Why should necrophilia be banned?

Fair point Montag.

Its pretty hard to tell with a rotten sheep carcus thought.

Im asumunig female sheep but I have no idea if it actually felt gender wise it felt male or in between
 
Fair point Montag.

Its pretty hard to tell with a rotten sheep carcus thought.

Im asumunig female sheep but I have no idea if it actually felt gender wise it felt male or in between

I suppose it's related, and I have it in mind because it happened near where I live: a man is caught having sex with a dead dog. One of the first reactions (before it all got to court) was along the lines of, "Why isn't this illegal?" And, technically, it wasn't. It didn't fall under animal abuse because the dog was dead. It didn't fall under necrophilia because the object of desire wasn't a human.

In any case, he eventually pleaded out. "Sheeran [the judge] sentenced Kuch in July to three years in prison for the resisting charge and 18 months for indecent exposure. All three sentences will be served concurrently, and Kuch was granted credit for 255 days served."

Link: http://blog.mlive.com/bctimes/2008/02/saginaw_man_convicted_of_sex_w.html

If he hadn't taken the plea deal, they were going to try and convict him as a "sexually delinquent person" and he would have risked life in prison. Also from the piece: "Michigan has no law specifically forbidding sex with an animal carcass."
 
I suppose it's related, and I have it in mind because it happened near where I live: a man is caught having sex with a dead dog. One of the first reactions (before it all got to court) was along the lines of, "Why isn't this illegal?" And, technically, it wasn't. It didn't fall under animal abuse because the dog was dead. It didn't fall under necrophilia because the object of desire wasn't a human.

In any case, he eventually pleaded out. "Sheeran [the judge] sentenced Kuch in July to three years in prison for the resisting charge and 18 months for indecent exposure. All three sentences will be served concurrently, and Kuch was granted credit for 255 days served."

Link: http://blog.mlive.com/bctimes/2008/02/saginaw_man_convicted_of_sex_w.html

If he hadn't taken the plea deal, they were going to try and convict him as a "sexually delinquent person" and he would have risked life in prison. Also from the piece: "Michigan has no law specifically forbidding sex with an animal carcass."

Basically, he had done nothing wrong, but was jailed "just to make sure".

The US justice system sometimes scares me!
 
There was a typical slippery slope type argument trotted out in the recent incest thread, which I'd like to explore here.

Necrophilia is another one of those horribly "squicky" paraphilia's that people almost universally shudder at and is (as far as I know) pretty much banned everywhere.

But why? There's no issue of consent, there's no possibility of offspring and no one is harmed (except the person doing the *********** possibly).

Imagine for a moment that I'm a necrophiliac and belong to an online community of like-minded weirdos. Perhaps the INF (International Necrophiliacs Forum). I then write a will which explicitly states that after death, my corpse is to be donated to one of my necrophile friends with the explicit direction that he is free to use my corpse for her own carnal pleasures. Should this be allowed?

Why? If not, why not?


If the family is not involved and the body is legally in the usage of the necrophiliac, i see no reason to ban it. The body , the corpse is not a human anymore it is an object. Sex with many object is allowed. So beside the cultural Yuck, there is no reason to ban it, within a legal framework of who has the corpse guard.
 
I believe the thinking was that he did plenty "wrong," just nothing illegal.

Exactly! That is what is so worrying!

He has done nothing illegal, but is jailed anyway.
(That is something you do in third world countries!)
 
Exactly! That is what is so worrying!

He has done nothing illegal, but is jailed anyway.
(That is something you do in third world countries!)

I'm not sure I understand all the details, but he certainly didn't have to plead guilty. He could have fought it in court. The problem would be he'd then be facing a jury of his peers, who, unless I miss my guess, would be out to get him anyhow. Still, he could have made the prosecutor prove his case.

And, to be fair, there was another charge about resisting arrest or something. So he might not have gone to jail for the doggy-fun, but gone nonetheless.

I'm pretty sure he's out now, that whole thing was several years ago.
 
The problem with legalizing necrophilia is the enormous potential for embarrassing misunderstandings. Consider the following movie quotes:

(From Big Jake, 1971)
Jonh Fain: "I thought you were dead."
Jake: "Not hardly."

(From Alien Resurrection, 1977)
Distephano: "I thought you were dead."
Ripley: "Yeah, I get that a lot."

(From Escape from New York, 1981)
Brain: "Swear to god Snake, I though you were dead."
Snake: "Yeah, you and everybody else!"

Now, re-imagine those lines of dialog as scenes from romantic comedies in worlds where necrophilia is legal. See the problem?
 
Last edited:
Exactly! That is what is so worrying!

He has done nothing illegal, but is jailed anyway.
(That is something you do in third world countries!)

Well, no. He did do something illegal, starting with indecent exposure.

There's an argument to be made about an abuse of the system with the threatened heavier prosecution and the scope of the sentence, but it's really not true that he did nothing illegal. He most certainly did.
 
Probably been discussed, but how can someone prove sex with a corpse is consentual?

Without propping them in a chair with strings and making their head nod.
 
I think it's called "Anatomy." I haven't seen it (I can't watch movies like that, barely made it through Salo, too squeamish and girly), but it certainly seems to have a reputation preceding it. If you watch it, let us know how it is. :p

You may talking about Nekromantik which is pretty stupid and poorly made. It's like Cannibal Holocaust in the sense that maybe at the time it was pretty bad and deals with some gruesome subject matter, but this is 2015! Step your game up.

Then again they did actually illegally butcher a wild tortoise on film in Cannibal Holocaust which was the real driving factor about why it was banned and subsequently made notorious, which in itself is interesting in the fact that it was disturbing because it's a real death of a rather harmless and kind of cute animal and not an effect, but had it been an effect it would have actually been more visually disturbing.
 
You may talking about Nekromantik which is pretty stupid and poorly made. It's like Cannibal Holocaust in the sense that maybe at the time it was pretty bad and deals with some gruesome subject matter, but this is 2015! Step your game up.

Then again they did actually illegally butcher a wild tortoise on film in Cannibal Holocaust which was the real driving factor about why it was banned and subsequently made notorious, which in itself is interesting in the fact that it was disturbing because it's a real death of a rather harmless and kind of cute animal and not an effect, but had it been an effect it would have actually been more visually disturbing.

No, I've seen both of those movies. Nekromantik in particular was somewhat boring. Gross, but boring.

The tortoise thing made me sad. I like reptiles :(
 
Last edited:
No, I've seen both of those movies. Nekromantik in particular was somewhat boring. Gross, but boring.

The tortoise thing made me sad. I like reptiles :(

OK. The reason why I thought so was because it is also often on similar lists.
 
Well, I suppose a comment or two in order to satisfy a juvenile urge to test limits of convention are ok but, seriously, it would make more sense to be discussing the merits of watermellons or bananas in relation to sex without attempting to make excuses for a mental sickness.
 
Well, I suppose a comment or two in order to satisfy a juvenile urge to test limits of convention are ok but, seriously, it would make more sense to be discussing the merits of watermellons or bananas in relation to sex without attempting to make excuses for a mental sickness.

No one's making excuses for anything. We're discussing it objectively. Very few people have said anything juvenile either, frankly.

If it's something that bothers you too much to discuss, fine, I can understand that. But there's nothing wrong with people debating the nature of a taboo.
 
No one's making excuses for anything. We're discussing it objectively. Very few people have said anything juvenile either, frankly.

If it's something that bothers you too much to discuss, fine, I can understand that. But there's nothing wrong with people debating the nature of a taboo.

Discussing it juveniley, like kids giggling over a taboo held by adults.
 
Discussing it juveniley, like kids giggling over a taboo held by adults.

Psssh, okay. :rolleyes: Have you read the whole thread? Injecting a little humor into an uncomfortable discussion is hardly something limited to children. Read the study I linked earlier in the thread if you'd like the discussion free of any jokes or banter.

In fact, you know what? I'll link it again so you don't have to dig.

http://www.anilaggrawal.com/ij/sundry/news_and_notes/316_A new classification of necrophilia.pdf

It's all about the different classifications of necrophilia, and a bit about the theorized psychology behind them. Did you know certain classifications aren't even considered particularly pathological? It's a very interesting paper, and bereft of anything even remotely resembling jokes, as scientific papers ought to be.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom