You Can't Fly A 757 Like That!

What would happen if you were to switch off the Flight Augmentation Computers (yes, I've been investigoogling :)) on the Airbus - would you have the control authority necessary to do what you describe? Or would the thing be uncontrollable (inherently unstable like the F-16) in that state?
Good question. I have no idea. :)

ETA - some good gen on Airbus "laws" here at PPRuNe. Seems that you could revert to "direct law" flight if necessary (if, to choose an example at random, a shadow government operative was trying to take over control of your aircraft in order to crash you into a landmark as a pretext for a middle-east invasion).

Sounds similar to the 777. There are 3 flight control modes: normal, secondary, and direct. In direct mode, the PFCs(see above) are bypassed and the ACEs(see above) outputs go straight to the hydro actuators. The direct mode can be selected manually by the pilots, or automatically should all PFCs crap out. And believe it or not, there is a backup mechanical system should all the ACEs crap out as well, or if all power is lost.
 
Continuing with the aircraft video theme...

This nice little video thoroughly refutes any and all "fly-by" claims at both The Pentagon and the WTC...

Notice how far away the airliner is from the source of the smoke... and yet the influence is still very clear.



-Gumboot
 
What would happen if you were to switch off the Flight Augmentation Computers (yes, I've been investigoogling :)) on the Airbus - would you have the control authority necessary to do what you describe? Or would the thing be uncontrollable (inherently unstable like the F-16) in that state?

ETA - some good gen on Airbus "laws" here at PPRuNe. Seems that you could revert to "direct law" flight if necessary (if, to choose an example at random, a shadow government operative was trying to take over control of your aircraft in order to crash you into a landmark as a pretext for a middle-east invasion).

Even some inherently unstable aircraft have "full mechanical" backup flight modes. I don't know about the F-16 Falcon in particular, but I do know for a fact that the F/A-18 Hornet does have a mechanical mode. I know this because I went through flight safety reviews of an experiment I flew on board a Hornet two years ago, and we evaluated every conceivable impact and mitigation if the experiment malfunctioned.

Having said that, while an unstable aircraft may have a mechanical control mode, it is considered a desperate last resort. We were unable to find any evidence of an F/A-18 ever having been flown in that configuration. :eek:

P.S.: The landmark film Apocalypse Now has a great example of a wingtip vortex made visible by the smoke plume from an explosion, over the shoulder of Robert Duvall in the legendary "Ride of the Valkyries" sequence. And that vortex was generated by a helicopter.
 
I don't know about the F-16 Falcon in particular, but I do know for a fact that the F/A-18 Hornet does have a mechanical mode. /snip
snip/ unable to find any evidence of an F/A-18 ever having been flown in that configuration. :eek: /snip

Mech Mode on the F/A-18 is only designed to get the aircraft out of enemy airspace and the pilot back to a safe area to eject. Preferably in the neighbourhood of his ship. Although no there may be no record of an aircraft using this system in a real emergency I'm 100% certain that it was at least successfully flown during original flight testing. I will check with some of the pilots at work but I would not be surprised if flying in Mech Mode was part of their training.
 
I know we've well and truely debunked this claim, but it's always fun to add some more nails to the coffin...

For all those who make claims about the impossibility of maneouvering AA77 the way Hanjour did... these should do the trick:

-Gumboot

The second one certainly seems to have the a/c at about 60 feet, fast, and trimmed with no wheels down, and no flaps or slats extended.

That would be what Flt 77 was doing just before hitting the first lamp posts.
 
Unfortunately, the PentaCon truthers are using this same sort of video to "prove" that a 757 could pull off the flyover maneuver posited by Merc and Lyte...



I haven't ever heard anyone claim it's impossible for a 757 to perform a low-level flyover of The Pentagon. What we refute is the strange notion that none of the literally thousands of people in the vicinity of The Pentagon would notice. We also refute the notion that somehow the 757 failed to produce visible vortices in the smoke from the explosion.

Wing vortices in smoke are unmistakable.

-Gumboot
 
Oh there are those who claim the 757 could not be flown the way it was. I posted earlier in this thread about once such encounter with a woo-woo who was saying exactly that.I have also encountered and debunked other claims that the 'ground effect' would negate being able to fly such a large aircraft so low and fast(basically zero alt just before impact). It can be shown that ground effect is actually a lesser percentage of total drag the faster an aircraft is going than it would be in a slower a/c.

As for PW , I for one can certainly assure all here that he is indeed the poster known as Phantomwolf at both BAUT and AH in which his attitude towards the events of 9/11 match those of the majority at JREF. (well, if he isn't he does a slam dunk impression of that poster)
He has explained his reason for not using the quote feature and those who insist that he do it even though its use would be onerous in light of his dial-up connection are being somewhat elitist, IMHO.
 
Guys,

Excellent summaries.

For the geeks, the next level of aerodynamic design. (Completely irrelevant to 757s, but fascinating nonetheless.)

All passenger airplanes (and jets up to & including the F-16) are "conventional" flight controls, meaning that the planes are inherently stable.

This means that the center of gravity always stays ahead of the center of lift of the wings. Then the rear stabilizer add a small downward force to balance the "moment". This is exactly equivalent to a load that the plane has to carry.

IF you ever violate this (by overloading the back seat of a cessna, for example), the plane will simply pitch nose up, stall & crash. You can see that this also puts large constraints on the location of fuel tanks to be near the CL.

Newer planes (starting with the FA-18) changed the rules. In these planes, the CG can be ahead of or behind the Center of lift. And the rear stabilizer does not have to be producing a large downward force. But as a result, the jet has no stability at all. It is constantly trying to pitch up or pitch down. And the pitch gyros are constantly correcting for this. As a direct result, all the control surfaces (leading & trailing edges on the wings & horizontal stabilizers) are always constantly in motion. A friend of mine who used to fly them said that the constant wing correction made him really nervous after transitioning from F14s. It made him so nervous that he fixed the problem for the first several months by no longer looking at the wings.

This adds tremendous maneuverability to the jet.

One of the other kool benefits of the true digital control system is that they now build all the "loop gains" into software & eprom. The general trade-off in control systems is Gain vs. Stability. You can increase the gain (i.e., responsiveness), but eventually you run into instability & oscillation.

The key factor here is that, in the old days when stability was provided by the planes physical geometry, getting rid of an instability meant physically changing some of the parts of the airplane. With the F18, if you need to get rid of an oscillation, you burn a new PROM.

I got a chance to fly the FA18 simulator at Lemoor NAS when it first came out. As I was trying carrier landings, the plane kept getting into oscillations. I was convinced that I had no future as a pilot, until my friend told me that this was a true reflection of what the earlier PROM performance. They had changed some loop gains and gotten rid of this oscillation. They hadn't yet upgraded the PROM in the simulator, and the oscillation wasn't fixed.

All I can say about that weekend, after 1.5 hours of air to air combat, and a couple billion dollars worth of (virtual) Sidewinders, Sparrows & Mk 84 dumb bombs, is "best video game I ever played". By a country mile.

tk
 
Guys,

Excellent summaries.

For the geeks, the next level of aerodynamic design. (Completely irrelevant to 757s, but fascinating nonetheless.)

All passenger airplanes (and jets up to & including the F-16) are "conventional" flight controls, meaning that the planes are inherently stable.

This means that the center of gravity always stays ahead of the center of lift of the wings. Then the rear stabilizer add a small downward force to balance the "moment". This is exactly equivalent to a load that the plane has to carry.

IF you ever violate this (by overloading the back seat of a cessna, for example), the plane will simply pitch nose up, stall & crash. You can see that this also puts large constraints on the location of fuel tanks to be near the CL.

Newer planes (starting with the FA-18) changed the rules. In these planes, the CG can be ahead of or behind the Center of lift.

Isn't that the case with the swedish jet Jas-39 Gripen?

http://www.gripen.com/en/GripenFighter/TheGripenFighter.htm
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/JAS_39_Gripen

I remember SAAB presenting the balancing to keeping it stabel as "sitting on the front of a speeding car, whilst rolling a bike backwards in front by holding the handlebar "
 
Last edited:
I don't get it. All I saw was a 757 doing routine stuff. My dad was a 747 pilot and would do that sort of stuff as part of standard training exercises to teach the trainee what the handling capabilities and limitations were.
 
PP,

Isn't that the case with the swedish jet Jas-39 Gripen?

http://www.gripen.com/en/GripenFighter/TheGripenFighter.htm
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/JAS_39_Gripen

I remember SAAB presenting the balancing to keeping it stabel as "sitting on the front of a speeding car, whilst rolling a bike backwards in front by holding the handlebar "

The short answer is, "I'm not sure."

At first, I thought that it was unlikely. The key to the FA-18s pitch instability is putting the center of lift coincident with the center of gravity. This will cause the nose to want to either pitch up or pitch down as the fuel shifts, as the AoA changes, etc. And the flight control system is always compensating.

Looking at the Grippen, with its aft located delta wings (presumably holding lots of the fuel capacity), looked like the CL was going to be permanently aft of CG. But it turns out that the body & strakes can produce a significant amount of the lift, so it's tough to tell just from looking at the plane.

The key is the flying (i.e., variable pitch) canard. It actually takes the role of the horizontal stabilizer. A typical, old-school fixed canard (like on a Long-EZ) didn't make the plane unstable. Quite the opposite, it added pitch stability by making the plane un-stallable. The AoA of the canard was a few degrees greater than the wings, and therefore would stall just before the wings would, which would drop the nose. This prevents the wings from stalling. This configuration, which is pretty similar to the Viggen, is inherently stable.

Nonetheless, it sure sounds like it is an inherently unstable design from your description and from the comments in Wiki. Specifically: "unstable canard design" and "The totally integrated avionics make it a "programmable" aircraft." And there is a lot to say for "convergent evolution" in technology. All those guys are trying to solve the same problem, they're generally damn sharp guys, and the solutions frequently have lots in common.

Regardless, it looks like a heck of an airplane.

tom
 
What an awesome thread to bump. I was trying to find this thread a few weeks ago!
 
Bump.

F/A-18 is actually a relatively stable fighter aircraft. NASA uses theirs to test large aerfoils or chunks of structure, and other big draggy things that hang off the pylons, specifically because it is pretty stable -- close to neutral. Not nearly so snappy as an F-16, for instance.

There's a good discussion of instability in fighter aircraft here. As they correctly point out, this mainly affects pitch. Roll rate is important for a fighter, but unaffected by stability, though engine/stores placement that increases the roll moment is a big no-no -- and there's another concern. If the roll moment differs greatly from the pitch moment, you can get inertial coupling, making your aircraft sloppy and difficult to keep on target. Same story goes for yaw rate, which is not as important on its own. The other big important feature is controllability at high alpha, which has more to do with wing/body interaction, control surfaces, and wing cross-section than stability.

Another thread you might want to bump and carry the discussion to is this one, good example of an educational discussion.
 
Last edited:
Ryan,

Bump.

F/A-18 is actually a relatively stable fighter aircraft. NASA uses theirs to test large aerfoils or chunks of structure, and other big draggy things that hang off the pylons, specifically because it is pretty stable -- close to neutral. Not nearly so snappy as an F-16, for instance.

Thanks for the links.

I agree that the Hornet is incredibly stable. You watch the Blue Angels do their act with wing separation of a couple of feet... It looks like the planes are on rails.

My point was that the stability (specifically pitch stability, in this case) is not inherent to the airframe, but the result of the active computer system control. Inertial sensors as are measuring pitch accelerations about 40 times per second IIRC, and applying minor corrections to bring the pitch back to zero (or whatever the yoke input demands).

The end result being that the plane becomes astonishingly well behaved, and still agile.

tom
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom