Why should necrophilia be banned?

Just dont do it in front of me and dont leave arms or legs in my rubbish bin when they start falling off

Not sure why this objection needs to be stated, although I often find that when someone grudgingly concedes that maybe some specific sexual encounters are not going to affect them after all, they will invent stipulations that they feel need to be agreed to. I think people used to say that about homosexuality:

"What they get up to in their own homes, behind closed doors, where I can't hear them, then I suppose it's okay. But if they come round my house and start doing it on my coffee table, when my mother's here serving tea to the vicar when Last of the Summer Wine is on the telly, I shall OIIIII! FELLARS! NO!"
 
On the contrary. If two hot homosexual girls want to get it on in front of me I have no probs
 
Angrysoba

You are blending person distaste for something. Be it thrpugh religion, social or personal reasons with non-existant hatred.
 
That's already a big "should". In your opinion what should be legal should be determined more or less democratically, then. And whatever they choose should be accepted.

Correct.

Of course, if I were a tyrant who knew better what the people wanted than they did themselves, I could argue that what should be legal is what best supports Fundamental Rights X, Y, and Z.

Or I might argue that what should be legal is what causes individual suffering to the "victim" and I could argue that if there be none (a victimless crime) then the state has no business interfering.

So while I am giving particular reasons why we may choose to make something legal or not, and you can argue that they are arbitrary, I don't think you have made any case that your reasoning is less arbitrary.

All true, but what I suppose you see as a criticism is really a strength.

What I'm proposing as my "should" is arbitrary in one sense, but not in another. It is arbitrary in the sense that some other system would work as well. We could have laws based on a tyrant (as you mentioned) or a Holy Book, or a council of the wise, or even a computer program running a law-making algorithm. All would accomplish the same ends - laws that are not capricious, extend over some time (to allow planning and prediction), and are understandable by those subject to the laws. In fact, when we look around the world, we see lots of different systems in play. So they are arbitrary in the sense of choice being part of the mix.

Note that even with these choices on the table, one attribute of any working system is the consent of the governed, even in systems which are totalitarian. (I'll set that aside to get to the next bit.)

So how is what I'm suggesting not arbitrary then?

Consider a situation where we are acting as a society. We wish to put in a bus line and enough bus stops so that people do not have to walk too far to catch a bus. And, to make it a meaningful decision, let's say we are going to build shelters at each bus stop at some significant cost. Our task then is to establish what "too far to walk" will mean.

The decision has some fixed properties within which we have to operate. No one can walk to the moon, and our budget limits how many bus stops we can build. But within these parameters we are left trying to decide where to put them. The choice is arbitrary, since "too far to walk" depends on my physical capabilities and how I feel about walking.

We have some system (also arbitrary) we use to come up with an answer, and the bus stops are installed. Some people think there are too many stops and that we've wasted money. Others think there are too few and claim they have to walk too far.

What is no longer arbitrary, and is now objective fact, is where we have built the bus stops. They exist, and more importantly, they have been placed as a result of running our system to get an answer. We can expect that, if we were to revisit the problem, our system (whichever one we operate under) will again place the bus stops where they are now. That's the part that isn't arbitrary.

In the same way, if I ask whether necrophilia should be illegal, there is a comment and judgement external to my own sense of right and wrong - the result of the system in play (the one I agree to be governed by) and the law as it stands now. If there is no law, I can run the matter through the same system and get an answer.

Furthermore, it is our allegiance to this larger system which extends and informs the individual laws. It also identifies our group, so that members of our group who do not agree to be governed by our chosen system will be punished and eventually excluded - they have been identified as "not like us." We will take away their freedom to participate as our equal - eventually excluding them altogether by way of prison or execution.

What's the role of disgust and revulsion for necrophilia in all this? It's a benchmark that predicts my attitude toward the activity, and one I assume is shared by enough of my fellows so that the system in play will produce a law against it. But perhaps not; except I see there are such laws, so I can reliably point out the decision has been made, and made by the system I hold to be proper, reliable, and fair.
 
Last edited:
Marplots

I apologise if this offends you, but what over long toss.

Do you think it should be legal?

yes or no
 
Marplots

I apologise if this offends you, but what over long toss.

Do you think it should be legal?

yes or no

No offense taken.

As to whether it should be legal or not, I don't really care either way. I suppose the closest I could come is to say I would think less of someone who practiced it, but the emotion would be closer to pity than outrage.

I do think it can be a proper target for the law though. In other words, behaviors that purportedly "harm no one" shouldn't be excluded from judgement on that basis alone.
 
Last edited:
It seems to be one of those first persn second person things

Would I mind dad shagging me dead mum? No

Should he care what I think? Probably not
 
There are a few problems that arise if the criteria for something to be legal or illegal is that it must cause someone harm.

Per dictionary.com a society is:
an organized group of persons associated together for religious, benevolent, cultural, scientific, political, patriotic, or other purposes.

I interpret this to mean a group of people who live together based upon a general agreement on how they should live. Common values, beliefs or whatever.

So imagine a society that develops with the shared value that people should maintain their property in an orderly way that includes keeping your lawn trimmed. But then a person becomes a member of that society (either by birth or immigration) who doesn't like to mow his lawn. So the grass on his lawn grows several feet tall and, in the view of the rest of the society, is an eyesore.

Now, is his unmowed lawn hurting anyone? No, not really. But it does violate the shared values that define how that society wishes to live.

If we say that things should only be made illegal if they harm someone, then the people who want to live in the type of society where lawns are mowed must leave in order to do so. In other words, the one dissident has power to change the social compact, not by convincing others, but by doing whatever he wants as long as no actual harm is caused.

You can insert other behaviors, obviously: public nudity is a good example. When I grew up there was a guy down the street who liked to do his gardening in the nude. Including mowing, which sounds unpleasant. This caused conflict with his next door neighbor (a police officer with young children). The point is that communities are formed over shared values and interests and some laws are made with the purpose of enforcing those shared values. I think this is legitimate. It is also legitimate to point out that some of those values are wrong or obsolete and should be changed.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom