Why Liberal Suck at Understanding Conservatives and Why it Matters

That's because there are so few actual conservatives. Looking for the reactionary perspective isn't just easy, it's unnecessary.

This is my perspective as well. In the USA, textbook Conservatives are mostly Democrats. This is why they are consistently obtaining the popular vote: they have both progressive and conservative support, which is a majority of Americans, and the recent election demonstrated this.

The Republican Party has been shifting toward Reactionary for two generations; Conservatives have become a minority there, and as of this election, I think they have lost power possibly permanently. Conservatives who remained aligned with the GOP were very competent at winning congressional seats, despite low overall popularity for their policies. Unfortunately, they had no governing competence, which led to a need for urgent change.

But democratic change was blocked in 2010. Gerrymandering meant the public could not elect Democrats in enough districts to send Congress the signal that their "do nothing" approach was unpopular, which created two problems: one, the only remaining path to change was through the presidency, so this was why we got Obama. But the Executive doesn't have enough power, especially if Congress' single purpose becomes to cripple the people's government at all costs. And secondly, the GOP Conservatives were so busy "doing nothing" theatrically that they didn't worry about the Reactionaries' long term plan to conquer the GOP, and have been outmaneuvered.

The GOP is now the party of white supremacy, Evangelical theocracy, misogyny, and capital. The plan appears to revert to 19th century social conditions. Conservatives are not really welcome there, as this is a radical, urgent, reckless experiment, rejected by the majority of voters, and Conservatives caution against this sort of thing.
 
Me too: rural, traditional, conservative, religious, meat and potatoes, dad with his pipe upbringing. I think most liberals understand conservatives quite well because we grew up with them and still spend our holidays with them.

What we don't understand about conservatives is how they never picked up on the same things we did despite being exposed to the same information (that last bit an potentially unsupported assertion, of course). For example, if you travel to some state where people don't recycle plastics, cans, etc. it can be pretty jarring. "What's with these backwards people here - they don't even recycle!" The other issue concerns hypocrisy. I got in an argument with my mom about Trump and his racial rhetoric. I ended up explaining to her that she was the one who instilled me with this sense of equality and justice when I was a little boy - was that all a lie? She was the one who made me go to church constantly and was, presumably, listening to the same sermons about love, peace, tolerance, and forgiveness that I was. Why did that message resonate with me but not with her? I think that's the kind of stuff liberals are struggling to understand about conservatives.

Yep. We all sang "Whatsoever you do to the least of my brothers, that you do unto me" in church. And when we went home, they had no problem being racist and did nothing to help the poor (all their charity was to the church, who, at best, used it for "the missions"). Was I the only one listening to the words we were singing?

I have stated elsewhere, I am not surprised that those areas are high in concentration of right-wing bigots. It's because if you thought any differently, you got the hell out. I did. I have no interest in being there any more. Why would I want to be around those ********?

There aren't a lot of gay people in those areas, either. Because they all leave and go to New York or California, where they can live in peace. But New York and California votes don't count as much in the election, because, you know, that's where all the people are.

Here's the question: how many people living in New York or California grew up in red states, vs how many in red states grew up in California or New York? How many Iowans are in NY? How many New Yorkers move to Iowa? And how many do it to get away from where they grew up?

Don't tell me I don't understand conservatives. I grew up with them, and understand them all too well. That's why I got the fudge out.
 
This is my perspective as well. In the USA, textbook Conservatives are mostly Democrats. This is why they are consistently obtaining the popular vote: they have both progressive and conservative support, which is a majority of Americans, and the recent election demonstrated this.

The Republican Party has been shifting toward Reactionary for two generations; Conservatives have become a minority there, and as of this election, I think they have lost power possibly permanently. Conservatives who remained aligned with the GOP were very competent at winning congressional seats, despite low overall popularity for their policies. Unfortunately, they had no governing competence, which led to a need for urgent change.

But democratic change was blocked in 2010. Gerrymandering meant the public could not elect Democrats in enough districts to send Congress the signal that their "do nothing" approach was unpopular, which created two problems: one, the only remaining path to change was through the presidency, so this was why we got Obama. But the Executive doesn't have enough power, especially if Congress' single purpose becomes to cripple the people's government at all costs. And secondly, the GOP Conservatives were so busy "doing nothing" theatrically that they didn't worry about the Reactionaries' long term plan to conquer the GOP, and have been outmaneuvered.

The GOP is now the party of white supremacy, Evangelical theocracy, misogyny, and capital. The plan appears to revert to 19th century social conditions. Conservatives are not really welcome there, as this is a radical, urgent, reckless experiment, rejected by the majority of voters, and Conservatives caution against this sort of thing.

That is absolute fantasy. Or perhaps it's how things are in Canada. Both are outside my experience.
 
That is absolute fantasy. Or perhaps it's how things are in Canada. Both are outside my experience.

Perhaps we can work our way backward from facts we can agree on first?

In the first paragraph, I point out that the majority of voters rejected Trump. Agreed?
 
Perhaps we can work our way backward from facts we can agree on first?

In the first paragraph, I point out that the majority of voters rejected Trump. Agreed?

Rejected? No. Voted for somebody else? Yes. Meaningful in the slightest? No. Voters have different levels of motivation. Many potential Trump voters didn't vote (e.g. those in California who had almost zero reason to do so, outside of a dozen or so Congressional districts).
 
Rejected? No. Voted for somebody else? Yes. Meaningful in the slightest? No. Voters have different levels of motivation. Many potential Trump voters didn't vote (e.g. those in California who had almost zero reason to do so, outside of a dozen or so Congressional districts).

OK: I can rephrase that: Trump's candidacy received fewer votes than his rival Clinton, but he obtained the presidency despite less voter support. According to how democracy works: His policies were less popular than Clinton's among voters. Agreed?
 
Perhaps we can work our way backward from facts we can agree on first?

In the first paragraph, I point out that the majority of voters rejected Trump. Agreed?

That is correct. It is also true that Democrat presidents Kennedy, Truman, Polk, Wilson twice, Clinton twice, Cleveland twice, and Buchanan were all rejected by the majority of voters.

Also, Republican presidents Garfield, Hayes, GWBush, Harrison, Nixon and Lincoln were all rejected by the majority of voters.
 
That is correct. It is also true that Democrat presidents Kennedy, Truman, Polk, Wilson twice, Clinton twice, Cleveland twice, and Buchanan were all rejected by the majority of voters.

Also, Republican presidents Garfield, Hayes, GWBush, Harrison, Nixon and Lincoln were all rejected by the majority of voters.

Understood. Meaning, none of those obtained the majority of votes, despite being the candidate with more votes than all others. I get it.

I'm not intentionally performing wordplay. My main point was that Democratic party positions are generally more popular, and the election demonstrated this.

I don't think this is 'fantasy' as sunmaster14 alleges.
 
OK: I can rephrase that: Trump's candidacy received fewer votes than his rival Clinton, but he obtained the presidency despite less voter support. According to how democracy works: His policies were less popular than Clinton's among voters. Agreed?

I don't see how this is relevant, but in any case, I don't agree. It's somewhat of a pedantic point, but US democracy doesn't work that way. It is not the case that all votes are equal. Nor is there any reason why all votes should be weighted equally. Personally, I think my vote should count for more than the average voters' since I think I'm far more knowledgeable than the average, and I think I care more about the future of the country (and less for my selfish interests) than the average. As it turns out, my vote probably counts for a little less than the average.
 
Understood. Meaning, none of those obtained the majority of votes, despite being the candidate with more votes than all others. I get it.

I'm not intentionally performing wordplay. My main point was that Democratic party positions are generally more popular, and the election demonstrated this.

I don't think this is 'fantasy' as sunmaster14 alleges.

There are lots of other factors. For example, Democrats have most of the media on their side, including Hollywood writers, directors and actors. Their message is amplified because of the power of their chosen professions, and they use some of their power to maintain their control of such professions.

The Democrats have been complaining about Russia digging up dirt on Hillary's campaign, but are they willing to acknowledge that the New York Times and the Washington Post preferentially dig up dirt on Republicans and hide dirt on Democrats? Why is Russia's impact considered illegitimate, but the impact of partisan media isn't?

Another factor, of course, is that Democratic policies appeal to popular misconceptions about how economics works. Weirdly, Trump actually tried to copy that playbook in this election, e.g. on free trade and attacking Wall Street, but some habits die hard. By the way, there have been studies that show the more people understand economics, the more conservative they get on economic issues.
 
I don't see how this is relevant, but in any case, I don't agree. It's somewhat of a pedantic point, but US democracy doesn't work that way. It is not the case that all votes are equal. Nor is there any reason why all votes should be weighted equally. Personally, I think my vote should count for more than the average voters' since I think I'm far more knowledgeable than the average, and I think I care more about the future of the country (and less for my selfish interests) than the average. As it turns out, my vote probably counts for a little less than the average.

How US Democracy works does not change the fact that Clinton was more popular, nation-wide than Trump.
 
How US Democracy works does not change the fact that Clinton was more popular, nation-wide than Trump.

It depends on what you mean by popular. Do you mean better liked? Or higher network ratings? Or more likely to attract large adoring crowds? I think the answer is "no" to all three.
 
It depends on what you mean by popular. Do you mean better liked? Or higher network ratings? Or more likely to attract large adoring crowds? I think the answer is "no" to all three.
Really you don't know?
Most votes from people in the general election.
 
I don't see how this is relevant, but in any case, I don't agree. It's somewhat of a pedantic point, but US democracy doesn't work that way. It is not the case that all votes are equal. Nor is there any reason why all votes should be weighted equally.

I think we observe that not all votes are equal... I'm saying that's a bug, not a feature.

Seeing a less popular candidate's platform victorious should genuinely worry people who admire democracy. (democracy being known as "rule by majority" rather than "rule by rube goldberg machine")

Here's a question, then.. what are the limits of "Nor is there any reason why all votes should be weighted equally"? In this situation a 6% greater popularity for Clinton's proposals didn't translate into the government actually providing them to the taxpayers who chose them. What percentage gap would worry you? When does it become taxation without representation?
 
Really you don't know?
Most votes from people in the general election.

I did know what you meant. My point is that you're using an uncommon definition of the word popular. By conflating that with its more common definition (well-liked, admired, or enjoyed by many people), you end up giving Hillary way too much credit. I think she's relatively unpopular. It will be interesting to see how much she gets paid for speeches these days from the likes of Goldman Sachs. My guess is about 1/3rd of what she was commanding in the years leading up to the election.
 
Another factor, of course, is that Democratic policies appeal to popular misconceptions about how economics works. Weirdly, Trump actually tried to copy that playbook in this election, e.g. on free trade and attacking Wall Street, but some habits die hard. By the way, there have been studies that show the more people understand economics, the more conservative they get on economic issues.

I believe the relationship, but I'm not sure that paper demonstrated causality. That is: they didn't control for the fact that more economically conservative people are predisposed to taking business classes in the first place, and pursue professions accordingly. Selection bias, basically.

ie: the thesis is essentially, "Of people who decided to go into business, they're disproportionately Republican leaning." Well, no **** Sherlock.

(Disclosure: I have an MBA and was the only leftie in my year)
 
I think we observe that not all votes are equal... I'm saying that's a bug, not a feature.

Seeing a less popular candidate's platform victorious should genuinely worry people who admire democracy. (democracy being known as "rule by majority" rather than "rule by rube goldberg machine")

Here's a question, then.. what are the limits of "Nor is there any reason why all votes should be weighted equally"? In this situation a 6% greater popularity for Clinton's proposals didn't translate into the government actually providing them to the taxpayers who chose them. What percentage gap would worry you? When does it become taxation without representation?

There is no margin which would bother me personally. The year when 5 voters in Wyoming are expected to command 3 electoral votes all by themselves is also the year when I move to Wyoming, and the number becomes 6 (or 7 if my wife comes along).

The point it becomes taxation without representation is precisely that point at which there is enough support to change the electoral college by Constitutional Amendment, but the government, or the military, prevents it from happening by exercising unconstitutional power.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom