10 year old Arrested for Cutting Meat in School

I asked earlier, at what age are children considered old enough to handle knives. Apparently there is no age, at least in the US. I refer you to:

Code:
United States Code
TITLE 18 - CRIMES AND CRIMINAL PROCEDURE
PART I - CRIMES
CHAPTER 44 - FIREARMS
Section 930. Possession of firearms and dangerous weapons in Federal facilities

      (a) Except as provided in subsection (d), whoever knowingly
    possesses or causes to be present a firearm or other dangerous
    weapon in a Federal facility (other than a Federal court facility),
    or attempts to do so, shall be fined under this title or imprisoned
    not more than 1 year, or both.
      (g) As used in this section:
        (2) The term "dangerous weapon" means a weapon, device,
      instrument, material, or substance, animate or inanimate, that is
      used for, or is readily capable of, causing death or serious
      bodily injury, except that such term does not include a pocket
      knife with a blade of less than 2 1/2  inches in length.

so you quote a section of the US Code dealing with weapons in FEDERAL FACILITIES where signs are posted at the door outlining the LAW and its penalties, then expect us to swallow that this applies to a local schoolhouse, where it is a POLICY that is ambiguous at best.
 
so you quote a section of the US Code dealing with weapons in FEDERAL FACILITIES where signs are posted at the door outlining the LAW and its penalties, then expect us to swallow that this applies to a local schoolhouse, where it is a POLICY that is ambiguous at best.

If you look up the text of those school policies, you will find a lot of them are cut and pasted from the federal law. Why is this important? Because you haven't looked at the part I (and the schools) left out.
 
True. But the employees are still treated like children.

Agreed! That is the intention of a bureaucracy for its employees, non-thinking direction followers. The purpose of public schooling is to educate children to understand their child-like roles in a bureaucracy as adults.



Now we are getting somewhere!
:D
 
Last edited:
For the record, I wasn't deceived. I said it was a deceptive title...which it is. She was arrested (sadly) for having a steak knife in her possession...not for cutting meat, as your title clearly states.

Right, but you're making it out to be a purposefully deceptive title, and furthermore compared it to people in the Loose Change forums that tend to use such tactics to further their anti-government agenda.

It tends to make your argument look silly. It's kinda like bringing up the Nazis. ;)

Just a tip: Next time, simply saying that the title was deceptive might do the trick. It also helps if you don't immediately act like it was purposefully deceptive without evidence.

Mince said:
Utterly ridiculous. I absolutely agree with the OP. Idiots like those that took action that lead to her arrest or did nothing to prevent it, seem to lack the requisite common intelligence required to educate others. Man, I want to be a radio talk show host so badly so I can interview these people on air.
Agreed.
 
Last edited:
Utterly ridiculous. I absolutely agree with the OP. Idiots like those that took action that lead to her arrest or did nothing to prevent it, seem to lack the requisite common intelligence required to educate others. Man, I want to be a radio talk show host so badly so I can interview these people on air.
Fortunately, most of those people would not be stupid enough to allow themselves to be interviewed by a terribly biased talk show host, and those who did would deserve whatever happened for being stupid as opposed to doing what they did because it is required by their employer who can fire them if they do not follow a policy mandated by that employer and completely legal. You need to read more (or pay attention more - your choice.). [Especially since I kindly located and provided the Marion County (their employer)School Board policy so you could read it - 2 or 3 pages back.]:):confused:
 
Bah.

I once made an explosive out of a pencil eraser, chalk dust and Elmer's glue.
My best friend as a teen was well none trouble maker in our area - drug taker, drug dealer, amateur chemist (as in explosives), he used to call in bomb threats when he didn't feel like going to school. He used to make that contact explosive with ammonia and iodine crystals. He also made flash powder a lot. He used to put it in those party poppers that look like little champagne bottles and you pull the string and out pops confetti. Those things could take the limbs off of tree and people. He left one in the shed of his families house and forgot about it. A couple of years later his little sister went out in the shed and found it and pull the string. It blew her thumb a few of her fingers off. It is a story I document in my book which will forever remain 3/4 done.
 
My best friend as a teen was well none trouble maker in our area - drug taker, drug dealer, amateur chemist (as in explosives), he used to call in bomb threats when he didn't feel like going to school. He used to make that contact explosive with ammonia and iodine crystals. He also made flash powder a lot. He used to put it in those party poppers that look like little champagne bottles and you pull the string and out pops confetti. Those things could take the limbs off of tree and people. He left one in the shed of his families house and forgot about it. A couple of years later his little sister went out in the shed and found it and pull the string. It blew her thumb a few of her fingers off. It is a story I document in my book which will forever remain 3/4 done.

Nitrogen tri-iodide.
 
My best friend as a teen was well none trouble maker in our area - drug taker, drug dealer, amateur chemist (as in explosives), he used to call in bomb threats when he didn't feel like going to school. He used to make that contact explosive with ammonia and iodine crystals. He also made flash powder a lot. He used to put it in those party poppers that look like little champagne bottles and you pull the string and out pops confetti. Those things could take the limbs off of tree and people. He left one in the shed of his families house and forgot about it. A couple of years later his little sister went out in the shed and found it and pull the string. It blew her thumb a few of her fingers off. It is a story I document in my book which will forever remain 3/4 done.

A good friend of mine in high school used to make homemade napalm, played war games with live ammo in the woods with his buddies, and carved a swastika in his arm with a knife.

He was our saludatorian, and went on to West Point.

(When he was accepted to WP, he had to burn the swastika from his flesh with a piece of hot iron.)
 
ETA oops, posted in the wrong thread. MUST....HAVE....CAFFEINE...croak
 
Last edited:
Perhaps if you looked in this thread.

Dan O., if you know the origin, would you mind posting it here, please? It would be easier than slogging thru a thread.

Is it from one of the Pullman books?

I heard someone use the phrase in an interview recently (unrelated to those books), but I can't recall who it was, and I had no idea at the time if the phrase was original with the interviewee or borrowed from elsewhere.

Thanks.
 
I just googled for the quote. There were only 3 hits including the one in this thread. The other two were from the reviews of The Golden Compass. I assume that Jerome heard the phrase in a review of the movie.
 
I just googled for the quote. There were only 3 hits including the one in this thread. The other two were from the reviews of The Golden Compass. I assume that Jerome heard the phrase in a review of the movie.

The case of the orphaned quote. Dun Dun Dunnnn.
 
It does not seem that way. Most people seemed to think that it was appropriate to bring the knife to school for the reasons she did.

If you asked whether or not the people on this thread would approve of allowing children to bring knives to school, I'm sure the overwhelming majority would say no. After all, we'd still have a line that needs to be drawn. Guns are out, but switchblades? Butcher knives?

The thing is, a teacher could have taken all of 30 seconds to go over to the student, confiscate the knife and explain to the student that it's not acceptable to bring those sorts of objects to school. If they were really quite worried about whether or not she had malicious intent, her parents could have been called, and the rules about bringing such objects to school could have been gone over with all parties present.

If a teacher sees someone using a pencil, they think nothing of it. If a teacher sees someone threatening another person with a pencil, they confiscate the pencil and reprimand the child.

This template could certainly have been followed quite easily in this case. That's not to say that the teacher should have done nothing, but informing the principal and having him/her talk to the student seems to be the most sensible option.

But people often overlook sensibility.
 
I just googled for the quote. There were only 3 hits including the one in this thread. The other two were from the reviews of The Golden Compass. I assume that Jerome heard the phrase in a review of the movie.

That surprises me, since the quote sums up very well what for many is the worst thing about being a child. Surely equivalent quotes exist with slightly different wordings.
 
That surprises me, since the quote sums up very well what for many is the worst thing about being a child. Surely equivalent quotes exist with slightly different wordings.

That is the intention of a bureaucracy for its employees, non-thinking direction followers. The purpose of public schooling is to educate children to understand their child-like roles in a bureaucracy as adults.
 
That is the intention of a bureaucracy for its employees, non-thinking direction followers. The purpose of public schooling is to educate children to understand their child-like roles in a bureaucracy as adults.

It's just the nature of being a child, unless you were an Egyptian pharaoh or something. The same quote could be applied to pets as well.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom