Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

Ok, let's accept, for the moment, that it is simply a naturalistic fallacy. Answer the question, what make rape wrong? Do you believe that rape is a priori wrong?

Look, I realize that you have in your head this idea that anything natural that would or could lead anyone to a moral conclusion is, on its face, fallacy. Ok, but if that's the case then you need to give us an answer. Why is rape wrong?

Take away empathy and make a case.

Repeating ad nauseam "natural fallacy" isn't resolving the issue.

Rape is wrong because of the suffering that it causes.
It may also be wrong for other reasons as well, but certainly that is one of them.
 
Since you haven't explained in enough detail what your morality is, I have no idea.

My morality is this: whatever we are doing to and with animals here in north america (US and Canada) right now is acceptable. Existing regulations and legislation are adequate and no more is needed.

I suspect if you explained your morality I'd say that your "morality" doesn't actually count as morality because it lacks one or more qualities I think are necessary to a moral theory, but until you elaborate a bit more that can only be a suspicion.

My morality is morality because I say it is. And the same goes for your morality. You and I are both entitled to determine our own values and live accordingly. I respect your freedom of belief and thought, you should do the same for me.

And don't give me any crap how I'm not moral because I don't walk talk and think exactly like you.

Just because you are free to do something
doesn't mean it's good for you to do it,

I am free do to things because I am free. I don't need your approval to live my life my way.

and don't pretend that somebody is trying to take away your "right" to eat meat.

PETAs public statements indicates they are out to do exactly that. Furthermore, they have stated quite clearly their intent to place all of our lives at risk by putting an end to vital medical research.

The one thing protecting our lives and freedoms from PETA fascists is their own incompetence and their bizarre extremist ideology which puts off the vast majority of people from falling for or supporting their crap.

Now if they could sucker 100 million more people... they might be a threat.
 
My morality is this: whatever we are doing to and with animals here in north america (US and Canada) right now is acceptable. Existing regulations and legislation are adequate and no more is needed.

One of the stock arguments against religious believers is that most of them just believe whatever it is they were brought up to believe, as opposed to arriving at their religious beliefs through unbiased examination and self-reflection.

It seems to me that you are in the same boat. At the very least you have to admit that it's an amazing coincidence that the legal environment for animals right now in the USA and Canada in 2009 just happens to be an acceptable system.

Do you think you would feel the same way if this were 1990? 1980? 1970?

My morality is morality because I say it is. And the same goes for your morality. You and I are both entitled to determine our own values and live accordingly. I respect your freedom of belief and thought, you should do the same for me.

Once again you are hiding behind the straw man that someone is attacking your precious freedom. I'm just questioning your values. Sorry, but in a free society I get to do that.
 
Once again you are hiding behind the straw man that someone is attacking your precious freedom. I'm just questioning your values. Sorry, but in a free society I get to do that.


And in a free society I get to roll my eyes at you and wipe A1 sauce off my face. Yay freedom.
patriot.gif
 
PETA are idiots, but on the quality of the responses posted here, it seems a large number of people on this forum are too.
 
You'd have missed me otherwise, Drudgie.


I honestly would have, my friend.


Kill anything lately?


I haven't hunted in two years now. Miss it a lot less than I thought it would actually.

And for the record I never claim to have the moral or intellectual high ground here. PETA acts retarded, I respond in kind. It's nature's way. :D
 
I've said it before and I've said it again - if a nutritionally-balanced plant-based diet is readily available (which it is for pretty much everyone who posts on this forum), then there is no rational reason for continuing to eat meat.

The idiotic "I'm going to eat a juicy steak to make PETA cry" posts seem to underline just how considered a diet that includes meat really is. You all make yourself look ridiculous.
 
I haven't hunted in two years now. Miss it a lot less than I thought it would actually.

Maybe you're finally growing up? ;)

And for the record I never claim to have the moral or intellectual high ground here. PETA acts retarded, I respond in kind. It's nature's way. :D

Sinking to the level of idiots risks making you look like an idiot.

You're smarter than that, DW.
 
How about "I like meat" as a reason?

"I like rape", "I like littering", "I like pissing in the street".

In other words - that's not a rational reason. It's a reason, but it's an untenable one.

Try again.
 
Last edited:
Why?

I like meat.

I intend to keep eating it.

I don't particularly care what you, hippies or PETA think about that.
 
"I like rape", "I like littering", "I like pissing in the street".

In other words - that's not a rational reason. It's a reason, but it's an untenable one.


Comparing social ills to social norms for the purposes of moral superiority is far less rational.
eng101.gif
 
Why?

I like meat.

I intend to keep eating it.

I don't particularly care what you, hippies or PETA think about that.

Well, now you put it like that - sorry for ever doubting you had a sensible and rational basis for your diet.

:rolleyes:

What ever made me think otherwise, I'll never know.
 
Well, now you put it like that - sorry for ever doubting you had a sensible and rational basis for your diet.

:rolleyes:

What ever made me think otherwise, I'll never know.

I've got these sharp canines, yes? I assume you do as well? Or have you had yours shaved down/extracted?

After all, if you're no longer eating meat, I can assume that such things are of no more use to you?
 
I've got these sharp canines, yes? I assume you do as well? Or have you had yours shaved down/extracted?

Are you able to take a bite out of a live cow? Kill a sheep using only your teeth? Hunt down a pig and kill it with a nibble on its jugular vein? You have teeth like our omnivorous cousins, the bears? Seriously?

And, more to the point, since when does an is equal an ought? When you immediately resort to fallacies, your argument ceases to be rational.
 
Last edited:
Are you able to take a bite out of a live cow? Kill a sheep using only your teeth? Hunt down a pig and kill it with a nibble on its jugular vein? You have teeth like our omnivorous cousins, the bears? Seriously?

And, more to the point, since when does an is equal an ought? When you resort to fallacies, your argument ceases to be rational.

Poor comparisons. We are not straight carnivores. Our cousins, the bears, have fairly sharp claws.

The argument is fairly simple:

The teeth we have are the result of quite a bit of evolution. As such, I intend to use mine.

I would just like to know, have you gotten yours removed? If not, why not?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom