Why Liberal Suck at Understanding Conservatives and Why it Matters

They hoped to create a government that could avoid such brinkmanship. We're failing at that for the same reason the EU is. It is neigh impossible for any central authority system to represent so much landmass and so many socio-cultural viewpoints. Eventually there's so many people on the fringes (or who feel like they're on the fringes) that it starts to unravel and turbulent shifts start occurring.

Bit of an aside... but that's exactly the reason the US has the electoral college, as well as having senate representation based on the count of states rather than the volume of population. Imperfect, perhaps, but it is at least an attempt to govern with respect to the size of the land mass and the variety of cultural differences.

Can you imagine the EU trying to govern exclusively on population, with complete disregard for each member country's voice?
 
One big thing that we will never agree on is abortion. I don't believe it should be legal. Why? Simple, killing is wrong. Taking life is wrong, no matter what the reason is. As a Conservative I see the women march with signs chanting "My body my choice!" To me personally, that's horrific. Knowing they actually think they have a right to take a life because that life happens to be inside them......They don't, nobody does, and that will never change.
When you're out hunting the nonexistent bigfoot, packing large as you term it, and someone tries to jack your car after your grueling two hour hike, you can't shoot and kill him, right?

How about when you shoot at a shadow you think is a bigfoot and it turns out to be a boy scout?
 
That's not particularly true. One extremist conservative here doesn't think I qualify as a true scotsman. I'm not convinced of his authority on the topic.

Well, neither do I. It was a tongue-in-cheek jab at people on both sides seeing black & white on everything.
 
Anyone conservative. Explain to me how fewer people having access to healthcare is moral. I'm open to hear your ideas here.
First, let's correct your misconception here. The vast majority of conservatives aren't seeking to have fewer people with access to healthcare - that's not the objective. In this particular case, I'll speak as a general conservative, not necessarily as myself. My viewpoint on this topic varies a bit from mainstream conservatives, because I work in this industry and have a significantly deeper understanding of the forces at play than the average citizen does.

For the general conservative, they'd be quite happy to have everyone have access to health care. The problem is that this isn't achievable in our current system as it exists. Health care isn't free. Most conservatives would happily extend health care to those less fortunate, but they don't support creating a system where that care is extended by increasing the burden on others. They object to obligating other people to cover the cost of that care.

Every social safety net imposes an obligation on others. There needs to be a balance point between the collective and the individual. It's no different for health care than it is for shelter, food, or clothing. Yes, some people face the risk of death - as do those without homes and those without adequate food. But if the policy enacted to address that need creates a disadvantage in others that reduces their well-being, then that really needs careful and thorough thought.

Most conservatives, myself included, find it unacceptable to obligate other people to take on a burden. You yourself are welcome to volunteer your own resources to help, I am perfectly happy to volunteer my own resources. But I find it objectionable to obligate other people to contribute without a full understanding of their personal and individual needs and wellbeing.

If the cost of helping another person get healthcare means that my family can't get adequate food, or that my family has to face challenges or reduces security, that isn't a trade that I'm willing to let you make for me.

At the end of the day, it generally boils down to other people imposing an obligation without the consent of those being obligated. It's the removal of a voice, it's the infringement upon my agency and my liberty to govern my own life and decide my own fate.

*** Personally, I support a subsidized free market for health care, similar to Switzerland system - essentially Medicare Advantage. But I do NOT support it without significant efforts from the government to enforce cost controls, and it would need to have a very well-defined triage system to cover necessary care. The current system is untenable in its current state.

Also, how is having easier access to guns more moral? Again I'm hoping to hear the rationale.
Again, your misconceptions are based on a false caricature and a lack of understanding. It's not about "easier access to guns". It's about the ability to protect oneself, to be responsible for one's own safety. If my access to firearms is significantly restricted in general (as opposed to restricted as a result of my own actions), then that directly reduces my ability to defend myself against those who would do me harm. The risk of harm might be small, but it's not non-existent. The willingness to remove another person's ability to protect themselves and their family is generally viewed as a distinct lack of care for them. Why do you believe you have the right to sacrifice my well-being?
 
First, I think liberals tend to equate lack of access to the most state of the art and expensive treatment for a life-threatening illness as lacking access to healthcare. That is simplistic. Not everybody can have the best possible treatment for a life-threatening illness, by definition. Bill Gates can afford to get better treatment for cancer than I can, and I don't think that's immoral.

Second, healthcare is not just about life and death issues, which are the ones that tug on our heart strings and are the most morally fraught. In fact, most healthcare spending is about comfort and convenience. The moral implications are no different from buying a car or a house in a nice neighborhood with good schools.

This seems like a strawman to me. I'm concerned because of all the people I know that have NO access to healthcare unless they go to the ER and put themselves in essentially permanent credit-wrecking debt. People who don't get treatment for things like cysts full of staph that are making them sick, because they don't have a couple hundred dollars to spare to go to the doctor and get it cleaned out and fill an antibiotics prescription, or the time and persistence and transportation to figure out if there were any reduced fee clinics they could go to. Some places have great systems in place for this, for example in Sarasota, Florida I had no trouble finding out where the city's public clinic was and how to get help for low income people there. But in Atlanta, Georgia I still don't know where to send any low income friends. One hospital charged nearly $400 for the intake appointment where you got the paperwork to apply for the hospital's charity program.

I would be incredibly happy, I would consider it a massive step forward, if we had universal free-at-point-of-delivery access to 1990 level health care for all outpatient conditions.
 
Where are you wrong? You think you're better. You refuse to see that this Country was founded on freedom and rights. You think other's beliefs are silly when they don't fit with your own. You don't respect other's rights, you impose your view of society to be forced on those that don't share or accept those views. I could go on for days on where Liberals are wrong but it won't do any good as you'll obviously deny all. Chris B.
I'm late an didn't read all replies to this post, but it is such a concise statement of the disconnect in this conversation, that I can't not reply.
You can simply exchange the word liberals for conservatives and off you go.
Generally speaking,

Liberals want to force fairness and compassion on people. Conservatives want to do that with competitiveness and sexual role models.
Liberals don't respect your freedom to own guns or the right to do things the way you want if it could possibly affect other people in a negative way.
Conservatives don't respect your freedom to love whomever however you want, or your right to societal support if you happen to get ground up in society's gears.

The point is that we obviously need to start talking to each other again in terms of differences of opinion, not as "enemies", as the people soon to run the US are doing.
 
Bit of an aside... but that's exactly the reason the US has the electoral college, as well as having senate representation based on the count of states rather than the volume of population. Imperfect, perhaps, but it is at least an attempt to govern with respect to the size of the land mass and the variety of cultural differences.

Can you imagine the EU trying to govern exclusively on population, with complete disregard for each member country's voice?

Exactly people in Wyoming are 3 times more american than people in california.
 
First, let's correct your misconception here. The vast majority of conservatives aren't seeking to have fewer people with access to healthcare - that's not the objective. In this particular case, I'll speak as a general conservative, not necessarily as myself. My viewpoint on this topic varies a bit from mainstream conservatives, because I work in this industry and have a significantly deeper understanding of the forces at play than the average citizen does.

For the general conservative, they'd be quite happy to have everyone have access to health care. The problem is that this isn't achievable in our current system as it exists. Health care isn't free. Most conservatives would happily extend health care to those less fortunate, but they don't support creating a system where that care is extended by increasing the burden on others. They object to obligating other people to cover the cost of that care.

Every social safety net imposes an obligation on others. There needs to be a balance point between the collective and the individual. It's no different for health care than it is for shelter, food, or clothing. Yes, some people face the risk of death - as do those without homes and those without adequate food. But if the policy enacted to address that need creates a disadvantage in others that reduces their well-being, then that really needs careful and thorough thought.

Most conservatives, myself included, find it unacceptable to obligate other people to take on a burden. You yourself are welcome to volunteer your own resources to help, I am perfectly happy to volunteer my own resources. But I find it objectionable to obligate other people to contribute without a full understanding of their personal and individual needs and wellbeing.

Exactly if you have a kid with Hemophilia you better have either millions of dollars or have the brat put down. Otherwise you are just a burden on others.
 
When you're out hunting the nonexistent bigfoot, packing large as you term it, and someone tries to jack your car after your grueling two hour hike, you can't shoot and kill him, right?

How about when you shoot at a shadow you think is a bigfoot and it turns out to be a boy scout?

You certainly are paranoid. To answer your questions, I don't kill. Do I eat meat, certainly. But I do not kill for sport, science, or even self preservation. I will not kill, period.
Chris B.
 
Exactly if you have a kid with Hemophilia you better have either millions of dollars or have the brat put down. Otherwise you are just a burden on others.

And we all know, even though we are a community here on Earth, we shouldn't act like it.

That was by far the strangest rationalization that I've ever heard, but with a tinge of upbeat smile to it.

It's not that we, as a collective, should decide to disregard those who need help. It's just that, we don't really want to give up anything that we have or want to help them.

I think I found out why I don't understand conservatives, and despite the thread title, I don't think it matters. It's like trying to figure out how to hit a knuckleball. It doesn't make any damn sense.
 
You certainly are paranoid. To answer your questions, I don't kill. Do I eat meat, certainly. But I do not kill for sport, science, or even self preservation. I will not kill, period.
Chris B.

Paranoid about what. You're the one who bragged about packing large when you go bigfootin'. What are you doing that for, then?
 
Yeah, no. I don't need to be accepted by the left. I do, however, feel obligated to not unnecessarily alienate people by my behavior. I believe I'm responsible for my actions and behaviors, and that I have a duty to not intentionally harm others - that includes emotional harm. I'm very strongly anti-aggression. I also find it important to reflect my own values; if I find it unseemly for others to act in a condescending, antagonistic, and combative fashion... I also find it unacceptable for me to act in the same manner in retaliation. But hey, that's a personal choice.

But somehow you felt it necessary to marginalized me as being part of a two person team who are too extreme for you (I have to know who the other is?) ;)

Im totally fine with aggression although I would never be aggressive to another unless first attacked. You also realize where we're posting, I've had people constantly attacking me here and I'm perfectly fine giving it back. I can carry all ten of them through hell in my little pocket.

Yet another case of "you don't believe the exact same things as me, therefore you don't qualify as xxxx". I wonder, does this fall into the category of "No True Scotsman"? Disregarding my views on government, governance, community, duty, tradition, personal responsibility, and individual freedom... you've decided to exclude me from the sphere of conservativism based solely on the fact that I don't think it's the government's business to interfere in people's private lives?
Because I label you as something different, that isn't an attack, it's just a fact. Most want to be considered conservative, no one wants to be considered liberal, funny how that is.

Im not disregarding your views, I'm putting them into the correct category. I happen to agree with you on most of your views (except when you accused me of being a racist) just the not the social ones.
 
Last edited:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=247153&highlight=packin+large&page=55

ChrisBFRPKY said:
I can and do carry openly anytime I'm out in nature. Since any caliber from .44 magnum and above can crack a cast iron engine block, I don't feel it would be any problem to penetrate skull, bone or muscle tissue. I usually carry 2 sidearms and a box of cartridges for each.

From a distance of 25 feet or less, I can put a bullet anywhere I choose with a sidearm. Whether the target is stationary or moving at me rapidly makes no difference. This doesn't take any higher education to accomplish though, it's attained the exact same way you get to Carnegie Hall, practice, practice, practice.
If you won't kill, period, what's all this, then? Macho bluster?
 
So make all guns NFA guns. I am ok with that. NFA weapons don't get into the hands of criminals. I suggest you promote that to your congress people and get that made the law of the land.


Only long distance internet sales. As long as we meet in some parking lot it is totally legal to sell non NFA guns to strangers on the internet.


No they are not they are all on paper. See paper is not a computer. The ATF is barred by law from computerizing records so that means that it is effectively impossible to find who legally purchased a gun as someone has to go through all the paperwork by hand.

For someone who seems to be arguing about firearms law you are very ignorant of many sections of it.

Registered NFA firearms do not get into the hands of criminals, this is true. However since criminals don't follow the rule of law, being criminals, they can have NFA type firearms like machine guns or bombs, explosives etc. Remember, the law does not apply to criminals, only law abiding citizens. Only the law abiding citizen will adhere to the laws and jump thru the hoops.

Obama's Exec action prohibits private sale of firearms by individuals, internet, meeting at the parking lot, some guy at work, gun shows etc.

The FBI has a database of guns and owners as well as the ATF. By name and serial number of the weapon. How do you think they recover stolen weapons? Why do you think pawn shops have to run the serial numbers prior to buying a firearm? This is to ensure the weapon has not been reported stolen. How do you think they trace a firearm back to the original owner? Form 4473 , and yes those are digitized into a computer database for ease of access.

Before trying to sell a narrative that gun owners are not on a computer database, please type into a search the following: "eform 4473" . This one form completely erases any doubt of a computer database for guns and owners.
Chris B.
 
Because its a tool and you use the correct tool for the job?
Yes, and the tool he carries is used to kill, which he just claimed he won't do for science, sport, or self-preservation, period.

So the question still stands.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom