You Can't Fly A 757 Like That!

In that thread I was warned by one poster that my use of facts concerning 9/11 was not going to win me any friends over there.

I'm glad I wasn't drinking when I read that jdh.
 
Why are CTers so incredibly dumb?

We're planning to solve that right after "What is dark matter?" "Where does dark energy come from?" "What are quarks make up of?" and "How does one resolve GR and QM?"
 
Why are CTers so incredibly dumb?

We're planning to solve that right after "What is dark matter?" "Where does dark energy come from?" "What are quarks make up of?" and "How does one resolve GR and QM?"

You can use the Quote buttion on the lower right of the post to reply and capture the post without cut and paste.

That is true. But it is funny how their own post debunk them the best!

http://old.smartcockpit.com/b737/VMO_MMO_Limitations_Review.pdf

They post the Vmo limits. And even in that paper it tells you,
At speeds in excess of Vmo/Mmo, however, normal airplane handling characteristics are not assured.​

Note they did not say destroy anything in any time limit. It is like doing 150 mph in your car with only 120 mph tires. You are taking a chance. But JDX and Bill are lost in their dumb world of CT. Bill may just be dumb, JDX is a fraud trying to make money.$$$
 
Last edited:
You can use the Quote buttion on the lower right of the post to reply and capture the post without cut and paste.

I know, I just tend to post this way. It's lasted me for 7000+ posts on other boards, I'm sure you'll get used to it. ;)
 
A warning but hardly a statement that the plane will not allow such a thing to occur nor that if the plane does exceed these limits that it will discintegrate in flight.

Then he wants links to show that the Boeing was not computer limited (computer overrides pilot commands)

I do so here
http://www.proxywhore.com/invboard/index.php?s=&showtopic=58556&view=findpost&p=885564
and here
http://www.proxywhore.com/invboard/index.php?s=&showtopic=58556&view=findpost&p=885605
In both examples I show that Boeing aircraft, the second example is a 757, did things that bill says they simply could not do. Hmmmm....
I am not sure if bill ever did understand how wrong he was. He is in good company now as one of JDX's buddies.
In that thread I was warned by one poster that my use of facts concerning 9/11 was not going to win me any friends over there.:D


How are you not banned from there already?! I didnt last 5 minutes...literally.

Anyhow, this is actually a complicated topic. Its true that if a 757 pilot wanted to fly right on past VNE, the plane will let him, but it will give lots of indications that what you're doing might be dangerous(master caution, master warning, EICAS message, aural alert, overspeed clacker). As was indicated above, the 757 is not FBW and has no software limits. There are software thrust limits though, and I think your pilot may be getting confused by this fact.

The 757's powerplants are fly-by-wire and have 4 computers that govern all aspects of operation, they are the Electronic Engine Control{EEC}, Thrust Management Computer{TMC}, the Engine Indicating and Crew Alerting System Computer{EICAS} and the Performance Interface Moniter Unit{PIMU}***

The functions of these computers range from engine control, engine operation(valve operation/ stator vane sequencing, etc), monitering(self monitering as well as engine perf. monitering), indication, and protection. The EEC will do its best to provide protection from surges and overspeeds, but in this case, overspeed only refers to the turbine itself - not the airframe. The EEC will also automatically shut an engine down under certain circumstances like excessive vibration, excessive exhaust temperature, very low oil quantity, etc..(not pertinent, just FYI)

The TMC is basically the auto-throttle computer, it doesn't control engine speed unless the autothrottle is engaged. It has other functions during manual operation(autothrottle disengaged) such as setting the thrust limits, which cannot be exceeded.(unless you switch the EECs control switches from "NORM" to "ALT" which changes the way the EEC schedules fuel flow and removes the TMC limits)

The EICAS computer is an indication/warning computer only. The PIMU moniters the engine and EEC for faults and is only used for maintenace. Neither of these two have control functions.

The short version to all of that is you can overspeed the airplane as long as you dont overspeed the engines.

If your guy wants something from flight manual or maintenance manual, I'd be happy to provide it.;)


*** PIMU might be called something else on RR powered 757s
 
Last edited:
How are you not banned from there already?! I didnt last 5 minutes...literally.

I never actually registered. I posted as a guest.

Don't tell me that the great and open proxywhore forum now requires registration and is as ban happy as LCF now.

On "pilots for..."
I am on permanent 80% warn level. I simply do not attempt debate of 9/11 there. This way I can still read what such complete (yes, complete) idiots as George Hayduke have to offer.
 
Last edited:
I never actually registered. I posted as a guest.

Don't tell me that the great and open proxywhore forum now requires registration and is as ban happy as LCF now.

On "pilots for..."
I am on permanent 80% warn level. I simply do not attempt debate of 9/11 there. This way I can still read what such complete (yes, complete) idiots as George Hayduke have to offer.

Yeah, I thought you were talking about the PffffT forum - the funny thing is JohnD'oh had to break his own forum rules to ban me, who broke no forum rules(none that were listed anyways). Funny that.

Anyhow, if you really want to end the fly by wire/overspeed protection debate with Bill. Just post this excerpt which is from the 777 Operations Manual

Flight Envelope Protection

The flight envelope protection system reduces the possibility of inadvertently exceeding the airplane's flight envelope. The flight envelope protection system provides crew awareness of envelope margins through tactile, aural, and visual cues. The protection functions do not reduce pilot control authority. The protection functions are described later in this section and include:
• stall protection
• overspeed protection
• roll envelope bank angle protection.

....

Overspeed Protection

Overspeed protection limits the speed to which the airplane can be trimmed. At VMO/MMO, overspeed protection limits the trim reference speed so that trim is inhibited in the nose down direction. The pilot must apply continuous forward column force to maintain airspeed above VMO/MMO. Use of the alternate pitch trim levers does not reduce column forces.

Yep, even the smart, fly-by-wire 777 doesnt prevent you from busting Vmo.
 
Wonder how long before Lyte takes that second vid in the OP to prove his "flyover theory".

Unfortunately, that video clearly shows the plane would be more than visible as it pulled up, up, and away from the Pentagon.
 
Yep, even the smart, fly-by-wire 777 doesnt prevent you from busting Vmo.



On the fly-by-wire thing, I just thought I'd point out that the more modern computer-controlled fly-by-wire such as in the Boeing 777 is digital fly-by-wire. Before that there was analogue fly-by-wire - the first to use it being the Avro Vulcan in the 1950's. The first airliner to use fly-by-wire was the Concorde in 1969.

Given that the 757 and 767 aircraft entered service in the early 1980's I would suspect they used an analogue fly-by-wire flight control system, rather than a mechanical or hydraulic system.

What's interesting is the different approach to flying that Boeing and Airbus have always taken. In Airbus aircraft, software limits have generally been hard limits - the computer simply would override the pilot's inputs. This has obvious problems, and most likely caused the crash of Air France Flight 296.

In contrast, Boeing have always followed the policy of only WARNING pilots that they are exceeding design specifications, by using lights and alarms etc... but allowing the pilot the option of exceeding such specifications in an emergency.

Thus to claim a Boeing aircraft is incapable of exceeding design specs because the computer will not allow it is a total lie.

-Gumboot
 
This has obvious problems, and most likely caused the crash of Air France Flight 296.

Nope. There were problems with the early A320's engine control response times in certain situations, but the often quoted idea of the computer trying to over-ride the cockpit is as wrong as the often made claims that the HMS Sheffield was made of Aluminium.
 
This has obvious problems, and most likely caused the crash of Air France Flight 296.

Nope. There were problems with the early A320's engine control response times in certain situations, but the often quoted idea of the computer trying to over-ride the cockpit is as wrong as the often made claims that the HMS Sheffield was made of Aluminium.



I'm well aware of the "official" report, which frankly sounds ludicrous. An experienced airline pilot is not going to be late in applying throttle while doing a low level fly past. Air France had been notified that the A320's computer was not responding to throttle inputs in a low altitude low speed flight profile, and they chose not to pass that on to their pilots.

The reality is Airbus fly-by-wire limits DO override pilot input.

Boeing and Airbus differ in their FBW philosophies. In Airbus aircraft, the computer always retains ultimate control and will not permit the pilot to fly outside the normal flight envelope. In a Boeing 777, the pilot can override the system, allowing the plane to be flown outside this envelope in emergencies.

-Gumboot
 
An experienced airline pilot is not going to be late in applying throttle while doing a low level fly past. Air France had been notified that the A320's computer was not responding to throttle inputs in a low altitude low speed flight profile, and they chose not to pass that on to their pilots.

But this was a technical error, it wasn't the computer overriding the pilot, it was the computer not responding to the inputs correctly.

The reality is Airbus fly-by-wire limits DO override pilot input.

Oh, not disputing that, just pointing out that in the case of FRA Flight 296, this wasn't the issue, but rather it was a configuration error that meant the plane responded slower than it should have.

Noone can fly planes planes like Kiwis do!

Our strike force pilots went to TopGun and beat the USN pilots there, well when we had a strike force. :(
 
Our strike force pilots went to TopGun and beat the USN pilots there, well when we had a strike force. :(



Actually I was just watching a video from an RNZAF HUD camera showing our A4K pilots repeatedly (and easily) shooting down F-16s with both guns and missiles.

Pretty impressive.

Add to that their Air to Surface capabilities...

We had an exercise in the Sea of Japan with the kiwis in their old clunky A4Ks trying to take out the latest and greatest US Naval vessels. We sunk their ships over and over again.

How?

We didn't have sophisticated ECM gear, so instead they just came in low. VERY low. They flew down the troughs in the waves. They were technically flying below sea level. They were low enough, and the wave swell was big enough, that even at 500yds out the American ships couldn't see them. Then at the last second they'd pop up seemingly out of the water, accquire a lock, launch their mavericks, and disappear again.

:D

Our boys had NO trouble finding new jobs with foreign airforces when they ditched the strike wing.

-Gumboot
 
On the fly-by-wire thing, I just thought I'd point out that the more modern computer-controlled fly-by-wire such as in the Boeing 777 is digital fly-by-wire. Before that there was analogue fly-by-wire - the first to use it being the Avro Vulcan in the 1950's. The first airliner to use fly-by-wire was the Concorde in 1969.

Given that the 757 and 767 aircraft entered service in the early 1980's I would suspect they used an analogue fly-by-wire flight control system, rather than a mechanical or hydraulic system.

What's interesting is the different approach to flying that Boeing and Airbus have always taken. In Airbus aircraft, software limits have generally been hard limits - the computer simply would override the pilot's inputs. This has obvious problems, and most likely caused the crash of Air France Flight 296.

In contrast, Boeing have always followed the policy of only WARNING pilots that they are exceeding design specifications, by using lights and alarms etc... but allowing the pilot the option of exceeding such specifications in an emergency.

Thus to claim a Boeing aircraft is incapable of exceeding design specs because the computer will not allow it is a total lie.

-Gumboot

I think referring to the "analogue" FBW thing is misleading. The F-16 has what might be described as analogue FBW; whilst the F/A-18E/F for example, is "digital" FBW. Electro-hydraulically actuated flight controls as on the Vulcan and Concorde (where inputs are enhanced to reduce necessary stick forces) aren't the same thing as electrical signals sent via computer being converted into control surface movement. The latter, I imagine, is important to the CTists, because it seems to suggest that inputs could be over-ridden remotely. Not true for true FBW aircraft in any case of course, but nonetheless to call the 757 FBW would IMO be inaccurate. Wikipedia seems to be the main source for referring to electro-hydraulics as "analogue FBW"; I'd be interested in an aviation industry source that uses those words.

As well as the method of actuation itself, the other major implication of the term FBW is that the aircraft's flight management computer (non-existent in the two aircraft you mention) constantly makes control surface adjustments to keep the aircraft a) in flight and b) going where the stick inputs suggest. Now, the 757's computer does something similar to that description, but the flight controls themselves aren't actuated by either analogue or digital FBW.
 
Last edited:
Wikipedia seems to be the main source for referring to electro-hydraulics as "analogue FBW"; I'd be interested in an aviation industry source that uses those words.


I've found a number of sources (including Jane's All The World's Aircraft) citing the Concorde as having analogue FBW (FBW just means control inputs are transmitted via electronic signals rather than mechanical systems). However these same sources indicate that the B777 was the first Boeing aircraft to use FBW (and it's digital FBW) so that would indicate that although the Concorde was Analogue FBW, the 757 and 767 retained mechanical control systems.

I think part of the problem is people have come to think of digital computer-controlled fly-by-wire as the only type of fly-by-wire. But it's not. The first fly-by-wire used electronic controllers, and the second type used analogue computers. Only the very latest type of fly-by-wire is digital.

The F-16 is an example of analogue fly-by-wire. Like the Concorde, aircraft response was simulated by an artificial movement of the control column. However while in the Concorde this was done through hydraulics, in the F-16 it was done via analogue computers (the original F-16 flight stick didn't actually move at all but pilots didn't feel comfortable flying an aircraft with an entirely unresponsive control column).

-Gumboot
 
Actually I was just watching a video from an RNZAF HUD camera showing our A4K pilots repeatedly (and easily) shooting down F-16s with both guns and missiles.

Pretty impressive.

Add to that their Air to Surface capabilities...

We had an exercise in the Sea of Japan with the kiwis in their old clunky A4Ks trying to take out the latest and greatest US Naval vessels. We sunk their ships over and over again.

How?

We didn't have sophisticated ECM gear, so instead they just came in low. VERY low. They flew down the troughs in the waves. They were technically flying below sea level. They were low enough, and the wave swell was big enough, that even at 500yds out the American ships couldn't see them. Then at the last second they'd pop up seemingly out of the water, accquire a lock, launch their mavericks, and disappear again.

:D

Our boys had NO trouble finding new jobs with foreign airforces when they ditched the strike wing.

-Gumboot

This doesn't surprise me too much. When we did have our strike wing, it consisted of only 24 Skyhawks (IIRC, may be some other fighters as well); so I suppose they had to make every pilot count.
 
Last edited:
Sheee-yit howdy, the liquid in the glass (whatever it is, I'm not sure I believe the "iced tea" claim) hardly moves at all. (Relative to the glass/plane, anyhow.)

Clearly there's more to this maneuver than rotation around the roll axis. The plane's trajectory must be following the surface of a cylinder. (Maybe that's why they call it a barrel roll... duh. I do get a kick out of figuring out stuff that should have been obvious to begin with.)

Respectfully,
Myriad
Yeah. A barrel roll is following a cylindrical trajectory, and the g's remain positive and (ideally) prependicular to the floor through the entire maneuvre. A roll (ideally) follows a straight line, and anything not buckled down solidly will get thrown around. I don't think a roll is advisable with an airliner although the airframe can probably withstand it without problems.

Hans
 
IIRC, may be some other fighters as well

The Aermacchi were trainers, but in a war I guess they could have outfitted them.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom