You Can't Fly A 757 Like That!

So the consensus of all the qualified people here is that there's no aerodynamic, electronic, or mechanical reason to believe that a 757 could not be flown the way it was in DC on 9/11? Is that what we're saying?

Yes, I already knew that, but I just wanted to hear it from you guys.. :)
 
So the consensus of all the qualified people here is that there's no aerodynamic, electronic, or mechanical reason to believe that a 757 could not be flown the way it was in DC on 9/11? Is that what we're saying?

Yes, I already knew that, but I just wanted to hear it from you guys.. :)


Yes. :)

Furthermore we have proof in the form most accepted by Troofers...

A youtube video!

-Gumboot
 
If only we had some footage of one of those airliners flying through a big cloud of smoke that we could show the Truthers.

We could then watch how they deny that the vortices would have been the same at the Pentagon.
 
If only we had some footage of one of those airliners flying through a big cloud of smoke that we could show the Truthers.

We could then watch how they deny that the vortices would have been the same at the Pentagon.



I know it's not an airliner, but the film "We Were Soldiers" has some excellent examples of that.

-Gumboot
 
I've found a number of sources (including Jane's All The World's Aircraft) citing the Concorde as having analogue FBW (FBW just means control inputs are transmitted via electronic signals rather than mechanical systems). However these same sources indicate that the B777 was the first Boeing aircraft to use FBW (and it's digital FBW) so that would indicate that although the Concorde was Analogue FBW, the 757 and 767 retained mechanical control systems.

I think part of the problem is people have come to think of digital computer-controlled fly-by-wire as the only type of fly-by-wire. But it's not. The first fly-by-wire used electronic controllers, and the second type used analogue computers. Only the very latest type of fly-by-wire is digital.

The F-16 is an example of analogue fly-by-wire. Like the Concorde, aircraft response was simulated by an artificial movement of the control column. However while in the Concorde this was done through hydraulics, in the F-16 it was done via analogue computers (the original F-16 flight stick didn't actually move at all but pilots didn't feel comfortable flying an aircraft with an entirely unresponsive control column).

-Gumboot

Looking deeper, you're right about the "analogue" term; I was wrong to imply that it's an invalid term. As you say, it refers to aircraft that transmit control inputs via electrical means. But, and this is why I say it's misleading to use the term, is that it's not at all the same thing as what I'll call "true FBW", where inputs are processed by the flight computer (be it an analogue or a digital computer). In my view, you need both features;

a) electrical or electronic actuation of control surfaces
b) a processing computer for input signals that interprets and moderates, "judging" to what degree surfaces should be moved (i.e. interfering)

...for a flight control system to be meaningfully described as being FBW. Certainly for twoofer purposes, aircraft like Concorde, the Vulcan and of course the 757, are not FBW aircraft in the sense that they think of it (ie teh eeevil NWO pooter in charge!!!111). Now, we know that simply actuating your surfaces by alternative means ("analogue FBW" if you will) gives no opportunity for sinister third-party interference or for the limits that some suggest were exceeded. But we also know that even true FBW, with an all-singing, all-dancing computer system (e.g. Airbus A380), could not realistically be co-opted (though the software limits would apply). The 757 is in between in that it's not true FBW, having mechanical/hydraulic flight controls but also having a computer able to "interfere" in limited ways between the controls and the surfaces. We also know that the pilots could override it at any time and as such, the CT FBW theories are debunked. With this in mind, I think it's safe to say that the 757 should not be described as being "fly-by-wire". To summarise for those I haven't already bored to tears:

Airbus A380 - electrically actuated flying surfaces + digital flight management computers = true (digital) fly-by-wire.

Concorde (& Vulcan bomber) - electrically actuated flying surfaces + no flight management computer = what Gumboot has (perfectly acceptably) described as "analogue" fly-by-wire.

F-16 fighter - electrically actuated surfaces + analogue flight management computer = true (analogue) FBW. Although you could describe both the Concorde and F-16 systems as being "analogue FBW", they are radically different in that there was no computer in the Concorde interpreting/moderating/adjusting the stick inputs.

Boeing 757 - hydraulically actuated flying surfaces + flight management computer = NOT fly-by-wire by any other than the twoofer definition (i.e. that there's a computer in the loop is enough for them to say FBW=NWO).

This is semantics, of course, for which I apologise. But it goes back to a fundamental misunderstanding (and fear) of how aircraft and computer systems work that allows the CTists an opportunity. So I think it's important to close that door to them by clarifying what's meant by "fly-by-wire" whenever it's brought up in relation to 9/11.
 
Last edited:
This is semantics, of course, for which I apologise. But it goes back to a fundamental misunderstanding (and fear) of how aircraft and computer systems work that allows the CTists an opportunity. So I think it's important to close that door to them by clarifying what's meant by "fly-by-wire" whenever it's brought up in relation to 9/11.



No apology necessary, an excellent summary. The only ammendment I'd make is that a FBW that used an analogue computer to process the inputs (such as in the original F-16) is also analogue fly-by-wire, just a more sophisticated version than the plain electrical circuitry of the earlier examples.

Digital fly-by-wire to me, indicates control via a DIGITAL computer (the big difference being, from the CT point of view, that a DIGITAL computer can be programmed and reprogrammed relatively easily, where as an analogue computer cannot.

However, you're right. In the nature relevant to 9/11 CT claims, digital fly-by-wire is the key.

Of course, it's all irrelevant anyway as our research has determined that both the 757 and 767 were entirely MECHANICAL and were not in any shape or form FBW.

And, in my mind, the final devastating blow in the CT coffin is the WELL DOCUMENTED fact that Boeing do not put hard limits in their digital fly-by-wire aircraft whereas Airbus do. Arguably, an advanced upgrade of a 757 or 767 done by Boeing might potentially involve the insertion of a digital flight computer between a new digital FBW control column and the mechanical flight controls that monitors and involves itself in the flying of the aircraft, but even if this WAS done the Boeing company policy is to only have soft limits which would warn pilots they were exceeding design specs rather than prevent them exceeding them at all.

Thus the CT FBW claim is moot on TWO points.

JREF Ninjas to the rescue again... :D

-Gumboot
 
I know its not an airliner but do a youtube search for harrier afghanistan. There is footage of a harrier flying extremely low and extremely fast taken by British soldiers...

I can't put a link to it because I haven't made enough posts yet.
 
So the consensus of all the qualified people here is that there's no aerodynamic, electronic, or mechanical reason to believe that a 757 could not be flown the way it was in DC on 9/11? Is that what we're saying?
Last year before the government released the Flight 77 data, there were all kinds of insane things attributed to how it flew in the minutes before the crash. Mostly about the circle that it made to drop altitude. I had always assumed something like a five mile wide circle while dropping altitude, but the Troothers made other assumptions. My favorite was from JohnDoeX, now of PilotsForTruth infamy, who drew his best guess of the path on a Google Earth map. It was headed for DC, then a couple of miles out it made a circle whose diameter was about a quarter mile across, while dropping 5000 feet. I guess that would be like a dive into a vertical barrel roll, then a pullout.

That's what they were saying Hani Hanjour would be incapable of. No sh**, Chuck Yeager would be incapable of that.

Shortly thereafter, the government released the data, which showed a fairly standard-rate turn while descending. Since then, I haven't really seen anything from the Troothers about how Hani could not have flown that path. Now they're having to grasp at other straws.
 
An experienced airline pilot is not going to be late in applying throttle while doing a low level fly past. Air France had been notified that the A320's computer was not responding to throttle inputs in a low altitude low speed flight profile, and they chose not to pass that on to their pilots.

But this was a technical error, it wasn't the computer overriding the pilot, it was the computer not responding to the inputs correctly.

The reality is Airbus fly-by-wire limits DO override pilot input.

Oh, not disputing that, just pointing out that in the case of FRA Flight 296, this wasn't the issue, but rather it was a configuration error that meant the plane responded slower than it should have.

Noone can fly planes planes like Kiwis do!

Our strike force pilots went to TopGun and beat the USN pilots there, well when we had a strike force. :(

Please use the quote button, so we can see to whom you are responding.
No matter how you "do it" elsewhere, we do it this way.
When In Rome...
 
Looking deeper, you're right about the "analogue" term; I was wrong to imply that it's an invalid term. As you say, it refers to aircraft that transmit control inputs via electrical means. But, and this is why I say it's misleading to use the term, is that it's not at all the same thing as what I'll call "true FBW", where inputs are processed by the flight computer (be it an analogue or a digital computer). In my view, you need both features;

a) electrical or electronic actuation of control surfaces
b) a processing computer for input signals that interprets and moderates, "judging" to what degree surfaces should be moved (i.e. interfering)

...for a flight control system to be meaningfully described as being FBW. Certainly for twoofer purposes, aircraft like Concorde, the Vulcan and of course the 757, are not FBW aircraft in the sense that they think of it (ie teh eeevil NWO pooter in charge!!!111). Now, we know that simply actuating your surfaces by alternative means ("analogue FBW" if you will) gives no opportunity for sinister third-party interference or for the limits that some suggest were exceeded. But we also know that even true FBW, with an all-singing, all-dancing computer system (e.g. Airbus A380), could not realistically be co-opted (though the software limits would apply). The 757 is in between in that it's not true FBW, having mechanical/hydraulic flight controls but also having a computer able to "interfere" in limited ways between the controls and the surfaces. We also know that the pilots could override it at any time and as such, the CT FBW theories are debunked. With this in mind, I think it's safe to say that the 757 should not be described as being "fly-by-wire". To summarise for those I haven't already bored to tears:

Airbus A380 - electrically actuated flying surfaces + digital flight management computers = true (digital) fly-by-wire.

Concorde (& Vulcan bomber) - electrically actuated flying surfaces + no flight management computer = what Gumboot has (perfectly acceptably) described as "analogue" fly-by-wire.

F-16 fighter - electrically actuated surfaces + analogue flight management computer = true (analogue) FBW. Although you could describe both the Concorde and F-16 systems as being "analogue FBW", they are radically different in that there was no computer in the Concorde interpreting/moderating/adjusting the stick inputs.

Boeing 757 - hydraulically actuated flying surfaces + flight management computer = NOT fly-by-wire by any other than the twoofer definition (i.e. that there's a computer in the loop is enough for them to say FBW=NWO).

This is semantics, of course, for which I apologise. But it goes back to a fundamental misunderstanding (and fear) of how aircraft and computer systems work that allows the CTists an opportunity. So I think it's important to close that door to them by clarifying what's meant by "fly-by-wire" whenever it's brought up in relation to 9/11.

I still think you're a tad confused. There is absolutely no need to include the Flight Management Computer when talking about flight controls, its used strictly for navigation and it complements the autopilot, not the manual flight controls. Even the 737-200 can be fitted with an FMS, doesn't mean the flight controls have gone digital.

I still think some people are getting hung up on the role of computers in the 757s flight control systems. Lets clear that up - as far as the primary flight controls are concerned, there are none. When the airplane is on autopilot, the Flight Control Computers have control of the airplane; turn off autopilot and you're literally flying with cables, pulleys, and cranks.

Looks look at the flow of control for the 757.

757 Flight Controls
Control column(wheel)-> Mechanical linkage(cables, pulleys, quadrants, cranks, overrides, lockouts, feel and centering mechanisms, spoiler mixers, etc..) -> Hydraulic actuators -> More linkage(rods, torque tubes, reaction links, and control arms) -> Control surface.

757 Autopilot
Autopilot mode control panel and FMS inputs -> Flight Control Computers -> Autopilot Servos -> Linkage -> Control surface.

There are computers in the secondary flight controls(spoilers, flaps, slats) but they are obviously not used to limit control authority as you dont use these devices to control the direction of flight.
 
What's interesting is the different approach to flying that Boeing and Airbus have always taken. In Airbus aircraft, software limits have generally been hard limits - the computer simply would override the pilot's inputs. This has obvious problems, and most likely caused the crash of Air France Flight 296.

In contrast, Boeing have always followed the policy of only WARNING pilots that they are exceeding design specifications, by using lights and alarms etc... but allowing the pilot the option of exceeding such specifications in an emergency.

Thus to claim a Boeing aircraft is incapable of exceeding design specs because the computer will not allow it is a total lie.

-Gumboot

I think both philosophies have their upsides. Airbus seems to realize that most aviation accidents are caused, at least partly, by pilot error and wants to keep the pilots from developing bad habits. Boeing wants the pilot to able to temporarily fly outside the envelope if they need to.

There was a case where a United 747-400, at max takeoff weight, lost an engine on takeoff roll just as the copilot called V1 (decision speed). Since the failure was at or past V1, they legally had to continue the takeoff. The engine could not have failed at a worse time because the airplane was on a collision course with a Mt. San Bruno and was struggling to climb - it didnt have the performance to clear it. The pilots had to pull up into a stall just to clear the mountain and immediately pushed the nose over to regain speed and recover the stall(all this was happening below 1500 ft). In an Airbus, this escape maneuver would not have been possible and the plane likely would flown into the mountain, killing hundreds.

As to the reason Airbus chose the philosohpy it has? I'm convinced this accident was a big reason.
 
IIRC, may be some other fighters as well

The Aermacchi were trainers, but in a war I guess they could have outfitted them.

Phantom please use the quote feature. it'll be much easier to read your replies if you do so. It helps us to know whom you're responding to so that we can also see what post (in its entirety) if we should like to see that post in its original context.


I dont care if you have 7000 posts on another forum; JREF isn't those "other" forums. Ill never get used to it (and I participate on over 20 forums). If users of those forums of varying softwares can use the quote feature, why can't you?

If you continue to post this way, then i'll just judge that you have nothing important to say and put you on ignore.

ETA: BTW, another poster here didn't use the quote function, and was revealed as a sock of a known abuser. Would you want to be treated as such? Right now, I believe that you are a sock of one of the many posters that have been banned from this forum.
 
Last edited:
Phantom please use the quote feature. it'll be much easier to read your replies if you do so. It helps us to know whom you're responding to so that we can also see what post (in its entirety) if we should like to see that post in its original context.

Firstly, I generally use the quick reply, especially at home since I'm on dial up and page loads take a long time, secondly, since I tend to reply to parts of the post, you're not going to get it in "it's entirety" in my posting, and often it'll be one only a few above mine anyway, so I make the strange assumption you likely just read it.

If you continue to post this way, then i'll just judge that you have nothing important to say and put you on ignore.

Well if you judge what a poster has to say on the style of their posting rather than the actually content of the post, it is you that loses out. One of the most eloquent and most knowledgeable people I know on Apollo has a very similar style to mine (in fact I probably mostly post this way because after reading his so often I found it was faster and easier to get to the heart of the matter.) If you put him on ignore just because you didn't like his posting style, you'd lose out big time. Now personally, I don't think I'm in his league with knowledge, but hey, if you put me on ignore all that happens is you miss out when I do have something interesting to say, so no skin off my nose.

BTW, another poster here didn't use the quote function, and was revealed as a sock of a known abuser. Would you want to be treated as such? Right now, I believe that you are a sock of one of the many posters that have been banned from this forum.

Interesting way to make friends and influence people, threaten them and call them names.

I've made no secret of who I am, I've posted it several times. There are people here that know who I am since we are on BAUT together, and a google search of "PhantomWolf" will pull up my profile there and on ApolloHoax (the others aren't me) in the 2nd and 3rd positions on the first page. If however you want to carry on this silliness, instead of making baseless and, frankly, rather rude, allegations, just report it to moderator and they'll pretty quickly see I am exactly who I say I am (I run my own board so I know they can check IP's and that it's show I'm in New Zealand.)

For the most part I have to say that most folks here seem pretty great, but I am a little disappointed in the hostile reaction by some posters simply because I don't fit into "the mould" in my posting style. As far as I'm concerned, unless I'm breaking the rules, or have a moderator tell me to change, my style stays, if you don't like it, well that really is your problem and not mine.
 
Firstly, I generally use the quick reply, especially at home since I'm on dial up and page loads take a long time, secondly, since I tend to reply to parts of the post, you're not going to get it in "it's entirety" in my posting, and often it'll be one only a few above mine anyway, so I make the strange assumption you likely just read it.



Well if you judge what a poster has to say on the style of their posting rather than the actually content of the post, it is you that loses out. One of the most eloquent and most knowledgeable people I know on Apollo has a very similar style to mine (in fact I probably mostly post this way because after reading his so often I found it was faster and easier to get to the heart of the matter.) If you put him on ignore just because you didn't like his posting style, you'd lose out big time. Now personally, I don't think I'm in his league with knowledge, but hey, if you put me on ignore all that happens is you miss out when I do have something interesting to say, so no skin off my nose.



Interesting way to make friends and influence people, threaten them and call them names.

I've made no secret of who I am, I've posted it several times. There are people here that know who I am since we are on BAUT together, and a google search of "PhantomWolf" will pull up my profile there and on ApolloHoax (the others aren't me) in the 2nd and 3rd positions on the first page. If however you want to carry on this silliness, instead of making baseless and, frankly, rather rude, allegations, just report it to moderator and they'll pretty quickly see I am exactly who I say I am (I run my own board so I know they can check IP's and that it's show I'm in New Zealand.)

For the most part I have to say that most folks here seem pretty great, but I am a little disappointed in the hostile reaction by some posters simply because I don't fit into "the mould" in my posting style. As far as I'm concerned, unless I'm breaking the rules, or have a moderator tell me to change, my style stays, if you don't like it, well that really is your problem and not mine.
Phantom:
By using the quote button, we can go back and get the full context of what you are quoting.
I mean, it's not like nobody has ever quoted out of context, or modified "quotes" before, or anything like that.
It is simply that we tend to check evidence presented. We want to see the original. And it ain't just cuz your new here, and that we've had "reasonable" newbies who turned out to be raving lunatics. Heck we even check Claus Larsen's posts
--Ok, bad example, but you get the point?
The little red arrow up there by the "originally posted by" is a direct link to the original post
Thank you.
 
I still think you're a tad confused. There is absolutely no need to include the Flight Management Computer when talking about flight controls, its used strictly for navigation and it complements the autopilot, not the manual flight controls. Even the 737-200 can be fitted with an FMS, doesn't mean the flight controls have gone digital.

I must be using incorrect terminology myself then; what's the correct name for the computer(s) that interprets control inputs? I was trying to make the distinction between FBW that just replaces old fashioned control linkages, and computer-moderated FBW systems that actually interpret the signals sent (the F-16 as distinct from Concorde for example). Initially I was under the impression that to call a system without an interpretive computer (whatever it should actually be called!) wasn't true FBW. I see I've misunderstood myself, but still think that the distinction is important when debating the CTs. It's just another layer of "no way" to add to the debunking.

I still think some people are getting hung up on the role of computers in the 757s flight control systems. Lets clear that up - as far as the primary flight controls are concerned, there are none. When the airplane is on autopilot, the Flight Control Computers have control of the airplane; turn off autopilot and you're literally flying with cables, pulleys, and cranks.

I was trying to make that point (that however you define FBW, the 757 ain't got it!) myself, albeit no doubt mired in my unnecessary exposition re Concordes, Vulcans and F-16s!

Looks look at the flow of control for the 757.

757 Flight Controls
Control column(wheel)-> Mechanical linkage(cables, pulleys, quadrants, cranks, overrides, lockouts, feel and centering mechanisms, spoiler mixers, etc..) -> Hydraulic actuators -> More linkage(rods, torque tubes, reaction links, and control arms) -> Control surface.

757 Autopilot
Autopilot mode control panel and FMS inputs -> Flight Control Computers -> Autopilot Servos -> Linkage -> Control surface.

There are computers in the secondary flight controls(spoilers, flaps, slats) but they are obviously not used to limit control authority as you dont use these devices to control the direction of flight.

Great summary; that's all the CTists should need to read.
 
I must be using incorrect terminology myself then; what's the correct name for the computer(s) that interprets control inputs? I was trying to make the distinction between FBW that just replaces old fashioned control linkages, and computer-moderated FBW systems that actually interpret the signals sent (the F-16 as distinct from Concorde for example).


Gotcha. It sounded like you were 95% there, but you just threw me off a little by noting the FMC in regard to flight controls...

I'm not sure there is a generic description of the computer that crunches the input signals from the stick/column on FBW aircraft. On the 777, there are 2 sets of computers, the ACE{Actuator Control Electronics} and the PFC{Primary Flight Computers}. The ACE just more or less receives the control inputs and transmits unconditioned error signals straight to the hydraulic actuators - or - sends the inputs to the PFCs, which actually upgrade the control inputs depending on other conditions(air data, inertial reference, thrust settings, etc..), enhancing the aircrafts handling and response.

Great summary; that's all the CTists should need to read.


Here is the long version:http://www.911myths.com/Remote_Takeover.pdf

:)
 
That is superb; it ought to be required reading. I've helped push things somewhat off topic, but reminders about docs like that make it worthwhile.
 
As to the reason Airbus chose the philosohpy it has? I'm convinced this accident was a big reason.



Eeek!

Another example of the advantages of the Boeing model is a Boeing 747 (I don't recall the flight or anything, but think it was Korean Air or something?) that tumbled out of the air. The pilot recovered the aircraft using maneouvering that put a force of over 4 G's on the airframe - something the Airbus computer would not allow.

-Gumboot
 
What would happen if you were to switch off the Flight Augmentation Computers (yes, I've been investigoogling :)) on the Airbus - would you have the control authority necessary to do what you describe? Or would the thing be uncontrollable (inherently unstable like the F-16) in that state?

ETA - some good gen on Airbus "laws" here at PPRuNe. Seems that you could revert to "direct law" flight if necessary (if, to choose an example at random, a shadow government operative was trying to take over control of your aircraft in order to crash you into a landmark as a pretext for a middle-east invasion).
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom