Why Liberal Suck at Understanding Conservatives and Why it Matters

Liberals will never, repeat never, understand Conservatives. It's simple really. To change the United States away from the values and liberties it was founded on would in effect destroy it. You cannot or will not understand this principle, therefore you will never understand Conservatism.

Like slavery? Or genocide?
 
Liberals will never, repeat never, understand Conservatives. It's simple really. To change the United States away from the values and liberties it was founded on would in effect destroy it. You cannot or will not understand this principle, therefore you will never understand Conservatism.

Like slavery? Or genocide?

Going the other way:

Like peaceful change of government by petition and redress of grievances or changing of policies through sending representatives to enact new legislation that reflects our ever-changing worldviews?
 
Were their slaves equally liberal though?

Do you think this single example, from back in the day where slavery was more common, somehow nullifies my point? Do you think it's impossible for them to be more liberal than most in their day without being against slavery? Or did you just think it was a witty riposte that didn't require more thought on your part?
 
Like peaceful change of government by petition and redress of grievances or changing of policies through sending representatives to enact new legislation that reflects our ever-changing worldviews?

Nonsense. Native Americans "petitioned" government to be put in increasingly smaller reservations and otherwise exterminated? Slaves "sent representatives" to "enact new legislation" to be enslaved? There are the values and principles the US was founded on.
 
Do you think this single example, from back in the day where slavery was more common, somehow nullifies my point?

You seem to think owning slaves makes someone "liberal", even if you qualify it as "for their time". And why on Earth do you think this is a single example? They had more than one slave you know, or does their perspective on whether the situation could be described as "liberal" not count? Only the slave-owners' perspective counts?
 
You didn't support Hillary by voting for her.............this is the thinking that gets you into trouble. Chris B.

Chris you clearly understand what the country is dealing with here. Im just thankful and glad the country got it and has thrown them out. Even here people fake confusion, the more the left tries to confuse, the more people get what they really are.

Our victory was so very sweet, I look forward to the left suffering more defeat!
 
You seem to think owning slaves makes someone "liberal", even if you qualify it as "for their time".

How incredibly dishonest of you. You know full well what I said. I said, clearly, that the Founders of the US were liberal for their time. That doesn't exclude having positions that we would consider abhorrent today, or having positions that wouldn't be liberal back then.

You deliberately decided on the most extreme interpretation of what I said, bordering on rewriting what I said completely, just in order to win internet points and 'win' an argument by responding with a clever post.

Despicable. You should be ashamed of yourself.
 
How incredibly dishonest of you. You know full well what I said. I said, clearly, that the Founders of the US were liberal for their time. That doesn't exclude having positions that we would consider abhorrent today, or having positions that wouldn't be liberal back then.

You deliberately decided on the most extreme interpretation of what I said, bordering on rewriting what I said completely, just in order to win internet points and 'win' an argument by responding with a clever post.

Despicable. You should be ashamed of yourself.

Nonsense, I explicitly accounted for your "for their time" - owning slaves never was consistent with being liberal, at any time.
 
Last edited:
As to hate, yes -- all the conservatives I've known and with whom I've had discussions on these topics have expressed hate for LGBT persons and the poor.

As to greed, yes again -- conservatives as a group tend to place personal enrichment above the suffering of those they have never met and whom they do not understand.

I rather suspect you have your cause and effect backwards. I'd bet that you've interacted with a large number of people who consider themselves to be conservatives, but who don't express (nor harbor) any hatred for LGBT, poor, etc. Similarly, I would bet that many of them also don't place personal enrichment above the suffering of strangers in the way you imply. I would be willing to bet that you've interacted with a large number of them, but because you have defined an association between these negative traits, you don't view them as conservative.
 
How incredibly dishonest of you. You know full well what I said. I said, clearly, that the Founders of the US were liberal for their time. That doesn't exclude having positions that we would consider abhorrent today, or having positions that wouldn't be liberal back then.

You deliberately decided on the most extreme interpretation of what I said, bordering on rewriting what I said completely, just in order to win internet points and 'win' an argument by responding with a clever post.

Despicable. You should be ashamed of yourself.

The broader point is surely who gives a **** what their positions were and why would anyone hold themto be true now?
 
I rather suspect you have your cause and effect backwards. I'd bet that you've interacted with a large number of people who consider themselves to be conservatives, but who don't express (nor harbor) any hatred for LGBT, poor, etc. Similarly, I would bet that many of them also don't place personal enrichment above the suffering of strangers in the way you imply. I would be willing to bet that you've interacted with a large number of them, but because you have defined an association between these negative traits, you don't view them as conservative.

I think you would need to evidence this. It doesnt hold even for the uk and our conservatives would be left of Obama. In my experience at least.
 
Well, we know there's a punitive sacrifice phenomenon out there, which has always surprised me (eg: people are willing to earn 10% less, as long as their peers earn 20% less, for example). So that part makes sense.

But I haven't seen evidence that it aligns with political spectrum, so aligning it with a political aspect doesn't make sense to me either.

Here's a ref to the research I'm thinking of: [Is more always better?: A survey on positional concerns]

If I were going to be applying motive, it wouldn't be because the right wing wants the left to suffer (what Travis said). It would be more along the lines someone has misled the right wing into thinking anything a poor person gets from the government is a freebie, and that's what the right abhors, someone getting something the right winger isn't getting.

It's part of the selective attention though, because the right wing person is more inclined to overlook corporate welfare while something going to an individual is more of an irritant.
 
How so? Look at our resident conservatives here and tell me how well they understand the left, please.

With the exception of one or two specific individuals, I'd say we understand the left fairly well. Indeed, I'd bet that you don't even recognize the handful of conservatives on this forum as being conservative in the first place.

I generally consider myself relatively conservative. I'm liberal in terms of social interactions - I think the government has no business getting involved in anyone's sex lives ever, full stop. I think that physical attributes and characteristics like sexual preference and gender should have no bearing whatsoever on how one is treated by other people. But I'm fiscally conservative, and I'm generally opposed to regulations and laws that tell people what to think or how to behave. My personal life is personal, it's not your business and it's not the governments. I generally oppose raising taxes (with a very narrow exception for education).

But would you consider me a conservative, given how they're being described in this thread? Am I evil? Do I wish pain and suffering on others? Do I demonize my opponents? Am I stupid beyond repair? Do I, based on your interactions with me, fit the description and the caricature of conservatives that so many in this thread seem to believe is absolute unshakable truth?

I value the loyalty of my family and friends, and I grant them my loyalty in return. I value the authority of the rule of law, and I adhere to those laws faithfully. I value the sanctity of marriage and of oaths given, and I hold myself to them. These are not "evil" values, and I am not evil for valuing them in society. I also value care and fairness, with a deep and abiding loyalty to those principles.
 
Wouldnt it be great if someone could put aside the holy texts and just say the second amendment is wrong?

Who here would say that? Certainly no one here who considers themself to be liberal would say that. It has been well-established within this very thread by liberals that all liberals favor the 2nd Amendment.
 
Nonsense, I explicitly accounted for your "for their time" - owning slaves never was consistent with being liberal, at any time.

And again you dishonestly ignore what I've said in favour of some twisted mockery of what I said. Why would you continue to do this after being corrected, I wonder?

Do you really think that holding some traditional ideas somehow counter my point that they were liberal for their time? Do you even understand what I said, I wonder?

Wouldnt it be great if the idea it was wrong on principle could get some traction?

You know what'd be even greater? If you substituted an argument for those leading questions.

The broader point is surely who gives a **** what their positions were and why would anyone hold themto be true now?

It'd also be nice if you read my initial comment for context. ChrisBFRPKY suggested that the US was founded on conservative values.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom