Why Liberal Suck at Understanding Conservatives and Why it Matters

Me too: rural, traditional, conservative, religious, meat and potatoes, dad with his pipe upbringing. I think most liberals understand conservatives quite well because we grew up with them and still spend our holidays with them.

What we don't understand about conservatives is how they never picked up on the same things we did despite being exposed to the same information (that last bit an potentially unsupported assertion, of course). For example, if you travel to some state where people don't recycle plastics, cans, etc. it can be pretty jarring. "What's with these backwards people here - they don't even recycle!" The other issue concerns hypocrisy. I got in an argument with my mom about Trump and his racial rhetoric. I ended up explaining to her that she was the one who instilled me with this sense of equality and justice when I was a little boy - was that all a lie? She was the one who made me go to church constantly and was, presumably, listening to the same sermons about love, peace, tolerance, and forgiveness that I was. Why did that message resonate with me but not with her? I think that's the kind of stuff liberals are struggling to understand about conservatives.
 
I don't think the differences are what is causing people to feel alien to the other side. It is the result of a political system that turns politics into a spectator sport with only two competing teams, where one can only be for or against any side. Where "winning" is more important than making well balanced decisions on all of the most difficult questions a society has to find an answer for. What makes people the other side feels alien is because they have been taught to think of politics as taking "sides" and to think of the "other side" as "alien".

Amen.
 
Since I’m from Red Texas, I may be biased, but Giz’s statement doesn’t ring true to me; it’s bass ackward.
Perhaps it might be more accurate to say conservatives tend to think liberal are "immoral", and liberals tend to think conservatives are "stupid". But, either way, I see it as only a first-approximation of the differences. Moral Foundations Theory goes deeper as to why, so we can see that neither label is true, and also how either label COULD SEEM to be true before looking deeper.

While I can agree that it is certainly beneficial to try to understand one another better, it nevertheless cannot close the gap between how conservatives view the world and how liberals do.
We have to start somewhere. Other than George Lakoff, do you have any other suggestions for closing the gap?

I do like George Lakoff’s efforts to understand the conservative mind. His portrayals of left v. right as originating in the con’s Strict Father Model against the lib’s Nurturing Family Model has the benefit of corresponding to the world that I know. Lakoff’s views are meant to frame issues favorably for broad consumption and not just targeting right-wingers.
Lakoff might be hitting on another way to frame some of the same types of ideas. Though, I will have to read his material more, to know for certain.
Somehow, I doubt his work will be as fundamental, even if that was the case. Thus, it would not "close the gap" on its own, either.
But, we shall see.

I still cry every time I think about it.
Xenophobia, like paranoia, strikes deep.

The very idea of defending minorities, that one does not even belong to, from injustice: That is such a relatively new idea, only liberal mutants would whole-heartedly go for such a thing!

Formulated like this it seems pretty meaningless. How could there not be?
Of course YOU might ask that, because YOU are already smart enough to know there could be. But, to many people: This is a very non-intuitive notion.
When conservatives claim liberals are "immoral", they are assuming everyone would really have the same morality.
When liberals claim conservatives are "stupid", they are not acknowledging there is even a moral issue at stake.

More important issues are whether the things Haidt claims are "moral foundations" actually are, whether the list is sufficiently complete, and whether they are distinguishable from eachother in a meaningful way.
I agree these are important, and research is ongoing, I am sure.

Though, for practical use, it seems fairly solid, so far.

See post #455, http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=11630088&postcount=455 , where I say "a very good exercise!", in bold, to see how it can work in practice.

That Americans can apparently only discern 2 or 3 large groups is problem that should not be ignored. It seems ridiculous to me that all of human thought on morality can be meaningfully be summarised in 2 or 3 categories.
For casual use, it has sufficient meaning to work fairly well.

Understanding BOTH ENDS of a broad spectrum can still allow us to understand those between the extreme ends. Understand the differences along one dimension helps us acknowledge and understand other dimensions that can exist, when we see them.

Which is probably a large majority.
The "large majority" is not ignored. A comprehensive understanding, of extreme ends, can still capture the views of those in between.

(One could argue that there was a Great Sort in the U.S., where politics have become more divisive, thus the majority you spoke of does not really exist, anymore, anyway. But, I am giving you the benefit of doubt, that it does.)

I don't think the differences are what is causing people to feel alien to the other side. It is the result of a political system that turns politics into a spectator sport with only two competing teams, where one can only be for or against any side. Where "winning" is more important than making well balanced decisions on all of the most difficult questions a society has to find an answer for. What makes people the other side feels alien is because they have been taught to think of politics as taking "sides" and to think of the "other side" as "alien".
There is NO DOUBT your spectator sport argument is true! That is a very general pattern in HOW people are driving themselves apart.

But, UNDERSTANDING the other side requires us to put ourselves in the other side's shoes. WHAT is different between them, at a fundamental level, that they CAN BE divisive and alienated about?

Your argument is true, but it is very generic. It does not get into what people think, when they join up on each side of the spectator stands.

Do I see any harm in trying to understand other people's motivations by looking through a terribly distorted lens? Yes, I actually do.
If it works, it was not very distorted. If it is not going to work, we won't find out until we try. If anyone has a better idea, I am willing to listen, though.

(And, of course, Diplomacy Matters! It's not like we are going to use this foundation to "beat people over the head" or anything.)

I'll take that as a "no".
If it was "no", why would there be a references section?

Sure. Two is just too small a number. Most countries have at least 10 discernably large political parties, and even those have plenty of infighting over their "moral foundations".
Other countries are better at keeping their politics from drifting into two sides, as what happens in the U.S. But, when quizzed on their morals, studies show everyone still drifts into the same groups. That is what Haidt's international results seem to show.

I like to point out that not only is the political spectrum much broader, it is far more multi-dimensional than the term "spectrum" would suggest.
I can agree with that. In fact, since there are 6 foundations, there could be a potential of 6 different axes of dimensions. Though, only 3 were uncovered in Haidt's work, as having any significant population.

A lot of those people who "swing side to side" do so not because their views change drastically, but rather that the "sides" don't really represent them.
Fine. Let me rephrase, then: But, understanding conservatives is still part of a comprehensive understanding of everyone, including those who are not necessarily represented by any one side.

What we don't understand about conservatives is how they never picked up on the same things we did despite being exposed to the same information (that last bit an potentially unsupported assertion, of course). For example, if you travel to some state where people don't recycle plastics, cans, etc. it can be pretty jarring. "What's with these backwards people here - they don't even recycle!"
Might have something to do with the Care/Harm foundation.

The other issue concerns hypocrisy. I got in an argument with my mom about Trump and his racial rhetoric. I ended up explaining to her that she was the one who instilled me with this sense of equality and justice when I was a little boy - was that all a lie? She was the one who made me go to church constantly and was, presumably, listening to the same sermons about love, peace, tolerance, and forgiveness that I was. Why did that message resonate with me but not with her? I think that's the kind of stuff liberals are struggling to understand about conservatives.
I am going to guess that your mom does not recognize Trump's statements as racist. She is NOT in favor of racism, I am guessing. But, she simply does not see it in others when she admires their charismatic rhetoric in some way. If I am right, hypocrisy is not exactly the problem: It could be cognitive dissonance. If I am wrong: I apologize, and perhaps we can learn more from your corrections on my assumptions.

I will say that Trump is very skilled at veiling his racially insensitive remarks. Those who DESIRED a racist President feel like they got exactly what they want. While at the same time, those who DENY they are racist, themselves, had enough plausible deniability, to vote for Trump AS IF he wasn't some kind of racist.
 
Perhaps it might be more accurate to say conservatives tend to think liberal are "immoral", and liberals tend to think conservatives are "stupid". But, either way, I see it as only a first-approximation of the differences. Moral Foundations Theory goes deeper....

Actually, quite many ideas that purport to be based on evolutionary psychology seem more like convenient ideological retrofits than good science. Loose language is clearly a problem: looking at the wiki for Moral Foundations Theory, one immediately encounters the term "moral" (no surprise) to describe and classify behaviors. This clearly works as a backdoor value judgment by elevating those behavioral traits relating to irrational behavior to the status of morals. Quite silly. Bad science; no proper is/ought firewalls.

Or, simply take the core value shared by all variations, as per the theory: fairness. What is that really related to? How can fairness be a concept if fundamental sameness and standing are not brought into play? Clearly, "fairness" itself is open to interpretation, requiring more precise definitions. Be that as it may, how are "values" translated into prescriptions for behavior? Culturally and individually, or is there some purported "direct relation" one can trace - allow me to barf - to specific GOP policies?

Nah, this ain't science, and it ain't even good ethics. You'd do better taking something like the idea of purity, clearly of value if related to survival, such as avoiding disease-causing practices (don't **** where you eat), and then examining how self-interest comes into play in order to rationalize dehumanizing opponents, the most common use of this "value" among goose steppers. And so full circle: it is 'moral' to violate the most basic shared moral, 'fairness.' I realize why conservatives are entirely silent on my earlier post regarding values in action: the profoundly self-contradictory nonsense conservatives push as "values" is indefensible, and only sounds good when pontificating.

If you, uh, want science, start with the three sources of behavioral heuristics: genetic; learned yet subconscious; and conscious, rational thought. All three come into play. My guess is that a good portion of what these boys think is genetic is far more raw and basic than the high level definitions given, and what they are really dealing with is learned behavior and the effect of rationalizations (loose social 'theories,' i.e., bias).
 
The cystic fibrosis drug Orkambi.

Yes, individual drugs and treatments are excluded by NICE if they are not deemed cost effective. I thought you were saying that there were areas of treatment that were covered by Medicare that aren't covered by the NHS. :o

NHS coverage is still far broader both in terms of the range of things covered (vision, hearing, dentistry) and of course it covers the whole population
 
I am going to guess that your mom does not recognize Trump's statements as racist. She is NOT in favor of racism, I am guessing.
My parents (dad now gone) were not racist for 1950 but they are for the 21st Century. They always thought black people should vote, have equality under the law, etc., but they were a lot more inclined to complain about so-called reverse discrimination than they were discrimination. Other than that kind of subtle white-privilegey racism, however, they certainly did not try to perpetuate those stereotypes among their kids. For example, they never used the n-word or other racial epithets in my experience, and they exposed us to endless messages of peace, love, and equality at Church.
 
Yes, individual drugs and treatments are excluded by NICE if they are not deemed cost effective. I thought you were saying that there were areas of treatment that were covered by Medicare that aren't covered by the NHS. :o

NHS coverage is still far broader both in terms of the range of things covered (vision, hearing, dentistry) and of course it covers the whole population

With no financial cap. (Acknowledging QALY calculations)
 
Universal healthcare in the US would necessitate increased government expenditures relative to what is spent today. That would require either a reduction in other government spending or increased taxes, or some combination thereof. I suppose it's technically possible that the US government could cut spending from some program that doesn't somehow directly affect any actual people... but I'm not going to hang my hat on that assumption.

My best guess is that Universal Healthcare would be accomplished through raising taxes. And for at least some people, that increase in taxes will result in lower take-home pay, with enough marginal impact to affect other necessities. In this case, the example being a reduction in food spend for that family.

U.S. Health Care From a Global Perspective


You are missing a big part of the equation - a couple of things, actually. One is that without single-payer UHC, many people spend buckets of money on health insurance. With single-payer UHC, that goes away.

With single-payer UHC, certain industries go away - for better or worse. You don't need as many people whose job is to categorize which costs are and aren't covered by insurance. You don't need actuaries to calculate rates. In fact you would need only a tiny health-insurance industry. (I am in favor of allowing people to purchase supplementary insurance).

According to the link I posted, the U.S. leads in price of heart bypass surgery with an average of $72,345. The second-highest rate is Australia's $42,130.

Under public spending alone, the U.S. pays more for worse outcomes. When you include the aggregate, it's even worse.

Though that link is somewhat out-of-date (2013) it dices and slices data in a concise apples-to-apples way (I think; I'm not a statistician, but you have some background?). Some of what drives higher costs in the U.S. is a much greater use of magnetic resonance imaging and other sophisticated imaging. Why? Probably a couple of reasons. One is that many insurance plans (Medicare definitely) reimburse according to the procedures performed. It's in a hospital's best interest to keep that MRI machine going 24-7. (There is probably debt service on the machines as well). I think another reason may be that doctors are afraid to miss something because of malpractice suits (I'm not sure if the health care costs include physicians' malpractice premiums). Americans also have the highest prescription costs, and by far the highest in-hospital prescription costs. Plus they have more prescriptions to begin with.

If Donald Trump really wanted something better than Obamacare and is the master negotiator he claims to be, he'd probably end up favoring single-payer UHC. You are right that there might be an initial tax increase, but spending on insurance would plummet. I paid $7,200 last year and my total consumption was one doctor visit, one blood test and about $50 per month savings on prescriptions. (I probably should have had a bunch more tests, but kinda late in the year now). Next year that goes up to $8,400. The fine for not having insurance is much cheaper, but I don't dare take that risk. I'm 57 and one of these days (or years, I hope), I'll have a health crisis. The offsets: I did receive a tax credit for part of my insurance premium, but I'm not sure how much.

Oh: And the "public spending" in the 2013 report did not count the tax credits given to companies with health-insurance plans.

So, I have gone off topic but I have learned something and I have hit on only a few of the issues explored in that link.
 
Last edited:
Yes, individual drugs and treatments are excluded by NICE if they are not deemed cost effective. I thought you were saying that there were areas of treatment that were covered by Medicare that aren't covered by the NHS. :o

NHS coverage is still far broader both in terms of the range of things covered (vision, hearing, dentistry) and of course it covers the whole population

They even pay for up to 3 in-vitro fertilization cycles.
 
I grew up in a small southern town in the 50s. There was a black community that lived exclusively in a row of shacks along the railroad tracks. (There was one small farm outside of town that was owned by a black family, but it was unusual enough that it was a well-known exception to the rule.) I have no idea where their kids went to school, but they certainly didn't go to my school. There was a black janitor there, though, who was famous for never saying anything -- just a polite nod if you said hello. In fact, about the only time I saw blacks was a crew digging a ditch. (There was equipment available for that even then, but apparently it was cheaper to hire manual labor from men desperate to feed their families.) It is not hyperbole to say that they were treated and talked about as sub-human. But that was just "the way things are" so I never gave it much thought.

That is, until one spring Sunday morning when I was 7 or 8. I was out on the church lawn where all the men went to smoke between Sunday School and church service. The topic of discussion was how outrageous it was that blacks were coming into "town" (the two blocks where all the stores were) on Saturday afternoon. That was when white people preferred to do their shopping, so blacks were expected to stay away so they wouldn't offend anyone. There was general agreement that the police chief needed to "talk" to them about that.

The reason I remember it so vividly is that the Sunday School lesson that morning had been "Do unto others as you would have them do unto you."

I still cry every time I think about it.

Dallas was segregated when I was growing up. The only blacks I encountered meaningfully were on Amos and Andy, or Pearl Bailey, Louis Armstrong etc., on variety shows. I remember a sign above the door of a downtown cafeteria that read Whites and Gentiles only. It wasn't till I was a senior in high school did I see a black student (and only one). My father and I used to go around and around on the civil rights issues of the day. Blacks were deemed lazy, potentially dangerous, not too smart, and they smelled. Once, a black man delivered circulars on our street, and all eyes were on him till he passed on to another street.

Those were the days...
 
I grew up in a small southern town in the 50s. There was a black community that lived exclusively in a row of shacks along the railroad tracks. (There was one small farm outside of town that was owned by a black family, but it was unusual enough that it was a well-known exception to the rule.) I have no idea where their kids went to school, but they certainly didn't go to my school. There was a black janitor there, though, who was famous for never saying anything -- just a polite nod if you said hello. In fact, about the only time I saw blacks was a crew digging a ditch. (There was equipment available for that even then, but apparently it was cheaper to hire manual labor from men desperate to feed their families.) It is not hyperbole to say that they were treated and talked about as sub-human. But that was just "the way things are" so I never gave it much thought.

That is, until one spring Sunday morning when I was 7 or 8. I was out on the church lawn where all the men went to smoke between Sunday School and church service. The topic of discussion was how outrageous it was that blacks were coming into "town" (the two blocks where all the stores were) on Saturday afternoon. That was when white people preferred to do their shopping, so blacks were expected to stay away so they wouldn't offend anyone. There was general agreement that the police chief needed to "talk" to them about that.

The reason I remember it so vividly is that the Sunday School lesson that morning had been "Do unto others as you would have them do unto you."

I still cry every time I think about it.

I grew up outside the nation's capital. There was the black-only single street of houses over behind the white-only golf course, one of many along a fine famous avenue leading out of the capital; an extreme difference in neighborhoods to the east of 16th Street and the west in DC; the railroad track corridors on which black people traveled by foot to move inconspicuously, and in general almost complete segregation.

I could go on, but my intention isn't to match your fine accounts, rather, to simply add that what for me is truly amazing is that, in reality, just about everyone of a certain, mostly Trump-voting age knows all this. That's what really digs at me, the casual dismissal of this rather hideous past and myriad other short-comings. What with all the chest-thumping "greatness," it gets really exasperating.
This is just ridiculous, at my young age, we don't casually dismiss it, my generation has moved past it.

Your side still wants to relive it as its part of the leftist narrative to keep the races fighting. My generation has adopted black culture and there isn't any going back. You two should be ashamed!
 
Dallas was segregated when I was growing up. The only blacks I encountered meaningfully were on Amos and Andy, or Pearl Bailey, Louis Armstrong etc., on variety shows. I remember a sign above the door of a downtown cafeteria that read Whites and Gentiles only. It wasn't till I was a senior in high school did I see a black student (and only one). My father and I used to go around and around on the civil rights issues of the day. Blacks were deemed lazy, potentially dangerous, not too smart, and they smelled. Once, a black man delivered circulars on our street, and all eyes were on him till he passed on to another street.

Those were the days...

Ahh when america was great.
 
While Lakoff is not neutral in the conservative, liberal debate, I find his point of view a help in understanding some of what is behind conservatism. Here is a freshly minted article by Lakoff:

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/a-minority-president_us_5834526be4b030997bc136f7

I think Lakoff's Family metaphor is compatible with Moral Foundations Theory.

Going back to Haidt's taste analogy - It's like the difference between describing flavour theory to chefs vs the physiology of flavour, which they don't really need to understand at that level of detail.

The idea is that Haidt's Moral Foundations Theory is describing a layer from which the Family metaphors originated.


Regarding Hlafordlaes' concerns... specifically "Loose language" - this sounds like it's more a weakness of using a Wikipedia entry to evaluate any psychological model.

Wikipedia says the prefrontal cortex is responsible for executive functioning. Well, "executive functioning" sounds like loose language too; but as it turns out, brain region research is more rigid in its definitions. MFT is, as well, try not to get too hung op on that until you drill a bit further into the actual research.
 
You two should be ashamed!

Oh, I am. One thing I'm ashamed of is that when I standing in that church yard, knowing that what I was hearing was wrong, I was afraid to say anything.

I got over that.

And I'm getting less and less interested in hearing about the reflection in your bubble.
 
Oh, I am. One thing I'm ashamed of is that when I standing in that church yard, knowing that what I was hearing was wrong, I was afraid to say anything.

I got over that.

And I'm getting less and less interested in hearing about the reflection in your bubble.

You're stuck in the fifties and you accuse me of living in a bubble?
 
If anyone cares, I have collected the check from The Central Scrutinizer, and I will deposit it in the morning. The Electoral College has elected Trump, for better or worse (probably worse). And, so some charity that fights against him will soon be $100 richer.

Actually, quite many ideas that purport to be based on evolutionary psychology seem more like convenient ideological retrofits than good science.
Okay, yeah, that might be true to some degree. Though, this is more than that.

Loose language is clearly a problem: looking at the wiki for Moral Foundations Theory, one immediately encounters the term "moral" (no surprise) to describe and classify behaviors. This clearly works as a backdoor value judgment by elevating those behavioral traits relating to irrational behavior to the status of morals. Quite silly. Bad science; no proper is/ought firewalls.
I think you are focusing too much on the language. Yes, loose language is an issue, but the empirical findings do NOT rely on that specific language. You can replace "morals" with "values" and perhaps folks like you will see how it works, better.

Or, simply take the core value shared by all variations, as per the theory: fairness. What is that really related to? How can fairness be a concept if fundamental sameness and standing are not brought into play?
The book goes into more detail: For liberals Fairness often implies equality, at least of opportunity. For conservatives, it is more about proportionality: Being rewarded in proportion to what you contribute, even if the outcomes are going to be unequal.

Clearly, "fairness" itself is open to interpretation, requiring more precise definitions. Be that as it may, how are "values" translated into prescriptions for behavior? Culturally and individually, or is there some purported "direct relation" one can trace - allow me to barf - to specific GOP policies?
Haidt spells out the nature of this value in his book. My own wording might be vague, but do not mistake that for lack of precision on Haidt's part. These have all be empirically isolated from each other, in scientific studies.

Nah, this ain't science, and it ain't even good ethics.
What this is, is a fairly successful approach to help folks on all sides of the political spectrum to understand each other better. I argue it is one of the better sciences we have on this subject (though not the only one, as my next post will emphasize). And, if you have something better, I would like to know what that is.

If you, uh, want science, start with the three sources of behavioral heuristics: genetic; learned yet subconscious; and conscious, rational thought. All three come into play. My guess is that a good portion of what these boys think is genetic is far more raw and basic than the high level definitions given, and what they are really dealing with is learned behavior and the effect of rationalizations (loose social 'theories,' i.e., bias).
Fascinating. Haidt's book actually touches on those, as something his own Foundations Theory rests on. Right before he goes into the specific values (such as Fairness), he talks about what "innate" means in the areas you mention.

He does not go into those in any great detail. Books from Stephen Pinker tend to do that well enough. And, both folks seem to think their ideas are compatible with each other.

(And, ironically, it is NOW YOU who is talking about evolutionary psychology. But, I don't mind.)

My parents (dad now gone) were not racist for 1950 but they are for the 21st Century. They always thought black people should vote, have equality under the law, etc., but they were a lot more inclined to complain about so-called reverse discrimination than they were discrimination. Other than that kind of subtle white-privilegey racism, however, they certainly did not try to perpetuate those stereotypes among their kids. For example, they never used the n-word or other racial epithets in my experience, and they exposed us to endless messages of peace, love, and equality at Church.
Did your mother recognize that Trump was even a racist, in the first place; or did the veiling of his words convince her that he is "not really racist"?

While Lakoff is not neutral in the conservative, liberal debate, I find his point of view a help in understanding some of what is behind conservatism. Here is a freshly minted article by Lakoff:

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/a-minority-president_us_5834526be4b030997bc136f7
That is a very good, comprehensive article. I do not see it contradicting anything Haidt said very much. I would go into why, but it happens that blutoski beat me to it relatively well.


Coming Soon:
I would like to state that: Although this thread has focused on one particular theory, it is certainly NOT the SOLE factor for understanding conservatives. Though, I do think it is the MOST IMPORTANT one. The end of my parent post implied that we can connect the Moral Foundations theories to works by others, that further our understanding: The work of human nature by Stephen Pinker, cognitive dissonance as described by Carol Tavris, to name a couple.
I will also add Ian Morris' history lessons about war and politics to the mix, even though I did not mention him during the SkeptiCamp presentation. My post elaborating this is in the works.
It might not be very long. But, I hope that broadening this discussion to some degree with have some value.
 
It is a very new drug :


Emphasis mine. Breakthrough drug are usually not widely available instantaneously.
Care to cite something approved for longer than 18 months ?

Why should I? There are legitimate benefits to receiving a treatment 18 months sooner. I don't agree with your discounting of it.
 
(a great deal snipped)
What this is, is a fairly successful approach to help folks on all sides of the political spectrum to understand each other better. I argue it is one of the better sciences we have on this subject (though not the only one, as my next post will emphasize). And, if you have something better, I would like to know what that is.

Fascinating stuff. I think social psychology has a lot of insight here. I'd like to ask if you are familiar with Argumentative Theory (AT)? It suggests the coherent explanation you are after isn't the driving process.

Here is a paper on it: http://www.dan.sperber.fr/wp-content/uploads/2009/10/MercierSperberWhydohumansreason.pdf
Here is a short talk by one of the authors: https://www.edge.org/conversation/hugo_mercier-the-argumentative-theory

The thrust of it is that we might be looking for salience and reason where deconstructing worldviews is misleading, that underneath we should not expect to find understanding or rationality, but instinct and tribal affiliation instead.

It makes me wonder how much of what we think is going on is constructed by investigators examining a dispersed environment where we are better served by more general (and distant) conceptual analysis.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom