I don't see how anyone can honestly believe that these ZT policies are anything but ridiculous and harmful.
Yeah, I understand that people do. I just don't understand why they do.
ZT policies teach kids 2 things, and 2 things only:
1. Adults have no ******* sense.
2. The rules are arbitrary.
I don't think it's productive to give kids that message.
It doesn't encourage respect for adults, respect for teachers and principals and police and courts in particular, respect for authority in general, or a respect for the law.
And it certainly doesn't encourage free enquiry, or any sense of personal responsibility, or the notion that we all have to communicate and compromise and consider each other's circumstances if we're all going to get along.
Instead, it encourages a disdain for authority and drives home the message that if you want to live your life in a sensible way, you'd better try to dodge the rules, because they're unreasonable.
Even a child can see this is ridiculous.
I don't mean it should be anything-goes. When I was a kid, there wasn't a day at school that I didn't have a knife in my pocket. And sure, some kids had guns in their cars.
Most of us used these "weapons" for mundane purposes.
But then again, we also had stabbings and shootings at my schools. So I'm not opposed to banning knives and guns from schools. No one really needs these things in class.
But this business of "we had no choice" is totally bogus. ZT produces that. If there's a ZT rule, we adults get the luxury of not having to think, or deal with gray areas. But our kids pay the price.
We need to be adults. We need to be the grown-ups. And that means judging the circumstances and coming to a decision based on the facts, not just throwing up our hands and saying "we had no choice".
That's a sorry dodge, and an evasion of responsibility, and even a schoolkid can see that.