Ok, let's accept, for the moment, that it is simply a naturalistic fallacy. Answer the question, what make rape wrong? Do you believe that rape is a priori wrong?
Look, I realize that you have in your head this idea that anything natural that would or could lead anyone to a moral conclusion is, on its face, fallacy. Ok, but if that's the case then you need to give us an answer. Why is rape wrong?
Take away empathy and make a case.
Repeating ad nauseam "natural fallacy" isn't resolving the issue.
Rape is wrong because of the suffering that it causes.
It may also be wrong for other reasons as well, but certainly that is one of them.