in this whole ordeal, I never once thought the teachers were stupid for doing what they did... my entire argument is against zero tolerance in the first place. ZT = Zero THOUGHT, in my book.

Once these policies are in place, however... what's an educator to do except follow them?

I mean seriously, I could have my career ended by simply not recognizing that a kid is being abused.... Oops, didn't see the signs, though others thought they were evident... suddenly I lose my job AND face criminal charges for failure to report. Gee...

... Maybe I should rethink my new career choice. *sigh*
 
Actually LW... I think our teacher friend here has a good point.
Whether or not he had a point, calling others "fools" for disagreeing with him was not very convincing.

Here I am studying to be a math teacher... I'm putting 5 years of time in to my education here. Do I really want to risk losing a job in the local school district because of a technical violation such as not calling the police as mandated?
Even so, I do not get why blaming the parent is 100% kosher. It makes several assumptions, and I've already shown it to be inconsistent; the children are held to be responsible enough to be violent even with the "correct" parental guidance, and yet the parents are blamed if the child decided to bring a steak knife.

Personally, I'd say that he's made a lot more statements and claims than simply that a teacher should obey the rules out of fear for being fired. Calling all of us fools, for instance, didn't have anything to do with that. :)

Remember that many cities have a single school district, so losing your job from that one means you're damn near out of luck with regards to finding another job in that city. Do I really want to have to move just to continue my career? Do i want to have to sell my house, just because I didn't follow some stupid rule?

Lucky for me, I live in a city with like 15 school districts around the area. Still, having to change jobs, and having the "reason for leaving" on my resume, it could be a real career killer...

All for a job that pays $35,000 per year?

Don't blame the teachers for following the rules and covering their asses. They have families, kids of their own, and mortgage payments to worry about.

Blame the idiot administrators that make up these rules. Blame the asshats in the school boards for instituting ZT policies.

TBH, in this whole ordeal, I never once thought the teachers were stupid for doing what they did... my entire argument is against zero tolerance in the first place. ZT = Zero THOUGHT, in my book.

Once these policies are in place, however... what's an educator to do except follow them?

I mean seriously, I could have my career ended by simply not recognizing that a kid is being abused.... Oops, didn't see the signs, though others thought they were evident... suddenly I lose my job AND face criminal charges for failure to report. Gee...

... Maybe I should rethink my new career choice. *sigh*

That's all interesting and all that, but is that really Prometheus' only point?
 
And how would you react if, while your daughter were displaying her pride-inspiring ability to use a knife, some malicious little boy (perhaps a member of one of the many pre-teen gangs who accord their members "props" for committing senseless acts of violence), feeling envious of her steak while he had nothing but peanut butter and crackers, distracted her, grabbed her knife and stabbed her?

And why is it that you as an educator haven't recognized this pre-teen antisocial gang member and dealt with him before he resorted to violence? The table utensil is not the problem here.

It's a shame that it takes a little girl getting stabbed in the lunch room for you to recognize who the bad apples are. But it's better for everybody if you find out when it's only a flimsy stake knife and not after the kid is abel to acquire guns and go on a shooting rampage killing both students and teachers.

Did we even have shooting rampages in schools before the guns and knives were banned?
 
And how would you react if, while your daughter were displaying her pride-inspiring ability to use a knife, some malicious little boy (perhaps a member of one of the many pre-teen gangs who accord their members "props" for committing senseless acts of violence), feeling envious of her steak while he had nothing but peanut butter and crackers, distracted her, grabbed her knife and stabbed her? Oh no, you wouldn't be filing a lawsuit or demanding that someone be fired and a new law be passed, would you--despite the fact that the whole thing was your fault.


You blaming someone other than the attacker doesnt make much sense to me. I find it crazy that you would blame the parents for a hypothetical stabbing when the attacker could have stabbed her with almost anything at any time. it seems like you think the knife itself somehow causes an assault. is that accurate?
 
And why is it that you as an educator haven't recognized this pre-teen antisocial gang member and dealt with him before he resorted to violence? The table utensil is not the problem here.
Because he keeps coming back! The kids he beat up on, who were suspended, left and went to private schools for their education, and these bullys got nowhere else to go.
Besides, it was her fault for provoking him by existing.
It's a shame that it takes a little girl getting stabbed in the lunch room for you to recognize who the bad apples are. But it's better for everybody if you find out when it's only a flimsy stake knife and not after the kid is abel to acquire guns and go on a shooting rampage killing both students and teachers.

Did we even have shooting rampages in schools before the guns and knives were banned?
um...probably. But they weren't ammo in some politician's personal agenda.
 
I don't pity myself, I pity the fools--oops sorry my Mr.T alter ego popped in their for a second. :)
And on second thought, I won't place all of the blame on just her parents, I'll also blame you and other fools who enable such negligent parenting by complaining about teachers who follow the rules insisted on by parents on the school board. The course of action you suggest would most likely have been a reasonable one. And I have little doubt that at least some of the people involved would have chosen it had it been entirely up to them. That's completely irrelevant, however, as it was not left up them, and the knife never should have been there in the first place. And, yes, some 10 year olds are fully capable of packing their own lunches. This one, apparently was not capable of doing so in a responsible manner, with the requisite level of forethought. If she was allowed to do so nonetheless, then that is again her parents' negligence. I agree with you about situational awareness; as I've already stated previously I don't support "zero tolerance"; but I'll never blame those who've been forced to work under such an idiotic policy from implementing it.

Fuelair's second rule of bureaucracies: Always follow the rules - you can't get in trouble. If the rule is stupid, follow it and bad stuff will happen (and it will probably go away). If the rule is ok, follow it and bad stuff won't happen. If you can't be sure, follow it and see which way stuff goes.
 
This little girl's parents were negligent for allowing her to bring that knife, no matter what they thought of her abilities, and no matter what she or they knew or didn't know about the law or the school's policies.
Yes. I didn't dispute that. I just objected to those who called the girl stupid.
 
Whether or not he had a point, calling others "fools" for disagreeing with him was not very convincing.

Lonewulf is, of course, absolutely correct about this. In the heat of the moment I included an inappropriately personal attack in my comments, and I was wrong to do so. Too bad he can't read my apology. :)

Even so, I do not get why blaming the parent is 100% kosher. It makes several assumptions, and I've already shown it to be inconsistent;

So now we cannot be inconsistent, nor can we have a "one-size-fits-all" policy. Sheesh. I guess I should just report to prison and not even bother trying to figure out what's right.

the children are held to be responsible enough to be violent even with the "correct" parental guidance, and yet the parents are blamed if the child decided to bring a steak knife.

That's actually a good point, even though I can't agree with it wholeheartedly. Had the girl actually brought the knife for the purpose of using it as a weapon, and attacked someone with it, I would be loathe to indict the parents for her crime, though I would also not blame the parents of her victim if they wanted to. On the other hand, in the actual case in question, no one that I've seen has suggested actually punishing the parents. It was the little girl who has been punished albeit somewhat disproportionately.

Calling all of us fools, for instance, didn't have anything to do with that. :)

Again, I was wrong to use such *harsh* :) language, but in my partial defense, I did not call everyone fools, only those that would blame the teachers for following the rules. Nevertheless, even that was, I admit, over the top.

That's all interesting and all that, but is that really Prometheus' only point?

Nope. I have several other points as well:

1) The administrators should not have been blamed, as it's unlikely that they created the ZT policy entirely of their own volition, and even if they did, it would have been done with the advice of legal counsel in an attempt to best protect the children and employees under their charge, the school, the town, and indirectly the taxpayers who would ultimately have to pay for any lawsuits that might have come about had they not done so.

2) The police should not have been blamed for showing up when they were called. Whether or not they should have been blamed for actually making an arrest depends on actual Florida law, which I'm unfamiliar with. I know that the steak knife pictured in the link included in the OP appeared to have a blade longer than 3 inches, and thus it would have been a crime subject to arrest for someone to have carried it in a concealed manner where I am. Did the child conceal it on her way to school? I don't know, but I doubt she would have gotten as far as the lunch room without concealing it.

3) Perhaps the prosecutor should be blamed for making an indictment. I've admitted this previously, though I'm still ambivalent. I don't really know how much discretion prosecutors are actually allowed, but it seems to me that some other reaction might have been better.
 
Yes. I didn't dispute that. I just objected to those who called the girl stupid.

I'm sorry if my rather long rant came off as an attack on you. That was not my intent. I completely agree with you that the girl should not be called stupid.
 
Because he keeps coming back! The kids he beat up on, who were suspended, left and went to private schools for their education, and these bullys got nowhere else to go.
Besides, it was her fault for provoking him by existing.

um...probably. But they weren't ammo in some politician's personal agenda.

I'm actually beginning to like you quite alot, rwguinn! Please don't take my earlier comments personally!
 
For the record, she was not arrested for "cutting meat". The thread title is a little deceptive. It sounds like a typical thread title on The Loose Change forums:

"Man shot and killed for speeding five miles over the limit." And then when you read the story: "Oh yeah, he also pulled a gun on the police officer."

That said, yes, arresting and levying felony charges against a 10-year old for bringing a kitchen knife to school is a bit ridiculously surreal.


ETA: I just noticed this thread is 8-pages long. Perhaps this territory has been covered. If so, my apolgies. But the title still sucks.
 
Last edited:
You blaming someone other than the attacker doesn't make much sense to me. I find it crazy that you would blame the parents for a hypothetical stabbing when the attacker could have stabbed her with almost anything at any time. it seems like you think the knife itself somehow causes an assault. is that accurate?

This illustrates the muddled thinking that permeates today's society. For whatever reason, there seems to be the tendency for people to diffuse responsibility. It's never the fault of the individual, it's the fault of society for permitting an individual to be in possession of the device used to commit the criminal act (whether it's a gun, knife, nail clippers or a sharpened popsicle stick). Take the example cited where a ten yo girl could've had the knife grabbed away from her and her getting stabbed for her cookies by a deviant. I submit that, although possible, it would have been far more likely that a person inclined to such behavior would have brought with them their own knife despite whatever school policy might have been in force. I fail to understand why so many folks seem unable to grasp this ...
 
If you think you need "tons of brains" to work out that taking a knife to a school with a "no weapons" policy is an unwise thing to do, we may have different definitions on what "tons of brains" means.

When I was ten I would have been quite surprised if I were told that it's illegal to bring a steak knife to school but pocket knives are ok. In fact, it still surprises me, and I'm a long way from ten.

No it isn't. You see steak really shouldn't be tough like shoe leather requireing a special knife to cut it.

I am sorry that this is news to you.

Newsflash: Go to the finest of restaurants. Order the tenderest of steaks. Prepare to be amazed when they serve it with a steak knife.

Yes. The knife isn't the issue, the kid is.

DR

Darth, I respectfully disagree. The issue isn't the knife or the kid. The issue is the parents who sent the knife to school, and the teachers and cops who overreacted.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom