Why should necrophilia be banned?

And age!

We need some sado-homo-zoo-paedo-necro-porn.

And preferably an animal from an endangered species!




On a serious note: if the deceased has given consent before sodding off, health concerns should be the main worry.

Lets not take this thread too seriously.

However, we do need to check ID on all people/animals/anime/cyborgs.

The anime ID might be difficult. Major Motoko Kusanagi and Deunan Knute are over 18 but I don't think they do porn. But, they are non-living so I guess having sex with them might qualify as a type of necrophilia if they held still. I'm sure some sanctimonious twit will see it that way.
 
Last edited:
There was a typical slippery slope type argument trotted out in the recent incest thread, which I'd like to explore here.

Necrophilia is another one of those horribly "squicky" paraphilia's that people almost universally shudder at and is (as far as I know) pretty much banned everywhere.

But why? There's no issue of consent, there's no possibility of offspring and no one is harmed (except the person doing the *********** possibly).

Imagine for a moment that I'm a necrophiliac and belong to an online community of like-minded weirdos. Perhaps the INF (International Necrophiliacs Forum). I then write a will which explicitly states that after death, my corpse is to be donated to one of my necrophile friends with the explicit direction that he is free to use my corpse for her own carnal pleasures. Should this be allowed?

Why? If not, why not?

Because you can buy silicone dolls that do that much better and because it is a sign of sickness that should not be encouraged as it may be hard for someone so inclined to always get permission before natural death.

Are you trolling?
 
I wonder if there is legit necrophilia porn floating around out there.

Dunno, but there is a movie that's well known as one of the most disturbing movies ever made. It's German I think and it features a pathologist who is attracted to his patients (?). Anyway, I can't remember the title and I am not going to go looking for it right now because I am *ahem* not at home.

It's on the same kind of lists as "Salo" (now, there's an idea for another thread!), and "A Sebian Film" (which I have not watched).
 
Because you can buy silicone dolls that do that much better and because it is a sign of sickness that should not be encouraged as it may be hard for someone so inclined to always get permission before natural death.

Are you trolling?

He's not trolling, it's sort of a spin-off thread from the incest thread, wherein we have a lively debate unfolding about the reasoning behind ethics. :)

It's just a thought experiment. I think it's good for people to examine their own beliefs, intolerances, and preconceptions. I like doing it even when it gets heated or I get frustrated or disgusted.

One of the things we were focusing on was the difference between permitting something and encouraging it. I think there's a third spin-off thread going now, but I don't have the energy to join another one today. Haha, maybe tomorrow.
 
Dunno, but there is a movie that's well known as one of the most disturbing movies ever made. It's German I think and it features a pathologist who is attracted to his patients (?). Anyway, I can't remember the title and I am not going to go looking for it right now because I am *ahem* not at home.

It's on the same kind of lists as "Salo" (now, there's an idea for another thread!), and "A Sebian Film" (which I have not watched).

I think it's called "Anatomy." I haven't seen it (I can't watch movies like that, barely made it through Salo, too squeamish and girly), but it certainly seems to have a reputation preceding it. If you watch it, let us know how it is. :p
 
Dunno, but there is a movie that's well known as one of the most disturbing movies ever made. It's German I think and it features a pathologist who is attracted to his patients (?). Anyway, I can't remember the title and I am not going to go looking for it right now because I am *ahem* not at home.

It's on the same kind of lists as "Salo" (now, there's an idea for another thread!), and "A Sebian Film" (which I have not watched).
That's Serbian, but who's counting:D
 
The point I'm trying to make is that we shouldn't make disgust the deciding factor when making laws that others have to follow.

I don't think we have much choice in the matter. I only have the sample of one to go on, but my disgust doesn't seem open to logical argument.

So, for example, if I find out someone spit in my soup, it does little good to explain that the soup was subsequently cooked and no bacteria would have survived. I still won't eat it. I might come up with some bogus reasoning and invent a harm, but that comes afterward. The real picture is I act based on this unthinking, and deep, immediate reaction to the idea of phlegm in my soup.
 
I don't think we have much choice in the matter. I only have the sample of one to go on, but my disgust doesn't seem open to logical argument.

So, for example, if I find out someone spit in my soup, it does little good to explain that the soup was subsequently cooked and no bacteria would have survived. I still won't eat it. I might come up with some bogus reasoning and invent a harm, but that comes afterward. The real picture is I act based on this unthinking, and deep, immediate reaction to the idea of phlegm in my soup.

But that isn't an argument to prevent someone else who knowingly wants to eat the soup from doing so.
 
I think it's called "Anatomy." I haven't seen it (I can't watch movies like that, barely made it through Salo, too squeamish and girly), but it certainly seems to have a reputation preceding it. If you watch it, let us know how it is. :p

Ah, I think the movie is called Aftermath and it's actually Spanish. Just thought it was worth mentioning if anyone is interested.:eek:
 
I think I'll stop by the morgue on the way home and have a cold one.

<rimshot>
 
Not true, activities can be legal but regulated as with smoking and alcohol (and indeed sex itself).

Yes, but "regulated" kind of implies there's going to be some point where not following the regulations turns up the dial - at that point, it crosses over to illegal. But yes, you are correct that some forms of a broad category may be permitted while the entire gamut isn't.

But that isn't an argument to prevent someone else who knowingly wants to eat the soup from doing so.

It is, if I intend to make soup pollution illegal to avoid the bit I don't like. Certainly, the spit eater is caught up in the same rule unintentionally, but whether to make a rule or not depends on me - at least from my point of view.

So, our law might come out like this: "It is illegal to make, sell, or serve any food item containing human bodily fluids." The intent of which springs from my disgust at the possibility of being served such a dish, but it would simultaneously capture others who find excretions tasty.

This is where the courts come in - a way of making law we haven't discussed in this thread yet. They get to interpret both the relationship to other laws, the intent of the law, and the practical applications. "The court finds that, under the intent and meaning of this law, moisture normally found in the exhaled breath does not rise to the level of being an 'excretion' as used in this law."
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom