Since I’m from Red Texas, I may be biased, but Giz’s statement doesn’t ring true to me; it’s bass ackward.
Perhaps it might be more accurate to say conservatives tend to think liberal are "immoral", and liberals tend to think conservatives are "stupid". But, either way, I see it as only a first-approximation of the differences. Moral Foundations Theory goes deeper as to why, so we can see that neither label is true, and also how either label COULD SEEM to be true before looking deeper.
While I can agree that it is certainly beneficial to try to understand one another better, it nevertheless cannot close the gap between how conservatives view the world and how liberals do.
We have to start somewhere. Other than George Lakoff, do you have any other suggestions for closing the gap?
I do like George Lakoff’s efforts to understand the conservative mind. His portrayals of left v. right as originating in the con’s Strict Father Model against the lib’s Nurturing Family Model has the benefit of corresponding to the world that I know. Lakoff’s views are meant to frame issues favorably for broad consumption and not just targeting right-wingers.
Lakoff might be hitting on another way to frame some of the same types of ideas. Though, I will have to read his material more, to know for certain.
Somehow, I doubt his work will be as fundamental, even if that was the case. Thus, it would not "close the gap" on its own, either.
But, we shall see.
I still cry every time I think about it.
Xenophobia, like paranoia, strikes deep.
The very idea of defending minorities, that one does not even belong to, from injustice: That is such a relatively new idea, only liberal
mutants would whole-heartedly go for such a thing!
Formulated like this it seems pretty meaningless. How could there not be?
Of course YOU might ask that, because YOU are already smart enough to know there could be. But, to many people: This is a very non-intuitive notion.
When conservatives claim liberals are "immoral", they are assuming everyone would really have the same morality.
When liberals claim conservatives are "stupid", they are not acknowledging there is even a moral issue at stake.
More important issues are whether the things Haidt claims are "moral foundations" actually are, whether the list is sufficiently complete, and whether they are distinguishable from eachother in a meaningful way.
I agree these are important, and research is ongoing, I am sure.
Though, for practical use, it seems fairly solid, so far.
See post #455,
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=11630088&postcount=455 , where I say "a very good exercise!", in bold, to see how it can work in practice.
That Americans can apparently only discern 2 or 3 large groups is problem that should not be ignored. It seems ridiculous to me that all of human thought on morality can be meaningfully be summarised in 2 or 3 categories.
For casual use, it has sufficient meaning to work fairly well.
Understanding BOTH ENDS of a broad spectrum can still allow us to understand those between the extreme ends. Understand the differences along
one dimension helps us acknowledge and understand
other dimensions that can exist, when we see them.
Which is probably a large majority.
The "large majority" is not ignored. A comprehensive understanding, of extreme ends, can still capture the views of those in between.
(One could argue that there was a Great Sort in the U.S., where politics have become more divisive, thus the majority you spoke of does not really exist, anymore, anyway. But, I am giving you the benefit of doubt, that it does.)
I don't think the differences are what is causing people to feel alien to the other side. It is the result of a political system that turns politics into a spectator sport with only two competing teams, where one can only be for or against any side. Where "winning" is more important than making well balanced decisions on all of the most difficult questions a society has to find an answer for. What makes people the other side feels alien is because they have been taught to think of politics as taking "sides" and to think of the "other side" as "alien".
There is NO DOUBT your spectator sport argument is true! That is a very general pattern in HOW people are driving themselves apart.
But, UNDERSTANDING the other side requires us to put ourselves in the other side's shoes. WHAT is different between them, at a fundamental level, that they CAN BE divisive and alienated about?
Your argument is true, but it is very generic. It does not get into what people think, when they join up on each side of the spectator stands.
Do I see any harm in trying to understand other people's motivations by looking through a terribly distorted lens? Yes, I actually do.
If it works, it was not very distorted. If it is not going to work, we won't find out until we try. If anyone has a better idea, I am willing to listen, though.
(And, of course, Diplomacy Matters! It's not like we are going to use this foundation to "beat people over the head" or anything.)
I'll take that as a "no".
If it was "no", why would there be a references section?
Sure. Two is just too small a number. Most countries have at least 10 discernably large political parties, and even those have plenty of infighting over their "moral foundations".
Other countries are better at keeping their politics from drifting into two sides, as what happens in the U.S. But, when quizzed on their morals, studies show everyone still drifts into the same groups. That is what Haidt's international results seem to show.
I like to point out that not only is the political spectrum much broader, it is far more multi-dimensional than the term "spectrum" would suggest.
I can agree with that. In fact, since there are 6 foundations, there could be a potential of 6 different axes of dimensions. Though, only 3 were uncovered in Haidt's work, as having any significant population.
A lot of those people who "swing side to side" do so not because their views change drastically, but rather that the "sides" don't really represent them.
Fine. Let me rephrase, then: But, understanding conservatives is still part of a comprehensive understanding of everyone, including those who are not necessarily represented by any one side.
What we don't understand about conservatives is how they never picked up on the same things we did despite being exposed to the same information (that last bit an potentially unsupported assertion, of course). For example, if you travel to some state where people don't recycle plastics, cans, etc. it can be pretty jarring. "What's with these backwards people here - they don't even recycle!"
Might have something to do with the Care/Harm foundation.
The other issue concerns hypocrisy. I got in an argument with my mom about Trump and his racial rhetoric. I ended up explaining to her that she was the one who instilled me with this sense of equality and justice when I was a little boy - was that all a lie? She was the one who made me go to church constantly and was, presumably, listening to the same sermons about love, peace, tolerance, and forgiveness that I was. Why did that message resonate with me but not with her? I think that's the kind of stuff liberals are struggling to understand about conservatives.
I am going to guess that your mom does not recognize Trump's statements as racist. She is NOT in favor of racism, I am guessing. But, she simply does not see it in others when she admires their charismatic rhetoric in some way. If I am right, hypocrisy is not exactly the problem: It could be cognitive dissonance. If I am wrong: I apologize, and perhaps we can learn more from your corrections on my assumptions.
I will say that Trump is very skilled at veiling his racially insensitive remarks. Those who DESIRED a racist President feel like they got exactly what they want. While at the same time, those who DENY they are racist, themselves, had enough plausible deniability, to vote for Trump AS IF he wasn't some kind of racist.