You Can't Fly A 757 Like That!

The OP reminded me of this film of a 707 rolling by a test pilot (a chandelle actually - which is only 1g - but impressive)
Hey Drag,

I was confused when I first heard the audio attached to this video seem to claim that it was a chandelle instead of a barrel roll. I think that this must be the result of strange audio splicing, and Tex must have been talking about a different maneuver that he did. Because he certainly knows the difference between a chandelle & a barrel roll.

A chandelle is, of course, the maneuver you use if you've flown into a box canyon and you want to make a minimum radius 180° heading reversal. And it is most definitely not a 1g maneuver.

Chandelle: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chandelle
Barrel roll: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barrel_roll

Note that the barrel roll wiki entry actually mentions this very maneuver by Johnston.

tom
 
That video shows a big aileron roll. It is not a true barrel roll and certainly not a chandelle, but closer to a barrel roll than a chandelle.

He basically just rolled the aircraft while keeping it at 1 g, which again is closer to an aileron roll. The difference is basically in the size of the maneuver.

A chandelle is indeed a 1800 max performance climbing turn that ends up just above a stalled condition headed in the opposite direction.
 
How do you maintain 1G with an aileron roll?

It looks to me like he starts out a little flat in the first 90°, but then he seems to add some horizontal & vertical displacements thru the last 270°. Kinda tough to tell from this video.

I'll bow to your experience, tho.

tom
 
How do you maintain 1G with an aileron roll?

Very smoothly! ;)


Now that my smart ass remark is out of the way.. :D He would start the roll with the nose high and just maintain g during the roll. It appears to me that's what he did. There will obviously be slightly more than 1 g at some point or points, but not much more if done very smoothly. I suspect he was generalizing about 1 g.

Let's just agree that it wasn't a pure aileron roll, nor a pure barrel roll. It absolutely wasn't a chandelle.
 
Last edited:
From a purist standpoint a barrel roll would be executed so that the wings are either parallel or perpendicular to the level flight horizon at the cardinal points of the circle. All done at a constant roll rate and constant g.

It is difficult to tell from the video exactly what he did during the roll, but a true barrel roll in that aircraft would have had a much larger diameter. It's not worth quibbling about as it was essentially a cross between an aileron roll and a barrel roll done at about 1 g. Still quite impressive and not many folks would or should attempt it in that aircraft.....
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom