10 year old Arrested for Cutting Meat in School

For the record, she was not arrested for "cutting meat". The thread title is a little deceptive. It sounds like a typical thread title on The Loose Change forums:

"Man shot and killed for speeding five miles over the limit." And then when you read the story: "Oh yeah, he also pulled a gun on the police officer."

For the analogy to be accurate, then the girl involved should have brandished and threatened another person (child or no) with the knife.

Did this occur, and if it did, could you please cite your source?

Quite frankly, I personally don't see the big difference... instead of being arrested for cutting meat, she was arrested for possessing a knife with which to cut her steak. Yes, I see the immediate similarity to a man pulling a gun on a cop! TOTALLY LOGICAL!
 
Last edited:
Darth, I respectfully disagree. The issue isn't the knife or the kid. The issue is the
parents who sent the knife to school, and the teachers and cops who overreacted.

Nope... the issue is the zero tolerance rule in the first place. To say the teachers and cops overreacted when they were doing exactly what they're trained, told, and expected to do (lest they lose their jobs) is misplacing the blame.
 
For the analogy to be accurate, then the girl involved should have brandished and threatened another person (child or no) with the knife.

Did this occur, and if it did, could you please cite your source?

Quite frankly, I personally don't see the big difference... instead of being arrested for cutting meat, she was arrested for possessing a knife with which to cut her steak. Yes, I see the immediate similarity to a man pulling a gun on a cop! TOTALLY LOGICAL!


Forget the content of the analogy and focus on the principle (it has absolutely nothing to do with pulling a gun, bringing a knife to class or cutting meat):

The title is deceptive (regardless of the topic) because it suggested an utterly ridiculous premise which wasn't true.
 
The title is deceptive (regardless of the topic) because it suggested an utterly ridiculous premise which wasn't true.
I agree, but the point is moot since the actual discussion fortunately didn't revolve around that premise.
 
Forget the content of the analogy and focus on the principle (it has absolutely nothing to do with pulling a gun, bringing a knife to class or cutting meat):

The title is deceptive (regardless of the topic) because it suggested an utterly ridiculous premise which wasn't true.

I assumed everyone would understand that she was cutting meat with a knife.

How exactly were you deceived, did you think she was cutting the meat with a fork?

She was not arrested for threatening anyone with a knife, she was arrested for cutting meat with a knife in school.
 
No, she was arrested for bringing a knife to school.

UGGH.

She was arrested for bringing a knife to school to cut her meat.


Think about someone being arrested for speeding and reckless driving because they were avoiding major accident.

If the title of the thread was: "Man arrested trying to avoid an accident", would this also be deceptive?
 
Sigh. She would probably also have been arrested if she had used the knife to carve her initials into a tree.
 
For the record, I wasn't deceived. I said it was a deceptive title...which it is. She was arrested (sadly) for having a steak knife in her possession...not for cutting meat, as your title clearly states.

I was under the assumption that the majority on this forum were bright enough to understand the meaning of the title. Obviously you did understand it by your above words, as did everyone that responded. Why exactly did you have the concern?
 
Why exactly did you have the concern?

I don't know. I guess I'm overly pedantic and I know I'm overly neurotic. Despite the capacity for one to understand your meaning, why not be precise with your title? Adding "with a knife she brought to school" is unencumbersome and absolutely unambiguous. But, like you're suggesting, I guess it's no big deal.
 
Last edited:
I don't know. I guess I'm overly pedantic and I know I'm overly neurotic. Despite the capacity for one to understand your meaning, why not be precise with your title? Adding "with a knife she brought to school" is unencumbersome and absolutely unambiguous. But, like you're suggesting, I guess it's no big deal.

What are your thoughts on the arrest for the possession of a knife;) for the purpose of cutting meat by a 10 year old in school?
 
Last edited:
What are your thoughts on the arrest for the possession of a knife;) for the purpose of cutting meat by a 10 year old in school?


Utterly ridiculous. I absolutely agree with the OP. Idiots like those that took action that lead to her arrest or did nothing to prevent it, seem to lack the requisite common intelligence required to educate others. Man, I want to be a radio talk show host so badly so I can interview these people on air.
 
Last edited:
I asked earlier, at what age are children considered old enough to handle knives. Apparently there is no age, at least in the US. I refer you to:

Code:
United States Code
TITLE 18 - CRIMES AND CRIMINAL PROCEDURE
PART I - CRIMES
CHAPTER 44 - FIREARMS
Section 930. Possession of firearms and dangerous weapons in Federal facilities

      (a) Except as provided in subsection (d), whoever knowingly
    possesses or causes to be present a firearm or other dangerous
    weapon in a Federal facility (other than a Federal court facility),
    or attempts to do so, shall be fined under this title or imprisoned
    not more than 1 year, or both.
      (g) As used in this section:
        (2) The term "dangerous weapon" means a weapon, device,
      instrument, material, or substance, animate or inanimate, that is
      used for, or is readily capable of, causing death or serious
      bodily injury, except that such term does not include a pocket
      knife with a blade of less than 2 1/2  inches in length.
 
Last edited:
I asked earlier, at what age are children considered old enough to handle knives. Apparently there is no age, at least in the US. I refer you to:

Code:
United States Code
TITLE 18 - CRIMES AND CRIMINAL PROCEDURE
PART I - CRIMES
CHAPTER 44 - FIREARMS
Section 930. Possession of firearms and dangerous weapons in Federal facilities

      (a) Except as provided in subsection (d), whoever knowingly
    possesses or causes to be present a firearm or other dangerous
    weapon in a Federal facility (other than a Federal court facility),
    or attempts to do so, shall be fined under this title or imprisoned
    not more than 1 year, or both.
      (g) As used in this section:
        (2) The term "dangerous weapon" means a weapon, device,
      instrument, material, or substance, animate or inanimate, that is
      used for, or is readily capable of, causing death or serious
      bodily injury, except that such term does not include a pocket
      knife with a blade of less than 2 1/2  inches in length.


Nice research, but public schools are not Federal facilities.
 
Utterly ridiculous. I absolutely agree with the OP. Idiots like those that took action that lead to her arrest or did nothing to prevent it, seem to lack the requisite common intelligence required to educate others. Man, I want to be a radio talk show host so badly so I can interview these people on air.

I prefer the forum. It allows me a chance to think prior to relating my thoughts. If this forum were instant like the radio I would have been banned several times over.:D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom