Why Liberal Suck at Understanding Conservatives and Why it Matters

Well it seems we got two good topics for us to learn on.

Anyone conservative. Explain to me how fewer people having access to healthcare is moral. I'm open to hear your ideas here.

Also, how is having easier access to guns more moral? Again I'm hoping to hear the rationale.
 
Well it seems we got two good topics for us to learn on.

Anyone conservative. Explain to me how fewer people having access to healthcare is moral. I'm open to hear your ideas here.

Also, how is having easier access to guns more moral? Again I'm hoping to hear the rationale.

Someone did a fine job up thread with the puritan/protestant work ethic angle.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protestant_work_ethic

Consider the "world owes you nothing" based memes you may see posted by conservatives. Also the attacks on todays youth as a generation with issues of entitlement.

To have the discipline to work very hard even for a meagre existance is honorable. To not make such effort is to be despised and any suffering is your own deserts. Any wordly suffering on the honest worker is to be endured with eternal rewards awaiting in the afterlife. If you accept the Bible as truth its all quite coherent.

As for guns, havent you been paying attention to arguments in those threads? Lets not start thst here anyway.
 
Last edited:
Explain to me how fewer people having access to healthcare is moral. I'm open to hear your ideas here.

Two things. Healthcare doesn't have to be viewed through the lens of morality. For example, I reject arguments against abortion on purely moral grounds. I also wouldn't force end of life care on anyone.

Second, even if it is best addressed on moral grounds, healthcare doesn't stand alone - there are competing moral issues and trade-offs. For example, to what extent should the needs of others encroach on my own needs?
 
And again you dishonestly ignore what I've said in favour of some twisted mockery of what I said. Why would you continue to do this after being corrected, I wonder?

Do you really think that holding some traditional ideas somehow counter my point that they were liberal for their time?

Slaves are not "ideas", they are people. Not only do you handwave the point away that their slaves might have a different idea about their masters' "liberalism" than what you are proposing here, now you're simply dehumanizing them.

Do you even understand what I said, I wonder?

I understand you just fine - remember those old days when you could be a liberal and hold slaves? It's ********, no slave-owner was ever liberal, for their own time or anyone else's.
 
For liberals, the Care/Harm foundation is SO STRONG, they are blind to think the MERE LIBERTY of unrestricted gun ownership Should ever be as important to anyone. If you look at the chart on the parent post, you will see how this all fits in.
How do conservatives who favour stricter gun laws fit into this?

Liberty, in this context, is more Libertarian-style: Free market type of stuff.
In other words, what in political science is called "negative freedom", favoured by Classical Liberals.

Despite the shared root word, this form is not found so solidly in liberals.
Perhaps then the term is too narrowly defined, just to exclude them. Or the definition of "liberal" is wrong.

Haidt defines them quite thoroughly, and his studies extract them quite quantifiably.
So what are those definitions? And are "liberal" and "conservative" defined clearly enough to map those "moral foundations" onto them in a meaningful way?

But, it seems to cover the most prevalent bases for now.

The theory is accurate enough, that we can make use of it, in IMPORTANT ways.
I am not convinced this is true.

His papers on the matter probably DO address these more directly.
Are those papers accessible somewhere?

But, his book meant for public consumption has to have SOME limits in its scope, even if it can afford to be vastly longer than my presentation on it.
You chose to present the theory here. I think you could do more to explain it.

I am arguing that liberals suck at understanding conservatives, and showing them a way to improve in that field.
I don't think understanding political movements is helped by stubbornly holding on to a liberal/conservative dichotomy. Especially since those are not even opposites; there are political movements that are liberal and conservative at the same time without necessarily being centrist.

I think if we want to understand oneanother, the first thing we need to do is to stop pidgeonholing oneanother into 2 or 3 categories.

If we learn why that point of view is not appreciated by others (regardless of whether or not you agree with that other viewpoint), we can begin the process arguing your own points more effectively to them.
Maybe it is because some people just don't believe in miracles :p
 
Slaves are not "ideas", they are people.

What are you on about? We're discussing whether someone is for or against slavery. That is an idea. You can be liberal for your time and still have ideas that are conservative. This isn't a black-and-white issue.

Not only do you handwave the point away that their slaves might have a different idea about their masters' "liberalism" than what you are proposing here, now you're simply dehumanizing them.

You are being ridiculous. We're talking about the opinion, not the slaves themselves. Stop peddling strawmen. They're not your slaves.

I understand you just fine - remember those old days when you could be a liberal and hold slaves? It's ********, no slave-owner was ever liberal, for their own time or anyone else's.

Then you have no idea what liberalism is. However, I suspect that you understand exactly what it is that I'm talking about, but found yourself saying something silly as an initial response and are now unable to admit to have been wrong, so you're just digging further with irrelevancies and non sequiturs.
 
. . . there are competing moral issues and trade-offs. For example, to what extent should the needs of others encroach on my own needs?

Agreed. Even here we sometimes conflate what is moral and what is Christian. Had Travis' question asked how it is Christian to put one's own needs ahead of the care of others I'd agree with him. Because he used the word moral, however, I agree with you.
 
Well it seems we got two good topics for us to learn on.

Anyone conservative. Explain to me how fewer people having access to healthcare is moral. I'm open to hear your ideas here.

First, I think liberals tend to equate lack of access to the most state of the art and expensive treatment for a life-threatening illness as lacking access to healthcare. That is simplistic. Not everybody can have the best possible treatment for a life-threatening illness, by definition. Bill Gates can afford to get better treatment for cancer than I can, and I don't think that's immoral.

Second, healthcare is not just about life and death issues, which are the ones that tug on our heart strings and are the most morally fraught. In fact, most healthcare spending is about comfort and convenience. The moral implications are no different from buying a car or a house in a nice neighborhood with good schools.

Third, conservatives believe that setting up a system to enforce an equal distribution of healthcare resources results in a suboptimal allocation, utility-wise. If I'm a couch potato, I don't really value that knee surgery that will allow me to play tennis again. Why should I be given equal priority to somebody who loves to play tennis and needs the same knee surgery? Without a free market system, there is no incentive for individuals to do their own cost-benefit analysis. Furthermore, supply does not respond optimally to true demand. It responds to artificial demand. If everybody gets free knee surgery, then lots of resources will be allocated to knee surgery. But perhaps those resources are better allocated to curing priapism (something I would pay top dollar for right now). The beautiful thing about the price system is that demand for scarce resources results in more of those resources being produced. That doesn't happen as well when resources are distributed by other mechanisms. The bottom line is that more people will have access to better healthcare in the long run under a free market system than is possible under any other system. That is what conservatives believe. You don't have to agree, but I think you have to concede that the philosophy is moral.

Also, how is having easier access to guns more moral? Again I'm hoping to hear the rationale.

People should have the right to self-defense. As the old saying goes, God made man, but Samuel Colt made them equal. Without guns, the physically strong can intimidate the weak. Men can intimidate women. Etc, etc. Guns really create an equal playing field, and make all individuals worthy of due consideration. Liberals want to leave the enforcement of this important principle up to the police. But, as another saying goes, when seconds count, the police are only minutes away.
 
Last edited:
What are you on about? We're discussing whether someone is for or against slavery.

No we're not, we're discussing your claim of some specific slave-owners being "liberal for their time" and whether their slaves might not have something else to say about that. But you keep ignoring the latter.

But fine, if some slave-owners were liberal for their time, then what about people who didn't own slaves back then or who set their slaves free if they found themselves having them?
 
No we're not, we're discussing your claim of some specific slave-owners being "liberal for their time" and whether their slaves might not have something else to say about that. But you keep ignoring the latter.

It's because the latter has nothing to do with the claim. So no, we're not actually discussing this.

You seem to think that the fact that some of them were pro-slavery disqualifies them for being "liberal" but have not offered any argument or reasoning for this besides an appeal to emotion.
 
For example way back when sometime, a person got it in their head to appoint a woman to a powerful position that had never been granted to one before. Is there no room to note that they did so in a society that was hostile to the idea and it probably got them a lot of enemies or is it all shame and boos and hisses because it was the only woman they elevated in their entire reign?

Personally I don't care about women in powerful positions, nor anyone else in powerful positions.

The people in those days who were "liberal for their time" were the ones who did not have slaves, refused to have slaves and set their slaves free if they might find themselves owning them. It was not the slave-owners which were "liberal for their time".
 
It's because the latter has nothing to do with the claim. So no, we're not actually discussing this.

It has everything to do with your claim. If you're claiming that someone is liberal then a first question would be "would their slaves agree with that determination?"

You seem to think that the fact that some of them were pro-slavery disqualifies them for being "liberal" but have not offered any argument or reasoning for this besides an appeal to emotion.

Liberalism values freedom. Owning slaves is taking away other peoples' freedom, hence the two are plainly inconsistent.
 
It has everything to do with your claim. If you're claiming that someone is liberal then a first question would be "would their slaves agree with that determination?"

I wasn't aware that slaves had to agree with their owners' political views. that's very interesting. How about you explain why it's relevant in the first place?

Liberalism values freedom.

Yes, it does. You'll notice that they also didn't allow women to vote. You'll also notice that I said they were liberal for their time. You can be liberal relative to something.
 
I think you're answering my question from above, where I asked "where do you draw the line?"

I don't understand your answer. It's an historical description of the current set of regulations. My question is: why do we need the old regulations you describe? Why are the weapons restricted in those acts appropriate? Why was Reagan not 'attacking the 2nd Amendment' by adding new restrictions?

Reagan further added to the machine gun provision that was already in effect NFA act of '68). Nothing changed within it except that "new" machine guns could no longer be made, unless for the military and law enforcement agencies.

Although this did cause the price of machine guns to rise, nobody was in that big a tiff over it as the market was not there anyway for new fully automatic guns. Only a small percentage of the population is willing to jump thru all the legal hoops required to own one anyway and for those folks a used gun is fine. Most are historical gun collectors with little interest in the new stuff.

Chris B.
 
I wasn't aware that slaves had to agree with their owners' political views. that's very interesting. How about you explain why it's relevant in the first place?

You are the one who's claiming that their owner is "liberal". Your claim is being disputed on the basis that slave-ownership is inconsistent with liberalism.

You'll also notice that I said they were liberal for their time. You can be liberal relative to something.

Relative to the people in their time who did not own slaves nor wanted to own slaves? Relative to the slaves themselves? Yes, I've already brought it up, which you ignored. If you're just going to cherry-pick a set of people to compare them to so they can come out as "more liberal" - then remember that Hitler was a liberal for his time, compared to Himmler.
 
You are the one who's claiming that their owner is "liberal". Your claim is being disputed on the basis that slave-ownership is inconsistent with liberalism.

So you now agree that the opinions of the slaves are irrelevant. It was simply about you considering that being anti-slavery is a necessary condition of liberalism. That is wrong, of course, and using an unnecessarily narrow definition of the word.

Relative to the people in their time who did not own slaves nor wanted to own slaves? Relative to the slaves themselves?

Again with irrelevancies: relative to people in their time. That was obvious from the get go, since this is what I said right off the bat.
 
I think you actually hit a good, (if VERY hot-button) topic to illustrate the differences we can help understand.

Liberals should NOT be required to agree with your stance on gun ownership. But, I think liberals CAN LEARN a lot about conservatives, if they investigate WHY they feel how they do.

For liberals, the Care/Harm foundation is SO STRONG, they are blind to think the MERE LIBERTY of unrestricted gun ownership Should ever be as important to anyone. If you look at the chart on the parent post, you will see how this all fits in.

I, for one, support the Second Amendment. Though, I do believe it is important to keep guns out of the hands of "bad guys", but into those "good guys" who want them. I see the issue of gun control being about that: Specifically keeping guns out of "bad guys" hands, and not about restriction of freedoms to those responsible folks who want them.

I DO THINK that some of the regulations we have are too restrictive. But, I hope you agree that SOME form of regulation is necessary, for the sake of separating the "good guys" from the "bad guys", and nothing more beyond that.

But, that is going off on a tangent. Let us get back to the main topic:

You stated Liberals will "never understand conservatives". Is there any way you think you can present the issues, more effectively, that will allow them to do that? Pointing things that other Liberals said (such as the Hillary quote you linked to) seems to be a poor way of doing that. Perhaps we can think of something more from YOUR point of view?!
You are NOT required to agree with my stance, of course. If you disagree, we can learn why that is. That understanding is the goal, here.

*snipped*

Thank you for an honest attempt at conversation rather than another heated attack.

The differences are so vast between Conservatives and Liberals. The 2nd Amendment and gun control are a small part of the differing views.

One big thing that we will never agree on is abortion. I don't believe it should be legal. Why? Simple, killing is wrong. Taking life is wrong, no matter what the reason is. As a Conservative I see the women march with signs chanting "My body my choice!" To me personally, that's horrific. Knowing they actually think they have a right to take a life because that life happens to be inside them......They don't, nobody does, and that will never change.

The argument of abortion is a moral one. Anyone that is for it, by definition is an immoral individual. And it really is that black and white of a decision. You don't get to sit on the side lines. You're either for it or against it. If you vote Liberal, you're for it.
Chris B.
 
Thank you for an honest attempt at conversation rather than another heated attack.

The differences are so vast between Conservatives and Liberals. The 2nd Amendment and gun control are a small part of the differing views.

One big thing that we will never agree on is abortion. I don't believe it should be legal. Why? Simple, killing is wrong. Taking life is wrong, no matter what the reason is. As a Conservative I see the women march with signs chanting "My body my choice!" To me personally, that's horrific. Knowing they actually think they have a right to take a life because that life happens to be inside them......They don't, nobody does, and that will never change.

The argument of abortion is a moral one. Anyone that is for it, by definition is an immoral individual. And it really is that black and white of a decision. You don't get to sit on the side lines. You're either for it or against it. If you vote Liberal, you're for it.
Chris B.

If the choice is the fetus or the mother?

If the fetus is the result of rape or incest?

If the fetus is malformed to such an extent that post-natal life would not only be one filled with pain, but also very brief?

Let's face it: the one thing that really separates liberals from conservatives - at least your type of conservatives - is that you see everything in black-and-white while liberals see nuance.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom