10 year old Arrested for Cutting Meat in School

Well, I were a parent, I would be proud of my daughter's ability to properly use a steak knife without giving it much thought. I would be far less impressed if she had memorized the school rules instead.
 
Last edited:
Well, I were a parent, I would be proud of my daughter's ability to properly use a steak knife without giving it much thought. I would be far less impressed if she had memorized the school rules instead.

Yeah because the only way anyone could realise that taking a knife to school might be a bad idea was if they had memorized the school rules. :rolleyes:

Is common sense really so uncommon?
 
Yeah because the only way anyone could realise that taking a knife to school might be a bad idea was if they had memorized the school rules. :rolleyes:

Is common sense really so uncommon?

I'd certainly say the parents were displaying an alarming lack of common sense in sending her to school with a steak knife, even if she personally could indeed be trusted with it.
 
Yeah because the only way anyone could realise that taking a knife to school might be a bad idea was if they had memorized the school rules. :rolleyes:

Is common sense really so uncommon?
Do you remember being a child? If the girl was used to handling knifes at home, she won't have found anything unusual in bringing one to school. To her it was common sense to use a knife if she wants to cut a steak.
 
Do you remember being a child? If the girl was used to handling knifes at home, she won't have found anything unusual in bringing one to school. To her it was common sense to use a knife if she wants to cut a steak.

I do. I knew that certain things that were perfectly acceptable at home, were unacceptable in other contexts, e.g. school. I do not subscribe to the notion that 10 year olds are incapable of making such distinctions.
 
I responsibly carried a pocket knife my entire life since the age of seven. I used the knife as a tool when I needed to or, perhaps one could say, when I wanted to. Are we going to implement laws now based on what an authority determines an individual needs???
If you are living in the US, we always have. Just moreso in the last 20/30 years.:)
 
I know my parents locked the steak knifes in the gun safe. Forks were locked up separately with the ammunition. I submit that all sharp objects be legally banned from all persons under 18 according to the same logic used in this instance. That way 10 year olds' common sense will include the fact that cutting meat with a knife is obviously wrong and absurd if you happen to be in school and common sense will exclude that arresting a 10 year old for cutting meat with a knife is absurd.
 
A couple of years ago I heard a similar zero-tolerance-idiocy story. A child took one of the flimsy plastic knives out of the school cafeteria, and a teacher found him with it. The child was suspended, parents and police immediately called as the child was "carrying a weapon on school premises".

Sensibly, the parents said that if the school expelled their child because the plastic knife was a weapon, they would take the school to court for supplying weapons to minors.

The school backed down. :)
 
almost anything can be a weapon.
Such as belts - ready made garrottes and whips. A belt can also be used for grappling.

And why not ban pupils to bring equestrian equipment to school? You can put someones eye out with a dressage whip and with spurs on your heel kicks gets real nasty. Of course, some will die beacuse they had to go home and pick up their gear and then go to the riding lesson (longer route, higher probability to die in a traffic accident.) But hey, zero-tolerance policies looks good on paper, therefore they are good IRL.
 
Last edited:
The prevalent argument in favor of "zero tolerance" is that a child carrying a knife is an unnecessary and unacceptable risk, precisely because we cannot know the child's intent...
Yes, that would seem to be an insurmountable problem.

Though I suppose someone could ask the kid. "Susie, why do you have a knife...?" Then the teacher could make a judgment call regarding what to do about it.

Nah. That's stupid. Let teachers use their own best judgment? Better to lock them into some stupid rule that treats a ten-year old girl with a steak knife in her lunch bucket the same as a 17-year-old hoodlum with a switchblade in his pocket.

That said, I'm not in favor of any sort of "zero tolerance" policy. I just don't think kids should be allowed to carry knives to school. I don't much care whether they're steak knives or pen knives or ritual ghurka decapitation knives. There is absolutely no instance in which a child needs to have a knife at school unless it's provided by teachers for a specific, supervised project, and returned to the teacher at the conclusion of the project.
You can certainly make a sane argument for that. What's not sane is saying that if the rule is violated, the police must be called and the girl must be arrested.
 
Well Piggy, for the sake of our future society, I sincerely hope that I am wrong and that you are right...

I think he is right, but it may be no benefit to future society. How much does the perception of unfairness matter when you are not a potential victim? I imagine many school officials and teachers see zero tolerance policies as unfair and worthless for their supposed purpose, but quite useful for avoiding lawsuits, firings, and responsibility in general.
 
Yes, because all 10 year olds are JUST ALIKE, and have all the same experiences and values that all of you have.

Seriously, the people in this thread are hilarious. Keep it coming, I'm laughing my heart out.

BPSCG said:
Though I suppose someone could ask the kid. "Susie, why do you have a knife...?" Then the teacher could make a judgment call regarding what to do about it.

Nah. That's stupid. Let teachers use their own best judgment? Better to lock them into some stupid rule that treats a ten-year old girl with a steak knife in her lunch bucket the same as a 17-year-old hoodlum with a switchblade in his pocket.
Justice isn't just blind, it's also deaf and dumb.
 
Last edited:
I see in the ivory tower only prime filet mignon is served. :rolleyes:

Fact is, you don't know if it was steak, ham, chicken, or pork. You don't know that most people can't afford to buy the finest cuts of meat, you don't know that even the best piece of steak cooked by the finest chef will require a sharp knife when eaten a day later cold.

You do know that most table knives are sufficient for all of those? Naa, you refuse anything that can't stab someone.
 
When I was in 8th grade, a kid shot a vice principal in the bus yard. When I was in 9th grade, a friend got his gut sliced open in the cafeteria, and later an armed race fight involving literally hundreds of kids in the schoolyard, including myself, was barely averted (after 6th grade, each school was county-wide, so even by my senior year there were over 500 kids in my class).

But haven't you been paying attention? That sort of school violence is a myth.
 
A rational society would decide that a pocket knife is a handy tool and a rather poor weapon. But the US is now a fear driven society that doesn't make rational decisions. We blindly classify all knives as weapons and set policy based on that absurdity.

Define pocket knife.
 
I don't see how anyone can honestly believe that these ZT policies are anything but ridiculous and harmful.

Yeah, I understand that people do. I just don't understand why they do.

ZT policies teach kids 2 things, and 2 things only:

1. Adults have no ******* sense.

2. The rules are arbitrary.

I don't think it's productive to give kids that message.

It doesn't encourage respect for adults, respect for teachers and principals and police and courts in particular, respect for authority in general, or a respect for the law.

And it certainly doesn't encourage free enquiry, or any sense of personal responsibility, or the notion that we all have to communicate and compromise and consider each other's circumstances if we're all going to get along.

Instead, it encourages a disdain for authority and drives home the message that if you want to live your life in a sensible way, you'd better try to dodge the rules, because they're unreasonable.

Even a child can see this is ridiculous.

I don't mean it should be anything-goes. When I was a kid, there wasn't a day at school that I didn't have a knife in my pocket. And sure, some kids had guns in their cars.

Most of us used these "weapons" for mundane purposes.

But then again, we also had stabbings and shootings at my schools. So I'm not opposed to banning knives and guns from schools. No one really needs these things in class.

But this business of "we had no choice" is totally bogus. ZT produces that. If there's a ZT rule, we adults get the luxury of not having to think, or deal with gray areas. But our kids pay the price.

We need to be adults. We need to be the grown-ups. And that means judging the circumstances and coming to a decision based on the facts, not just throwing up our hands and saying "we had no choice".

That's a sorry dodge, and an evasion of responsibility, and even a schoolkid can see that.

You're absolutely right on all accounts. My experience in school (class of '99) taught me contempt for authority figures and rules in general. On the bright side, it also taught me how to break those rules, and the law, without getting caught.
 
You do know that most table knives are sufficient for all of those? Naa, you refuse anything that can't stab someone.

So you're now claiming that it was possible for her to bring in a table knife? I thought the rules were explicit... anything over 3". I don't know many table knives that small.

But don't let the facts get in the way! Zero Tolerance people never do. :)

Tony said:
You're absolutely right on all accounts. My experience in school (class of '99) taught me contempt for authority figures and rules in general. On the bright side, it also taught me how to break those rules, and the law, without getting caught.
Your "bright side" seems to be rather dim. :p

But yes, agreed. The one time I defended myself against bullies, I got punished for kick 'em in the face. The day they stuff my head in the dirt telling me to eat it... the authority figures didn't care. I guess because I wasn't crying enough or something.

I tell ya something... making someone that's nearly twice your size that loves to gang up on you and beat you... to kick him in the face while chasing me up a ladder and see him bawling like a baby...

I didn't regret it for a moment. And though I was punished, I still look back fondly on that moment.

Maybe authority figures should try to teach less through punishment, and more for setting a good example? Because the punishment didn't teach me a damned thing, except that authority figures could be silly and dumb. By the way, this was back in the... second grade, I think. I think the kids that chased me were third or fourth graders. I also think that the only reason I remember them being so big was thanks to my subjective memory. :D

Either way, yeah, the girl was REAL dumb to bring a knife. Stupid child. She should be put in handcuffs.

Lucky the bitch wasn't tazered. That would show her.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom