You Can't Fly A 757 Like That!

Well a few of the witnesses at the pentagon did mention the engines seeming to power up the last few seconds. Judging from Gumboots excellent NZ airforce footage. I wonder how much was power up and how much was the doppler effect of the motors.

And as someone said "God bless the Boeing company" Well given I have used their excellent products a few times, I would like to second that

Worth passing a compliment to the pilots. Stuff like on them videos makes you glad it takes these guys as long as doctors to get qualified for the big passenger jobs :)
 
The 757 is fly by wire, the flying conditions that day were perfect, and with power like that, damaging the pentagon would have been a doddle.
You sure the 757 is fly-by-wire? Everything I've read says that it and its sister the 767 are mechanically linked. The 777 is fly-by-wire.
 
350kt (402MPH) 100ft, pulling up to 45o of climbout to 7500ft.

That's straight from the horse's mouth... WGCDR Davies, 757 display pilot and former CO 40 SQN, RNZAF.

-Gumboot

So the plane at the Pentagon was probably going faster than these ones. Something else to think about.

Not to mention lower.
 
You sure the 757 is fly-by-wire? Everything I've read says that it and its sister the 767 are mechanically linked. The 777 is fly-by-wire.

You're right, the 757 is not FBW. Fly-by-wire = electronic flight controls. When CTists refer to FBW, they mean (I think) the flight management computer referred to in this Boeing write-up. Not the same thing, and needless to say, eminently possible to override manually.
 
This is a clear case of the Deniers mixing "can't" physically with "should not". Pilots of course should not do barrel rolls with passenger planes for the simple reason that it almost guarantees severe injury to the passengers and crew.

Or maybe not.
 

Sheee-yit howdy, the liquid in the glass (whatever it is, I'm not sure I believe the "iced tea" claim) hardly moves at all. (Relative to the glass/plane, anyhow.)

Clearly there's more to this maneuver than rotation around the roll axis. The plane's trajectory must be following the surface of a cylinder. (Maybe that's why they call it a barrel roll... duh. I do get a kick out of figuring out stuff that should have been obvious to begin with.)

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Slightly OT- but here's another example of what a passenger jet "can't do" (which really just mean that the layman rarely sees it happen).



http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NVV3SNCvXEs

Due to the fact that there is such a strong crosswind when these planes are attempting to land, the pilot has to "lean into" the wind in order to compensate- so as to not be blown off the runway. Passenger aircraft have landing gear that can angle significantly to perform this maneuver so that when the plane touches down, the landing gear are pointing forward and will right the plane on the centerline of the runway.

An odd looking event, but not something that's impossible or unheard of.

When I was in the Arctic I saw a P-3 Orion do this in a 40 MPH crosswind while I was standing at the RVR. Verrry impressive!
 
There is no question a 757 is capable of the maneuver made at the Pentagon. And there is no question AAL77 did indeed hit the Pentagon.

The real question is, who-- or what-- was flying AAL77 when it hit the Pentagon.

That is a hard question. NOT

Darn it was a terrorist. Simple answers. Gee, too bad the CTers can not find answers. Why are CTers challenged with logic and reason?

Even a CTer could have flown 77 into the Pentagon. It is too easy to fly and hit things. Very few people are incapable of hitting targets as large as a 150 foot wide runway let alone the one time largest office building in the world.

The terrorist was lucking he was aiming well when he applied full throttle, which witnesses verify as does the FDR, because the turn radius was well past 100,000 feet at 500 mph for slight bank angles less than 10 degrees.
 
Last edited:
Sheee-yit howdy, the liquid in the glass (whatever it is, I'm not sure I believe the "iced tea" claim) hardly moves at all. (Relative to the glass/plane, anyhow.)

Clearly there's more to this maneuver than rotation around the roll axis. The plane's trajectory must be following the surface of a cylinder. (Maybe that's why they call it a barrel roll... duh. I do get a kick out of figuring out stuff that should have been obvious to begin with.)

Respectfully,
Myriad

A pilot could do a barrel roll while people are eating and no one would know unless they were looking out.
 
Last edited:
But then, if people think it rarely happens, they have obviously never been to Wellington

I absolutely hate flying into and out of Wellington, especially in a Metroliner.

Our airforce used to operate the Hawker Siddeley Andover which was a STOL aircraft with the second largest prop blades of any aeroplane in the world.

Now they have have 3 kites and a paper dart, which is better that the Navy, they got a row boat without any oars or that little rubber bung for the bottom. ;)
 
But then, if people think it rarely happens, they have obviously never been to Wellington

I absolutely hate flying into and out of Wellington, especially in a Metroliner.

Our airforce used to operate the Hawker Siddeley Andover which was a STOL aircraft with the second largest prop blades of any aeroplane in the world.

Now they have have 3 kites and a paper dart, which is better that the Navy, they got a row boat without any oars or that little rubber bung for the bottom. ;)

Do you guys pay any taxes?
 
Do you guys pay any taxes?

Yup, pays for half of the buggers in Wellington to pretend to do some work in a Govt department and then claim it wasn't their fault when something goes wrong.
 
Do you guys pay any taxes?

Less than 1% of our budget is spent on defense. I'm of the opinion that we're depleting our defense capabilities to dangerous levels. Given that our foreign policy is also ostracising us from our closest traditional allies - the United States and Australia - and we have a real problem.

Most of our government budget is spent on unemployed people defrauding the government for social welfare support, which the government turns a blind eye to, because it ensures a lot of votes.

-Gumboot
 
Now they have have 3 kites and a paper dart, which is better that the Navy, they got a row boat without any oars or that little rubber bung for the bottom. ;)


To be fair what we do have is pretty good, we just don't have enough of it... ;) The P3Ks, the ANZAC Frigates, the NZLAVs, Pinzgauers, all our new upcoming ships, the upcoming NH90 choppers...they're all world class.

-Gumboot
 
Most of our government budget is spent on unemployed people defrauding the government for social welfare support, which the government turns a blind eye to, because it ensures a lot of votes.

Did I hear someone say Pitcairn Island?
 
True enough, just still ticked off over the F-16's mostly. ;)


Have you ever been to the Air Force museum...?

In the Strike Wing section, on the wall in enormous letters they have the quote from the White Paper stating that a Strike capability is an essential element of NZDF capabilities, and should be upgraded.

And on the opposite wall, in equally big letters, is the quote from Helen Clark stating that after study they have concluded New Zealand does not need a strike wing, so they're going to scrap it.

It's just priceless.

-Gumboot
 
Re: flt 77 pulled heavy g's to perform its manouvers, my post here;
http://www.proxywhore.com/invboard/index.php?s=&showtopic=58556&view=findpost&p=871980

In that same thread a poster named bill(who is now one of the actual pilots on Pilots for 911 Truth forum) had originally posted that ther plane had performed high g manouvers. In the post I reference above I showed that it did not pull a high lateral g load. He then came back with this (please examine the math)

About the G's

the turn was basically a "standard rate turn" which is actually a timed turn used in IFR it takes 2 minutes to complete a 360 degree turn --very close to the pentagon manuever--it is very gentle maybe 1.1 G's


BUT

the pilot had to pull out of the dive of roughly 2800 ft per second(7000 feet divided by 2.5 minutes) at 450 mph

this is a high G maneauver and very difficult to execute to level flight especially at 450 mph

Did you see it?
He divided 7000 feet by 2.5 minutes and got 2800 feet per second

It pained me (no not really ) to then point out
Well now that's more like it. bill actually chose to stay on topic.

Your numbers.........


2.5 minutes = 150 seconds
7000ft/150 = 46.7 fps average over the entire desent. (That is 7000 ft AGL, right?)

7000/2.5 = 2800 feet per minute

Pulling out of 46.7 fps over 1.5 seconds would result in 1 g


So by my calculations the plane did not exceed 1 g laterally nor vertically.

Again I state that if there is an error in my math then please point that error out. I truly want to know if I make a mistake in that.

Try again bill.

His reply
Well lets see
the force on the wing has to be 1 G in level flight
so if you add the acceleration of pulling out of the dive that would be about
2 G's total

did I miss something

and mine

Now if it did only take 1.5 seconds then that is the number it would register BUT I chose 1.5 seconds only because it gives the answer of 1 g. I have not seen anyone give a number on how long it took for the plane to level out from that average drop of 47 fps.

At 400 mph the plane would travel 587 feet per second, we have it dropping at 47 fps vertically. That means it was coming down at a 4.5 degrees to the horizontal. (the stairs in a house are steeper, a wheelchair ramp is steeper) Slightly steeper than a normal glide slope path(3 deg). Granted it was moving a lot faster than a normal landing, it was never meant to be a normal landing.

If the plane was flying at 400 mph then in 1.5 seconds it would travel 880 feet horizontally and level out in 35 feet vertically if it took 1.5 seconds to level out. It could easily do that between the highway and the helicopter pad. The lampposts were hit about 30 feet agl but they were on the highway which itself was well above the helo pad and even higher than the lawn, which was below the level of the pad.
<<snip>>
Hell man, I am still waiting for the calculations for the 3,4,5 or 7 g figures you gave before.

Was it now 2 g? Did the plane level out from 47 fps in 1.5 seconds? was it 2 seconds?(0.7g) 4 seconds? (0.35 g) I don't care, add the 1 g to it anyway, are you stating that the plane couldn't take it? If not, what would happen bill? Would the plane completely disintegrate? Not likely. Would the wings tear off? Nope, other planes have experienced such g forces in crashs before and still had their wings attached when they hit the ground.

You so far have demostrated that your math skills only go as far as adding 1+1. Why is it that you did not notice that desending 7000 ft in 2.5 minutes was NOT 2800 fps. Even without actually doing the math to see what the number is, why is that not absolutly , immediatly obvious since at 2800 fps it would only take 3 seconds to go 8400 feet. (I can multiply 28 times 3 in my head. I, and everyone in my class, learned to do that in grade 3!) Is your mind so 'open' to a conspiracy that you allowed your brains to fall out?

In true CT fashion he changes the subject to one I had already debunked, that the flight computer would override any command to go over certain limits such as Vmo.

Actually it was probably 7000 feet MSL but it is a moot point since Wash DC is essentially at sea level

I never said 3,4,5,or 7 G's BTW

What I did say and will repeat here again

The 757 WILL NOT ALLOW controlled flight faster thatn the VMO air speed

which is 350 KCAS (about 402 mph, Go ahead and check my math on this, genius)

Flying an aircraft over VMO or VNE is very dangerous

Control surfaces can and do go into flutter conditions --this will destroy them is seconds

Control surfaces can become inoperable above VMO this is why the pilot CANNOT EXCEED VMO in controlled flight in the B757

Here is the type certificate for the 757

http://www.fas.org/man/dod-101/sys/ac/docs/a2nm.pdf

VMO = 350 KCAS = 402 mph

KCAS = Knots Calculated Air Speed

it takes into consideration altitude and temperature

the altitude very close to standard, temperature very close to standard

in other words we can used 350 Knots here for the plane that hit the Pentagon on 9/11

Oh and BTW at least I knew that you had to add the G forces, Genius

Look, you believe what you want I really don't give a rat's ass.

I'm going flying
.

Ok, I respond yet again
http://www.proxywhore.com/invboard/index.php?s=&showtopic=58556&view=findpost&p=884560

and

http://www.smartcockpit.com/b737/VMO_MMO_Limitations_Review.pdf
Exceeding Vmo/Mmo can pose a threat to exceeding
design structural integrity and design stability & control
criteria of the airplane. At speeds less than Vmo/Mmo the
airplane’s flight characteristics have been confirmed by flight
testing to meet FAR requirements. At speeds in excess of
Vmo/Mmo, however, normal airplane handling characteristics are
not assured.
A warning but hardly a statement that the plane will not allow such a thing to occur nor that if the plane does exceed these limits that it will discintegrate in flight.

Then he wants links to show that the Boeing was not computer limited (computer overrides pilot commands)

I do so here
http://www.proxywhore.com/invboard/index.php?s=&showtopic=58556&view=findpost&p=885564
and here
http://www.proxywhore.com/invboard/index.php?s=&showtopic=58556&view=findpost&p=885605
In both examples I show that Boeing aircraft, the second example is a 757, did things that bill says they simply could not do. Hmmmm....
I am not sure if bill ever did understand how wrong he was. He is in good company now as one of JDX's buddies.
In that thread I was warned by one poster that my use of facts concerning 9/11 was not going to win me any friends over there.:D
 
Last edited:
Re: flt 77 pulled heavy g's to perform its manouvers, my post here;
http://www.proxywhore.com/invboard/index.php?s=&showtopic=58556&view=findpost&p=871980

In that same thread a poster named bill(who is now one of the actual pilots on Pilots for 911 Truth forum) had originally posted that ther plane had performed high g manouvers. In the post I reference above I showed that it did not pull a high lateral g load. He then came back with this (please examine the math)

Ok, I respond yet again
http://www.proxywhore.com/invboard/index.php?s=&showtopic=58556&view=findpost&p=884560

http://www.smartcockpit.com/b737/VMO_MMO_Limitations_Review.pdf

A warning but hardly a statement that the plane will not allow such a thing to occur nor that if the plane does exceed these limits that it will discintegrate in flight.

Then he wants links to show that the Boeing was not computer limited (computer overrides pilot commands)

I do so here
http://www.proxywhore.com/invboard/index.php?s=&showtopic=58556&view=findpost&p=885564
and here
http://www.proxywhore.com/invboard/index.php?s=&showtopic=58556&view=findpost&p=885605
In both examples I show that Boeing aircraft, the second example is a 757, did things that bill says they simply could not do. Hmmmm....
I am not sure if bill ever did understand how wrong he was. He is in good company now as one of JDX's buddies.
In that thread I was warned by one poster that my use of facts concerning 9/11 was not going to win me any friends over there.:D
Bill told you a 757 can not exceed 350KCAS it will be destroyed in seconds; or some stupid statement. No facts just junk.

Why are CTers so incredibly dumb? How could the planes fly at all if they could not be flown to their limits over and over. The fact is 4 planes exceed the 350KCAS limit on 9/11. 3 of them did so with no apparent problems as seen by witnesses. 93 may have lost some parts but no one was around to see it. I have been with people who exceed the low altitude limit on their airplanes; they lost some skin under the wing. Some Al skin came off of some honeycomb sections under the wing. 9/11 over speeds were interrupted by buildings and ground before damage could be done.

JDX and his other pilots are nuts. They are not even as studied as the terrorist. The terrorist learned enough to do their mission of flying into buildings. Bill and JDX are so dumb they forgot to study before they started to tell lies.

Questions for JDX and Bill. Are you just dumb or do you know you are telling lies?

How can there be such dumb pilots? JDX and his list of nut case pilots and techs, and other are here to be seen. If one is your pilot run, do not walk to the nearest exit; these guys are clueless and could ruin your day.

http://pilotsfor911truth.org/core.html

This is the great list that JDX says make his stuff right. A list of idiots who make up lies and do not understand flying and systems as even most lay people can.

JDX still says the g force was 5 to 11g to do something on 9/11. He is challenged with flying facts.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom