Why Liberal Suck at Understanding Conservatives and Why it Matters

So what? Medicare does not cover long term care for example those people are moved to medicaid after their finances have been pillaged. So it is easier for a chronically sick person to actually leave an inheritance in those nations.

And you don't see things like forced divorces because otherwise the well spouse will be reduced to living in poverty. That is one of the benefits of the US system.

Umm, what are you talking about? US per person expenditures are 3 times higher under my numbers than the NHS. Why are you acting like I said it was lower?
 
One drug? I'm sure there are probably others but Medicare does not cover areas of care such as dental care and vision and hearing.

You didn't say how much I had to provide. But I can pretty much Google "NICE rejects" and then Google Medicare and that service all day and get hits.
 
I'm really sensitive to making the right apples to apples comparison.

Medicare spends 646 billion to cover 44 million 65+

NHS spends 54 billion to cover 11.4 million 65+

Does the NHS even produce a number for how much it spends on this age group? If so, why? It provide medical care for everyone whether they are 65+ or not why bother breaking it down into 65+? It also your number for the NHL appears to be just plain wrong. The NHS reports that as of 2014 it provided care to 14.9 million people over the age of 60. Regardless it’s Apples to oranges. US spending in 65+ includes both Medicate AND Medicaid.

http://www.nhsconfed.org/resources/key-statistics-on-the-nhs
The number of people aged 60 and over is projected to increase from 14.9m in 2014 to 21.9m by 2039.
.

In the US Medicaid + Medicare + VA spending on healthcare and that comes to around 1.1 Trillion, or ~$3700 per person in the US. Total purchasing power adjusted per capita spending on healthcare in the UK=is ~$4000 per person and this covers 100% of the population.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_total_health_expenditure_per_capita
 
Does the NHS even produce a number for how much it spends on this age group? If so, why? It provide medical care for everyone whether they are 65+ or not why bother breaking it down into 65+? It also your number for the NHL appears to be just plain wrong. The NHS reports that as of 2014 it provided care to 14.9 million people over the age of 60. Regardless it’s Apples to oranges. US spending in 65+ includes both Medicate AND Medicaid.

http://www.nhsconfed.org/resources/key-statistics-on-the-nhs
.

In the US Medicaid + Medicare + VA spending on healthcare and that comes to around 1.1 Trillion, or ~$3700 per person in the US. Total purchasing power adjusted per capita spending on healthcare in the UK=is ~$4000 per person and this covers 100% of the population.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_total_health_expenditure_per_capita

I have a BBC report that 40% is spent on 65+.

I went with 65+ because a) all people in US have coverage, b) they cost several times more than younger adults. Obviously the US system is inefficient, but the additional per capita to cover this young population even under a very inefficient system could be really low or really high.
 
Obviously the US system is inefficient, but the additional per capita to cover this young population even under a very inefficient system could be really low or really high.

Why not adopt the successful, more cost effective systems already proven to work elsewhere.
 
Why not adopt the successful, more cost effective systems already proven to work elsewhere.

Because we have ideologues in this country who do not care about empiricism. See, government has certain "proper," "limited" functions. So, for example, it might be allowed to incarcerate citizens, but should not educate them. You cannot take from Peter to educate Pablo. "Wait a second," you say, "what if we can reduce total government spending by supplying public education?" Nope, not a proper function. What if we can reduce government spending via a universal health-care system? Also a no-go. You cannot reason with these people.
 
Last edited:
Because we have ideologues in this country who do not care about empiricism. See, government has certain "proper," "limited" functions. So, for example, it might be allowed to incarcerate citizens, but should not educate them. You cannot take from Peter to educate Pablo. "Wait a second," you say, "what if we can reduce total government spending by supplying public education?" Nope, not a proper function. What if we can reduce government spending via a universal health-care system? Also a no-go. You cannot reason with these people.

You can use their own axioms to reason why it is a proper function.

Empiricism is another ideology. Well, that it has value anyway.
 
Last edited:
That calculation is incorrect. The marginal tax rate was 91% so the loss of income would be far less than you state. That said, it does strengthen your case.

Alongside that, the purpose of a high marginal tax rate at the top isn't entirely about generating tax revenue, but a way to incentivize (re)investment.

Basically "put your money to use towards some greater social purpose or we'll do it for you."
 
You can use their own axioms to reason why it is a proper function.

Such as? Even the people who accept the existence of a nightwatchman state as an efficient natural monopoly remain principally opposed to health-care (or even public education). The moment we begin to argue a single-payer system works better we are back to empiricism.

Generally speaking, at best you can demonstrate that according to their own premise -- usually some version of the non-aggression of force principle -- any kind of government function is a violation of liberty since enforcing negative rights entails positive obligations. Peter attacks Pablo... so why do I have to pay protect someone else's rights?

Hell, the very basis of this reality-challenged, property-rights-in-everything philosophy involves the troublesome matter of how land was justly seized from the commons and privatized in the first place.
 
I was born and raised and lived most of my life in Red Texas. My youth was lived in the conformist 1950s and the revolutionary 1960s. Lucky me. I still remember the family get-togethers and picnics where discussions rarely turned to the illegitimacy of southern apartheid or of the Vietnam war; instead our families would bemoan “*******” looking for government handouts, or “dirty hippies” who should be run out of the country, or war protesters, who should be shot on sight. Such concerns and prescriptions were normal, seemingly universal, held without question, and were considered just good common sense. American conservatism, like Islam, is not just a religion, it is a way of life.

I’m a liberal. I’ve been called a “libtard,” among other things, by conservatives. I listen to conservative talk radio, and once heard a new host ranting, “I hate liberals,” a strong statement made, I presume, to impress his new audience. A Facebook friend, one of my co-workers, posted a meme stating liberals are responsible for the death of millions and millions of babies, with the helpful photo illustration of a Gerber baby. Dallas’ radio host in the 80s, David Gold, once proclaimed that “liberals hate God;” this was some time after he stated that a score of illegal immigrants making their way to America who died from exposure, “got what they deserved.” Rush Limbaugh, once when a group of four from Christian Peacemaker Team, a pacifist human rights org, was kidnapped in Iraq, and one of the group was killed, said, “I like any time a bunch of leftist feel-good hand-wringers are shown reality… I’m telling you folks, there’s a part of me that likes this.” My older brother, raised on the musings of H.L. Hunt, and also an admirer of Joseph McCarthy and a consumer of talk-radio, once shocked the dinner table when he stated Timothy McVeigh had the right idea (in blowing up the federal building in Oklahoma), he just picked the wrong time of day (when children were inside). I have hundreds of real life examples such as these.

Imagine my surprise and faux-enlightenment, then, when I ran across this thread. Here is Giz responding to the OP (#6 comment), for instance: “It could also be that liberal views are colored by a basic misunderstanding of their opponents. I.e. conservatives tend to think that liberals are well intentioned but naive. Liberals tend to think that conservatives are evil. It’s hard to engage honestly when your default view of your opponent is ‘evil.’” Since I’m from Red Texas, I may be biased, but Giz’s statement doesn’t ring true to me; it’s bass ackward.

I haven’t read Haidt, although I will. Wowbagger is impressed with Haidt and seems to agree with him to say conservatives have a better understanding of liberal points of view than do liberals in understanding conservatives; libs don’t get the underlying unstated beliefs of cons so as to understand them better. I find this contrary to my own experience, but I’m guessing my anecdotal argument won’t carry the day for others. While I can agree that it is certainly beneficial to try to understand one another better, it nevertheless cannot close the gap between how conservatives view the world and how liberals do.

I do like George Lakoff’s efforts to understand the conservative mind. His portrayals of left v. right as originating in the con’s Strict Father Model against the lib’s Nurturing Family Model has the benefit of corresponding to the world that I know. Lakoff’s views are meant to frame issues favorably for broad consumption and not just targeting right-wingers.
 
Last edited:
I was born and raised and lived most of my life in Red Texas. My youth was lived in the conformist 1950s and the revolutionary 1960s. Lucky me. I still remember the family get-togethers and picnics where discussions rarely turned to the illegitimacy of southern apartheid or of the Vietnam war; instead our families would bemoan “*******” looking for government handouts, or “dirty hippies” who should be run out of the country, or war protesters, who should be shot on sight. Such concerns and prescriptions were normal, seemingly universal, held without question, and were considered just good common sense. American conservatism, like Islam, is not just a religion, it is a way of life.

I grew up in a small southern town in the 50s. There was a black community that lived exclusively in a row of shacks along the railroad tracks. (There was one small farm outside of town that was owned by a black family, but it was unusual enough that it was a well-known exception to the rule.) I have no idea where their kids went to school, but they certainly didn't go to my school. There was a black janitor there, though, who was famous for never saying anything -- just a polite nod if you said hello. In fact, about the only time I saw blacks was a crew digging a ditch. (There was equipment available for that even then, but apparently it was cheaper to hire manual labor from men desperate to feed their families.) It is not hyperbole to say that they were treated and talked about as sub-human. But that was just "the way things are" so I never gave it much thought.

That is, until one spring Sunday morning when I was 7 or 8. I was out on the church lawn where all the men went to smoke between Sunday School and church service. The topic of discussion was how outrageous it was that blacks were coming into "town" (the two blocks where all the stores were) on Saturday afternoon. That was when white people preferred to do their shopping, so blacks were expected to stay away so they wouldn't offend anyone. There was general agreement that the police chief needed to "talk" to them about that.

The reason I remember it so vividly is that the Sunday School lesson that morning had been "Do unto others as you would have them do unto you."

I still cry every time I think about it.
 
(In fact, Haidt found his foundations do work across cultures, though each one give different names to each side.)
Or just attached the names of whatever seemed to fit.

Perhaps it might be best to look beyond the words used, and to look at the basic idea, that there are differing moral value foundations between groups of people.
Formulated like this it seems pretty meaningless. How could there not be? More important issues are whether the things Haidt claims are "moral foundations" actually are, whether the list is sufficiently complete, and whether they are distinguishable from eachother in a meaningful way.

There are only 2 or 3 discernably large groups,
That Americans can apparently only discern 2 or 3 large groups is problem that should not be ignored. It seems ridiculous to me that all of human thought on morality can be meaningfully be summarised in 2 or 3 categories.

though there are certainly people who will not fit so well into any of them.
Which is probably a large majority.

And, more to the point, these differences are causing people on one part of the line to feel alien to people on another.
I don't think the differences are what is causing people to feel alien to the other side. It is the result of a political system that turns politics into a spectator sport with only two competing teams, where one can only be for or against any side. Where "winning" is more important than making well balanced decisions on all of the most difficult questions a society has to find an answer for. What makes people the other side feels alien is because they have been taught to think of politics as taking "sides" and to think of the "other side" as "alien".

Do you see any harm in some of us putting it into practice, to find out?
Do I see any harm in trying to understand other people's motivations by looking through a terribly distorted lens? Yes, I actually do.

There is a References section in the back of the book, but I have not had time to try to dig any of them up, yet, to find out.
I'll take that as a "no".

For MOST informal purposes, it is sufficient to SUMMARIZE the landscape of political beliefs into a small number of groups.
Sure. Two is just too small a number. Most countries have at least 10 discernably large political parties, and even those have plenty of infighting over their "moral foundations".

I agree that the political spectrum is much broader than conservatives and liberals (as Earthborn likes to point out).
I like to point out that not only is the political spectrum much broader, it is far more multi-dimensional than the term "spectrum" would suggest.

But, understanding conservatives is still part of a comprehensive understanding of everyone, including those who might swing from side to side.[/qote]A lot of those people who "swing side to side" do so not because their views change drastically, but rather that the "sides" don't really represent them.
 
I was born and raised and lived most of my life in Red Texas....

I grew up in a small southern town in the 50s. There was a black community that lived exclusively in a row of shacks along the railroad tracks....

I grew up outside the nation's capital. There was the black-only single street of houses over behind the white-only golf course, one of many along a fine famous avenue leading out of the capital; an extreme difference in neighborhoods to the east of 16th Street and the west in DC; the railroad track corridors on which black people traveled by foot to move inconspicuously, and in general almost complete segregation.

I could go on, but my intention isn't to match your fine accounts, rather, to simply add that what for me is truly amazing is that, in reality, just about everyone of a certain, mostly Trump-voting age knows all this. That's what really digs at me, the casual dismissal of this rather hideous past and myriad other short-comings. What with all the chest-thumping "greatness," it gets really exasperating.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom