A warning but hardly a statement that the plane will not allow such a thing to occur nor that if the plane does exceed these limits that it will discintegrate in flight.
Then he wants links to show that the Boeing was not computer limited (computer overrides pilot commands)
I do so here
http://www.proxywhore.com/invboard/index.php?s=&showtopic=58556&view=findpost&p=885564
and here
http://www.proxywhore.com/invboard/index.php?s=&showtopic=58556&view=findpost&p=885605
In both examples I show that Boeing aircraft, the second example is a 757, did things that bill says they simply could not do. Hmmmm....
I am not sure if bill ever did understand how wrong he was. He is in good company now as one of JDX's buddies.
In that thread I was warned by one poster that my use of facts concerning 9/11 was not going to win me any friends over there.
How are you not banned from there already?! I didnt last 5 minutes...literally.
Anyhow, this is actually a complicated topic. Its true that if a 757 pilot wanted to fly right on past V
NE, the plane will let him, but it will give lots of indications that what you're doing might be dangerous(master caution, master warning, EICAS message, aural alert, overspeed clacker). As was indicated above, the 757 is not FBW and has no software limits. There
are software thrust limits though, and I think your pilot may be getting confused by this fact.
The 757's powerplants are fly-by-wire and have 4 computers that govern all aspects of operation, they are the Electronic Engine Control{EEC}, Thrust Management Computer{TMC}, the Engine Indicating and Crew Alerting System Computer{EICAS} and the Performance Interface Moniter Unit{PIMU}***
The functions of these computers range from engine control, engine operation(valve operation/ stator vane sequencing, etc), monitering(self monitering as well as engine perf. monitering), indication, and protection. The EEC will do its best to provide protection from surges and overspeeds, but in this case, overspeed only refers to the turbine itself -
not the airframe. The EEC will also automatically shut an engine down under certain circumstances like excessive vibration, excessive exhaust temperature, very low oil quantity, etc..(not pertinent, just FYI)
The TMC is basically the auto-throttle computer, it doesn't control engine speed unless the autothrottle is engaged. It has other functions during manual operation(autothrottle disengaged) such as setting the thrust limits, which cannot be exceeded.(unless you switch the EECs control switches from "NORM" to "ALT" which changes the way the EEC schedules fuel flow and removes the TMC limits)
The EICAS computer is an indication/warning computer only. The PIMU moniters the engine and EEC for faults and is only used for maintenace. Neither of these two have control functions.
The short version to all of that is you can overspeed the airplane as long as you dont overspeed the engines.
If your guy wants something from flight manual or maintenance manual, I'd be happy to provide it.
***
PIMU might be called something else on RR powered 757s