You Can't Fly A 757 Like That!

I always thought the "you can't fly a plane like that" argument was pretty weak. I used to live in the Seattle area and the Boeing employees there (and they were legion) used to tell stories about test pilots doing barrel rolls in 757's. I don't know if that's true, but given the video of the 707 doing one, I wouldn't be surprised.

ETA:

http://seattlepi.nwsource.com/business/272028_testpilot30.html

In this news story, they say that modern test pilots turn the big planes upside down "accidentally". Suuuuure it's an accident.
 
Last edited:
I always thought the "you can't fly a plane like that" argument was pretty weak. I used to live in the Seattle area and the Boeing employees there (and they were legion) used to tell stories about test pilots doing barrel rolls in 757's. I don't know if that's true, but given the video of the 707 doing one, I wouldn't be surprised.

This is a clear case of the Deniers mixing "can't" physically with "should not". Pilots of course should not do barrel rolls with passenger planes for the simple reason that it almost guarantees severe injury to the passengers and crew.
 
Every time I see the OP for this, I hear some redneck going "Oh yeah? Hold muh beer! Watch this!"
 
This is a clear case of the Deniers mixing "can't" physically with "should not". Pilots of course should not do barrel rolls with passenger planes for the simple reason that it almost guarantees severe injury to the passengers and crew.

I would think that you COULD do a barrel roll with pretty much any plane, all the way up to a 747, given sufficient speed. You SHOULDN'T, but you COULD.

Or is this one of those counter-intuitive things?
 
Very intresting videos, thanks for posting them. The conspiracy liars would reply with, "Well only an experienced pilot could do those manuvers, not someone like Hani Hanjour."

My theory, and it's only a theory, is that Hani Hanjour was indeed a horrible pilot and that it was a pure accident that he hit The Pentagon. I think the target building for AA77 was either The Capital Building or The White House. Hanjour missed and instead hit The Pentagon. He could have as easily hit The Bureau of Printing and Engraving.

Why do I think this? For those you not familiar with the layout of Washington DC, look at a Google Earth map of the area. How long does it take you to find the The Capital Building, The White House and The Pentagon? I bet it takes much, much longer to find The Pentagon. Now imagine Hani Hanjour doing the same thing. The Pentagon was a too difficult target.

Of course since everyone on the flight died we will never no for sure what AA77's target was, but there is no conclusive evidence it was The Pentagon.
 
Last edited:
My theory, and it's only a theory, is that Hani Hanjour was indeed a horrible pilot and that it was a pure accident that he hit The Pentagon. I think the target building for AA77 was either The Capital Building or The White House. Hanjour missed and instead hit The Pentagon. He could have as easily hit The Bureau of Printing and Engraving.

Why do I think this? For those you not familiar with the layout of Washington DC, look at a Google Earth map of the area. How long does it take you to find the The Capital Building, The White House and The Pentagon? I bet it takes much, much longer to find The Pentagon. Now imagine Hani Hanjour doing the same thing. The Pentagon was a too difficult target.

Of course since everyone on the flight died we will never no for sure what AA77's target was, but there is no conclusive evidence it was The Pentagon.



The selection of targets by Al Qaeda is actually pretty well documented.

KSM chose two and OBL chose two. I believe OBL wanted to hit The Pentagon and the White House, however it was concluded that the White House would be far too difficult to hit, being rather small and low to the ground. So instead it was chosen that the targets would be the Capitol and The Pentagon. The Pentagon would actually be exceedingly easy to locate. Not only is it the largest office building in the world, but well, it's in the shape of a giant frikken pentagon!

KSM chose the two towers as his preferred targets.

Furthermore, we know that AA77's target was The Pentagon and UA93's target was the Capitol Building.

-Gumboot
 
There is no question a 757 is capable of the maneuver made at the Pentagon. And there is no question AAL77 did indeed hit the Pentagon.

The real question is, who-- or what-- was flying AAL77 when it hit the Pentagon.
 
There is no question a 757 is capable of the maneuver made at the Pentagon. And there is no question AAL77 did indeed hit the Pentagon.

The real question is, who-- or what-- was flying AAL77 when it hit the Pentagon.


Space Monkeys.

-Gumboot
 
I know we've well and truely debunked this claim, but it's always fun to add some more nails to the coffin...

For all those who make claims about the impossibility of maneouvering AA77 the way Hanjour did... these should do the trick:





-Gumboot

The second video is terrifying, I had no idea passenger jets were capable of climbs like that. Was that second plane tweeked in any way prior to that? damn...
 
The second video is terrifying, I had no idea passenger jets were capable of climbs like that. Was that second plane tweeked in any way prior to that? damn...


Nope just a regular Boeing 757-200 powered by two Rolls Royce RB211535E4/4B turbofans.

-Gumboot
 
That's an amazing aircraft. I kind of want to be on one that does that, and kind of don't...


:D

Our airforce used to operate the Hawker Siddeley Andover which was a STOL aircraft with the second largest prop blades of any aeroplane in the world.

Taking off in one of them in STOL format is a pretty weird feeling. It actually takes off so steeply that the wings are completely stalled. The props become like helicopter rotors and just pull the aircraft into the air.

-Gumboot
 
Watching those I can easily see how all those witnesses at the Pentagon could have mistaken a 20 ft long cruise missile, or a propeller driven Predator UAV for a 757. /end sarc

God bless the Boeing company!!!

JamesB
Seattle, WA
 
Watching those I can easily see how all those witnesses at the Pentagon could have mistaken a 20 ft long cruise missile, or a propeller driven Predator UAV for a 757. /end sarc

God bless the Boeing company!!!

JamesB
Seattle, WA
I drive by a railroad yard every day on my way to work. Occasionally, there are 737 bodies on cars, on their way to Wichita for assembly. Way smaller than a 757 or 767. Yeah, I could see how you could mistake that for a missle (not!). I've seen a few missles up close & personal, and to think you could mistake something that small for something as large as a commercial aircraft, even a small commercial jet, is absurd!
 
The selection of targets by Al Qaeda is actually pretty well documented.

KSM chose two and OBL chose two. I believe OBL wanted to hit The Pentagon and the White House, however it was concluded that the White House would be far too difficult to hit, being rather small and low to the ground. So instead it was chosen that the targets would be the Capitol and The Pentagon. The Pentagon would actually be exceedingly easy to locate. Not only is it the largest office building in the world, but well, it's in the shape of a giant frikken pentagon!

KSM chose the two towers as his preferred targets.

Furthermore, we know that AA77's target was The Pentagon and UA93's target was the Capitol Building.

-Gumboot

And using the example of New York, the cameras in Washington would have been out in force expecting the second attack. And worldwide we would have seen live footage of United 93 screaming down the Mall and taking out the Rotunda.

That was what the passengers of United 93 stopped from happening. You wish people would leave the word "diabolical" alone so that it could be properly employed to things like this.
 
Any idea how fast those flybys were?

350kt (402MPH) 100ft, pulling up to 45o of climbout to 7500ft.

That's straight from the horse's mouth... WGCDR Davies, 757 display pilot and former CO 40 SQN, RNZAF.

-Gumboot
 

Note most of the aircraft are Air NZ; when it's rough the international pilots usually chicken out and divert to Palmerston North or Christchurch.

-Gumboot
There is a great video of a RNZAF 727 landing in Wellington where it almost ends up planing one of the wings in to the ground because crosswind gusts!

Unfortunately I havent been able to find it!

Mailman
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom