Why should necrophilia be banned?

People having sex with corpses usually do so after first creating the corpse by murdering someone. I think.

In the ballroom with a knife. Oh say, a knife about 7 inches long. With a stab wound 4.5 inches below the neck. And then hiding the body in the closet until everyone else was asleep, and then I....

Whoops, did I say too much already?
 
I'm not sure why anyone would want to **** a dead body (maybe it's a guy who has only slept with really hot chicks).

Suppose hard-core atheist parents have a high school aged daughter who becomes a crazy, fundamentalist Christian. She tragically dies (because God works in mysterious ways). Can the parents act contrary to the girl's wishes to have a religious burial?
There are a lot of human wishes and desires that I don't understand.

If the daughter was over 18, and expressly indicated a religious burial in written instructions to their executor, it would be very hard for the parents to prevent it (although probably not completely impossible)
 
People having sex with corpses usually do so after first creating the corpse by murdering someone. I think.

That certainly happens. But it's far from the only classification.

Turns out, there's a ten-tier classification system for necrophiliacs.

1.) Role players
2.) Romantic necrophiliacs (:boggled:)
3.) People experiencing necrophiliac fantasy, hallucination, delusion, etc. (Sometimes called "necrophiliac miracle" :eye-poppi:boggled::boggled:)
4.) Tactile necrophiliacs (Need to touch a dead body in some way for sexual gratification)
5.) Fetishistic necrophiliacs
6.) Necromutilomaniacs (People who, while they don't actually have sex with dead bodies, get sexual pleasure from mutilating or desecrating a dead body in some way :eye-poppi:eye-poppi:eye-poppi!!!!)
7.) Opportunistic necrophiliacs ("Hey, it's there, might as well **** it!":eek:)
8.) Regular necrophiliacs (Strongly prefer sex with corpses over sex with living partners - might not even enjoy sex with living partners at all)
9.) Homicidal necrophiliacs (The type to whom Trebuchet was referring)
10.) Exclusive necrophiliacs (Completely unable to perform intercourse with anything but dead bodies; the rarest type of all)

Here's a fun article which goes into more detail than you probably ever wanted to know about these categorizations, as well as some of the psychology theorized to be behind this extremely taboo fetish. http://www.anilaggrawal.com/ij/sundry/news_and_notes/316_A new classification of necrophilia.pdf

And now, I think I need to go have a shower. :boggled:
 
Last edited:
Song I heard years ago:

I went down to the cemetary, to pick up my ex-girlfriend Mary/ But to my surprise, she was rolling her eyes at my ex-dead-best-friend Harry (Chorus) Dead girls, dead girls, dead girls, dancing with the dead girls...

**********************

Eew factor aside, my biggest concern is proper disposal when they're done. If people won't properly dispose of their kleenex in the peep shows (according to best of craigslists posts from employees) then we certainly can't count on them not to leave 150# of rotting meat in the alley like inconsiderate jerks when they're through playing.
 
Think about it though. If disgust is some kind of deep universal, it at least provides a benchmark, something to get us all on the same page in a swirling mix of subjectivity. That's an essential element when you want to do things as a group - some base of agreement to build from.

Of course, it's vulnerable to challenge that same way. As soon as someone stands up and answers the charge of "That's disgusting!" with "No it isn't." there's an immediate problem.

I wonder how it plays out with homosexual marriage as a parallel. It would be extremely interesting to see poll data, from say 1970 vs. 2000 on whether people find homosexual relations disgusting or not. Then, compare it with vote tallies on laws against it. It might not prove my case, but it could certainly disprove it if the numbers didn't change much along that dimension.
That's the problem, disgust isn't always universal. My late aunt would have spasms whenever she saw a black man in company with a white woman. She was incapable of understanding my view that if these two people wanted to be together it wasn't anybody's concern. Some Muslims get really really disgusted when they see someone eating pork.

I could give endless examples like this, but the bottom line for me, is that I don't care to be at the mercy of the queasy tummies of bigoted, sanctimonious twits! There has to be some other standard.
 
If disgust was truly universal, then we would not need to pass laws to ban such an action: no one would want to do it in the first place.

I believe that non-universal disgust is clearly subjective and as such a poor sole basis for a law, especially if the action does not objectively harm any ones, is legally consented to by adults, and would be private and typically never observed or even known as occurring by any non-participant.
 
Last edited:
Song I heard years ago:

I went down to the cemetary, to pick up my ex-girlfriend Mary/ But to my surprise, she was rolling her eyes at my ex-dead-best-friend Harry (Chorus) Dead girls, dead girls, dead girls, dancing with the dead girls...

**********************

Eew factor aside, my biggest concern is proper disposal when they're done. If people won't properly dispose of their kleenex in the peep shows (according to best of craigslists posts from employees) then we certainly can't count on them not to leave 150# of rotting meat in the alley like inconsiderate jerks when they're through playing.
It wouldn't be a problem if they were cannibalistic necrophiliacs. So we simply need to encourage these people to eat their dead after the erotic play. :) Taking the issue slightly more seriously, leaving dead bodies in a alleyway is a public health issue.
 
That's the problem, disgust isn't always universal. My late aunt would have spasms whenever she saw a black man in company with a white woman. She was incapable of understanding my view that if these two people wanted to be together it wasn't anybody's concern. Some Muslims get really really disgusted when they see someone eating pork.

I could give endless examples like this, but the bottom line for me, is that I don't care to be at the mercy of the queasy tummies of bigoted, sanctimonious twits! There has to be some other standard.

When you say you don't care to be at their mercy because of queasy tummies, aren't you just saying you don't want to be subject to their dictates for whatever reason? How would it be any different if they wanted to impose the values they found in their holy book instead - no queasy needed?

Where I'm at, pork is freely eaten, because one person's disgust, or even a few together, cannot overwhelm what the majority feels about it. It is not so everywhere and I wouldn't be surprised to hear that a Muslim country has outlawed pork altogether. I think they have the right to run their country however they see fit, illegal pork included.
 
If disgust was truly universal, then we would not need to pass laws to ban such an action: no one would want to do it in the first place.

I believe that non-universal disgust is clearly subjective and as such a poor sole basis for a law, especially if the action does not objectively harm any ones, is legally consented to by adults, and would be private and typically never observed or even known as occurring by any non-participant.

Think of all those annoyances we wouldn't have to deal with, if some people would simply stay in the closet.:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
When you say you don't care to be at their mercy because of queasy tummies, aren't you just saying you don't want to be subject to their dictates for whatever reason? How would it be any different if they wanted to impose the values they found in their holy book instead - no queasy needed?

Where I'm at, pork is freely eaten, because one person's disgust, or even a few together, cannot overwhelm what the majority feels about it. It is not so everywhere and I wouldn't be surprised to hear that a Muslim country has outlawed pork altogether. I think they have the right to run their country however they see fit, illegal pork included.

How big a majority do you need? 50.00001% ? A lot of queasy tummies are nothing but simple bigotry.
 
Here is a discussion of the basis for law that applies to this conversation:
http://www.iep.utm.edu/law-phil/#H2

Some here hold "harm" to be the standard, and agree with John Stuart Mill. Others, with Patrick Devlin, who holds morality to be the underpinning. There are valid critiques of each.
 
How big a majority do you need? 50.00001% ? A lot of queasy tummies are nothing but simple bigotry.

Seriously? I thought "queasy tummy" was a euphemism for "a sense of moral disgust." But to address the question, there is no set percentage. I don't see an advantage in trying to mathematize or script it in that way at all. Doing so is bound to fail, because this is a human activity we are talking about, not a bunch of computers.

If there is any doubt as to how it works in practice, I invite you to look around and try to see where laws you agree with (and the ones you object to) have arisen.

The whole point of grounding this in our sense of disgust is to accept the fact that it cannot be easily abstracted into a recipe. But even more so, if we create such a recipe, we still have to judge that formula as fair or foul - falling back on the very thing we wanted to avoid by coming up with the recipe in the first place.
 
When you say you don't care to be at their mercy because of queasy tummies, aren't you just saying you don't want to be subject to their dictates for whatever reason? How would it be any different if they wanted to impose the values they found in their holy book instead - no queasy needed?

Where I'm at, pork is freely eaten, because one person's disgust, or even a few together, cannot overwhelm what the majority feels about it. It is not so everywhere and I wouldn't be surprised to hear that a Muslim country has outlawed pork altogether. I think they have the right to run their country however they see fit, illegal pork included.
Do you really believe that the political majority has a right to dictate how every adult behaves even if such behavior objectively harms no one? Very interesting. So the laws in several Muslim countries that ban the teaching of non-Muslim religions are also fine by you?
 
Do you really believe that the political majority has a right to dictate how every adult behaves even if such behavior objectively harms no one? Very interesting. So the laws in several Muslim countries that ban the teaching of non-Muslim religions are also fine by you?

No they are not fine by me. I can agree that their methodology is the proper one, and still disagree with the result. I too have to ability to judge things. I would not want such laws to be in place where I live.

The problem comes in when we try to figure out who gets to decide. I may not agree with a bunch of things others do, and I will try and shape the world around me to best fit my own judgements, but simultaneously, others are doing the same thing. The result is a landscape that varies, and we should expect it to be so. Those parts of the world I can influence - say, voting against a repeal of necrophilia laws - I will attempt to do so. Those parts where I cannot, I cannot. That doesn't mean I don't think a particular behavior is wrong, it just means I lost the argument.

And I'd dispute your use of "dictate" there. It sounds so much friendlier if we say, "the collective will of those governed" instead. "Dictate" implies a dictator and the callous disregard for the majority - the opposite of a democracy. Further, in practice it doesn't shake out like a dictatorship. What you have instead is groups that aren't necessarily numerically superior, but superior by way of the strength of their beliefs. They have the ability to sway the big bubble of neutral to their side of things. There's a fluidity in the mix that "dictate" misses by framing things as black and white.
 
Last edited:
Seriously? I thought "queasy tummy" was a euphemism for "a sense of moral disgust." But to address the question, there is no set percentage. I don't see an advantage in trying to mathematize or script it in that way at all. Doing so is bound to fail, because this is a human activity we are talking about, not a bunch of computers.

If there is any doubt as to how it works in practice, I invite you to look around and try to see where laws you agree with (and the ones you object to) have arisen.

The whole point of grounding this in our sense of disgust is to accept the fact that it cannot be easily abstracted into a recipe. But even more so, if we create such a recipe, we still have to judge that formula as fair or foul - falling back on the very thing we wanted to avoid by coming up with the recipe in the first place.
I very much think that an clear number is absolutely crucial if you wish disgust to determine democratic laws. How many people must be disgusted to justify passage of a law? 50.1%? Or would we require more to be disgusted? Or less? 10% of the USA is 30 million people. Are 30 million people enough to justify a ban on a given action if it simply disgusts them?

I am particularly sensitive on this issue because I came from a minority religion. Some of my earlier (and current atheistic) beliefs would be very disturbing to most Americans, and they would believe that these beliefs would lead me to hell! Should they be able to pass a ban on practicing my religious and non-religious views (overturning the Bill of Rights first)? And remember that this is not only a sense of disgust (believe me, I am not exaggerating how many people I've met view minority religious views ss disgusting) but an additional feeling that my beliefs will harm me in the "afterlife" and will punish me now by "withholding God's blessings."
 
No they are not fine by me. I can agree that their methodology is the proper one, and still disagree with the result. I too have to ability to judge things. I would not want such laws to be in place where I live.

The problem comes in when we try to figure out who gets to decide. I may not agree with a bunch of things others do, and I will try and shape the world around me to best fit my own judgements, but simultaneously, others are doing the same thing. The result is a landscape that varies, and we should expect it to be so. Those parts of the world I can influence - say, voting against a repeal of necrophilia laws - I will attempt to do so. Those parts where I cannot, I cannot. That doesn't mean I don't think a particular behavior is wrong, it just means I lost the argument.

And I'd dispute your use of "dictate" there. It sounds so much friendlier if we say, "the collective will of those governed" instead. "Dictate" implies a dictator and the callous disregard for the majority - the opposite of a democracy. Further, in practice it doesn't shake out like a dictatorship. What you have instead is groups that aren't necessarily numerically superior, but superior by way of the strength of their beliefs. They have the ability to sway the big bubble of neutral to their side of things. There's a fluidity in the mix that "dictate" misses by framing things as black and white.

Okay as long as you see the contradiction. Why one but not the other?

If you don't like "dictate" we can use the "will of the majority instead" if you wish. But as you yourself indicate, it is often not really the will of the majority, but the will of the most politically powerful. And I don't use the word dictate to mean it is a dictatorship, but in the sense that an action is mandated, possibly against the wishes of the person subjected to the law. The laws in democracies dictate a prohibition against murder, and I don't mean this as a negative in this particular case.
 
Seriously? I thought "queasy tummy" was a euphemism for "a sense of moral disgust." But to address the question, there is no set percentage. I don't see an advantage in trying to mathematize or script it in that way at all. Doing so is bound to fail, because this is a human activity we are talking about, not a bunch of computers.

If there is any doubt as to how it works in practice, I invite you to look around and try to see where laws you agree with (and the ones you object to) have arisen.

The whole point of grounding this in our sense of disgust is to accept the fact that it cannot be easily abstracted into a recipe. But even more so, if we create such a recipe, we still have to judge that formula as fair or foul - falling back on the very thing we wanted to avoid by coming up with the recipe in the first place.

The point I am trying to make is that disgust by its self is not a just way to make laws. The majority of people in the US would likely find the idea of eating snails disgusting. Does that mean it's OK to outlaw Escargot?
 
I very much think that an clear number is absolutely crucial if you wish disgust to determine democratic laws. How many people must be disgusted to justify passage of a law? 50.1%? Or would we require more to be disgusted? Or less? 10% of the USA is 30 million people. Are 30 million people enough to justify a ban on a given action if it simply disgusts them?

I think it's probably a lot less than 50.1% in practice, because all you need is a vocal minority to push the issue. The example I can best think of is abortion, where at least one side has a strong sense of disgust about it. But in that case, there was a countervailing push from the other side. Animal welfare by PETA might be another example.

So my question would be the opposite - shouldn't those people have the right to try and pass legislation based on their own moral leanings?

I am particularly sensitive on this issue because I came from a minority religion. Some of my earlier (and current atheistic) beliefs would be very disturbing to most Americans, and they would believe that these beliefs would lead me to hell! Should they be able to pass a ban on practicing my religious and non-religious views (overturning the Bill of Rights first)? And remember that this is not only a sense of disgust (believe me, I am not exaggerating how many people I've met view minority religious views ss disgusting) but an additional feeling that my beliefs will harm me in the "afterlife" and will punish me now by "withholding God's blessings."

I think your answer is in your question - overturning the Bill of Rights would be an act even more disgusting (in service of some temporary good) than the problem being addressed by doing so. Which, I think is fairly common; a greater wrong preventing laws against a minor wrong (from their perspective).

And that, again, is the problem with trying to mathematize it. These things have a context and outside influences the numbers alone do not capture. It's not a single dimension, but a broad "sense of the masses" in play.

I think this is most obvious when we look at what's legal in private that isn't in public. In private, my vote counts more. Not so much in public and when laws are written. Still, I might very well undertake some behavior (making everyone pray, for example) in my own little castle, that wouldn't work when others have a say too.
 
I very much think that an clear number is absolutely crucial if you wish disgust to determine democratic laws. How many people must be disgusted to justify passage of a law? 50.1%? Or would we require more to be disgusted? Or less? 10% of the USA is 30 million people. Are 30 million people enough to justify a ban on a given action if it simply disgusts them?

I am particularly sensitive on this issue because I came from a minority religion. Some of my earlier (and current atheistic) beliefs would be very disturbing to most Americans, and they would believe that these beliefs would lead me to hell! Should they be able to pass a ban on practicing my religious and non-religious views (overturning the Bill of Rights first)? And remember that this is not only a sense of disgust (believe me, I am not exaggerating how many people I've met view minority religious views ss disgusting) but an additional feeling that my beliefs will harm me in the "afterlife" and will punish me now by "withholding God's blessings."

If they had the power, these sanctimonious twits with their queasy tummies would burn you at the stake. All based on their disgust at your lack of belief.
 
The point I am trying to make is that disgust by its self is not a just way to make laws. The majority of people in the US would likely find the idea of eating snails disgusting. Does that mean it's OK to outlaw Escargot?

Maybe. But the fact that we don't means something too. It means there's a scale in play. There is no simple black/white, disgust/not disgust. Something has to be repellent enough to overcome a reluctance to prohibit another's behavior.

Consider if we did outlaw Escargot, based on the premise that it's disgusting and indicative of a moral failure of the gourmand. Wouldn't that law, itself, trigger a sense of unfairness, even disgust in a system that promoted it?

All I'm saying is that it works from both sides. (And, interestingly, the disgust for foods is largely centered in the food itself, not the act or the actor who consumes it.)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom