Why Liberal Suck at Understanding Conservatives and Why it Matters

My experience at the gun range is that "automatic" rifle just means "fully auto."

When I'm handling a semi auto rifle, we call it "semi auto."

But yes, for a handgun, the terminology is less precise, as almost every "automatic" handgun is actually semi auto.

I hope gun nuts don't hang their hat on this sort of language precision, but then again, they are elitists who make time to pedantically correct less educated people's vocabulary.

Most military rifles are designed primarily for semi-automatic or burst use. The general concept is a high muzzle velocity mid-sized round that is accurate to ~300m. The military rifles of 100 years ago actually hit harder and were accurate at twice the distance of those used today, but the larger heavier round reduced the amount of ammunition you could carry, the size of the magazine, accuracy when you shot in quick succession and it turned out that most combat took place at much shorter distance. The other pre WWII weapon commonly used was a sub caliber machine gun, basically a machine gun that fired pistol rounds instead of full sized rounds. It was/is excellent in close quarter trench fighting but only accurate to ~50m.

With a midsized round you can design a single weapon to perform both roles adequately, and improve on rates of fire, magazine capacity and ammunition carrying capacity. In addition to close quarters fighting the burst capability allow for much more effective suppressing fire.

The first rifles built on these concepts were German and their name loosely translated to assault rifle, and despite what the gun nuts say it is an of used term to describe this style of rifle. Because this is a concept instead of a specific feature or set if features the gun nuts like to play a no true scottsman game where nothing qualifies or they point to single features in weapons that don’t fit the overall concept.

Also worth noting is the overall set of features makes these relatively poor for both hunting due to the lack of range, accuracy and stopping power and personal defense because rounds go well past your target and can hit things in the background you can’t even see are there. They can be a lot of fun at a range but have little practice use in a civilian setting.
 
So you now agree that the opinions of the slaves are irrelevant.

No I don't. Interesting question btw.

It was simply about you considering that being anti-slavery is a necessary condition of liberalism.

I never considered that. Your failure to distinguish between a slave and an idea in a slave-owner's mind is yours and yours alone.

That is wrong, of course, and using an unnecessarily narrow definition of the word.

If I walk up to you, declare "I'm a liberal" and then enslave you, then this would not stop me from being right about being a liberal?

Again with irrelevancies: relative to people in their time.

Most people in their time did not own slaves, more of them were slaves than slave-owners in fact.
 
No I don't.

Then explain why they're in any way more relevant than that of the cobbler who does their shoes.

I never considered that.

Then do you agree that it isn't a necessary condition? If so, then you have defeated your own argument.

Your failure to distinguish between a slave and an idea in a slave-owner's mind is yours and yours alone.

I'm pretty sure the failure was yours when you took my comment about the idea to mean that I was talking about the actual slaves.

If I walk up to you, declare "I'm a liberal" and then enslave you, then this would not stop me from being right about being a liberal?

Not enough information to make the determination.

Most people in their time did not own slaves

Interesting attempt at a bait-and-switch, but did you think I wouldn't notice the difference between "being pro-slavery" and "owning slaves"?
 
*Snipped*

Do I not have a right to not be constantly afraid my neighbor will pick up his gun and come over to shoot me because the demon in the cupboard told him to?

Moreover what would it take for you to accept that maybe something in the Constitution was wrong? Would you defend a section that said the third born son of any first born male must be burned alive in the town square during a harvest moon?

I don't know your neighbor, so I really can't say. I will say if I had a neighbor like that, and I did not own a firearm, I'd move. Of course if your neighbor knows you are unarmed, you already have "0" deterrence. So there's that.


What would it take for me to accept something in the Constitution is wrong?
Considering the document was designed to outline how the Country should operate and was crafted specifically for the protection of freedom and liberty by some of the greatest minds of history, I don't see anything wrong myself.

Do you think you know more than they? Perhaps you'd be better off to start your own Country somewhere else rather than try to change this one into a European Country? The USA is and always will be different. It was designed to be.

Of course the Constitution is amended from time to time as it is sometimes viewed as a living document, however we must keep in mind and honor the original intent and meaning as it applies to everyone. When we forget the spirit in those original words, we forget our Nation. What we are, who we are, and why we began.
Chris B.
 
It happens I am describing a specific theory for why the differences happen, which seems to be a very effective one. But, it is NOT merely reading the book that matters, either. It is taking the actual theory to heart.

Perhaps you could put this discussion on a more pragmatic footing by an example. Can you take a liberal policy position such as marriage equality and use your understanding of conservatism to phrase a supporting argument that would appeal to conservatives? (If you don't like that topic, pick another.) We have some conservatives here that you can try it out on.
 
The NFA act of 1968 already outlined destructive devices and full auto weapons and ownership. In 1986 Reagan passed another NFA update that made it illegal to mfg new machine guns. Why do we need more regulations? It already costs an arm and a leg just to own an honest to goodness full auto weapon, not to mention the fact you basically give up your right to privacy and consent to search in order to have it. Chris B.

Next they will do things like computerizing records and making it difficult to sell off your guns to strangers on the internet.
 
Um, no. That's not the goal. That's not the goal of the Democratic Party, that's not a platform issue of Hillary Clinton's. Again, you're uncritically taking in a heaping helping of NRA propaganda.

What the "left" wants - and it's puzzling that everyone doesn't want this - is fewer toddlers shooting people..

But that is no ones fault.

See this

https://www.washingtonpost.com/national/after-a-toddler-accidentally-shot-and-killed-his-older-sister-a-familys-wounds-run-deep/2016/12/01/1c0dead2-9c85-11e6-9980-50913d68eacb_story.html?utm_term=.e30d360f3067

I mean the first time she was almost hit by a accidental discharge wasn't a hint to people. But no one did anything wrong this just happens because guns kill. Except when we are arguing that guns don't kill people people kill people. It is hard to keep the two straight most of the time.
 
Then explain why they're in any way more relevant than that of the cobbler who does their shoes.

Because the person who's liberalism is under consideration constrains the individual freedom of his slaves more than that of his cobblers.

Then do you agree that it isn't a necessary condition? If so, then you have defeated your own argument.

For reference, here is "my own argument":
Were their slaves equally liberal though?

Not enough information to make the determination.

What other information do you need? The enslaving is not consensual, if that's what you're wondering about.

Besides, shouldn't by your argument your answer then not be "my opinion doesn't matter because the opinion of the slaves doesn't matter"?

Interesting attempt at a bait-and-switch, but did you think I wouldn't notice the difference between "being pro-slavery" and "owning slaves"?

Apparently you didn't.
 
Last edited:
Someone did a fine job up thread with the puritan/protestant work ethic angle.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protestant_work_ethic

Consider the "world owes you nothing" based memes you may see posted by conservatives. Also the attacks on todays youth as a generation with issues of entitlement.

To have the discipline to work very hard even for a meagre existance is honorable. To not make such effort is to be despised and any suffering is your own deserts. Any wordly suffering on the honest worker is to be endured with eternal rewards awaiting in the afterlife. If you accept the Bible as truth its all quite coherent.

As for guns, havent you been paying attention to arguments in those threads? Lets not start thst here anyway.

And we need to tell that to rural america. No you lazy bastards we do not owe you a high paying job where you live. Do the work and earn a job. Stop using your sense of personal entitlement to destroy this nation.

Old rural white dudes are the most entitled people in the world.
 
Next they will do things like computerizing records and making it difficult to sell off your guns to strangers on the internet.

First of all, machine guns are a whole other world from buying a regular firearm. It takes literally months to complete paperwork and background checks and these transfers are made at/by only a few dealers designated to do so within the US. It's a painfully long and expensive process, but that's ok everyone understands the importance of such a purchase going in.

Obama has signed into law thru Executive privilege a measure that prevents transfer of any gun by individuals (from you to your buddy). All sales must now go thru a dealer and have background checks performed. This covers everything from internet sales to gun shows. Internet sales already required background checks and transfer at a FFL dealer anyway. The only real change he made was for the gun shows individual to individual sales/trades.

Gun records are already "computerized" as we have forms to fill out whenever we buy a firearm. The serial number from that gun is in effect registered to the buyer and a matter of record. So much for privacy or the "no gun registry" we in fact have a gun registry system in place in the US.
Chris B.
 
People should have the right to self-defense. As the old saying goes, God made man, but Samuel Colt made them equal. Without guns, the physically strong can intimidate the weak. Men can intimidate women. Etc, etc. Guns really create an equal playing field, and make all individuals worthy of due consideration. Liberals want to leave the enforcement of this important principle up to the police. But, as another saying goes, when seconds count, the police are only minutes away.

And the several deaths due to accidents and suicide are totally worth that feeling of safety. It is like trying to force people to wear a seatbelt. Sure statistically you are safer with a seatbelt and with out a gun in the house but it is about feelings not facts. You feel safer with a gun and you feel safer without a seatbelt. That is what is important.
 
Because the person who's liberalism is under consideration constrains the individual freedom of his slaves more than that of his cobblers.

You still haven't explained why their opinion matters here, especially since you can't go back and ask them.

For reference, here is "my own argument":

No, you said your "own argument" was this:

Your claim is being disputed on the basis that slave-ownership is inconsistent with liberalism.

But then, your "own argument" seems to change with every post, allowing you to avoid making a point or admitting to being wrong.

What other information do you need? The enslaving is not consensual, if that's what you're wondering about.

That wasn't your question. Do you think I can't keep track of the conversation here? You asked whether they could be considered liberal. Since I said that slavery is not the only issue concerned by liberalism, and that it is not a necessary condition to liberalism that you be anti-slavery, and you didn't provide further information, I cannot make that determination.

Besides, shouldn't by your argument your answer then not be "my opinion doesn't matter because the opinion of the slaves doesn't matter"?

I don't know, but since it isn't what I said, implied or thought, how is this relevant?

Apparently you didn't.

That doesn't make any sense. I just called you on you equating the two. At least make some sense in your answers, please.
 
First of all, machine guns are a whole other world from buying a regular firearm. It takes literally months to complete paperwork and background checks and these transfers are made at/by only a few dealers designated to do so within the US. It's a painfully long and expensive process, but that's ok everyone understands the importance of such a purchase going in.

So make all guns NFA guns. I am ok with that. NFA weapons don't get into the hands of criminals. I suggest you promote that to your congress people and get that made the law of the land.
Obama has signed into law thru Executive privilege a measure that prevents transfer of any gun by individuals (from you to your buddy). All sales must now go thru a dealer and have background checks performed. This covers everything from internet sales to gun shows. Internet sales already required background checks and transfer at a FFL dealer anyway. The only real change he made was for the gun shows individual to individual sales/trades.

Only long distance internet sales. As long as we meet in some parking lot it is totally legal to sell non NFA guns to strangers on the internet.
Gun records are already "computerized" as we have forms to fill out whenever we buy a firearm. The serial number from that gun is in effect registered to the buyer and a matter of record. So much for privacy or the "no gun registry" we in fact have a gun registry system in place in the US.
Chris B.

No they are not they are all on paper. See paper is not a computer. The ATF is barred by law from computerizing records so that means that it is effectively impossible to find who legally purchased a gun as someone has to go through all the paperwork by hand.

For someone who seems to be arguing about firearms law you are very ignorant of many sections of it.
 
Lol

Ahh yes, the need to be accepted by the left.
Yeah, no. I don't need to be accepted by the left. I do, however, feel obligated to not unnecessarily alienate people by my behavior. I believe I'm responsible for my actions and behaviors, and that I have a duty to not intentionally harm others - that includes emotional harm. I'm very strongly anti-aggression. I also find it important to reflect my own values; if I find it unseemly for others to act in a condescending, antagonistic, and combative fashion... I also find it unacceptable for me to act in the same manner in retaliation. But hey, that's a personal choice.

Tell me what is conservative about being socially liberal. The reason you're not recognized as conservative is because you aren't. Maybe you could explain your social liberalism a bit more than about someone's sex life. Who by the way I too think sex shouldn't be an issue. Just don't run it up a flag pole to me or shove it down my throat.
Yet another case of "you don't believe the exact same things as me, therefore you don't qualify as xxxx". I wonder, does this fall into the category of "No True Scotsman"? Disregarding my views on government, governance, community, duty, tradition, personal responsibility, and individual freedom... you've decided to exclude me from the sphere of conservativism based solely on the fact that I don't think it's the government's business to interfere in people's private lives?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom