epepke
Philosopher
- Joined
- Oct 22, 2003
- Messages
- 9,264
This thread, like many, is based on premises that are backward.
People don't do things, including make something illegal, because they have rational reasons to do so. They do it because that's what they want to do, and then they come up with reasons so that they can sound all rational.
This is not necessarily a bad thing. People want a world that they like. I want a world, for example, that has beer in it, just because I like beer. So I don't want a world with prohibition of the sale and consumption of beer. I don't want people to kill me, either, so I like laws against that. And I also like laws against killing other people, because they make me feel good when someone is caught. Of course, it's better when the person caught is actually guilty, because if they aren't, I might have to feel bad when an innocent person is put in prison. I don't like that.
That's really all it is, and what is comical is the amount of rationalization that gets done. There is sense in almost nothing; it's purely visceral, and the rationalizations that make it appear to make sense are almost always completely dishonest.
But that's just saying the same thing, isn't it? People like explanations to make sense, whether they do or not. The process of doing this is just a lot more elaborate than passing a law. It involves media and discourse and all sorts of other social factors.
People don't do things, including make something illegal, because they have rational reasons to do so. They do it because that's what they want to do, and then they come up with reasons so that they can sound all rational.
This is not necessarily a bad thing. People want a world that they like. I want a world, for example, that has beer in it, just because I like beer. So I don't want a world with prohibition of the sale and consumption of beer. I don't want people to kill me, either, so I like laws against that. And I also like laws against killing other people, because they make me feel good when someone is caught. Of course, it's better when the person caught is actually guilty, because if they aren't, I might have to feel bad when an innocent person is put in prison. I don't like that.
That's really all it is, and what is comical is the amount of rationalization that gets done. There is sense in almost nothing; it's purely visceral, and the rationalizations that make it appear to make sense are almost always completely dishonest.
But that's just saying the same thing, isn't it? People like explanations to make sense, whether they do or not. The process of doing this is just a lot more elaborate than passing a law. It involves media and discourse and all sorts of other social factors.