Why should necrophilia be banned?

If they had the power, these sanctimonious twits with their queasy tummies would burn you at the stake. All based on their disgust at your lack of belief.

At one time they did. And, not surprisingly, we now find those acts extremely disgusting and would make laws to prevent burning at the stake for religious beliefs. Something worked.
 
There was a typical slippery slope type argument trotted out in the recent incest thread, which I'd like to explore here.

Necrophilia is another one of those horribly "squicky" paraphilia's that people almost universally shudder at and is (as far as I know) pretty much banned everywhere.

But why? There's no issue of consent, there's no possibility of offspring and no one is harmed (except the person doing the *********** possibly).

Imagine for a moment that I'm a necrophiliac and belong to an online community of like-minded weirdos. Perhaps the INF (International Necrophiliacs Forum). I then write a will which explicitly states that after death, my corpse is to be donated to one of my necrophile friends with the explicit direction that he is free to use my corpse for her own carnal pleasures. Should this be allowed?

Why? If not, why not?

LOL, wtf?? Because you can catch all kinds of nastiness and then pass them on to other people, and THIS HAS happened in the UK back in the 90's, IIRC.
 
That certainly happens. But it's far from the only classification.

Turns out, there's a ten-tier classification system for necrophiliacs.

1.) Role players
2.) Romantic necrophiliacs (:boggled:)
3.) People experiencing necrophiliac fantasy, hallucination, delusion, etc. (Sometimes called "necrophiliac miracle" :eye-poppi:boggled::boggled:)
4.) Tactile necrophiliacs (Need to touch a dead body in some way for sexual gratification)
5.) Fetishistic necrophiliacs
6.) Necromutilomaniacs (People who, while they don't actually have sex with dead bodies, get sexual pleasure from mutilating or desecrating a dead body in some way :eye-poppi:eye-poppi:eye-poppi!!!!)
7.) Opportunistic necrophiliacs ("Hey, it's there, might as well **** it!":eek:)
8.) Regular necrophiliacs (Strongly prefer sex with corpses over sex with living partners - might not even enjoy sex with living partners at all)
9.) Homicidal necrophiliacs (The type to whom Trebuchet was referring)
10.) Exclusive necrophiliacs (Completely unable to perform intercourse with anything but dead bodies; the rarest type of all)

Here's a fun article which goes into more detail than you probably ever wanted to know about these categorizations, as well as some of the psychology theorized to be behind this extremely taboo fetish. http://www.anilaggrawal.com/ij/sundry/news_and_notes/316_A new classification of necrophilia.pdf

And now, I think I need to go have a shower. :boggled:

What if you substituted a zombie-like sex-doll for dead bodies? And, you really don't need to take a shower, just wash your hands after typing that.
 
What if you substituted a zombie-like sex-doll for dead bodies? And, you really don't need to take a shower, just wash your hands after typing that.

Glad you asked! The zombie-like sex doll would fall under either the "role playing" category or the "fetishistic" category. There's obviously a bit of a significantly overlapping Venn diagram between those two, but it's by no means an eclipse.

Also, the shower was a metaphor. I washed nothing! :cool:
 
I'd say no - it should be illegal. The reason isn't to prevent harm or keep you from doing it, but to identify you as a person who wants to do it. That is, to identify a character trait which separates you from the larger community.

Wouldn't it be easier to identify such individuals if it were legal? What, exactly, is the point of identifying such individuals?

Also, how big of an issue is this, anyways? Are we talking about a huge number of people who actually care that necrophilia is illegal?

It's outside of my realm of awareness, that's for sure.
 
I wonder if there is legit necrophilia porn floating around out there.

Yes, there is. Which would seem to contradict my previous statement that such things are outside of my realm of awareness. I won't elaborate on this.
 
I assume OP means non-religious and non-squickiness arguments against necrophilia (because I definitely have religious beliefs and arguments, as well as the religious beliefs and desires of the deceased). I think I saw mention somewhere that in ancient Egypt women would sometimes not be given to the embalmers for a few days after death to make necrophilia less likely...

We allow the dead to do a number of things, usually based on wishes expressed while they were alive, but sometimes not. Dispose of their possessions at the time of their death by will with an executor of their choice (who can refuse of course), set up a trust either during their lifetime or by will that will endure and act according to their expressed wishes after their death and possibly indefinitely, etc. Some jurisdictions allow trusts to be set up to look after pets. If someone was killed in a particular way their estate may be allowed to litigate and recover damages, quite apart from any possible lawsuits by their spouse and children. A directive not to transplant organs will be followed (though a directive to do so might not be if family objects, and some places treat no directive as consent).

So shouldn't there be an assumption that a person would not want their body used for sexual purposes after death, and that wish enforced, just as it is in so many other instances?

Now, if you want to hypothesize a situation in which the person explicitly consented to sexual use of their body after death, then we get into discussion about what one can or can't consent to while alive also, e.g. why are so many drugs prohibited, there are things consenting adults can't consent to with each other by law, etc.
 
Wouldn't it be easier to identify such individuals if it were legal?

Yes, but then you wouldn't have a mechanism in play to do anything about it.

What, exactly, is the point of identifying such individuals?

So you can shun, exclude, or punish them. Or, as is the modern fashion, do those things and also try to repair their defect.
 
At one time they did. And, not surprisingly, we now find those acts extremely disgusting and would make laws to prevent burning at the stake for religious beliefs. Something worked.
Experiencing disgust is not the issue, it's making disgust the deciding factor. We decided it's wrong to burn people at the stake, now we feel disgust. In western societies we decided keeping people as property is wrong, now we feel disgust at the practice of slavery. You are reversing cause and effect. Disgust is the result of a value judgement about an action. If the specific action can't be shown to cause actual harm, then your disgust is misplaced and shouldn't used as a reason to pass a law.
 
Last edited:
So shouldn't there be an assumption that a person would not want their body used for sexual purposes after death, and that wish enforced, just as it is in so many other instances?

Now, if you want to hypothesize a situation in which the person explicitly consented to sexual use of their body after death, then we get into discussion about what one can or can't consent to while alive also, e.g. why are so many drugs prohibited, there are things consenting adults can't consent to with each other by law, etc.

I believe that was the scenario outlined in the OP. :)
 
Experiencing disgust is not the issue, it's making disgust the deciding factor. We decided it's wrong to burn people at the stake, now we feel disgust. In western societies we decided keeping people as property is wrong, now we feel disgust at the practice of slavery. You are reversing cause and effect. Disgust is the result of a value judgement about an action. If the specific action can't be shown to cause actual harm, then your disgust is misplaced and shouldn't used as a reason to pass a law.

But your historical counterexamples weren't disallowed because they caused harm, were they? At least, not at the time they were popular. I expect burning someone at the stake was thought to reduce overall harm, since, quite obviously, a witch lusts to do evil against others.

I'm saying that what we deem harmful is also dependent on our value judgement - the thing you want to escape, or at least not acknowledge as having the significance I'm claiming.

Take slavery as an example. At the time, one escaped the moral duty against harming another by equating it to animal use - if a slave doesn't qualify as human, then the rules don't apply. So there's a logical dodge to use there.

But when confronted with the actual fact of slavery, and seeing the results, the disgust reaction triumphs over the rationalization needed to keep slavery going. You can see similar mechanisms in play with propaganda from various causes - there's a good reason PETA puts out pictures of abused and injured animals. They want to trigger that same disgust mechanism. So too do people who think abortion is wrong - they use pictures of fetuses because they believe I will agree, beneath my logical reasoning powers, that the whole business is disgusting.

I think the emotion has a primacy and the logical justifications come as an add on.
 
I believe that was the scenario outlined in the OP. :)

Ah, despite being interested as a theoretical argument over principles, my own sense of squickiness/ickiness led me to not read the entirety of the OP... :covereyes
 
<snip>
So shouldn't there be an assumption that a person would not want their body used for sexual purposes after death, and that wish enforced, just as it is in so many other instances?

Now, if you want to hypothesize a situation in which the person explicitly consented to sexual use of their body after death, then we get into discussion about what one can or can't consent to while alive also, e.g. why are so many drugs prohibited, there are things consenting adults can't consent to with each other by law, etc.

It used to be disgusting and forbidden to dissect dead bodies for religious reasons. Now in most places you can will your body to the local medical school. In California you can specify on your drivers license to allow your body to be used for spare parts if you have an accident.

In the OP the dead person decided, before their death, that their body could be used as a sex-toy by their friends after their death. As a practical matter this would have to be done soon after death if you didn't want pieces falling off during erotic play.

Drug use depends on context. In the US you can drink yourself into oblivion every night, but you can't drive a car, fly an airplane, operate heavy machinery, or practice medicine while drunk. This makes you a menace to others.
 
But your historical counterexamples weren't disallowed because they caused harm, were they? At least, not at the time they were popular. I expect burning someone at the stake was thought to reduce overall harm, since, quite obviously, a witch lusts to do evil against others.

I'm saying that what we deem harmful is also dependent on our value judgement - the thing you want to escape, or at least not acknowledge as having the significance I'm claiming.

Take slavery as an example. At the time, one escaped the moral duty against harming another by equating it to animal use - if a slave doesn't qualify as human, then the rules don't apply. So there's a logical dodge to use there.

But when confronted with the actual fact of slavery, and seeing the results, the disgust reaction triumphs over the rationalization needed to keep slavery going. You can see similar mechanisms in play with propaganda from various causes - there's a good reason PETA puts out pictures of abused and injured animals. They want to trigger that same disgust mechanism. So too do people who think abortion is wrong - they use pictures of fetuses because they believe I will agree, beneath my logical reasoning powers, that the whole business is disgusting.

I think the emotion has a primacy and the logical justifications come as an add on.

The disgust reaction comes about when we decide something is extremely wrong, like burning people at the stake. PETA propaganda works only if we agree that abusing animals is wrong. The disgust reaction to slavery works only if we accept slaves as full humans and decide it's wrong to treat humans that way. Seeing the reality of something (like abortion) may change your view of it, but the disgust comes from the fact that you changed your view of it.
I will admit that many people have disgust reactions without consciously knowing the reasons. Some people when confronted as to why they feel disgust may decide their reasons are not justified and the feeling of disgust fades.
 
Last edited:
The disgust reaction comes about when we decide something is extremely wrong, like burning people at the stake. PETA propaganda works only if we agree that abusing animals is wrong. The disgust reaction to slavery works only if we accept slaves as full humans and decide it's wrong to treat humans that way. Seeing the reality of something (like abortion) may change your view of it, but the disgust comes from the fact that you changed your view of it.

I don't disagree, except I don't think you can separate out the "changing your view of it" with the emotion of disgust engendered. Certainly, if you inform me the sandwich I'm eating had pork in it, and I'm a Muslim, the new information might trigger a disgust reaction, but I do not willfully decide to alter my view. So, I'd still say the disgust informs the attitude and not the other way round.

Here's another way to look at it. I can try to see things from someone else's point of view - and I often do it as a rational exercise. But I can't seem to manage to create disgust in myself on command. It seems deeper, more an uncontrolled reaction. In fact, there are time when I'd like to control it - as when it is impolite to react with the "disgust" face because someone smells bad or has an oozing wound.
 
Song I heard years ago:

I went down to the cemetary, to pick up my ex-girlfriend Mary/ But to my surprise, she was rolling her eyes at my ex-dead-best-friend Harry (Chorus) Dead girls, dead girls, dead girls, dancing with the dead girls...

**********************

Eew factor aside, my biggest concern is proper disposal when they're done. If people won't properly dispose of their kleenex in the peep shows (according to best of craigslists posts from employees) then we certainly can't count on them not to leave 150# of rotting meat in the alley like inconsiderate jerks when they're through playing.

Yeah, I think the rotting corpse factor substantially outweighs the ick factor.

It's easier for me to set aside my feeling of disgust when one of the partners in the relationship is dead since my personal concerns of unequal power and potential grooming don't apply. Mind you, I'd be against my child getting involved with a necrophiliac for fear of sex play going too far and ending badly, among other reasons.

But practically speaking, I have other concerns regarding necrophilia in terms of it being legalized. I went over to a psych forum and looked through the paraphilia threads (please pass the brain bleach) and it seems that there's a spectrum among necrophiliacs that could create problems in how the laws would be written.

For example, some posters claimed to be sexually aroused by thoughts of rubbing up against a corpse or having traditional forms of sex with it while others were aroused by fantasies of running their hands through the guts of a splayed corpse. A few talked about eating parts of a corpse and some said their fantasies included torturing a victim, killing them and then having sex with their corpse.

The gist I got from the forum is that paraphilias are often a combination of desires and in the case of necrophilia the sexual gratification needs can get complex. isissxn pointed out the formal classifications upthread while I derived my information purely from posters on a forum but they seem to line up pretty well.

So legally speaking, what kinds of guidelines and limitations would be needed? Are we talking fresh corpses with a one off experience, or storing the body in your home – would it be stamped with an expiration date like other kinds of meat? Who would be responsible for its disposal cost and what happens if the necrophiliac can't afford it?

Can you do taxidermy on a human in the same way animals are preserved? Would that spoil the sexual aspect for some necrophiliacs? None of the posters in that forum expressed a desire for a long term relationship or marriage with a corpse so I guess they'd need a constant supply of fresh ones.

OTOH, going online and writing in vivid detail what one would like to do to a corpse is very different from acting out in real life and I question how many of those posters have or would act out if an opportunity presented itself. Just guessing I'd say not 100 percent.

The practice does disgust me and I wouldn't vote for the legalization of necrophilia but not because of the ick factor - I have more worries about health problems and potential harm to the community at large if those health problems aren't dealt with. Based on limited research I also believe necrophilia is a mental disorder and when combined with other disorders, especially antisocial ones, it could pose a safety risk to people in a community. If there was a mechanism in place that would protect others from physical or emotional harm then I suppose at best I'd consider it a victimless crime. IOW, decriminalization vs legalization.
 
Ah, despite being interested as a theoretical argument over principles, my own sense of squickiness/ickiness led me to not read the entirety of the OP... :covereyes

I think many people regard talk about necrophilia as a sick joke, and thus tend to make fun of it. They don't focus on the reality of it. Look at all the jokes about undertakers and parody's about Frankenstein and Igor. These things used to be the subject of horror now we make fun.

"He must have an enormous schwanzstucker":D
 
Could you marry the corpse?

Wait. Isn't there a part of the vow about, '...till death do you part'? and some time shortly after that, a necessary acknowledgement of same said vow? How'll that work? :confused:

"Do you, putrefying corpse, formerly known as Mary, take Marvin as your lawfully wedded husband, through every unimaginable act until the very flesh falls from your bones, and/or, until his own death does he join you? If so, say nothing whatsoever and remain motionless, what with you being one-hundred percent already dead.
We shall now pause allowing for the very unlikely possibility of anything other than the also very expected non-response...

Assuming this non-response to mean the putrefying corpse, formerly known as Mary, has given consent, we will continue.
Do you Marvin, you sick son of a bitch, take the putrefying corpse, formerly known as Mary, as your lawfully wedded wife, in all it's sickness, and death, as long as you continue to live? If so, say, 'I do.'"


:covereyes
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom