Why should necrophilia be banned?

I'd say no - it should be illegal. The reason isn't to prevent harm or keep you from doing it, but to identify you as a person who wants to do it. That is, to identify a character trait which separates you from the larger community. Those of us who don't have the trait don't need the law - we aren't going to do it anyhow. We find it repugnant and disgusting. What's more, we expect others to feel the same way. If you don't, you get connected to the act and also become an object to revile - the disgust transfers.

Under this rubric, making it a law serves as a way to codify and communicate something about how society views an act. Not that the act itself has some separate and objective "wrongness," but only that your fellows deem it so. "We are the sort of people who do not have sex with corpses."
 
I'd say no - it should be illegal. The reason isn't to prevent harm or keep you from doing it, but to identify you as a person who wants to do it. That is, to identify a character trait which separates you from the larger community. Those of us who don't have the trait don't need the law - we aren't going to do it anyhow. We find it repugnant and disgusting. What's more, we expect others to feel the same way. If you don't, you get connected to the act and also become an object to revile - the disgust transfers.

Under this rubric, making it a law serves as a way to codify and communicate something about how society views an act. Not that the act itself has some separate and objective "wrongness," but only that your fellows deem it so. "We are the sort of people who do not have sex with corpses."

But we allow all kinds of hideous tattoos, cosmetic surgery and daft hairstyles. Why can't we as a society say no to those things too?
 
I'd say no - it should be illegal. The reason isn't to prevent harm or keep you from doing it, but to identify you as a person who wants to do it. That is, to identify a character trait which separates you from the larger community. Those of us who don't have the trait don't need the law - we aren't going to do it anyhow. We find it repugnant and disgusting. What's more, we expect others to feel the same way. If you don't, you get connected to the act and also become an object to revile - the disgust transfers.

Under this rubric, making it a law serves as a way to codify and communicate something about how society views an act. Not that the act itself has some separate and objective "wrongness," but only that your fellows deem it so. "We are the sort of people who do not have sex with corpses."

Yes but substitute "We are the sort of people who do not have sex with blacks, whites, Chinese, people of the same gender, people of the opposite gender etc. etc." If the society finds any of these things disgusting then what has changed?
 
Last edited:
But we allow all kinds of hideous tattoos, cosmetic surgery and daft hairstyles. Why can't we as a society say no to those things too?

Because we have a sense of scale and are not machines with bivalent logic circuits. There is much gray in the world.
 
Yes but substitute "We are the sort of people who do not have sex with blacks, whites, Chinese, people of the same gender, people of the opposite gender etc. etc." If the society finds any of these things disgusting then what has changed?

Hey. Stick to the topic at hand. If you want to talk about any one of those other things, start a new thread. This is about ******* dead people.
 
Yes but substitute "We are the sort of people who do not have sex with blacks, whites, Chinese, people of the same gender, people of the opposite gender etc. etc." If the society finds any of these things disgusting then what has changed?

It's exactly the same mechanism. But note, it also allows for: "I no longer think X is disgusting and we should drop that law - my ancestors were wrong."

There's nothing to prevent our grandchildren from rearranging things we now think on one side of the line or another. The current milieu is supposed to at least mostly reflect what those currently living think appropriate and what they reject.

I think both Biblical law and the Koranic style show clearly that trying to establish "forever laws" doesn't work out too well. We should have some input into the laws we live under. Pragmatically, even avid followers of Sharia law have a role for judges and modification by way of selective enforcement.
 
I'd say no - it should be illegal. The reason isn't to prevent harm or keep you from doing it, but to identify you as a person who wants to do it. That is, to identify a character trait which separates you from the larger community. Those of us who don't have the trait don't need the law - we aren't going to do it anyhow. We find it repugnant and disgusting. What's more, we expect others to feel the same way. If you don't, you get connected to the act and also become an object to revile - the disgust transfers.

Under this rubric, making it a law serves as a way to codify and communicate something about how society views an act. Not that the act itself has some separate and objective "wrongness," but only that your fellows deem it so. "We are the sort of people who do not have sex with corpses."

I understand your reasoning about a ban being society's way of saying "we don't do that", but isn't that the same justification for banning SSM?

What business is it of society if two necrophiliacs make a death pact to allow whomever dies second to go bananas on the first guys corpse?
 
Hey. Stick to the topic at hand. If you want to talk about any one of those other things, start a new thread. This is about ******* dead people.

We have very different viewpoints Caper, but this post made me laugh out loud :)
 
My point of view is that everything should be by default banned, including breathing. Then you just go down the list and un ban things as needed. For obvious reasons put breathing at the top of the list.
 
Hey. Stick to the topic at hand. If you want to talk about any one of those other things, start a new thread. This is about ******* dead people.

marplots said:
I'd say no - it should be illegal. The reason isn't to prevent harm or keep you from doing it, but to identify you as a person who wants to do it. That is, to identify a character trait which separates you from the larger community. Those of us who don't have the trait don't need the law - we aren't going to do it anyhow. We find it repugnant and disgusting. What's more, we expect others to feel the same way. If you don't, you get connected to the act and also become an object to revile - the disgust transfers.
Under this rubric, making it a law serves as a way to codify and communicate something about how society views an act. Not that the act itself has some separate and objective "wrongness," but only that your fellows deem it so. "We are the sort of people who do not have sex with corpses."


I was answering a argument based on using disgust as a standard. Complain to marplots.
 
My point of view is that everything should be by default banned, including breathing. Then you just go down the list and un ban things as needed. For obvious reasons put breathing at the top of the list.

You don't need that if you are dead. Which is subject of the thread. If you want to talk about breathing start a thread. :)
 
It's exactly the same mechanism. But note, it also allows for: "I no longer think X is disgusting and we should drop that law - my ancestors were wrong."

There's nothing to prevent our grandchildren from rearranging things we now think on one side of the line or another. The current milieu is supposed to at least mostly reflect what those currently living think appropriate and what they reject.

I think both Biblical law and the Koranic style show clearly that trying to establish "forever laws" doesn't work out too well. We should have some input into the laws we live under. Pragmatically, even avid followers of Sharia law have a role for judges and modification by way of selective enforcement.

There is something that bothers about making laws based solely on disgust.
 
I was just kidding. But in all seriousness. I don't mind disgust as a standard.

You should mind. Seriously, throwing people in jail or worse merely because they disgust someone is a very slippery slope.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom