Why should necrophilia be banned?

This thread, like many, is based on premises that are backward.

People don't do things, including make something illegal, because they have rational reasons to do so. They do it because that's what they want to do, and then they come up with reasons so that they can sound all rational.

This is not necessarily a bad thing. People want a world that they like. I want a world, for example, that has beer in it, just because I like beer. So I don't want a world with prohibition of the sale and consumption of beer. I don't want people to kill me, either, so I like laws against that. And I also like laws against killing other people, because they make me feel good when someone is caught. Of course, it's better when the person caught is actually guilty, because if they aren't, I might have to feel bad when an innocent person is put in prison. I don't like that.

That's really all it is, and what is comical is the amount of rationalization that gets done. There is sense in almost nothing; it's purely visceral, and the rationalizations that make it appear to make sense are almost always completely dishonest.

But that's just saying the same thing, isn't it? People like explanations to make sense, whether they do or not. The process of doing this is just a lot more elaborate than passing a law. It involves media and discourse and all sorts of other social factors.

This is a very fashionable view, and I think it misses an important point which is that people can be shown that their reasoning is flawed and that they may end up agreeing to things they do not viscerally like by using reason.

The fact that reason is in short supply in many cases, does not mean it does not exist, and the discovery that rationalization is more common than reason is no reason (ha ha!) to discard the latter or to declare its non-existence.
 
Sure, there is. The estate administrator or the executor (or whatever term is applied in a particular jurisdiction) has legal control over the bodily remains of the deceased (subject to some exceptions relating to criminal law provisions and such, depending upon the circumstances of the death) and can direct how the bodily remains are to be dealt with (e.g. burial or cremation, etc.) so there most certainly is an issue of consent.

Yeah but it's a great opportunity to make extra money by renting your mother-in-law.
 
I'd say no - it should be illegal. The reason isn't to prevent harm or keep you from doing it, but to identify you as a person who wants to do it. That is, to identify a character trait which separates you from the larger community. Those of us who don't have the trait don't need the law - we aren't going to do it anyhow. We find it repugnant and disgusting. What's more, we expect others to feel the same way. If you don't, you get connected to the act and also become an object to revile - the disgust transfers.

Under this rubric, making it a law serves as a way to codify and communicate something about how society views an act. Not that the act itself has some separate and objective "wrongness," but only that your fellows deem it so. "We are the sort of people who do not have sex with corpses."

How is this a rational position ? It seems to boil down to "most people don't like it, so it shouldn't be legal."
 
I'm struggling to work out how it can be legal but not rape at the same time

Why? What if consent was already given in a will?

Besides, if you were to chop the head off a corpse we would not consider it to be murder or grievous bodily harm, or actual bodily harm. There may be laws against desecration of a corpse, but it wouldn't be murder.
 
Why? What if consent was already given in a will?

Besides, if you were to chop the head off a corpse we would not consider it to be murder or grievous bodily harm, or actual bodily harm. There may be laws against desecration of a corpse, but it wouldn't be murder.

So it would only be legal if by will?

You would kind of have to have that or we would have a lot more weirdos entering the mortician profession
 
How is this a rational position ? It seems to boil down to "most people don't like it, so it shouldn't be legal."

It's not derived from something else, making it pre-rational. But that's the essence of it, yes. The only chance I'd make in how you phrased it, would be this: "Most people don't like it, so it shouldn't be isn't legal."
 
Last edited:
So it would only be legal if by will?

That might be one way of doing it.

You would kind of have to have that or we would have a lot more weirdos entering the mortician profession

Not necessarily. It doesn't mean that it would permit people to hump any dead body they find, and being a mortician still involves taking the job seriously just as we don't assume that all men who become gynecologists enter the profession just to get their jollies.
 
It's not derived from something else, making it pre-rational. But that's the essence of it, yes. The only chance I'd make in how you phrased it, would be this: "Most people don't like it, so it shouldn't be isn't legal."

But that's pretty trivially true. We pretty much know why necrophilia is not legal and I would imagine all opinion polls on the question "Would you like to perform necrophilia?" will come back overwhelmingly in the negative. But the question is why should it be banned?
 
But that's pretty trivially true. We pretty much know why necrophilia is not legal and I would imagine all opinion polls on the question "Would you like to perform necrophilia?" will come back overwhelmingly in the negative. But the question is why should it be banned?

Perhaps I was being too subtle. There is no particular reason that one thing should be banned over another. The only "should" in the mix (in my opinion), is that people should be able to make the laws they wish to live under - those laws to which they will be subject.

In that framing, any law that emerges has the same basis in "should." The system "should" exist, and this is what the system produced. The difference is between me being able to choose anything off the lunch menu (the "should" - I should have a choice) and the dish I actually choose (not a "should" at all).

Of course there's more to it in practice, but that's the important bit.
 
First you say...

There is no particular reason that one thing should be banned over another.

then you say...

The only "should" in the mix (in my opinion), is that people should be able to make the laws they wish to live under - those laws to which they will be subject.

That's already a big "should". In your opinion what should be legal should be determined more or less democratically, then. And whatever they choose should be accepted.

Of course, if I were a tyrant who knew better what the people wanted than they did themselves, I could argue that what should be legal is what best supports Fundamental Rights X, Y, and Z.

Or I might argue that what should be legal is what causes individual suffering to the "victim" and I could argue that if there be none (a victimless crime) then the state has no business interfering.

So while I am giving particular reasons why we may choose to make something legal or not, and you can argue that they are arbitrary, I don't think you have made any case that your reasoning is less arbitrary.
 
I think we should get a massive group of dead people tpgether and say "Any in favour of letting weirdo people shag you, raise your hand"

Then go with the majority
 
I think we should get a massive group of dead people tpgether and say "Any in favour of letting weirdo people shag you, raise your hand"

Then go with the majority

Don't be ghastly. :D

The OP is asking about if someone were to will their body, pre-death, to be used for necrophiliac purposes. Should that be legal.
 
I reckon if someone is willing their body for sex after death I suppose it is all good. It isnt like they are going to regret it.

Just dont do it in front of me and dont leave arms or legs in my rubbish bin when they start falling off
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom