Why Liberal Suck at Understanding Conservatives and Why it Matters

Why should I? There are legitimate benefits to receiving a treatment 18 months sooner. I don't agree with your discounting of it.

But just to clarify, the NHS refuses to supply specific drugs where they are deemed not to be cost effective. I'm not familiar enough with the U.S., does Medicare cover all drugs no matter how expensive or (in)effective ?

So that's on one side of the ledger. On the other medicare fails to cover whole areas of medicine and age groups and yet the exclusions are supposed to be somehow equivalent ?
 
But just to clarify, the NHS refuses to supply specific drugs where they are deemed not to be cost effective. I'm not familiar enough with the U.S., does Medicare cover all drugs no matter how expensive or (in)effective ?

So that's on one side of the ledger. On the other medicare fails to cover whole areas of medicine and age groups and yet the exclusions are supposed to be somehow equivalent ?

I never said they were equivalent. Don't construe anything I have said as a defense of Medicare. As I wish to abolish it, I'm not one to support even it's premise.

If anything, I would be on the pro Medicare side if debating it against the NHS because it does so much less.
 
Last edited:
I never said they were equivalent. Don't construe anything I have said as a defense of Medicare. As I wish to abolish it, I'm not one to support even it's premise.

If anything, I would be on the pro Medicare side if debating it against the NHS because it does so much less.

I guess this is the thing that puzzles me so much.

The UK's system is far from perfect but it achieves much better health outcomes than the US system for about half the cost (expressed in % of GDP terms) or 40% of the cost (expressed in $ per person). It's not clear to me how abolishing Medicare would improve the situation in the U.S.

Of course if the metric for success of the medical system isn't the health of the population at large and is instead the health of a handful or rich individuals then again, I still don't understand because healthcare costs procedure-for-procedure are so much higher in the US that it's even more expensive for the very rich.
 
Why should I? There are legitimate benefits to receiving a treatment 18 months sooner. I don't agree with your discounting of it.

No my point is that the same would happen if a new researched drug was in the UK under emergency treatment, the product would not be available outside. SAme if a new treatment was made in france.

My point is that you cannot expect soemthing not widely available commercially and not tested by the local FDA equivalent to be available.
 
No my point is that the same would happen if a new researched drug was in the UK under emergency treatment, the product would not be available outside. SAme if a new treatment was made in france.

My point is that you cannot expect soemthing not widely available commercially and not tested by the local FDA equivalent to be available.

So this gets more mushy on how much we call NICE as part of the NHS (I would say it is) and how much it equates to the FDA. While the FDA approves what can be be sold, nice is explicitly restricting the NHS

I think the cost analysis aspect puts it in a different category, and I can find many new drugs that enter Medicare a year to three years ahead of the UK.
 
So this gets more mushy on how much we call NICE as part of the NHS (I would say it is) and how much it equates to the FDA. While the FDA approves what can be be sold, nice is explicitly restricting the NHS

I think the cost analysis aspect puts it in a different category, and I can find many new drugs that enter Medicare a year to three years ahead of the UK.

Approve/restrict : same difference. The point is that you were speaking of a drug which explicitely was allwoed under the emergency therapeuthic.

Also note that whatever you want to use approve/or restrict , usually there is a burden to show that the drug efficacy+cost is better than existing treatement and has no worst side effect. The one you cited seem to attack the liver and does not seem much:

"The combination treatment improves lung function about 3% in such people and reduced hospitalization events by about 34%"

And look at the side effect.

Again, the FDA seamingly approve drugs as long as they show "some" efficacity comapred to side effect, whereas other country impose that a new drug msut be better , or the trade off on side effect warrant the cost.

It is quite clear that a 3% better lung function, does not seem to warrant the cost.
You can maybe argue that 34% less hospitalization event do, but look at the side effect.

So saying "drug X,Y,Z is not available boo-hoo bad NHS/Securité Socia/whatnot" without a context on the efficacity of the drug vs cost itself, and even without citing efficacity of alternative, is meaningless.
 
So this gets more mushy on how much we call NICE as part of the NHS (I would say it is) and how much it equates to the FDA. While the FDA approves what can be be sold, nice is explicitly restricting the NHS

I think the cost analysis aspect puts it in a different category, and I can find many new drugs that enter Medicare a year to three years ahead of the UK.

It's a mix. I monitor drug approvals for psychiatry, and many are approved in the US later than overseas. Some are never approved by the FDA despite being widely available in other countries. Classic case is Thalidomide. Canada approved it as a treatment for morning sickness; the USA didn't.

So, Canada probably works like the UK and the USA in this two step process.

1. federal regulator approves drug/procedure for legal use based on benefit/harm profile (FDA, Health Canada)

2. medicine delivery organization analyzes benefit/cost versus alternatives (HMOs/Insurers, Provincial Health Ministries)
 
What if it isn't either?

Good point. One of the metrics the Fraser Institute uses to create comparative scores for medical systems is "free marketyness". In fact, in one of their recent analysis, it was weighted 30%. More important than access.

Meaning: if a nation's health system allowed everybody to poison themselves, it might rank as superior to one that doesn't (according to the Fraser Institute's metrics), because their choice to do something that stupid was not restricted.
 
I think you are focusing too much on the language. Yes, loose language is an issue, but the empirical findings do NOT rely on that specific language. You can replace "morals" with "values" and perhaps folks like you will see how it works, better.
Changing one high level abstract for another doesn't help much.

The book goes into more detail: For liberals Fairness often implies equality, at least of opportunity. For conservatives, it is more about proportionality: Being rewarded in proportion to what you contribute, even if the outcomes are going to be unequal.
This is based on cognitive science, yes (see below), but there is some mapping of some high-level concepts to others that may or may not relate to innate traits as opposed to learned behavior.

Haidt spells out the nature of this value in his book. My own wording might be vague, but do not mistake that for lack of precision on Haidt's part. These have all be empirically isolated from each other, in scientific studies.... And, if you have something better, I would like to know what that is.
Cognitive science and neurology.

Fascinating. Haidt's book actually touches on those, as something his own Foundations Theory rests on. Right before he goes into the specific values (such as Fairness), he talks about what "innate" means in the areas you mention.
OK. Innates consist of highly granular rules. One example is the testing of at what age a young child can string two clues together to remember a location, such as "along longest wall" and "next to something blue." These skills are shared with rats, for example. With humans, later things like the use of a language crutch "to the left of" starts coming into play, and babies outperform rats. This is what most cognitive research looks like, not quite at the level of the higher order conceptual models of Haidt.

Note that, as of today, there is little connect between the functional descriptions of cognitive science and the physical examination of the brain. Early days to make too many claims. Even when studying young children, which affords a better window into the innate vs the learned, it is frightfully difficult to assign a behavior solely to one or the other once past just a few years of age. To get around this, there is the study of universals, but this is harder the more one gets away from structured rule sets like language.

He does not go into those in any great detail. Books from Stephen Pinker tend to do that well enough. And, both folks seem to think their ideas are compatible with each other.
I love Pinker. He is also, like me and other older linguists, getting past his due date. The best research is elsewhere now. Not an insult, just the way it goes.

I would like to state that: Although this thread has focused on one particular theory, it is certainly NOT the SOLE factor for understanding conservatives. Though, I do think it is the MOST IMPORTANT one.
I find Haidt's work fascinating and believe it dovetails very well with Frans de Waal 's work with primates. So I will admit to you there is something going on with social animals, and there are indeed innate heuristics. Still, there is room for more granularity in Haidt's work and further disaggregation of potential causes. Even the capuchin monkeys must be relying on something called a theory of mind, in itself composed of more granular notions.

What this is, is a fairly successful approach to help folks on all sides of the political spectrum to understand each other better. I argue it is one of the better sciences we have on this subject (though not the only one, as my next post will emphasize).

The problem, and this thread has already run afoul of it, is that a list of purported values only leads to a war of claims as to which is better. More of interest in my mind is for those who feel themselves to be conservatives or liberals to express what values they feel are important and how they wish to see them in action. The reason for this is the same: values as abstracts are worthless, values as concrete social and political policies are valuable in that the logic can be openly examined without further tools, as appropriate on this forum.

So, how about you? Please tell me what specific policies you feel best flow from the set of Haidt's morals that apply to you. Say, loyalty.
 
The problem, and this thread has already run afoul of it, is that a list of purported values only leads to a war of claims as to which is better.

My impression from Wowbagger's OP was that his intention was not to engage in a normative argument about which value cluster was 'right' - but rather, an attempt to explain why the population is clustered. I think the hope is that understanding the underlying nature of the clustering could lead to a strategy to curtail the polarization.

For me, it's important input for my model of a Skeptical Outreach program.


More of interest in my mind is for those who feel themselves to be conservatives or liberals to express what values they feel are important and how they wish to see them in action. The reason for this is the same: values as abstracts are worthless, values as concrete social and political policies are valuable in that the logic can be openly examined without further tools, as appropriate on this forum.

I think that may be missing the point... The problem may be that we're assuming people are translating their values into policy comparisons. I think the research is showing us that voting may not be very policy-oriented. That we are choosing candidates based on how they make us 'feel' they will fulfill our value goals.

Case in point... we constantly see surveys that show how point by point, Americans want every feature of a universal healthcare program. It's Americans' preferred policy. But they constantly vote against these initiatives. It's not Americans' preferred values.
 

I don't think that's new, but it's a different dimension.

eg: here's a similar one from 2010: [Political Orientations Are Correlated with Brain Structure in Young Adults]

We have good research that shows conservatives are more... Limbic system-y? Amygdala-y? That sounds like an insult, so let me explain.

One of Haidt's proposed moral modules is purity. Liberals do not emphasize it anywhere near as much as conservatives. This is one moral module where I'm similar to liberals - I'm not really disgusted by much. In fact... I don't think I've been disgusted by anything in my life. And I worked in a hospital wiping brains off the wall.

In the meantime, I have conservative colleagues who constantly use that type of vocabulary. Gay sex makes them 'want to puke'. Obese women are 'disgusting pigs'. The homeless are 'filthy.' This feels like they have a much more active Limbic or amygdala than I do. It doesn't make a person conservative in and of itself, but I'll bet it dials up the sensitivity on the Purity module.
 
I would like to step back a little and ask: How exactly does a better understanding of the conservative actually change anything?

For instance. There is a social hierarchy view of the world that is never explicitly stated in conservative argument. It is buried within an argument, taken as granted without verbalizing by the conservative, or maybe even unknown verbally but held instinctually or habitually by the individual conservative. The hierarchy takes many forms. God over man; man over woman; whites over people of color; heterosexuals over homosexuals; entrepreneurs over laborers; wealthy over poor; Americans over people of or from other countries, etc.

We can see this hierarchical construct as it relates to the social and political backlash (or “whitelash”) against President Obama and the apparent hatred of Hillary Clinton by the right. The reaction to Obama’s election and inauguration was immediately negative, openly hostile and largely irrationally held by many Republicans and conservatives. The Republicans in congress openly obstructed the President’s agenda, even if parts of it were similar or identical to Republican policy ideas. A conservative grassroots bought into any far fetched Alt-right/alt-reality nonsense that came down the pike, from the birther issue to the idea that Pres. Obama was readying federal troops to invade Red Texas. As for Ms. Clinton, the hatred for her by some conservative Trump supporters was so strong they wanted her literally imprisoned. We have to ask: why this state of affairs?

Republicans in congress obstructed Pres. Obama to the extent of one house denying him the advising of and consenting to his nominee to the Supreme Court, as is constitutionally required. This action was unprecedented as well as unconscionable (and hypocritical: one can imagine what Mitch or Rush will say if the Senate dems play hardball with Trump in likewise fashion.) Some Republicans, before the election, promised to keep the ban on reviewing any Supreme Court nominee if Hillary Clinton were president. What can we make of this?

If we want to go to the root, we merely apply the conservative’s embedded hierarchical view of society to understand why Republicans acted the way they did, regardless of their surface justifications. Simply put, the party, largely controlled by white men, was not going to allow a black or a woman a position of superiority concerning a far retching issue such as a Supreme Court nominee. To do so would have upended the “natural order” of things, in the conservative’s view of the world. (BTW, while it is true that not all conservatives are Republicans, in today’s GOP most, if not all, Republicans are conservative.)

Now, for the sake of argument, let’s grant the above as a true reflection of reality. My question: how does knowledge like this enable liberals to make a better case for their ideas when addressing conservatives?
 
Last edited:
why do liberals have to understand conservatives and not vice versa?

Two reasons. Or three rather. First, because conservatives are completely in charge for the next 2 years and probably 4. Second, because (IMHO) liberals have some catching up to do in the "understanding their opponent" sweepstakes. Third, because the mainstream media, the college campuses, and Hollywood are dominated by liberals, so the liberal perspective on things is easy to access. It is the conservative perspective which requires a bit of effort to find.
 
Two reasons. Or three rather. First, because conservatives are completely in charge for the next 2 years and probably 4. Second, because (IMHO) liberals have some catching up to do in the "understanding their opponent" sweepstakes. Third, because the mainstream media, the college campuses, and Hollywood are dominated by liberals, so the liberal perspective on things is easy to access. It is the conservative perspective which requires a bit of effort to find.

Finding a clan meeting does take some effort.
 
If conservatives are in charge, it doesn't matter if liberals understand them. In fact, it might be easier to oppose them if they aren't awarded too much empathy.
In a democracy, it is in fact the job of the ruling majority to take the views and needs of the minority into account.
. Not that conservatives understand that, which is kinda my point.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom