10 year old Arrested for Cutting Meat in School

Apologies if someone else has pointed this out, as I've not read the entire thread, but less than a week earlier in the same state a 10 year old was injured by a knife she found on a school bus:

http://www.news4jax.com/news/14839200/detail.html

The knife was probably stashed there when another 10yo kid discovered his mother had packed the knife in his lunch box so he could slice an apple. The smart kid knew it was better to leave the knife where it posed a hazard to other students rather than risk expulsion and life imprisonment being caught taking it into the school.
 
Last edited:
The current mantra is that a kid with any knife, including a penknife, is carrying it with deadly intent.

But we don't care if these same kids cart around a baseball bat.

Wrong. There is no such mantra. The prevalent argument in favor of "zero tolerance" is that a child carrying a knife is an unnecessary and unacceptable risk, precisely because we cannot know the child's intent, nor can we predict the likelihood of the knife getting into the hands of a different child with some other intent. Period.

That said, I'm not in favor of any sort of "zero tolerance" policy. I just don't think kids should be allowed to carry knives to school. I don't much care whether they're steak knives or pen knives or ritual ghurka decapitation knives. There is absolutely no instance in which a child needs to have a knife at school unless it's provided by teachers for a specific, supervised project, and returned to the teacher at the conclusion of the project.

Certainly, school officials should have some leeway to use their own discretion in determining how to react to any infraction. It's certainly true that lot's of administrators hide behind "zero tolerance" because they don't want to take such responsibility and leave themselves open to potential lawsuits and loss of their jobs, and this is a shame, but it's also perfectly understandable given the litigiousness of our society and the propensity to fire school officials first and ask questions later.
 
Last edited:
I don't see how anyone can honestly believe that these ZT policies are anything but ridiculous and harmful.

Yeah, I understand that people do. I just don't understand why they do.

ZT policies teach kids 2 things, and 2 things only:

1. Adults have no ******* sense.

2. The rules are arbitrary.

I don't think it's productive to give kids that message.

It doesn't encourage respect for adults, respect for teachers and principals and police and courts in particular, respect for authority in general, or a respect for the law.
...
snip
....

you left out the important ones:
Actions have no real consequences. Everybody gets treated the same, regardless of circumstance.
The girl cutting her steak is exactly equal to the thug threatening a teacher with a knife.
The attacker in a fight suffers no worse consequences than the person obligated to defend him/her self.
Resistance to abuse is punishable.
 
Even a child can see this is ridiculous.

I fear the opposite to be the case. Modern children raised in these Zero Tolerance environments are blind to the idiocy of it all. What else do they have to compare it to? I've read reports where schools have removed the word "gun" from the vocabulary and prohibited gun images because they are supposedly evil. I've heard of children being suspended for pointing a finger and yelling "bang-bang" during recess or for hugging a classmate. Our society is so intensely politically correct and hypersensitive that it approaches surreality. Consider that today's children, indoctrinated within such an environment, are going to be the law makers of tomorrow...
 
you left out the important ones:
<snip> The attacker in a fight suffers no worse consequences than the person obligated to defend him/her self.
Resistance to abuse is punishable.

Thanks for the reminder.

This is, in fact, how my school system operated. You were in a fight, you got punished. Didn't matter if you were jumped. No one cared, no one asked.

And yeah, my schools were violent.

And indeed, the lessons I learned from that policy was that adults were fools (turned out not to be true, but that's the impression I got), truth and fairness were fairy tales, you'd better watch out for yourself because no one else gave a **** (which actually was true, for all practical purposes), and if you were caught you'd better be a good liar.

By the time I graduated high school I had a raging disdain for authority and adult society, and felt no shame about lying to cover my butt. It took some hard knocks in my 20s to teach me different.

We can avoid this by being rational rather than lazy. ZT policies are lazy.
 
There is absolutely no instance in which a child needs to have a knife at school.


I responsibly carried a pocket knife my entire life since the age of seven. I used the knife as a tool when I needed to or, perhaps one could say, when I wanted to. Are we going to implement laws now based on what an authority determines an individual needs???
 
Last edited:
I fear the opposite to be the case. Modern children raised in these Zero Tolerance environments are blind to the idiocy of it all.

No, they're not.

Kids are instinctively sensitive to issues of fairness.

They have a keen memory for promises -- even those which adults make too casually -- and at certain stages of development can take the issue of fairness to extremes that adults have to take pains to moderate. (E.g., your brother gets more juice because he's bigger than you and you don't finish your juice if I give you that much -- which may or may not override a little kid's insistence that he be treated "fairly".)

Kids are programmed to scour their environment for social cues and norms, and their radars are quick to sound the alarm when they feel they are being punished unjustly.

Some of the most salient memories from my childhood involve unjust punishment. One of my earliest memories is getting my mouth washed out with soap in daycare, at about the age of 5, because one of the women snatched me up from the playground and said I'd been heard saying a dirty word -- I didn't even know any dirty words.

I never forgot (or forgave) that. I can tell you what the sink looked like.
 
I responsibly carried a pocket knife my entire life since the age of seven. I used the knife as a tool when I needed to or, perhaps one could say, when I wanted to.

I've also carried a pocket knife most of life--even carried one to school when I was a child. But this is completely irrelevant. Lot's of people carry guns without ever using them too, but children should still not be allowed to carry them to school. The point is that allowing kids to carry weapons is a risk. Sure some kids are responsible, but others aren't, and some are downright malicious. Teachers and school administrators have enough on their plates without having to figure out whether every kid with a knife is going to use it as a weapon, or accidentally (or purposefully) allow it to get into the hands of another kid who might. Obviously it's not possible to eliminate all danger from children's lives, and it's stupid to try. But school is one place where we should try to eliminate as much of it as possible, if only to reduce distraction from learning.

Are we going to implement laws now based on what an authority
determines an individual needs???

Not laws. School policies. I don't know what Florida law actually says about this sort of case. But I certainly don't think there should be a law requiring police to make an arrest, or prosecutors to make an indictment. I'm ambivalent about whether or not police should have been called in this case, but I see any reason why a teacher shouldn't be allowed to do so if there's even a slight possibility of being sued or losing his/her job for not doing so.
 
Last edited:
Prometheus: I'm with you.

Yeah, we all carried pocket knives, and come deer season there'd be a fair number of firearms in the parking lot. But none of us needed these things in school. We carried them because it was the culture.

Well, times have changed. In our day, "school shooter" wasn't a meme.

Not only that, but we did have violence in our schools involving weapons.

When I was in 8th grade, a kid shot a vice principal in the bus yard. When I was in 9th grade, a friend got his gut sliced open in the cafeteria, and later an armed race fight involving literally hundreds of kids in the schoolyard, including myself, was barely averted (after 6th grade, each school was county-wide, so even by my senior year there were over 500 kids in my class).

High school was no better.

And this wasn't some inner-city school. This was milltown Georgia.

So yeah, get rid of the knives and guns.

But of course let's do it sensibly, not irresponsibly.
 
I've also carried a pocket knife most of life--even carried one to school when I was a child. But this is completely irrelevant. Lot's of people carry guns without ever using them too, but children should still not be allowed to carry them to school. The point is that allowing kids to carry weapons is a risk. Sure some kids are responsible, but others aren't, and some are downright malicious. Teachers and school administrators have enough on their plates without having to figure out whether every kid with a knife is going to use it as a weapon, or accidentally (or purposefully) allow it to get into the hands of another kid who might. Obviously it's not possible to eliminate all danger from children's lives, and it's stupid to try. But school is one place where we should try to eliminate as much of it as possible, if only to reduce distraction from learning..

A rational society would decide that a pocket knife is a handy tool and a rather poor weapon. But the US is now a fear driven society that doesn't make rational decisions. We blindly classify all knives as weapons and set policy based on that absurdity.

If you haven't noticed, the same policies are being applied to adults. The metal detector in the courthouse I visited a couple weeks back was set to zero tolerance. I had to check in my Swiss Army penknife with a two cm blade attached to my car keys. Then empty my pockets, take off my watch and remove my belt to enter. Fear has driven us to the point that no security measures can be questioned. There is no such thing as being too safe.
 
A rational society would decide that a pocket knife is a handy tool and a rather poor weapon. But the US is now a fear driven society that doesn't make rational decisions. We blindly classify all knives as weapons and set policy based on that absurdity.

If you haven't noticed, the same policies are being applied to adults. The metal detector in the courthouse I visited a couple weeks back was set to zero tolerance. I had to check in my Swiss Army penknife with a two cm blade attached to my car keys. Then empty my pockets, take off my watch and remove my belt to enter. Fear has driven us to the point that no security measures can be questioned. There is no such thing as being too safe.

One of the other teachers I work with was attacked by a 14 year old with a pocket knife 2 years ago. The fact that he's still around is perhaps testament to just how poor a weapon a pocket knife is. I don't think that makes any difference at all. And, yes, pocketknives are handy tools--as I said, I carry one myself. But I leave it in my car when I'm on school grounds even though no one is checking me, simply because I don't ever need it in school (and I'm fairly certain that at least some of the children are rather skillful pickpockets). And the children absolutely never have any genuine need for the tool while doing anything remotely related to school work on school property. Allowing them is nothing other than an utterly unnecessary risk.

And, yes, I have noticed that more and more the same sorts of policies are being applied to adults, and that's dumb. I don't in anyway support the fear mongering that has become the norm throughout our society. I'm not sure that courthouse security is a good example of the policy taken too far, though, as there have been many instances of people being attacked in courthouses. But I sympathize with you on the inconvenience of it all. I had the same thing happen to me when I was on jury duty last year. Though, oddly, the courthouse had also had a rule that no one other than jurors could bring outside beverages in; at first I thought this was cool, as I strolled through the metal detector with a 24oz cup of coffee that earned me a look of envy from a few of the lawyers I saw inside. Then I noticed that several of the defendents being led around were glaring at me in pure hatred, obviously aware that since I had a cup of coffee I might be one of the jurors about to put them away. Made me feel like I had a target on my back.
 
At what point do we say the child has grown up and can safely handle a knife?
 
At what point do we say the child has grown up and can safely handle a knife?

I don't. I'm fairly certain that I'm an adult (though my wife might question that assertion). Nevertheless, I don't carry my pocketknife to school, even though I can if I choose to. I don't need it while I'm teaching, so why bother? I also don't care whether a child can safely handle a knife or not, and I don't care whether her parents let her carry one anywhere else she goes. She can go cliff-diving with a bowie knife between her teeth for all I care. She just can't bring one to school. I really don't even understand why this idea upsets anyone.
 
Last edited:
Just as well I have not said it does then, isn't it?
You disagreed with the intent of Lonewulf's sarcastic remark that the girl should have expected the paranoia. I took that to mean that you think she should indeed have anticipated the paranoia.
 
Last edited:
You disagreed with the intent of Lonewulf's sarcastic remark that the girl should have expected the paranoia. I took that to mean that you think she should indeed have anticipated the paranoia.

I disagreed that the girl needed "tons of brains" to know it was stupid to take a steak knife to school. How you wish to (mis)interpret that is your responsibility.
 
Dude, she's ten years old and probably hadn't given it any thought. Now she knows. I just don't feel the wisdom gained was worth the terror.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom