Why should necrophilia be banned?

This thread, like many, is based on premises that are backward.

People don't do things, including make something illegal, because they have rational reasons to do so. They do it because that's what they want to do, and then they come up with reasons so that they can sound all rational.

This is not necessarily a bad thing. People want a world that they like. I want a world, for example, that has beer in it, just because I like beer. So I don't want a world with prohibition of the sale and consumption of beer. I don't want people to kill me, either, so I like laws against that. And I also like laws against killing other people, because they make me feel good when someone is caught. Of course, it's better when the person caught is actually guilty, because if they aren't, I might have to feel bad when an innocent person is put in prison. I don't like that.

That's really all it is, and what is comical is the amount of rationalization that gets done. There is sense in almost nothing; it's purely visceral, and the rationalizations that make it appear to make sense are almost always completely dishonest.

But that's just saying the same thing, isn't it? People like explanations to make sense, whether they do or not. The process of doing this is just a lot more elaborate than passing a law. It involves media and discourse and all sorts of other social factors.
 
Wouldn't it be easier to identify such individuals if it were legal? What, exactly, is the point of identifying such individuals?

To do something bad to them in order to have someone to feel superior to. That's a lot of fun. It's so much fun that, when they don't have any people like this handy, they make them. Either they use some sort of -ism to classify people as bad even when they're perfectly fine people, or they actually force them to be bad so that they can justify hating them. The War on Drugs is a nice way to do the latter. People don't even have to do drugs; the cops just have to plant them. Nice. And then they get trained to be more severe criminals in prison so that they can provide more moral entertainment when they get out.

I often wonder if that's why the cops in Europe are relatively nice, though they tried the other way about 70 years ago. Europeans are so busy hating each other that they can get by. Of course, that's why they had that cultural festival about 70 years ago.
 
This thread, like many, is based on premises that are backward.

People don't do things, including make something illegal, because they have rational reasons to do so. They do it because that's what they want to do, and then they come up with reasons so that they can sound all rational.

This is not necessarily a bad thing. People want a world that they like. I want a world, for example, that has beer in it, just because I like beer. So I don't want a world with prohibition of the sale and consumption of beer. I don't want people to kill me, either, so I like laws against that. And I also like laws against killing other people, because they make me feel good when someone is caught. Of course, it's better when the person caught is actually guilty, because if they aren't, I might have to feel bad when an innocent person is put in prison. I don't like that.

That's really all it is, and what is comical is the amount of rationalization that gets done. There is sense in almost nothing; it's purely visceral, and the rationalizations that make it appear to make sense are almost always completely dishonest.

But that's just saying the same thing, isn't it? People like explanations to make sense, whether they do or not. The process of doing this is just a lot more elaborate than passing a law. It involves media and discourse and all sorts of other social factors.

I'm not sure if it's been apparent from my posts in this thread (I'm not always clear, though I try to be) but I pretty much agree. That's why I think discussions like this are beneficial. You see them start to circle, and if you're honest, you start to see the ridiculousness of it all for yourself. That's not to say total anarchy would be preferable. It's just nice to let yourself see how senseless most things truly are if picked apart enough.

Especially taboos. Especially especially sexual taboos. These are the ones with the most intrinsic visceral reactions of all. Sometimes, there's at least a clear reason for it (for example, if someone is harmed). Other times, eh... It's a bit tougher! And you see people start to froth and puff up like moral peacocks, clucking and decrying the perverts. The less sense it makes, the more that happens.

I'm just as disgusted by the idea of necrophilia as the next person. My off-the-cuff reaction is "Jesus, no, ban, BAN!" But when I start examining it logically, and discussing it with others attempting to do the same - let's just say it's fascinating how many senseless tautologies I find within my own position. Again, if I'm honest.

That's why I think these kinds of discussions are fruitful, even if they squick people out or infuriate.
 
I'm just as disgusted by the idea of necrophilia as the next person. My off-the-cuff reaction is "Jesus, no, ban, BAN!" But when I start examining it logically, and discussing it with others attempting to do the same - let's just say it's fascinating how many senseless tautologies I find within my own position. Again, if I'm honest.

That's just it, isn't it? Examining it logically.

People wearing sweatpants or pajamas in public is disgusting to me, and I'd like it banned.

But, really, there's no actual reason to.
 
I cant say I have heard of other species shagging their dead, but the it isnt something Id spend time studying
 
I'm not sure if it's been apparent from my posts in this thread (I'm not always clear, though I try to be) but I pretty much agree. That's why I think discussions like this are beneficial. You see them start to circle, and if you're honest, you start to see the ridiculousness of it all for yourself. That's not to say total anarchy would be preferable. It's just nice to let yourself see how senseless most things truly are if picked apart enough.

Especially taboos. Especially especially sexual taboos. These are the ones with the most intrinsic visceral reactions of all. Sometimes, there's at least a clear reason for it (for example, if someone is harmed). Other times, eh... It's a bit tougher! And you see people start to froth and puff up like moral peacocks, clucking and decrying the perverts. The less sense it makes, the more that happens.

I like your analysis here. But if we take it seriously, aren't we then left simply accepting that, "that's the way we are" once we recognize the underlying mechanism? I don't see a clear path to being different than how I am, even when I see the weaknesses.

Do you see this property (the post hoc rationalization) as part and parcel of what it is to be human, or is it something we might expect to alter?
 
I like your analysis here. But if we take it seriously, aren't we then left simply accepting that, "that's the way we are" once we recognize the underlying mechanism? I don't see a clear path to being different than how I am, even when I see the weaknesses.

Do you see this property (the post hoc rationalization) as part and parcel of what it is to be human, or is it something we might expect to alter?

Hoo-boy, that's a complicated question. I haven't decided. Perhaps a bit of both. Perhaps the blend of those two states is where ethical principles come from, and why they can change and evolve through the ages, and why some things in that vein don't change as much.

I don't have a definite answer. I'm still exploring the questions. What do you think? Help me out! :)
 
Hoo-boy, that's a complicated question. I haven't decided. Perhaps a bit of both. Perhaps the blend of those two states is where ethical principles come from, and why they can change and evolve through the ages, and why some things in that vein don't change as much.

I don't have a definite answer. I'm still exploring the questions. What do you think? Help me out! :)

I don't know either. I've recently been reading The Illusion of Conscious Will by Wegner, and he makes a convincing case that "rational" doesn't fit us often, if at all - that we really are much closer to instinctive (animal like) beings than we like to think.

But I don't really know what I think yet. I'll have to wait and see, I guess.
 
Now, if you want to hypothesize a situation in which the person explicitly consented to sexual use of their body after death, then we get into discussion about what one can or can't consent to while alive also, e.g. why are so many drugs prohibited, there are things consenting adults can't consent to with each other by law, etc.

All but perhaps the most hard-core libertarians agree there should be restrictions on what people can do even with consent. The most obvious example is selling oneself into slavery, though some anarcho-capitalists argue that "inalienable" rights are a restriction on liberty since we lose the freedom to surrender them.

Should I be allowed to contract a good and trusted friend to kill me? I think here's where the state/public can say, "you have the right to kill yourself, but if you're looking for assistance, then try a doctor." I haven't read through all of the replies but someone suggested a sex doll as an alternative. I'm sure necrophiliacs will contend, "it's not the same." Rather than a lethal injection, maybe a "big game hunter" insists he wants to be killed with his favorite rifle. And around it goes...
 
I suppose it's related, and I have it in mind because it happened near where I live: a man is caught having sex with a dead dog. One of the first reactions (before it all got to court) was along the lines of, "Why isn't this illegal?" And, technically, it wasn't. It didn't fall under animal abuse because the dog was dead. It didn't fall under necrophilia because the object of desire wasn't a human.

In any case, he eventually pleaded out. "Sheeran [the judge] sentenced Kuch in July to three years in prison for the resisting charge and 18 months for indecent exposure. All three sentences will be served concurrently, and Kuch was granted credit for 255 days served."

Link: http://blog.mlive.com/bctimes/2008/02/saginaw_man_convicted_of_sex_w.html

If he hadn't taken the plea deal, they were going to try and convict him as a "sexually delinquent person" and he would have risked life in prison. Also from the piece: "Michigan has no law specifically forbidding sex with an animal carcass."

This would be a clear example of conviction by disgust.

The term "sexually delinquent person" when used in this act shall mean any person whose sexual behavior is characterized by repetitive or compulsive acts which indicate a disregard of consequences or the recognized rights of others, or by the use of force upon another person in attempting sex relations of either a heterosexual or homosexual nature, or by the commission of sexual aggressions against children under the age of 16.
How in the Nine Names of Odin could one fit this mans behavior to the charge "sexually delinquent person"?
 
My gut tells me it is, but my gut isn't always entirely rational.

Sometimes, when I look at the state of things, my gut tells me to blow my 401(k) on hookers and gin.
Yes, but the hookers and producers of gin will hardly be disgusted by your behavior. Now, some of the more sanctimonious twits who post here, might find your behavior disgusting and thus should be forbidden by law. After all, they know better than you what you should do with your money or your sex organs.
 
Last edited:
I don't know either. I've recently been reading The Illusion of Conscious Will by Wegner, and he makes a convincing case that "rational" doesn't fit us often, if at all - that we really are much closer to instinctive (animal like) beings than we like to think.

But I don't really know what I think yet. I'll have to wait and see, I guess.

I think it can be demonstrated that many of us construct rational reasons to justify what we have already decided. So it's possible the "machine of decision" in our brain has little to do with reason. The R-complex actually is the driver and the fore-brain comes up with the "reasons" and the most effective way to carry out the decision.
 
To do something bad to them in order to have someone to feel superior to. That's a lot of fun. It's so much fun that, when they don't have any people like this handy, they make them. Either they use some sort of -ism to classify people as bad even when they're perfectly fine people, or they actually force them to be bad so that they can justify hating them. The War on Drugs is a nice way to do the latter. People don't even have to do drugs; the cops just have to plant them. Nice. And then they get trained to be more severe criminals in prison so that they can provide more moral entertainment when they get out.

I often wonder if that's why the cops in Europe are relatively nice, though they tried the other way about 70 years ago. Europeans are so busy hating each other that they can get by. Of course, that's why they had that cultural festival about 70 years ago.

Mlos Forman, a film director who grew up in Czechoslovakia under Communism, made the point in an interview, that totalitarians begin by going after the perverts (homosexuals, prostitutes, pornographers, people with odd fetishes etc.) because most of us don't like such people. The purpose is to reinforce the idea that it's OK to throw people in prison simply because you don't like what they do. Then you keep lowering the bar until the people the government doesn't like (political opponents, liberals, conservatives, the latest bogyman etc.) are classed with the perverts. This is why you need something besides disgust as a reason to pass laws.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom