Why should necrophilia be banned?

I understand your reasoning about a ban being society's way of saying "we don't do that", but isn't that the same justification for banning SSM?

Yes. It is also the justification for removing the same ban. "Justification" isn't quite the right word though. My remarks are more about the system in play and how it works. There's really no underlying justification, other than: "I think this is wrong." It's not unpacked in the way some are attempting by showing underlying harm, save that, when someone asks me to justify it, I might invent reasons.

What business is it of society if two necrophiliacs make a death pact to allow whomever dies second to go bananas on the first guys corpse?

The "business" is tied up in the meaning of what a society is. It's a pact that includes ideas about appropriate behaviors, norms and identification of "like me" and "unlike me."

We even have a place for outliers to push their own ideas of individuality. But notice the difference in play - someone intending the contract you describe would (I assume), keep it secret. And I'd propose they'd do so whether or not it was illegal. Why? Because they understand they would be an object of revulsion if people found out. So there is something there. Something pre-existing, no matter that it seems arbitrary.

I think we are cognizant of the zeitgeist in play. In fact, that might be part of the attraction - the lure of the forbidden. However, I'd expect a necrophiliac to know, in spite of their behavior, that society at large views it as taboo. Which makes the act, even with the contract in place, something they know to be "wrong" - at least in some sense. So they aren't simply neutral actors here; they are setting out on a path they already know to be illegal. That last bit, in and of itself, can be identified as a character flaw, even if you think necrophilia should be allowed.
 
There is something that bothers about making laws based solely on disgust.

It's pretty powerful. I read once (I think it was Ira Glass' mother who made the point - isn't she some kind of psychologist/marriage counselor?) that the best indicator of whether a couple will get divorced or not is if one or both feels disgust for the other. All the other negative emotions could be set aside - anger, disappointment, even deep animus - but disgust was so fundamental, so visceral, it couldn't be overcome. (I'm not really making a case for anything here, I just thought it was interesting.)
 
It's pretty powerful. I read once (I think it was Ira Glass' mother who made the point - isn't she some kind of psychologist/marriage counselor?) that the best indicator of whether a couple will get divorced or not is if one or both feels disgust for the other. All the other negative emotions could be set aside - anger, disappointment, even deep animus - but disgust was so fundamental, so visceral, it couldn't be overcome. (I'm not really making a case for anything here, I just thought it was interesting.)

Yes it is interesting. But it's still a bad reference for making laws. Normal people avoid things that disgust them and won't support such things. But it's dangerous to use that as the only criteria for making laws.
 
Yes it is interesting. But it's still a bad reference for making laws. Normal people avoid things that disgust them and won't support such things. But it's dangerous to use that as the only criteria for making laws.

Think about it though. If disgust is some kind of deep universal, it at least provides a benchmark, something to get us all on the same page in a swirling mix of subjectivity. That's an essential element when you want to do things as a group - some base of agreement to build from.

Of course, it's vulnerable to challenge that same way. As soon as someone stands up and answers the charge of "That's disgusting!" with "No it isn't." there's an immediate problem.

I wonder how it plays out with homosexual marriage as a parallel. It would be extremely interesting to see poll data, from say 1970 vs. 2000 on whether people find homosexual relations disgusting or not. Then, compare it with vote tallies on laws against it. It might not prove my case, but it could certainly disprove it if the numbers didn't change much along that dimension.
 
Marplots is much smarter then me. His reasoning is what I would say if I was smart.
 
Think about it though. If disgust is some kind of deep universal, it at least provides a benchmark, something to get us all on the same page in a swirling mix of subjectivity. That's an essential element when you want to do things as a group - some base of agreement to build from.

Of course, it's vulnerable to challenge that same way. As soon as someone stands up and answers the charge of "That's disgusting!" with "No it isn't." there's an immediate problem.

I wonder how it plays out with homosexual marriage as a parallel. It would be extremely interesting to see poll data, from say 1970 vs. 2000 on whether people find homosexual relations disgusting or not. Then, compare it with vote tallies on laws against it. It might not prove my case, but it could certainly disprove it if the numbers didn't change much along that dimension.

Marplots is much smarter then me. His reasoning is what I would say if I was smart.

I understand that disgust may be something many of us have in common and that it is better than most variables on which to base morality, but another variable, possibly less subjective than disgust, is harm. The idea is that nobody is harmed by the relationship, and moreover may be very happy with the relationship that it becomes an even less arbitrary standard with which to work.
 
I understand that disgust may be something many of us have in common and that it is better than most variables on which to base morality, but another variable, possibly less subjective than disgust, is harm. The idea is that nobody is harmed by the relationship, and moreover may be very happy with the relationship that it becomes an even less arbitrary standard with which to work.

Agreed - I posted something similar in the incest thread. To my mind, for a law to be just there needs to be some quantifiable social harm that is prevented by the ban or benefit that is gained by the ban.

Of course one could say that having a society that views necrophilia as an acceptable practise is in itself a social harm - although I'm not sure how you'd demonstrate that.
 
I'm not sure why this is a difficult subject.

As a society, we require respect for the dead because we respect the living. We do so for at least two reasons I can see.

(1) Defiling a corpse is not a victimless crime. The grieving survivors suffer[1]. Even if they are not directly aware, so long as we do not say that this behavior is beyond the pale, that they can expect their loved one's corpse to be treated with respect.

(2) Defiling a corpse is to treat something so apparently human with such disrespect that we should be concerned about whether it seriously damages the necrophiliac's empathy.

Okay, I think (2) won't get far in this crowd, so let's focus on (1). It may be that you can cook up some hokey scenario in which the deceased has no loved ones, and he didn't fear being loved up after death, and no one else will know and so on and so on, so there are no negative effects. But that's not how we make laws. We outlaw activities which are likely to produce negative effects, even if sometimes they don't.

And, for most persons, the thought of their recently deceased loved one as the object of sexual attention is somewhat of a distraction from the process of mourning.

[1] One may ask whether they ought to regard sex with their recently departed loved one a horrible thing, but that's a distinct question. No doubt, there is some emotional confusion in treating the lifeless corpse as the actual friend you loved, but it does seem almost unavoidable.
 
If there is any point in being serious, then I will point out:

1. For some reason, many people care about what happens to their body when they die (I don't). One can currently request that it be buried, burned, dissolved in NaOH, dumped at sea, autopsied, etc. So I would think any request to have it used for sex would require very clear instructions from the person when they were alive to do so (consent), Even so, I suspect that relatives would want to have a say, too, and in some cases they have been successful in determining the placement of the remains against the expressed wishes of the deceased.

2. Health issues. Dead bodies are not very healthy in most cases, so I can see a legitimate law against necrophilia for this reason alone, even if the dead person had previously agreed with the idea. Some people die of infectious diseases, others acquire nasty organisms as they rot. There are already laws against burying bodies near homes, dumping near shore, etc. I think using a body for sex would have serious health issues in most cases.

Assuming all of these concerns could be met (no easy feat) then I have no problem with what someone privately does with a body given the prior approval of the deceased. Make it into a coffee table if they so wish.
 
Last edited:
Could you marry the corpse?

A corpse can't be named your next of kin, given power of attorney, assume your debts, or enter into a mutual contract of marriage. I'm obviously not a lawyer of any sort, but that much is, I think, apparent to almost anyone. It's the same reason the ridiculous "marry your pet" slippery slope argument that pops up so much is just that - ridiculous.

Marriage is between living, human, adult beings with the ability to give knowledgeable consent. There is no slope.

Sex, on the other hand... well, the rules for sex and sexual fetishes aren't so cut and dried, are they?
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure why anyone would want to **** a dead body (maybe it's a guy who has only slept with really hot chicks).

Quite. In fact I started the thread because I agree that incest between consenting adults is no business but their own, however when considering the necrophilia question, the squickiness factor rises to full-on vomit-inducing nausea.

How about this: a widower's young daughter dies. He decides they should be together one more time. So you have the big three: pedophilia, necrophilia, and incest. The girl never consented to have her corpse used in this way -- she couldn't even grasp the concept since she was a whole year away from sixth grade.

Suppose hard-core atheist parents have a high school aged daughter who becomes a crazy, fundamentalist Christian. She tragically dies (because God works in mysterious ways). Can the parents act contrary to the girl's wishes to have a religious burial?
 
If there is any point in being serious, then I will point out:

1. For some reason, many people care about what happens to their body when they die (I don't). One can currently request that it be buried, burned, dissolved in NaOH, dumped at sea, autopsied, etc. So I would think any request to have it used for sex would require very clear instructions from the person when they were alive to do so (consent), Even so, I suspect that relatives would want to have a say, too, and in some cases they have been successful in determining the placement of the remains against the expressed wishes of the deceased.

2. Health issues. Dead bodies are not very healthy in most cases, so I can see a legitimate law against necrophilia for this reason alone, even if the dead person had previously agreed with the idea. Some people die of infectious diseases, others acquire nasty organisms as they rot. There are already laws against burying bodies near homes, dumping near shore, etc. I think using a body for sex would have serious health issues in most cases.

Assuming all of these concerns could be met (no easy feat) then I have no problem what someone privately does with a body with the prior approval of the deceased. Make it into a coffee table if they so wish.

Indeed, handling of the deceased is a significant social and health issue. I think the best way to deal with this is to have a list of things you ARE allowed to with dead bodies, and standardized procedures for doing so... and I don't think it would be reasonable to demand that there be standards for proper sexual intercourse with a corpse.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom