That's a different question. I've argued for years that how we frame things matters. There's no magic in assessing the values one's opponent is operating with.
Well, one of the main reasons liberals must seek to understand conservatives is for this very thing: How to frame things in ways that appeal to them.
There are other reasons, too, such as limiting the damage of Internet-based arguments, improving opportunities to learn from each other, etc. But, as I asked before: Describe a better theory for doing any of these things!
Weren't you at TAM 5 in 2007?
Yes, I was. Though, I only have vague recollections of you there, right now. Are you on the TAM 5 DVDs? I could watch that to refresh my memory, if so.
My point is there are a number of things the free market does not provide the best solutions for.
And, my main point is that those markets need better sales pitches, I guess.
A Conservative will try one salt, declare all the others sinful, pass laws to ban the use of any of the others and then occasionally beat to death someone who is open about wanting to try the others because Jesus.
I think you are mangling the True Taste analogy a bit worse than anyone else on this thread.
(I was going to respond to your 'medical treatment' comments, but I think others have done a sufficient job on that, for now.)
I mean...sanctity? What kind of sick, twisted person sees any value in sanctity?
You are NOT required to value sanctity. But, I think if you better understood WHY OTHERS value such things, it might improve how you seem to treat them.
The danger with thoughts like yours is that conservatives will see you as dishonestly representing them (even if you intended to be honest), and would thus not accept anything else you had to say on the matter. Maybe you don't care about that, yourself. But, collectively, this type of attitude will continue to cause harm to the Liberal cause.
If I make an argument against Single-Payer healthcare, it doesn't mean I don't have empathy or I want people to die. Telling me I lack empathy or want people to die is going to make me start to disregard your argument.
Where did I say that? Neither liberal nor conservatives, according to the model, would "lack empathy or want people to die". They both seem to value such things, perhaps with different priorities, but it is all still there!
Your wrong. Trump is not the threat, the people who support him are. When 50% of the people who vote want a clown for president, you know the country is doomed - whoever wins.
They are BOTH threats. Trump is a threat. AND the people who support him the most are threats.
Again your wrong. Even if the Democrats had garnered enough votes to 'win' we still would have lost.
Wrong about what?
If Hillary had won, I would be saying: "the fact that Trump got CLOSE to winning should still be
disquieting to those who assumed he never could win." (That is an exact line from the alternate speech I would have made, in that situation.)
I agree that if Hillary had won, there would still be big problems to deal with. I am suggesting we can BEGIN to resolve those problems by understanding each other better.
*Shrugs* It's how discussions are these days.
- My side is right, the other side is evil.
For the record, most of us are disagreeing with the few who are implying this.
- Therefore there are all sorts of rules the other side has to follow when dealing with me, no rules in my side dealing with them since the ends of defeating them justifies any means.
I do not recall reading anyone saying that, here. The whole "no rules" thing is really just a cheap form of pseudo-justification of otherwise monstrous deeds.
As I see it, the problem is that conservative morality is more consistent with our baseline impulses. People are naturally tribal the same way they're naturally superstitious.
That is largely true! Though, I would not dismiss the baseline origins of liberals, either.
Why wasn't religion vanquished long ago in this country?
This is off topic, but I like to say "religion is an evolutionarily effective strategy for converting resources into babies". Religion will stick around as long as that remains true.
Here's one of Haidt's more notorious scenarios, one that only highly educated, hard-core liberals found permissible:
My talk, being as short as it was, was going to skip over the questions that were part of the study. But, it happens that a friend of mine "loved" the chicken question (you know the one) so much, I gave him the opportunity to describe it.
But, yes, it is an important to talk about those questions, in this discussion thread. So, thank you for your contribution!
The good news is that the "expanding circle"/the "escalator of reason"/whatever can help us see past the illusion
That was something else I was going to get into, later: How Haidt's work ties into the works of others.
Actually, the conservative of today are not the one of 60 years or 120 years ago. Just like everybody, with generations moving on , they die out and are replaced by other type of conservative.
Yes, but the foundations in moral values are likely to remain consistent.
It is more than a semantic point. Moral is a loaded word with connotation when you "lack them". By painting it as moral blind spot, the author already pre-taint the debate.
I was using both the words "morals" and "values" as shorthand for "moral values". Perhaps I should avoid doing that. (Though, it is a bad habit I could not shake from my previous science/morality threads.) But, if you re-read what I wrote in that context, I hope it clarifies my points.
And reading the criticism snippet I see about his work (
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jonathan_Haidt#Criticism) particularly the second one, I would like to see more than the snippet because I think I am starting to see an inherent bias against "non conservatism" in how this is handled.
Is this quote, from the Wikipedia article, the "second one" you were referring to?
Social psychologist John Jost wrote that Haidt "mocks the liberal vision of a tolerant, pluralistic, civil society, but, ironically, this is precisely where he wants to end up."
I do not think Haidt mocks any of those things, at all. He very clearly wants a more tolerant society throughout. But, to get there, it takes RECOGNITION for how others feel. That is not the same as mocking how one really feels.
Without reading further I am betting if I google it I will find out that Haidt is a conservative : he pretty much has a good grasp of the fine granularity of the values of conservative as a whole, but seem to have a blind spot on the fine granularity of values of liberals...
It doesn't matter what Haidt is, as long as his research is objective enough to be reliably useful to anyone of any party. (And, moving from liberal to moderate does not mean one is conservative.)
Though, if you think he is missing granularity among liberals, I am curious to know what you think those missing elements are. It is likely he studied them, and did not find them useful enough to be noted. But, I could be wrong, on that point.
it's interesting to hear Americans discuss liberals.
I often wonder if they simply don't realise that their idea of liberal is fairly right wing for the rest of the world?
Yeah, I know. I wrote this for an American audience. Sorry about that.
What of these explains how unpopular Obamacare is, but all of its actual provisions are very popular?
It is not just Obamacare. It is standard practice for those who oppose socialized policies to need them the most.
The conservative rhetoric, where 'fairness' is more about keeping your own earnings, is one big thing that drove them against Obamacare. (Plus, a touch of racism for good measure.)
But, the practical needs of their family (perhaps with elements of sanctity for the spouse and children, and respect for the head of the household) had them accepting its provisions.
How so? Look at our resident conservatives here and tell me how well they understand the left, please.
I know that in studies, conservatives were better able to anticipate how liberals would react to different situations, than liberals were able to anticipate the same about conservatives. Haidt covers that fairly well.
The single most important thing to realize is that Liberals are pragmatists while Conservatives are idealists. A lot of people miss this because up until ~1990 it was the opposite.
I think such things are more indicative of who is in power. Those not in power become idealists about the future. Those not in power tend to be pragmatists in how to actually get things done with their power.
At the risk of cynical understatement, I'm still having a hard time seeing how DJT represents a victory for any type of morality, most especially including traditional conservative values.
It is not. Trump exploited the values of the voters to gain power, with no intention of making good on honoring those values.
His rhetoric, though empty, was the real victor, this time.
Michael Moore also "saw this coming" with a radically different (and considerable more convincing) explanation: Demagoguery works when frustration reaches a sufficiently high level.
I agree with Moore's assessment! And, it does NOT contradict my own. They are two elements of the same monster.
Liberals will never, repeat never, understand Conservatives. It's simple really. To change the United States away from the values and liberties it was founded on would in effect destroy it. You cannot or will not understand this principle, therefore you will never understand Conservatism.
If you desire to change that, at all, perhaps you can help us out! Give us one or two examples of values and liberties you are concerned about, and we will see if we can communicate those ideals better to the liberals you think are threatening them. And, then we will see if they understand the situations better. It might take a few iterations of this, before it works broadly across groups of liberals, but at least we can get started!
(ETA: I see you have started doing this, already. I will respond to some of those responses. But, if you'd like do "start over" with me, you can do that, as well.)
My observation is that Democrats are an alliance of Liberals and socially progressive fiscal Conservatives, while Republicans are a mix of social Conservatives and ultraconservative Reactionaries with a fiscally naiive Libertarian economic model.
That seems to be largely correct. Though, Haidt did find it useful to separate Libertarians from Conservatives in his later models.
one thing I have observed about skeptics is that we act like these cartoon Liberal Elites pretty consistently. We're the "They" in "They act like they know better than the average guy."
I agree skepticism can always improve its image and reputation. In sense, that is connected to what I am talking about, here. Though, more broadly than to just us skeptics.
Let's look at a specific example, and I know it is a sensitive topic, but let's consider Dawkins' approach. Number one: take for granted that the core morality is to reduce harm. Everything else (community cohesion, &c) needs to be subordinated to that ethic. OK, even if he's right, Conservatives disagree, so now what? Number two: there's no talking to these guys, so the right course of action is to mock their beliefs until they are sufficiently cowed. The Skeptical Champion is the same as the Liberal Elitist.
That is a
good example! (Though, a bit extremeist.)
It is elitist attitudes like that that I hope we can change, though understanding our fellow humans better. Cowing the opposition will continue to backfire, in the form of Trumps and Brexits, until we do!
MORE RESPONSES TO COME!