Why Liberal Suck at Understanding Conservatives and Why it Matters

I believe the relationship, but I'm not sure that paper demonstrated causality. That is: they didn't control for the fact that more economically conservative people are predisposed to taking business classes in the first place, and pursue professions accordingly. Selection bias, basically.

ie: the thesis is essentially, "Of people who decided to go into business, they're disproportionately Republican leaning." Well, no **** Sherlock.

(Disclosure: I have an MBA and was the only leftie in my year)

Well the Fed paper looks like it tried to disentangle causality. I haven't read the paper though. Just skimmed the first few pages.
 
There is no margin which would bother me personally. The year when 5 voters in Wyoming are expected to command 3 electoral votes all by themselves is also the year when I move to Wyoming, and the number becomes 6 (or 7 if my wife comes along).

The point it becomes taxation without representation is precisely that point at which there is enough support to change the electoral college by Constitutional Amendment, but the government, or the military, prevents it from happening by exercising unconstitutional power.

OK I think I understand your position on this.

I'm wondering how many Americans would feel the same way?
 
Well the Fed paper looks like it tried to disentangle causality. I haven't read the paper though. Just skimmed the first few pages.

I don't see them attempting to address it, unless I'm missing something. I do see them acknowledging it as a possible mitigating factor (eg: page 2). In fact, on page 24 in their conclusion they emphasize this limitation:
Unfortunately, we cannot say if our results reflect what individuals have learned in these courses and majors, or if the relationships identified here are due to self-selection among college graduates into different college majors and economics course taking.

Their actual thesis seems to be intended to be digging deeper into the relationship between 'education' and political affiliation (education is more associated with Democrats). They are demonstrating that certain types of education associate with parties differently. I don't think they're wrong about this.
 
I don't see them attempting to address it, unless I'm missing something. I do see them acknowledging it as a possible mitigating factor (eg: page 2). In fact, on page 24 in their conclusion they emphasize this limitation:

Well, on p. 4, they write this:

We analyze the relationship between these outcomes and
both the number of economics classes a person has taken and, in separate estimations, the
graduates’ choice to major in economics, business, or another field. We include controls for a
number of personal background variables found to affect civic behavior in earlier studies (for
example, Ashenfelter and Kelley 1975, Matsusak and Palda 1999, Dee 2004, and Acemoglu et
al. 2005), including income, a summary measure of the student’s academic ability/performance,
and whether or not the person went on to earn a graduate degree. The inclusion of the latter
covariates will provide insight into the channel through which economics course taking is related
with various outcomes, to gauge the extent to which they are captured by income and wealth
differences.

That's as far as I've gotten though.

Their actual thesis seems to be intended to be digging deeper into the relationship between 'education' and political affiliation (education is more associated with Democrats). They are demonstrating that certain types of education associate with parties differently. I don't think they're wrong about this.

Neither do I. I have found that people who have studied economics are far more willing to discuss competing economic philosophies dispassionately regardless of how extreme left or right they are ideologically. Those same people might get into shouting matches about other issues, but on, say, tax policy or the minimum wage, I've found that I can usually have good discussions with people who have taken a few economics courses. Perhaps it's because the concept of balancing costs and benefits is not alien to them.
 
Well, on p. 4, they write this:



That's as far as I've gotten though.

Yes, I read that too. They 'analyzed' selection of major, but didn't 'control' for it. Thus the report of it being a limitation, per their conclusion. They describe some elements they were able to control for in an effort to isolate the effect of field of study, such as starting wealth.



Neither do I. I have found that people who have studied economics are far more willing to discuss competing economic philosophies dispassionately regardless of how extreme left or right they are ideologically. Those same people might get into shouting matches about other issues, but on, say, tax policy or the minimum wage, I've found that I can usually have good discussions with people who have taken a few economics courses. Perhaps it's because the concept of balancing costs and benefits is not alien to them.

I'm not too sure it's much of an explanation for party affiliation, though. Specifically, the number of people we're talking about is a tiny fraction of the voters in either party. I don't think it generalizes to "Republicans know 0.02% more about economics than Democrats, so they're the party of economic credibility."
 
Yes, I read that too. They 'analyzed' selection of major, but didn't 'control' for it. Thus the report of it being a limitation, per their conclusion. They describe some elements they were able to control for in an effort to isolate the effect of field of study, such as starting wealth.





I'm not too sure it's much of an explanation for party affiliation, though. Specifically, the number of people we're talking about is a tiny fraction of the voters in either party. I don't think it generalizes to "Republicans know 0.02% more about economics than Democrats, so they're the party of economic credibility."

Well, I didn't mean to make that point. I just meant that popular economic policies are not necessarily good economic policies. Nor are they even the economic policies people truly want. It is unfortunate that people don't understand economics very well. And it's frustrating that the government indulges such misunderstandings (as opposed to rectifying them) by promoting sub-optimal policies.

Cash for Clunkers is a favorite example of mine. The tax credit program for electric cars is another. It's weird that Democrats want to subsidize the conspicuous consumption of fun, luxury cars by the affluent (e.g. Tesla Model S and X) to the tune of $7,500 each.
 
Well, I didn't mean to make that point. I just meant that popular economic policies are not necessarily good economic policies. Nor are they even the economic policies people truly want. It is unfortunate that people don't understand economics very well. And it's frustrating that the government indulges such misunderstandings (as opposed to rectifying them) by promoting sub-optimal policies.

Yeah, but that's life in a democracy. Wouldn't it be great if everybody was equally and sufficiently educated. Ergo my interest in JREF and Skepticism in general.

Having said that, there's also the reality that political competence doesn't seem to rely on domain specific expertise. Many voters have an effective heuristic or two that work for making effective decisions despite a lack of expertise in economics, diplomacy, war, law, medicine, &c...



Cash for Clunkers is a favorite example of mine.

Its main goal was economic stimulus, and it looks like it achieved its purpose. I guess I'd have to hear your specific criticism to understand why you think it is an example of voters not understanding economics.



The tax credit program for electric cars is another. It's weird that Democrats want to subsidize the conspicuous consumption of fun, luxury cars by the affluent (e.g. Tesla Model S and X) to the tune of $7,500 each.

The electric car subsidy is an investment in the future of American industry. The model specs were not pre-defined (sounds like they wanted to minimize regulation and let business decide how to use the incentive).

80 years ago it was investing in the production of electricity, even though electrical appliances were considered luxury items at the time. (Refrigerators! Lightbulbs! Kids today!)

Both look like good investments, if the goal is national economic growth, employment, and permanent energy independence. Kvetching about the model specs seems to be digging for something to criticize.
 
How to spell the word misogyny for one thing. Or the word "there" for that matter.

It is usually considered a bad form to solely criticize someone's spelling and not a bit the content (especially on international forum with varying degree of English mastery). "argue the argument not the arguer".
 
It is usually considered a bad form to solely criticize someone's spelling and not a bit the content (especially on international forum with varying degree of English mastery). "argue the argument not the arguer".

Oh, sorry. I don't care.
 
Originally Posted by Hercules56
What's their to understand about racism, misoginy, bigotry, and selfishness?

Originally Posted by sunmaster14
How to spell the word misogyny for one thing. Or the word "there" for that matter.

It is usually considered a bad form to solely criticize someone's spelling and not a bit the content (especially on international forum with varying degree of English mastery). "argue the argument not the arguer".

OK now it's: What's their to understand about racism, misoginy, bigotry, and selfishness, and bad form?

"argue the argument not the arguer", good advice progressives give but don't take
 
Oh, sorry. I don't care.
Of course you don't care. Spelling is more important than content because facts don't matter - the only thing that matters is 'winning' the argument by any means possible. Everyone makes a spelling mistake occasionally <snip> And even though attacking the arguer is a clear logical fallacy, you don't care because logic is only valid when it supports your argument (and is flippantly discarded when it doesn't).

Liberals may suck at understanding conservatives, but I understand you just fine.


Edited by Loss Leader: 
Edited for Rule 12
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Does it? According to jerrywayne, any time two conservatives get together it's effectively a clan [sic] meeting.

Personally, I know a Democrat and a liberal who I would say are racists. There are Republicans and conservatives I know who are not racists. But being from Red Texas and a white guy, someone other white guys talk to and joke with, I know what goes on privately, outside polite conversation. And I would say it's my experience racist comments overwhelmingly emanate from conservative mouths.
 
So, why do liberals suck at understanding conservatives, Wowbagger?

Basically because progressives have tunnel vision. They concentrate on their agenda. Look how this thread got derailed into the State providing medical care, on the assumption this is an unquestioned good.

Progressives see issues in term of outcomes, with no thought of unintended consequences.
Conservatives consider consequences, that the reason for restricting the interference of government is the great evil of adding unnecessarily to its power.
 
We have ample proof that Republican presidents are worse for the economy and budget than democratic ones.

And who voted for Clinton? The states with by far the greatest economic output. The "Rust Belt" is not called that for nothing, and neither is Silicon valley.

Trump's win is one of money spenders over money makers.
 
Conservatives consider consequences, that the reason for restricting the interference of government is the great evil of adding unnecessarily to its power.
Nonsense. Conservatives are happy with the government having overreaching powers when it suits their agenda. What you call 'interference' we call meeting its obligation to provide for the general welfare of the country. But conservatives are fine with trashing the Constitution when it clashes with their selfish desires.

The truth is, conservatives have consistently ignored the consequences of preventing the government from doing it's job properly, with predictable results. Then when called on it they either put the blame on Democrats or deny that there's even a problem...

But you have Trump now, so you'll be getting exactly you want. Kill the EPA so industries can trash the environment with impunity, let the rich get away with paying even less tax, remove financial regulations so we can have another crash, give racists and bigots a free reign, put your friends and relatives in positions of power for 'favors', and make Mexico pay for taking our jobs!

There will be consequences or sure, but if any conservatives did consider them they certainly don't care. Not that they should be blamed for it. You see, the Conservative brain is different from a normal brain - it lacks empathy and therefore is incapable of considering the effect its selfishness has on others.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom