Why Liberal Suck at Understanding Conservatives and Why it Matters

I think you mean spend more in aggregate compared to total private and public spending now?

No more in general. The US puts as much of the GDP into goverment run socialized medicine as any country that covers all the people with it. So suggest the US could not do the same is to suggest that the US is uniquely incompetent and corrupt.
 

Fair and balanced opening in good faith meant as a bridge. Not my fault, however, that "fair and balanced" in this case is, even if I tried hard, fairly damning of today's GOP through the sole act of quoting important items relating to the much-ballyhooed "values" of the Right.

I would like to understand conservative values. Are they based on faith? See the quoted post. On political ideology? Not the focus of the OP, but rough terrain these days, given the diminished roles of fact and reason. On social mores? Social mores, perhaps, are indeed the problem, as they are entirely arbitrary.

Regardless, I held off an easy hit on that last post. I'd do so again, providing we might address exactly how values get put into action, and how any final results sought might have both conservative and liberal paths to arrive there, allowing for, OMG, compromise.
 
No more in general. The US puts as much of the GDP into goverment run socialized medicine as any country that covers all the people with it. So suggest the US could not do the same is to suggest that the US is uniquely incompetent and corrupt.

On a per person basis that is because medicare covers only expensive people. Other nations have lower per capita spending partly because they pay for the healthcare of mid 20s employed people.


Wait. I see what you mean. You didn't mean by government. You meant as a nation.
 
Last edited:
During the Eisenhower era, when America was the great nation your President to be wants to make it again, tax on the richest in the country (who were, compared to today's 1% were not so rich) was at about that level. So it seems, taxing the rich at an appropriate rate can produce a successful and rich country. And really, if you are earning $200 million a year, you are saying you couldn't get by on about $40 million, which is what an 80% tax rate would leave you with? Really high taxes would only be aimed at the super rich btw, with a progressive scale of taxation at other levels. That is what all sensible nations round the world tried to do in the past before the super rich bought our democracies.

That calculation is incorrect. The marginal tax rate was 91% so the loss of income would be far less than you state. That said, it does strengthen your case.
 
Wait. I see what you mean. You didn't mean by government. You meant as a nation.

I'm not sure that Ponderingturtle is correct but I think that (s)he was referring to government expenditure.

A few years ago somehting came out showing that government spending on healthcare in the US was the same proportion of GDP as UK government spending on healthcare. The difference being that in the government coverage approached 100% whereas in the US it didn't

Total spend in the US expressed as a % of GDP was close to twice that in the UK
 
I'm not sure that Ponderingturtle is correct but I think that (s)he was referring to government expenditure.

A few years ago somehting came out showing that government spending on healthcare in the US was the same proportion of GDP as UK government spending on healthcare. The difference being that in the government coverage approached 100% whereas in the US it didn't

Total spend in the US expressed as a % of GDP was close to twice that in the UK

Remember the brexit bus? It went around Britain saying 350 million pounds were sent to the EU and that money could be used for the NHS. There was ton of argument that the number sent was wrong. Also that ukip wasn't going to put that money into the NHS. No one ever complained that NHS didn't need the money.

So underfunding your system by at least 18 billion a year probably helps (0.6% of GDP, not a lot).
 
I assume you're talking about the Bigfoot thread. Can't remember last time I was there.

You made a big show of stating you would never shoot anything live. But then you had said you had brought your gun while out looking for bigfoot. Then you claim the gun is only to scare away said bigfeet. It appears you are using a gun as just a noisemaker. That is not the purpose of a gun and it shouldn't be used as such from a gun safety point of view.

So where does Liberal ideology fit into all that?

See the underlined for the answer to your question. A gun is simply a tool used by the owner for a specific purpose to achieve a specific goal.

I'll bet you think guns are only meant for killing..........Chris B.
 
See the underlined for the answer to your question. A gun is simply a tool used by the owner for a specific purpose to achieve a specific goal.

I'll bet you think guns are only meant for killing..........Chris B.

I was unaware that intimidating non-existent ape monsters in the dark was widely regarded as a good use for a gun...
 
See the underlined for the answer to your question. A gun is simply a tool used by the owner for a specific purpose to achieve a specific goal.

I'll bet you think guns are only meant for killing..........Chris B.

I've heard that using a gun for purposes for which it was not designed is irresponsible gun ownership.

Maybe we could get a firing instructor in here to comment on this?
 
On a per person basis that is because medicare covers only expensive people. Other nations have lower per capita spending partly because they pay for the healthcare of mid 20s employed people.


Wait. I see what you mean. You didn't mean by government. You meant as a nation.

I didn't say per capita spending, I said spending on all those covered by the government. We pay the same for medicare and medicaid as a percentage of the GPD that other nations do to cover their entire populace, it is not a per capita metric.
 
See the underlined for the answer to your question. A gun is simply a tool used by the owner for a specific purpose to achieve a specific goal.

I'll bet you think guns are only meant for killing..........Chris B.

You'd lose that bet.

Is a specific purpose of a gun loaded with live ammo, as a noisemaker?

Why not use the proper tool? Such as a air horn or even a starters pistol if one's manhood requires one to carry a gun.
 
Universal healthcare in the US would necessitate increased government expenditures relative to what is spent today.
The US has a fundamentally inefficient system. Countries with single payer universal healthcare systems generally cover 100% of their population for ~ 1/2 of the per-capita cost in the US and provide care as good or better. The US system is not efficient at providing either coverage or care. The reasons and results are both quite well documented at this point, but Conservatives can never seem to get past the notion that there are cases where an under regulated free market just doesn’t work.

Again getting back to the idealist vs pragmatist stuff. Both Liberals and conservatives believe in free markets, in fact free markets are one of the core principles that defines Liberalism. The differences is that Conservatives get stuck on the idealized free market while Liberals move on to the market failures that may need to be addressed for a market to function and provide the best results.
On a per person basis that is because medicare covers only expensive people. Other nations have lower per capita spending partly because they pay for the healthcare of mid 20s employed people.


Wait. I see what you mean. You didn't mean by government. You meant as a nation.

Countries with single payer systems typically cover everyone, old, young healthy and unhealthy for per-capita costs similar to what the US spends on socialized programmes like Medicare and the VA. Their costs to cover everyone are typically around 1/2 of what the US spends per-capita currently. Even less well funded ones usually provide results comparable to what the US system currently provides.
 
Why 80%? Why not 99%?

We'll see if you can figure out why your idea would be a disaster.
Nobody needs to make 30 million in income. We can let them have the first million at 30% tax. The rest 80%. It's enough incentive. 20% of 29 million is still almost 6 million.
 
During the Eisenhower era, when America was the great nation your President to be wants to make it again, tax on the richest in the country (who were, compared to today's 1% were not so rich) was at about that level. So it seems, taxing the rich at an appropriate rate can produce a successful and rich country. And really, if you are earning $200 million a year, you are saying you couldn't get by on about $40 million, which is what an 80% tax rate would leave you with? Really high taxes would only be aimed at the super rich btw, with a progressive scale of taxation at other levels. That is what all sensible nations round the world tried to do in the past before the super rich bought our democracies.


Given the tax accountants are way ahead of the taxman at pretty much every turn, I think an 80% top rate tax would probably result in a reasonable seeming 40-50% top rate in reality.
 
The US has a fundamentally inefficient system. Countries with single payer universal healthcare systems generally cover 100% of their population for ~ 1/2 of the per-capita cost in the US and provide care as good or better. The US system is not efficient at providing either coverage or care. The reasons and results are both quite well documented at this point, but Conservatives can never seem to get past the notion that there are cases where an under regulated free market just doesn’t work.

Again getting back to the idealist vs pragmatist stuff. Both Liberals and conservatives believe in free markets, in fact free markets are one of the core principles that defines Liberalism. The differences is that Conservatives get stuck on the idealized free market while Liberals move on to the market failures that may need to be addressed for a market to function and provide the best results.


Countries with single payer systems typically cover everyone, old, young healthy and unhealthy for per-capita costs similar to what the US spends on socialized programmes like Medicare and the VA. Their costs to cover everyone are typically around 1/2 of what the US spends per-capita currently. Even less well funded ones usually provide results comparable to what the US system currently provides.

I'm really sensitive to making the right apples to apples comparison.

Medicare spends 646 billion to cover 44 million 65+

NHS spends 54 billion to cover 11.4 million 65+
 
I'm really sensitive to making the right apples to apples comparison.

Medicare spends 646 billion to cover 44 million 65+

NHS spends 54 billion to cover 11.4 million 65+

So what? Medicare does not cover long term care for example those people are moved to medicaid after their finances have been pillaged. So it is easier for a chronically sick person to actually leave an inheritance in those nations.

And you don't see things like forced divorces because otherwise the well spouse will be reduced to living in poverty. That is one of the benefits of the US system.
 
I'm really sensitive to making the right apples to apples comparison.

Medicare spends 646 billion to cover 44 million 65+

NHS spends 54 billion to cover 11.4 million 65+

So you made sure to do an apples and oranges comparison :confused:

The UK healthcare expenditure expressed as a percentage of GDP is roughly half that of the US. The US government expenditure expressed as a percentage of GDP is roughly the same as the UK's total expenditure and yet the UK covers everyone.

Of course because US GDP per capita is higher, the absolute spend is much higher.

Oh, and the UK has better overall healthcare outcomes as well (though not quite as good as many European countries).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom